User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Considering all the talk about respec-ing the game going round about now, this seems like exactly the right time to talk about this.

Right now it's easier to get a DE's speed up than a CB. (Major skill for both, but DEs have less major skills and get .5 per level to speed, versus .33 for CBs.) This is clearly wrong.

Weight is a way to solve this problem. It's not a wrinkle for the sake of adding a wrinkle.

Obviously you could shuffle around major skills or introduce different soft caps for different positions... but that doesn't seem a whole lot less intrusive than weight and doesn't solve the problem of large players who are already ridiculously fast.

Also, weight is a big part of real football, but almost no part of GLB. It's time to fix that.
 
Angry Bull
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
As stated (I didn't read a number of pages in the middle) it seems tilted toward lower weights because of the overimportance of Speed in the sim.

The block/break block bonuses should certainly apply to tackle/break tackle as well, and possibly also directly to Strength itself.

I'd also rather see it be a smooth curve rather than have classes. The difference between 186 and 189 should be as big as that between 189 and 192.

Otherwise, it works for me.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notthegint
Right now it's easier to get a DE's speed up than a CB. (Major skill for both, but DEs have less major skills and get .5 per level to speed, versus .33 for CBs.) This is clearly wrong.


It is wrong, but this weight classes proposal is wrong too. A 191 pound guy would have a .25s slower base 40 time than a 190 lb guy? Come on. If anything should be changed, it's the automatic level gains. The majors/minors system was always broken. Offensive tackles getting more points for stamina and tackling than for strength, blocking, etc, is insane. WRs getting more points for carrying than speed or catching is insane.

If you want to give people a reason to have shorter or lighter players, a very simple idea that would be reasonably effective would be to adjust player attributes at creation time. i.e. if a guy wants his WR to be 6'5" 230# instead of 5'11" 190#, then give him 140 points to play with instead of 149.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Actually, here's a new idea. I think it would be very practical, and would make shorter/taller or lighter/heavier players interesting. Might not work with the idea of players being able to gain or lose weight, though...

The idea:
Change the ability soft caps depending on the height and weight of the player. Actually now that I think about this I don't know why it wasn't done this way in the first place. For example:
Strength - Slightly lower for taller players, much higher for heavier players
Speed soft caps - Slightly higher for taller players, lower for heavier players
Agility soft caps - Lower for taller players, lower for heavier players
Jumping - Slightly higher for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Stamina - Slightly lower for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Vision - Slightly higher for taller players, unaffected by weight
Confidence - Unaffected by height and weight

So for example. Take a player that is 6'2" 220#. Does't matter what his position is. Soft caps might be:
Strength - 48
Speed - 52
Agility - 47
Jumping - 48
Stamina - 48
Vision - 50

On the other hand, a player that is 6'5" 300# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 60
Speed - 45
Agility - 41
Jumping - 45
Stamina - 44
Vision - 52

And a player that is 5'9" 190# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 43
Speed - 51
Agility - 57
Jumping - 50
Stamina - 53
Vision - 47

So the soft caps are determined by height and weight. You could have a button next to the rolls (and also on the player page later) where the user can just click it to see what their soft caps are at that height and weight. I think you could incorporate gaining and losing weight by allowing players to adjust their weight until they hit a soft cap. Once they hit a soft cap they are set, which IMO is fairly realistic because you rarely see NFL players change their weight significantly after their rookie year. (The only exception is at the end of careers you often see guys lose weight just because they can't stay fit at heavier weights anymore.)

Meanwhile, the player's automatic level gains are still determined by their position, because of what they do in practice. And with a new system more carefully tuned to each position rather than trying to fit the major/minor system.

So for a WR, automatic level gains something like:
Speed +.4 Catching +.4 Agility +.3 Jumping +.3 Stamina +.3 Vision +.2 Confidence +.2 Carrying +.2 Strength +.1 Blocking +.1 Throwing +.1 Tackling +.1

For a LB, automatic level gains something like:
Tackling +.4 Strength +.3 Agility +.3 Vision +.3 Confidence +.3 Stamina +.2 Jumping +.2 Speed +.2 Catching +.1 Carrying +.1 Blocking +.1

Those might not add up to 3 or whatever, but you get the idea. If you are making big changes, the strict majors/minors system really ought to go.

So if a guy really wants to make a linebacker that is 6'4" and quicker and faster than Randy Moss, he can do it, but it will cost him a lot more SP to do it than the guy who creates a 6'0" WR, and it will cost him even more SP to do it if he also makes the guy 250#.

If you want to re-vamp things, be it for new players only or whatever, in my humble opinion this is the way to do it.
 
