User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
If Speed is so important for OLinemen, and OT's especially, then why is it not even considered to be a minor attribute by Bort?

As one of my teammates brought up in our team forum, you have DE's gaining .5 into speed with each lvl up (up until lvl 23), but OT's are getting zilch!



Because tackling is more important?
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Of course a warlock understands being overpowered ;x


I wasn't a warlock in WoW, the nickname is from semi-pro football... because I used to paint my face up for games and wore medieval bracers (that had evil looking symbols on them) off the field.

Although, I did play WoW for a while, so know what you're referring to.

 
Porch
offline
Link
 
Actually in the three 3 games the guy has 16 sacks and the team has 23 sacks.

They sacked one team 5 times in which they only threw 16 times.
The other they got for 13 sacks in which they threw 41 times.
They got us for 5 in 27 attempts.

For the the year they have 23 sacks vs 79 throws. So if you drop back they will get a sack 1 out of 5 times.

Also I have heard a lot of talk about the back but of the 5 sacks we sent out only 4 WR's on most of them. Every single play had at least one back in to block and in one of them 2 backs. I will admit though that twice the back was on the wrong side. However that leaves 3 were not only the LT failed to pick him up but the back did as well.

Finally I know about the TE. On long passing plays we moved the TE over to help.

However even then against the TE it appears on this play nearly splits the double team untouched. Honestly it looks like we never even stopped him. Or this one where the FB comes to help and we still can't get the LT back to help out.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148637
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148666

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Its ridiculous.. DE's need some fine tuning. OT's with good stats are still getting whooped for no good reason.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
However even then against the TE it appears on this play nearly splits the double team untouched. Honestly it looks like we never even stopped him. Or this one where the FB comes to help and we still can't get the LT back to help out.


Can't get the LT back? Hmmm... what could help the LT get back... let me think....

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
The funny part of this entire debacle, is that I tried to bring up this issue back in season 3... when I first noticed it'd become a problem. The trolls got the thread locked and nothing was done.

I've never seen consistent success, at any level of RL football, from a weak yet super quick DE... they may on occasion get in there, but never consistently, like we're seeing in GLB.
 
Flu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148004 sack

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148818 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1149332 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1149881 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1149903 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1151823 sack

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1152661 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1152844 sack

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1152884 hurry

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1153396 sack

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1153407 sack

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1153439 hurry



These are some awesome plays to watch. Your OT gets schooled and probably deserves every second of it...
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eholling

When you reach a point in a game where one opposing force can dominate another and there's no way to compensate or account for it, then you have an overpowered situation that should be corrected in the best interests of the game as a whole.


That's not the issue here, though., as there are ways to compensate and account for it. You can build OTs that stop the best speed/agility rushers, and, if your OT is not built to do this at the moment, you can game plan in ways that reduces the effectiveness of those DEs (as evidence of this, we played the DE in the OP's post twice last season, once, earlier in the season he had two sacks and 4 hurries, the second time, after we adjusted our tactics and builds, he had 1 sack and 1 hurry. . .as far as I can tell, he hasn't boosted this season yet, so we played him with his current build).

The issue, as far as I can tell, is that people claim that you can't wear down pure speed/agility pass rushers by beating the crap out of them early by running at them. I'm not sure this is true, but if it is, then I'd think the answer is to increase the morale/stamina hits when DEs get run blocked by much stronger OTs, rather than simply nerfing speed DEs (which, by the way, would also nerf those OTs that have been built to try and stop them, which strikes me as a terribly unfair consequence).

I also don't think that it's the case that the competitive power of speed/agility pass rushers makes strength DEs useless or a wasted build. Strength DEs can be very effective against the running game, and, to my mind, of real value.

Last edited Nov 12, 2008 13:44:56
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by eholling


When you reach a point in a game where one opposing force can dominate another and there's no way to compensate or account for it, then you have an overpowered situation that should be corrected in the best interests of the game as a whole.


That's not the issue here, though., as there are ways to compensate and account for it. You can build OTs that stop the best speed/agility rushers, and, if your OT is not built to do this at the moment, you can game plan in ways that reduces the effectiveness of those DEs (as evidence of this, we played the DE in the OP's post twice last season, once, earlier in the season he had two sacks and 4 hurries, the second time, after we adjusted our tactics and builds, he had 1 sack and 1 hurry. . .as far as I can tell, he hasn't boosted this season yet, so we played him with his current build).

