User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > "Missing" Intense Training Combos
Page:
 
kilmor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by -boz-

why not just have every combo possible...


How is anyone gonna navigate thru 1,960 combinations? They'd be a mess to scroll thru looking for anything. It's absurd. If there are only like 2-4 combinations that are forbidden, then creating 1,956 combinations just to exclude 4 is madness.

Far better having 14 in one drop down, 14 in the other, and graying out the second attribute combination when the first is selected.

Seriously, I think it's partly to do with trying to have cool funky RPG-like things like names for the drills is why combinations got originally implemented. Which is absurd/ghey. Surely Bort sat there realizing it'd be easier to have two drop downs so why the infatuation with combinations unless to have RPG-like 'funky' drill names.

Functionality/common-sense > funky RPG elements.


I couldn't have said it better. Except I don't agree with limiting combinations. I like diverse builds. Does anyone really care what the activity is called?
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 22:46:47
 
x21times20
offline
Link
 
speed + jumping
speed + confidence
speed + blocking
blocking + confidence
jumping + confidence
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 01:24:37
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I dont agree with forbidding combinations either. But if Bort insists on that, graying out is the fix rather than what's currently happening.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by x21times20
why is there no jumping + speed


Because there are 1,960 possible combinations. Currently there are only like 30 that have been installed based on trying to limit training to cookie cutter methods applicable to their positions.

Every position should be free to train any two attributes it wants. Why cant a Guard train strength and throwing? If he wants to let him thru dual drop downs. If a RB wants to train tackling and jumping. Let him.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I dont agree with forbidding combinations either. But if Bort insists on that, graying out is the fix rather than what's currently happening.


I think leaving the "drills" is more for the football side of people.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I'm a football side of a person but still place functionality above drill names.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by GG

I dont agree with forbidding combinations either. But if Bort insists on that, graying out is the fix rather than what's currently happening.


I think leaving the "drills" is more for the football side of people.


But...

Originally posted by GG
I'm a football side of a person but still place functionality above drill names.


Exactly, GG.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
It comes down to what's more important. There's an obvious either/or here. Cant have the drill names AND the duel drop down function. One or the other. If it came to a vote, the masses would be unanimous.

But to insist still on the cool names over the functionality only renders the product itself (training) weaker. And exasperates the frustration of the userbase. All this is ok just to maintain the funky names?
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 23:56:35
 
GG
offline
Link
 
What market is this training appealing to? To 8 year old boys who "woohoo" that they're gonna go on a sled drill and purchase a super glove of jumping? Or the adult man/woman who wants to be mentally stimulated in devising and planning the development of their player thru unrestricted training methods as he sees fit?

What's more important? Having to click 50 times to go from the training page to the advanced EQT page, and people everywhere gnashing their teeth in frustration? Or, putting a user-friendly re-direct that takes you straight to the advanced store?

What's more interesting? Having bountiful individual player tactics and play creation modules and actual football strategizing? Or, the only strategy in the game is deciding which item of clothing to wear and which gives a higher bonus percentage than another item?

What's more fun? Having 24-17 games 99% of the time, where new people to the game can jump right in and be integral contributors from the get-go? Or having ever-widening disparity in every facet of the game---scores, chemistry, stadiums, finances, player market, etc etc?

These are the crux problems i have with all of it. GLB itself. It seems off-topic, but time and again these things are implemented seemingly without forethought. Or like the developers cant see the game from the userbase's pov/experience. Or like once they put the wheels in motion with an idea that's been prematurely developed/designed it becomes a "tough, not changing it" attitude after people make better suggestions.

What did Bort say once? This game is going to change, change is always going to happen, we're looking at improving and changing the game" etc etc. But we STILL have a lot of issues in the game (chemistry, promotion/relegation, level disparity, lack of plays, rich-getting-richer aspects everywhere, etc) that still havent been addressed after 4 seasons. Instead, more time spent on conjuring up funky names for items and creating all these ideas around bonus tokens and superficial RPG elements while the meat and bones of the game is still needing to be addressed.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 00:16:20
 
JerryRice
offline
Link
 
How about Speed/Throwing for Dual-Threat QB's?