Thunder39
offline
Link
 
Been banhammered for rick rolling peeps
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 14:25:57
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thunder39
I like the idea, and there's another site that's doing something similar here http://smouch.net/lol/


OMFG. I knew that link was going to be a prank but I didn't think it would be that disruptive. Bastard.
 
Madayew
offline
Link
 
Maybee, so your saying 100 speed on a LB would be different than 100 speed on a Cornerback?

Realistic and a good idea, my only fear is then the speedster returners and WR's will become supermen overnight if other positions are made slower based off their weight class

Implement skill point penalties instead, DE's cost more skill points to increase speed than a wide reciever to make it more realistic
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thunder39
I like the idea, and there's another site that's doing something similar here http://smouch.net/lol/


qfb
 
divinevert
offline
Link
 
I'd like it if a 6'5", 210 lb. receiver who could jump had a different skill cap than a 5'7", 160 lb. receiver. They are naturally able to do different things and I would like that to come through in the game.

It would also help scouting other teams.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Actually, here's a new idea. I think it would be very practical, and would make shorter/taller or lighter/heavier players interesting. Might not work with the idea of players being able to gain or lose weight, though...


Didn't want to quote the whole thing, but I like this idea a lot. All this would need is someone to iron the numbers out, and some way to integrate it into the current model. (Or confirmation that a wipe or respec-split are on the way.)

 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Actually, here's a new idea.

The idea:
Change the ability soft caps depending on the height and weight of the player.


+1 suggestion by Trevjo...
 
DM
offline
Link
 
poast
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Actually, here's a new idea. I think it would be very practical, and would make shorter/taller or lighter/heavier players interesting. Might not work with the idea of players being able to gain or lose weight, though...

The idea:
Change the ability soft caps depending on the height and weight of the player. Actually now that I think about this I don't know why it wasn't done this way in the first place. For example:
Strength - Slightly lower for taller players, much higher for heavier players
Speed soft caps - Slightly higher for taller players, lower for heavier players
Agility soft caps - Lower for taller players, lower for heavier players
Jumping - Slightly higher for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Stamina - Slightly lower for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Vision - Slightly higher for taller players, unaffected by weight
Confidence - Unaffected by height and weight

So for example. Take a player that is 6'2" 220#. Does't matter what his position is. Soft caps might be:
Strength - 48
Speed - 52
Agility - 47
Jumping - 48
Stamina - 48
Vision - 50

On the other hand, a player that is 6'5" 300# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 60
Speed - 45
Agility - 41
Jumping - 45
Stamina - 44
Vision - 52

And a player that is 5'9" 190# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 43
Speed - 51
Agility - 57
Jumping - 50
Stamina - 53
Vision - 47

So the soft caps are determined by height and weight. You could have a button next to the rolls (and also on the player page later) where the user can just click it to see what their soft caps are at that height and weight. I think you could incorporate gaining and losing weight by allowing players to adjust their weight until they hit a soft cap. Once they hit a soft cap they are set, which IMO is fairly realistic because you rarely see NFL players change their weight significantly after their rookie year. (The only exception is at the end of careers you often see guys lose weight just because they can't stay fit at heavier weights anymore.)

Meanwhile, the player's automatic level gains are still determined by their position, because of what they do in practice. And with a new system more carefully tuned to each position rather than trying to fit the major/minor system.

So for a WR, automatic level gains something like:
Speed +.4 Catching +.4 Agility +.3 Jumping +.3 Stamina +.3 Vision +.2 Confidence +.2 Carrying +.2 Strength +.1 Blocking +.1 Throwing +.1 Tackling +.1

For a LB, automatic level gains something like:
Tackling +.4 Strength +.3 Agility +.3 Vision +.3 Confidence +.3 Stamina +.2 Jumping +.2 Speed +.2 Catching +.1 Carrying +.1 Blocking +.1

Those might not add up to 3 or whatever, but you get the idea. If you are making big changes, the strict majors/minors system really ought to go.

So if a guy really wants to make a linebacker that is 6'4" and quicker and faster than Randy Moss, he can do it, but it will cost him a lot more SP to do it than the guy who creates a 6'0" WR, and it will cost him even more SP to do it if he also makes the guy 250#.

If you want to re-vamp things, be it for new players only or whatever, in my humble opinion this is the way to do it.


agreed, and is part of the basis for my big list of suggestions here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1540531

Its simply unrealistic for big guys to be able to get fast as easily as little guys, and for little guys to get strong the way big guys can. Use the soft caps to change the point where its harder for different types of players to add additional ability.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by divinevert
I'd like it if a 6'5", 210 lb. receiver who could jump had a different skill cap than a 5'7", 160 lb. receiver. They are naturally able to do different things and I would like that to come through in the game.

It would also help scouting other teams.


My suggestion here http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1540531 is to make actual jumping ability a factor of jumping points, player weight, lower body strength and agility.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.