The issue, as far as I can tell, is that people claim that you can't wear down pure speed/agility pass rushers by beating the crap out of them early by running at them. I'm not sure this is true, but if it is, then I'd think the answer is to increase the morale/stamina hits when DEs get run blocked by much stronger OTs, rather than simply nerfing speed DEs (which, by the way, would also nerf those OTs that have been built to try and stop them, which strikes me as a terribly unfair consequence).

I also don't think that it's the case that the competitive power of speed/agility pass rushers makes strength DEs useless or a wasted build. Strength DEs can be very effective against the running game, and, to my mind, of real value.



So instead, just let those people who used common sense when building a player suffer instead? No. People that exploited the game mechanics to have super-duper pass rushing DEs, should have expected to be nerfed. This is a simulation of real life football, it should try and emulate it... I don't see any DBs playing DE (at pretty much any level of play), do you?

Making a DE with no strength and super high speed and agility is an exploit of game mechanics... not doing anything about it will lose GLB far more players than fixing it will.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 13:57:56
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I'm sure someone will come in here shortly to re-litigate the "this is not RL football" argument for the thousandth time, though I won't.

What I will say is that a common sense approach to this internet game would have told you that 90% of OTs had been built by focusing entirely on strength and blocking during the first several seasons, then, as a pass-rushing DE, if you want to be able to beat them, you'd do it by being strong at areas where they are weak. A common sense approach to this game would tell you that if you are facing a DE with high speed/agility and little strength, that you'd attack them where they are weak and that you'd run at them regularly and pancake the shit out of them (if this doesn't work, then that's the area where Bort should make adjustments). A common sense approach to this game would tell you that if you were playing against that type of DE, you wouldn't want to throw a lot of long passes early in the game before his stamina and morale were dented dragging down his production. That, it strikes me, is what common sense would tell you.

Speed/agility DEs have been dominant for almost the entirety of the life of this game, which is now half the useful life of season 1 players. To expect a complete nerf of them at this point would be odd. To expect a complete nerf of OTs that were built to counteract them, would not only be odd, but damaging to players that actually paid attention to how the game worked, rather than watching the NFL on Sunday and then building a player here based on what they had seen on their TV.

Speed/agility pass rushing DEs can be taken advantage of, and can, to a certain extent, be defanged (again, I played against the DE in the OP's first post twice last season, and he didn't destroy us). Adjusting the sim so that their very low strength can be taken advantage of by the offense is a reasonable approach. Adjusting the sim so that speed/agility pass rushers can't get to the QB would be kind of crazy, no? I don't see many DBs playing DE in real world football, but I also see plenty of DEs that use speed and agility to get around the OT rather than use their strength to go through him. That's not such a weird thing.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 14:24:33
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
By the way, I should add that if Bort made changes to the sim during the offseason that makes speed/agility rushers more effective, then disregard everything else I've written above. My argument is against nerfing what has been status quo for a long time (as there were ways to counter the fast speed rushers), but if things have changed making speed/agility DEs more overpowering, then I'm all for toning it back down to what it had been in the past. My OT and two higher-level DEs played against a terrible team today, so it's hard to decipher whether things have changed. The preseason games, however, made it look as if things hadn't changed much.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 14:33:34
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Speed/agility DEs have been dominant for almost the entirety of the life of this game, which is now half the useful life of season 1 players.


Even after people using common sense have made players that are built to counter Speed/Agility DE's they are ridiculous. Meaning your common sense theories might not be completely well thought out.

There's something wrong with the way the O-Line works. Early on the O-Line was too powerful and held blocks for too long, and so tweaks were made and since that point, the OT's have not been very able to do anything.

There is something decidedly wrong with how DE's are working presently.

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
I'm sure someone will come in here shortly to re-litigate the "this is not RL football" argument for the thousandth time, though I won't.

