User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Good GOD, I agree with SI. But not on the strength vs. strength thing. Tackling should be way more important.
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
 
buckeyes33
offline
Link
 
to me it seems like a Brandon Jacobs with less carrying...i don't think you should need as much strength to bring down one of these players. if you are a good tackler with good form you can bring down a big, tough ball carrier. Brandon Jacobs doesn't break 15 tackles a game. maybe 5-7. these players shouldn't be untackleable like the are now, where they get 250+ broken tackles a season. i think a player would need higher tackling to bring down these type players. they can wrap up around the legs and bring them down just like any other RB. (for the most part)
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Bort

I like the gang tackle thing - I want to see dots drag other dots


between that, a small penalty to slower power backs, and a good use of Wrap up or Power tackling...the running should be far more realistic in this game in my opinion...


 
Air18
offline
Link
 
In case my first post was overlooked / a lot of you didn't read it cuz it seemed long...

IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say, 50% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 50% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Billsrgreat
would Stamina & Confidence effect that as well substituting on such depth?


Of course. High stamina will keep you fresher longer.
 
EastBayFunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by EastBayFunk

Originally posted by swoosh22


Originally posted by Bort



Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.



Everyone is still forgetting about how low the speed and agility of this player is. 50-60 speed and agility should be REALLY slow.

To me this build should represent like an offensive lineman, or a run stuffing DT. Not someone like Brandon Jacobs or Adrian Peterson


Yea, you could just as easily ask the question, "How much speed/agility do you think should be required for a very strong back to break tackles?"

It's not uncommon for a GLB power back to be slower and less agile than a defensive tackle of the same level. That's borked. In real life, a RB with tons of strength and mediocre speed and agility would get his ass handed to him.

Most successful NFL power backs have great speed. Think of someone like Jamal Anderson or Jamal Lewis. Those guys were faster and quicker than most linebackers, but they had a little bit of extra pop to break tackles and get yards after contact.

They weren't lumbering tanks with 100 strength and 60 speed/agility.



So are you suggesting a penalty to breaking tackles if you are traveling slower than a certain speed?


It depends on what you're aiming for.

I think a penalty to breaking tackles when running slow is certainly realistic.

In real football, you just don't see slow running backs. They're not effective because they're easy to tackle. You can be the biggest and strongest guy in the world, but if you're moving slow then it's easy to cut your legs or gang tackle you. Big backs actually take some of the most vicious hits of anyone since they're not able to defend themselves and get out of the way.

What makes most NFL backs great is the combination of quickness and power. They're quick enough to change directions instantly. That's where a lot of the broken tackles happen. They don't simply bowl people over, they get them off balance and escape. An off balance tackler is much less effective than someone who has the luxury to gather himself and unload (like they can do with big, slow backs).

Almost every RB in the NFL runs somewhere between a 4.3-4.6.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).


I think you're wrong. IRL, I think LBs would have about 80 speed, 70 of the other 3, 60 strength. This is football now, not in the 80s. LBs weigh 220-240 lbs. pretty often.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).


I agree with this
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).


Right, but we're talking about a power back who, in the example, is stronger than most o-lineman. Which isn't what power backs are, either.
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW

The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).


I agree with this


I disagree with this
 
Air18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW

The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.

Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:

Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90

Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:

Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60

A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).


I think you're wrong. IRL, I think LBs would have about 80 speed, 70 of the other 3, 60 strength. This is football now, not in the 80s. LBs weigh 220-240 lbs. pretty often.




They weigh even more than that. Normally, LB's outweigh RB's by a fair bit.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:04:42
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buckeyes33
to me it seems like a Brandon Jacobs with less carrying...i don't think you should need as much strength to bring down one of these players. if you are a good tackler with good form you can bring down a big, tough ball carrier. Brandon Jacobs doesn't break 15 tackles a game. maybe 5-7. these players shouldn't be untackleable like the are now, where they get 250+ broken tackles a season. i think a player would need higher tackling to bring down these type players. they can wrap up around the legs and bring them down just like any other RB. (for the most part)


I think if they "dragged" somebody it wouldn't count as a broken tackle quite so often because there would likely be another defender coming over to help bring him down. That would make the missed tackles stat go down (which people like to see) and still accomplish similar objectives.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Yeah Bort, Brandon Jacobs runs in the mid-4.5s. Do you really think 50 speed and 60 agility is 4.5 territory?
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Putting a break tackle penalty on going slow is a troublesome thing, especially for the PeeWee leagues and expansion leagues. Going fast, and being strong, is simply impossible until you're like level 30, just b/c of SP available.

I think elusive backs should be much much easier to tackle without strength as well. Too many backs have 25 strength, which is just absurd. They should get launched 5 yards back when tackled and lose a ton of energy with that sort of mismatch. Though, this isn't about elusive backs... (my powerback answer was a few pages back)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.