User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by Bort



I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


But.. He will still try to make the INT, sometimes, right?

Or is he ONLY going to try to bat the ball down?

CBs in real life, are able to do both.. Depending on the throw. We should too.


If he's close to the play, he's always got the chance of getting the int. He won't ever try and jump in front, though, and cut off the pass.


So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


I dunno, I think that is middle ground. If it's a bad pass there's still the chance to pick it off.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by Bort



I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


But.. He will still try to make the INT, sometimes, right?

Or is he ONLY going to try to bat the ball down?

CBs in real life, are able to do both.. Depending on the throw. We should too.


If he's close to the play, he's always got the chance of getting the int. He won't ever try and jump in front, though, and cut off the pass.


So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


k, suggestion as to how/what it should work/be?
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bukowski



Originally posted by Bort




I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


But.. He will still try to make the INT, sometimes, right?

Or is he ONLY going to try to bat the ball down?

CBs in real life, are able to do both.. Depending on the throw. We should too.


If he's close to the play, he's always got the chance of getting the int. He won't ever try and jump in front, though, and cut off the pass.


So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


k, suggestion as to how/what it should work/be?


allow the cb to jump the route if "he has help over the top" on medium or at least the new semi agressive choice.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski



So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


k, suggestion as to how/what it should work/be?


Perhaps a three way option:

Coverage distance

Cover style with no help

Coverage style with help

3 discrete settings.

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bukowski



Originally posted by Bort




I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


But.. He will still try to make the INT, sometimes, right?

Or is he ONLY going to try to bat the ball down?

CBs in real life, are able to do both.. Depending on the throw. We should too.


If he's close to the play, he's always got the chance of getting the int. He won't ever try and jump in front, though, and cut off the pass.


So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


k, suggestion as to how/what it should work/be?


Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.

But it would still allow us to play it conservative when our Super Vision tells us to, but on a really bad pass that they can obviously make the INT on, then they should be able to make the play - if their Vision dictates them being able to.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:56:20
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
I think that we should definitively keep a setting that doesn't have them trying for interceptions if they aren't 100% that they'll pull it off.

Maybe, a setting where they sometimes go aggressive would be nice for some teams. But, it would be really bad for a lot of teams.

I think bort's idea for season 7 off adding a 1-100% thing is a good one.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:56:37
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Bukowski




Originally posted by Bort





I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


But.. He will still try to make the INT, sometimes, right?

Or is he ONLY going to try to bat the ball down?

CBs in real life, are able to do both.. Depending on the throw. We should too.


If he's close to the play, he's always got the chance of getting the int. He won't ever try and jump in front, though, and cut off the pass.


So the only setting that would ever allow us to jump the route, would be aggressive?

Shouldn't we have a setting, that would SOMETIMES allow us to jump the route, just not as frequently?

That was what Medium was supposed to do, before.

It shouldn't be go for the pick all the time, or never.

We need to have some kind of middle ground.


k, suggestion as to how/what it should work/be?


Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


hence the option I presented to add a variable that makes a dynamic switch between coverage styles based on supervision.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski

Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bukowski


Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



No.. I mean they should still get beat sometimes.

But if a CB has a high enough Super Vision/Vision, then they should have better awareness as to when to jump a route, or when to hang back.

The CB should always be able to get beaten. But they should also be able to do multiple things, if they are more "aware" than the other CBs on the field.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:59:04
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bukowski


Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



I agree. Seems like a bit much.

Maybe have Vis/SV change the Go for int chance based on how they compare with the WR they're on?
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:59:55
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by GoVikings16

Originally posted by Bukowski


But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.


I didn't say they have to get it right every time.

But they should have a better idea than other CBs, dependent on how high Vision/Super Vision is.

But no, they shouldn't be as dumb as to make the same exact play on the ball every single down, no matter what the play dictates.

Besides, if you're playing football - do you not have a pretty good idea when you can catch the ball, and when you can't? Of course it won't be 100%, but that is what Super Vision is supposed to be for.


agreed, SAs should not be rendered useless by a generic fix. Super Vision should always give your player the bonus it was intended to regardless of the coverage distance/style because it determines how your player reacts and sees the play.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bukowski



Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



No.. I mean they should still get beat sometimes.

But if a CB has a high enough Super Vision/Vision, then they should have better awareness as to when to jump a route, or when to hang back.


I was having some fun there...but seriously, it sounds to me like Vis and SV play a big role in that already...and it seems that way from my testing as well.

 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bukowski


Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



just having high vision would not be enought if the WR has 10 more speed than you do. that will never change no matter how "smart" your player is.
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by tautology


Originally posted by Bukowski




Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



No.. I mean they should still get beat sometimes.

But if a CB has a high enough Super Vision/Vision, then they should have better awareness as to when to jump a route, or when to hang back.


I was having some fun there...but seriously, it sounds to me like Vis and SV play a big role in that already...and it seems that way from my testing as well.



Again.. People want GLB to fit "THEIR" player.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bukowski



Well, it would be a Vision/Super Vision check, that would allow the CB to sometimes take a chance for the INT, if there is a really high chance of coming down with the ball. If their Vision/Super Vision check tells then that they won't be able to get to it, then they shouldn't try.

The higher level of Vision/Super Vision, the more likely they are to make the right choice.

If they do make the wrong choice, then they get beat. But they would still have a chance to jump a route.

It would be slightly less than Aggressive.


Sounds a little like "Make big plays but don't get burned and never make bad choices..."

Seriously, I think this goes a bit far. WRs need to have some fun too you know



I agree. Seems like a bit much.


I still want the CB to get beaten.. As I have 3 WRs myself.

I just want their Super Vision to be able to dictate, them knowing how much of a chance they have at coming down with the ball, or if they should instead play it safe.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.