I see a lot of nominations just putting players out there, not commenting whether they played against any real competition, not showing any longevity or even highlighting the reason they should be considered. Whomever has to break down the list and get to a top-10 has some work on their hands.
Hey SweetJesus, if you need assistance with this endeavor, look me up. I would volunteer some time next season after I no longer own my team to help you sift through the players if you need it.
Here are my nominees with the reasons they should be considered:
KR Clifford Poindexter
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=128380 was only a full-time KR beginning in season 5. Since then he has over 28+ yard average on his returns. Maybe not the best return man, but considering it was all in the pros it's a very good average. 8 trophies from 4 different seasons.
OT Alpha Dog
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=26319&playoffs=0 is a Top Chef with 693 pancakes
WR Dash Parr
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=61635&playoffs=0 my own player, has racked up the yards and TDs against Pro competition. 10k+ yards, 3 seasons over 100 rec, 90 TDs, and this year he is an MVP candidate. 5 awards in seasons 5, 6 and 7.
DE Mr Bigglesworth
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=34513&playoffs=0 is an incredible DE, capping the line and stopping the run as well as getting to the QB and making plays. Look at these numbers: 418 tackles, only 35 missed tackles, 118 Hry, 72 Sacks, 63 TFL, 11 FFum and 7 FumRec. Wow.
CB Salon Defirski
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=42163&playoffs=0 is as steady as they come for a Pro CB. 634 Tackles, 352 PDs, 47 INTs, 8 DefTDs. Not much gets past this guy ever.
SS Dave Fox
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=32801&playoffs=0 playing in the same secondary as CB Defirski above, they were a shutdown pair in O-Pro for many seasons. 838 tackles, 146 PDs, 10 INTs, 18 FFum playing as a combination run stopper-pass defender.
LB Mickey Brasnus
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=28368&playoffs=0 Holy cow, this guy has stopped more players with the ball than anyone in O-Pro the past few seasons. 899 Tackles, 33 Hry, 74 TFL, 50 PDs, 19 FFum and 8 FumRec. Man, that's impressive.
RB Rex Racer
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=530495&playoffs=0 did not get the touches needed early in his career, but in seasons 6,7 and 8 he has a total of over 15,000 yards in returns, rushing and receiving. He will be looking to break the all-time yardage mark soon, if someone has it already.