User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > OMG Dooley NEEDS to be nerfed immediatly!
Page:
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
This thread delivers.

What, I don't know, but it delivers.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
One of the Gurupie WRs faked out 2 players on a play today. However, he was tackled really quickly but you can still see the fake on the other defensive player. It didn't help him break a huge play but i guess it still is possible to force people to blink from the WR spot. I looked for more but most of the time the WR was tackled immediately as he caught the ball so it's really hard to tell since they don't have as many chances
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze


How's that merger with the Stingrays going?


About as well as OTR's merger tbh.
Edited by StoutOne on Jul 7, 2009 15:57:43
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
One of the Gurupie WRs faked out 2 players on a play today. However, he was tackled really quickly but you can still see the fake on the other defensive player. It didn't help him break a huge play but i guess it still is possible to force people to blink from the WR spot. I looked for more but most of the time the WR was tackled immediately as he caught the ball so it's really hard to tell since they don't have as many chances


That's part of the problem with fake WRs, IMO. I'm thoroughly convinced that, for WRs, there is something programed in that they can't fake for X amount of clicks after the catch (either that or the CB has to be some set distance away before a fake will work on them). Because WRs are tkled immediately after the catch at such a high % (and it doesn't help them at all to get open), they didn't have a chance to use it much before. Now, with a further reduction, they get even less out of it.

As I wrote, I'm not trying to pretend that it doesn't happen anymore, just less and less effective. Before this, there were 3 types of WR builds that I thought were viable:
High STR tkl brkers
High agility fakers
high speed, with ultra high speed guys still being the most effective of the group (speed in the 120s and high 1st step)

It's still a little early, but, in my mind at least, this has made the high agility fakers not worth it to build anymore. They just can't measure up against the ultra high speed guys' production. That's just MO though
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Originally posted by Firenze



How's that merger with the Stingrays going?


About as well as OTR's merger tbh.


5-4 in USA Pro, and losing to the Shockers by 1 point =/= 4-5 in SA Pro, and losing to the Kai by 32 points.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by chronoaug

One of the Gurupie WRs faked out 2 players on a play today. However, he was tackled really quickly but you can still see the fake on the other defensive player. It didn't help him break a huge play but i guess it still is possible to force people to blink from the WR spot. I looked for more but most of the time the WR was tackled immediately as he caught the ball so it's really hard to tell since they don't have as many chances


That's part of the problem with fake WRs, IMO. I'm thoroughly convinced that, for WRs, there is something programed in that they can't fake for X amount of clicks after the catch (either that or the CB has to be some set distance away before a fake will work on them). Because WRs are tkled immediately after the catch at such a high % (and it doesn't help them at all to get open), they didn't have a chance to use it much before. Now, with a further reduction, they get even less out of it.

As I wrote, I'm not trying to pretend that it doesn't happen anymore, just less and less effective. Before this, there were 3 types of WR builds that I thought were viable:
High STR tkl brkers
High agility fakers
high speed, with ultra high speed guys still being the most effective of the group (speed in the 120s and high 1st step)

It's still a little early, but, in my mind at least, this has made the high agility fakers not worth it to build anymore. They just can't measure up against the ultra high speed guys' production. That's just MO though


Doesn't that make sense though? Why would you be able to fake immediately? You have to catch the ball while facing the QB, turn around looking downfield, secure the ball and your feet/balance from the catch, and then make a move. Definitely not as easy and shouldn't happen often. If you look at most good juke WRs in real life, they do their damage on bubble screens or short under routes. I don't think what you're looking for would really make much sense. WRs still fake defensive players out but they have so few oppurtunities to actually get off a good fake, plus only 3-6 catches per game and maybe 1-2 of those with a chance to actually fake. The odds just aren't really there


It works so much better for HBs because on screens and pitches they have a lot of room and have the ball for a few seconds before encountering anyone. Plus they get 20+ carries per game and it's much easier to get them the ball on screens.
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 7, 2009 16:08:48
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug


Doesn't that make sense though? Why would you be able to fake immediately? You have to catch the ball while facing the QB, turn around looking downfield, secure the ball and your feet/balance from the catch, and then make a move. Definitely not as easy and shouldn't happen often. If you look at most good juke WRs in real life, they do their damage on bubble screens or short under routes. I don't think what you're looking for would really make much sense. WRs still fake defensive players out but they have so few oppurtunities to actually get off a good fake, plus only 3-6 catches per game and maybe 1-2 of those with a chance to actually fake. The odds just aren't really there.


God, yes, that makes sense. I'm not bitching about that for a second. I was just explaining why I don't think it's worth the return on skill point investment.
1) Can't use head fake, Juke or high agility to fake CBs in coverage as advertised (try to use juke like moves early in route to get away from defenders (requires high agility)...Implies that it can actually work. Well, with 87 agility it hasn't happened for me 1 time in 2 ssns...May happen against poor CBs at low lvls, but never seen it for 2 ssns in any Pro Ball since ssn 7 or 8) Edit: not saying it never happens, just that I've never seen it since ssn 7-8. So, it can't be happening enough for it to be worth it

2) Don't have many opportunities to use it in games (because of above, which I agree with)

3) Fires off now less and is less effective on the rare times you can use it.

Add those 3 together and I think it becomes pretty hard to argue that the high agility WRs are worth it to build any longer.