What I will say is that a common sense approach to this internet game would have told you that 90% of OTs had been built by focusing entirely on strength and blocking during the first several seasons, then, as a pass-rushing DE, if you want to be able to beat them, you'd do it by being strong at areas where they are weak. A common sense approach to this game would tell you that if you are facing a DE with high speed/agility and little strength, that you'd attack them where they are weak and that you'd run at them regularly and pancake the shit out of them (if this doesn't work, then that's the area where Bort should make adjustments). A common sense approach to this game would tell you that if you were playing against that type of DE, you wouldn't want to throw a lot of long passes early in the game before his stamina and morale were dented dragging down his production. That, it strikes me, is what common sense would tell you.

Speed/agility DEs have been dominant for almost the entirety of the life of this game, which is now half the useful life of season 1 players. To expect a complete nerf of them at this point would be odd. To expect a complete nerf of OTs that were built to counteract them, would not only be odd, but damaging to players that actually paid attention to how the game worked, rather than watching the NFL on Sunday and then building a player here based on what they had seen on their TV.

Speed/agility pass rushing DEs can be taken advantage of, and can, to a certain extent, be defanged (again, I played against the DE in the OP's first post twice last season, and he didn't destroy us). Adjusting the sim so that their very low strength can be taken advantage of by the offense is a reasonable approach. Adjusting the sim so that speed/agility pass rushers can't get to the QB would be kind of crazy, no? I don't see many DBs playing DE in real world football, but I also see plenty of DEs that use speed and agility to get around the OT rather than use their strength to go through him. That's not such a weird thing.


I've played the game of football my entire life, primarily as a RDE and a LT. DEs, do not, use speed and agility to run around OTs... they use technique... strength, speed and agility merely help them succeed. Currently, no technique is being used, instead it's a damn foot race.

While I agree with you on the whole low strength thing (DEs with low strength should get mauled in the running game and eventually get worn out). There are still other issues, primarily with the pathing. These issues are because of how players move, which allow perfectly acceptable OT builds to get beat repeatedly. OTs rely very heavily on the kick slide and hand placement to maintain their superior positioning. They do not turn and move, turn and move, turn and move. Speed has nothing to do with an OT who is pass blocking.

The game needs to take the effectiveness of raw stats down a notch and make SAs (aka technique) more important. As well as balance out attributes, so that different builds are viable (just in different ways, not different roles).
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 14:39:37
 
The_Kirk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Madcow8me

again, his speed is 30ish



30 speed vs 70 speed is going to get abused like that.

blocking doesn't even come into play unless they lock up.


Maybe, but on a run, shouldn't that little DE be killed as well? Off tackle plays should be going for 10 yards a carry.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Warlock, those are good (and interesting) points. I'm not sure, however, that technique is completely separated out from attributes as GLB is currently designed. For example, I'm fairly certain that pass rushing techniques are available to players who don't have the points in their pass rushing SAs.

As for the value of speed to an OT, part of the issue is that it's very difficult (I imagine) to replicate in this game what goes into making a good OT in real life, as real life success isn't really just a confluence of a dozen discrete traits. I'd agree with you that in real life straight-line speed is of little value to an OT, but the ability to quickly move to keep your center of gravity in front of the DE is very important. In GLB, that ability seems to require a combination of speed, agility and vision (and, once the block is made, blocking to keep the DE engaged). At some level, I think vision, agility and blocking (and, maybe, some of the SAs) should be all that are needed to keep an OT in front of the faster DEs (there are very few successful OTs in real life that are not very agile, though sometimes their sheer enormity makes it hard to see), but the sim is designed so that speed plays a role in lateral quickness, and so it's necessary for OTs in this game.

I guess what I'm trying to say with all my babbling is that, while we might all want the attributes in this game to reflect perfectly what those words mean in real life (just ask any of the many agents of kickers who wonder why the hell "Jumping" is necessary for kicking), they don't and it would be hard to make them do so. "Speed" isn't really speed, "Agility" isn't really agility, etc. . .

In my view, so long as some combination of the attributes can make an OT successful against a speed DE (and it doesn't include jumping, kicking, throwing or punting), then I think it's ok, and just a function of figuring the game out. I just worry that large-scale nerfing of existing successful builds is a bad thing at this point in the game if there are other ways to solve the problem (like increasing morale/stamina degrading effects on low-strength DEs). While there's an argument that speed/agility DE builds are an exploit that should be nerfed, the OTs that were built to counter them weren't exploiting anything, and nerfing them would be a bad result.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.