User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
crms
offline
Link
 
http://centurymedia.com/temp/vital.remains.cover.art/Vital.Remains.Icons.Of.Evil.Final.version.jpg


peace newbs
 
Armaro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

If God cares that man does wrong, why make them able?
If God doesn't care that man does wrong, why punish them?


I'm not religious but I've gotten into this argument before. The common answer is free will. God gives us the ability to make that decision so that we aren't simply slaves to his/her/its will.

Technically, I think I'm an agnostic. I think.

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Armaro

I'm not religious but I've gotten into this argument before. The common answer is free will. God gives us the ability to make that decision so that we aren't simply slaves to his/her/its will.


I'm all for him giving us free will. But isn't it contradictory to also punish us for it?
 
Tier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Armaro


I'm not religious but I've gotten into this argument before. The common answer is free will. God gives us the ability to make that decision so that we aren't simply slaves to his/her/its will.


I'm all for him giving us free will. But isn't it contradictory to also punish us for it?


I think it's sort of what your parents do when you are a kid. They tell you the difference between right and wrong, and let you live your life *mostly* how you want to. If you screw up, they punish you. That's how I look at it.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tier

I think it's sort of what your parents do when you are a kid. They tell you the difference between right and wrong, and let you live your life *mostly* how you want to. If you screw up, they punish you. That's how I look at it.


But that is different. Your parents didn't get a set of personalities to mix n match and add together to create you.

It would be like the parents picking a personality that is very rebellious, then beating the living shit out of the kid when it doesn't follow the rules. Why would you do that? Why not just pick a "good" personality to begin with?

Last edited Oct 13, 2008 06:32:29
 
Tier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Tier


I think it's sort of what your parents do when you are a kid. They tell you the difference between right and wrong, and let you live your life *mostly* how you want to. If you screw up, they punish you. That's how I look at it.


But that is different. Your parents didn't get a set of personalities to mix n match and add together to create you.

It would be like the parents picking a personality that is very rebellious, then beating the living shit out of the kid when it doesn't follow the rules. Why would you do that? Why not just pick a "good" personality to begin with?



I think that he knew that it would be one miserable world to live in if everyone was the same. Who wants to be exactly the same as the 8+billion in the world? Not me.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
I think we're missing the most important question here-


What would Invisible Lion do?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Armaro


I'm not religious but I've gotten into this argument before. The common answer is free will. God gives us the ability to make that decision so that we aren't simply slaves to his/her/its will.


I'm all for him giving us free will. But isn't it contradictory to also punish us for it?


Who said we get punished for it?
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Armaro



I'm not religious but I've gotten into this argument before. The common answer is free will. God gives us the ability to make that decision so that we aren't simply slaves to his/her/its will.


I'm all for him giving us free will. But isn't it contradictory to also punish us for it?


Who said we get punished for it?


the Christian concept of the afterlife, for one.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Also, Dante Alighieri
 
Link
 
But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.
 
Savage Smurf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


So if i blow up an orphanage but accept jesus i'm not a bad person?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
God is all-powerful... yet won't stop all the fucked up things in the world.

I will not kneel for someone as evil as God.

Theodicy, the main issue theists have struggled with for centuries. Classical theists will deny (subtly) that evil actually exists, while admitting it exists (because it's mentioned in the Bible and is necessary for their world view) by calling it a "real privation of good". They also categorize types of evil, to account for natural disasters, etc. The whole reason they run into this problem, is because of their specific concept of God (as omnipotent, omnipresent and omniscient).

Basically, the Bible doesn't support the classical theist's God concept, and theodicy really arose out of the legacy of the church tradition (the Catholic church. But, really, theism often has little to do with the sacred texts of a religion). Over time, the classical theists conception of God became more and more centered on "coercive" power rather than "persuasive" power, which was all good and fine until the skeptics came along.

Neo-classical theists, or process theists, have a totally different conception of God, and thus a totally different answer to the theodicy problem. They'll say that God is not omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent (in the traditional sense), and claim ignorance to the limits/depths of God's power. Rather they focus on God's ability to persuade via love/compassion, and admit the presence of chaos, which accounts for "evil".

The process theist says, "understand that life is suffering, and philosophize from there".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie

But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


So if i blow up an orphanage but accept jesus i'm not a bad person?


The question is can you accept and love Jesus while knowingly and unrepetently(sp?) blowing up orphanages?
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


As interesting as my next point about original sin is, I have to go now.

I'll post when I get back :V
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.