Edited by PP on Jul 7, 2009 16:20:27
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by chronoaug



Doesn't that make sense though? Why would you be able to fake immediately? You have to catch the ball while facing the QB, turn around looking downfield, secure the ball and your feet/balance from the catch, and then make a move. Definitely not as easy and shouldn't happen often. If you look at most good juke WRs in real life, they do their damage on bubble screens or short under routes. I don't think what you're looking for would really make much sense. WRs still fake defensive players out but they have so few oppurtunities to actually get off a good fake, plus only 3-6 catches per game and maybe 1-2 of those with a chance to actually fake. The odds just aren't really there.


God, yes, that makes sense. I'm not bitching about that for a second. I was just explaining why I don't think it's worth the return on skill point investment.
1) Can't use head fake, Juke or high agility to fake CBs in coverage as advertised (try to use juke like moves early in route to get away from defenders (requires high agility)...Implies that it can actually work. Well, with 87 agility it hasn't happened for me 1 time in 2 ssns...May happen against poor CBs at low lvls, but never seen it for 2 ssns in any Pro Ball since ssn 7 or 8) Edit: not saying it never happens, just that I've never seen it since ssn 7-8. So, it can't be happening enough for it to be worth it

2) Don't have many opportunities to use it in games (because of above, which I agree with)

3) Fires off now less and is less effective on the rare times you can use it.

Add those 3 together and I think it becomes pretty hard to argue that the high agility WRs are worth it to build any longer.



Agreed. Then again, you may want to hold off retiring them this off season with new offensive plays coming out. Might be more opportunities.

User Fanaticsfins of the old margaritaville usa AAA2 team has 2 WRs that are pretty solid at faking. One is on Indy and the other i think minnesota or compton
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 7, 2009 16:27:26
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Feudel


Find me a Supreme Court justice that isn't biased in some fashion.

that is the literal meaning of the word but in REAL LIFE everyone has some form of bias.


It has nothing to do with bias.

If I was banning anyone who bitched and moaned about elusives supposedly sucking now (lol...) that would be biased. Calling them out on their ridiculous claim however, is not.


If you didn't waste all my time taking this thread down useless tangents, then perhaps I'd go break down a few games, or get some work done......

I'd probably go do the latter.


What about useless cotangents? Are they cool?
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
I never even logged back on GLB last night... but I can't believe this thread is still going.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Huh, I get what's going on now. The Fake chance per fake has not been lowered, but reducing it to only one guy faked per tick has had an interesting effect on the way fakes work overall.

See, I'm betting you only get one chance to fake each guy. You spot him (Vision check), you try to fake. If it works, great! The reason you only get one chance is that giving more chances would punish good tacklers. See, in Bort's system, good tacklers get spotted farther away (because their threat radius is larger, so the HB has to spot them sooner to get a chance to fake.) If HBs got to keep faking, they'd get more fake opportunities vs. good tacklers than vs. bad ones, which is clearly not a good idea at all.

In the old system, I bet something like this could happen:

HB is running and LB#1 enters threat radius. HB tries to juke, fails.
LB#2 enters threat radius before LB1 makes tackle. HB spots LB#2, tries to juke. This juke can still affect LB#1 - normally, he wouldn't get another chance at LB#1, but the entrance of #2 spawns another juke event. Let's say this juke works on both guys. HB runs away laughing.


In the new system:
HB is running, sees LB#1. HB tries to juke, fails.
LB#2 enters threat radius. HB tries to juke, succeeds, but the new code limits it to working on only one guy. LB#2 gets juked, LB1 makes tackle.



I'm starting to think that under the old system, the more guys going after the ball carrier, the more likely they were to get juked, because the HB got to fire off an area effect fake attempt for each would-be tackler.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
It still isn't very realistic... constantly making juke rolls as you move down the field.

A juke/hf needs to be an event - something that's triggered and does kick off an "area effect" chance to fake out defenders.

I feel the change that was made is taking us in the wrong direction turning these SAs into something that is just as unrealistic as before. The algorithm is all wrong.
 
Feudel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
It still isn't very realistic... constantly making juke rolls as you move down the field.

A juke/hf needs to be an event - something that's triggered and does kick off an "area effect" chance to fake out defenders.

I feel the change that was made is taking us in the wrong direction turning these SAs into something that is just as unrealistic as before. The algorithm is all wrong.


maybe you're wrong?
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Feudel
Originally posted by taurran

It still isn't very realistic... constantly making juke rolls as you move down the field.

A juke/hf needs to be an event - something that's triggered and does kick off an "area effect" chance to fake out defenders.

I feel the change that was made is taking us in the wrong direction turning these SAs into something that is just as unrealistic as before. The algorithm is all wrong.


maybe you're wrong?


Yeah I guess, if reality, the laws of physics, and common sense were "wrong".

Obviously some people with bias opinions here believe in none of the above.
 
Feudel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by Feudel

Originally posted by taurran


It still isn't very realistic... constantly making juke rolls as you move down the field.

A juke/hf needs to be an event - something that's triggered and does kick off an "area effect" chance to fake out defenders.

I feel the change that was made is taking us in the wrong direction turning these SAs into something that is just as unrealistic as before. The algorithm is all wrong.


maybe you're wrong?


Yeah I guess, if reality, the laws of physics, and common sense were "wrong".

Obviously some people with bias opinions here believe in none of the above.


i believe in wat
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.