Could be something like Bootleg Drills?
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 02:27:48
 
Talon
offline
Link
 
I apologize if this has been suggested previously, but I didn't feel like going through 19 pages of previous posts.
Instead of the 'set' pairs now available, how about Bort switches it to two drop-down boxes with each stat in each box. This would make training completely customizable, even allowing someone to double train the same stat on Intense. Or, if the Admins don't like that idea, allow each stat to only be selected once?
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talon
I apologize if this has been suggested previously, but I didn't feel like going through 19 pages of previous posts.
Instead of the 'set' pairs now available, how about Bort switches it to two drop-down boxes with each stat in each box. This would make training completely customizable, even allowing someone to double train the same stat on Intense. Or, if the Admins don't like that idea, allow each stat to only be selected once?


Not gonna happen, sry. Certain combos are intended not to be there.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
one interesting solution would be to allow people training on intense to choose one 'Physical Attribute' and one 'Football Skill'. in other words:
- one from strength/speed/agility/jumping/stamina/vision/confidence
- and one from blocking/tackling/throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting

since i'm bored, here's the list of combos that would be removed:
- Hurdle Drills (+jumping, +stamina)
- Hill Sprints (+speed, +stamina)
- Distance Run (+confidence, +stamina)
- Return Drills (+agility, +vision)
- Leg Press (+strength, +jumping)
- Up Downs (+agility, +stamina)
- Wind Sprints (+speed, +agility)
- Study Game Film (+vision, +confidence)
- Precision Catching Drills (+catching, +carrying)
- Coverage Drills (+jumping, +vision)

and here's the list of combos that would be added:
- strength + catching
- speed + blocking/throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting
- agility + throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting
- jumping + blocking/throwing/carrying/kicking/punting
- stamina + blocking/tackling/throwing/carrying/kicking/punting
- vision + blocking/tackling/catching/carrying/
- confidence + blocking/tackling/throwing/catching/kicking/punting
- blocking + speed/jumping/stamina/vision/confidence
- tackling + stamina/vision/confidence
- throwing + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence
- catching + strength/speed/agility/stamina/confidence
- carrying + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/vision
- kicking + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence
- punting + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence

that's a lot of additional combos (which is the point)... and if i'm understanding the concern undergirding the decision to avoid certain combos, i'm not seeing anything in that list that's any worse than speed+agility (which is currently allowed). another thought would be to do three lists (since 'Physical Attributes' are also split into 'Mental Attributes' on skill_points.pl)...

not an entirely serious suggestion, but i'm just throwing it out there. and yeah, this takes away from the "realism" of naming the training activities, but... how realistic is it for a player to do nothing but sled drills between each game?
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
one interesting solution would be to allow people training on intense to choose one 'Physical Attribute' and one 'Football Skill'. in other words:
- one from strength/speed/agility/jumping/stamina/vision/confidence
- and one from blocking/tackling/throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting

since i'm bored, here's the list of combos that would be removed:
- Hurdle Drills (+jumping, +stamina)
- Hill Sprints (+speed, +stamina)
- Distance Run (+confidence, +stamina)
- Return Drills (+agility, +vision)
- Leg Press (+strength, +jumping)
- Up Downs (+agility, +stamina)
- Wind Sprints (+speed, +agility)
- Study Game Film (+vision, +confidence)
- Precision Catching Drills (+catching, +carrying)
- Coverage Drills (+jumping, +vision)

and here's the list of combos that would be added:
- strength + catching
- speed + blocking/throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting
- agility + throwing/catching/carrying/kicking/punting
- jumping + blocking/throwing/carrying/kicking/punting
- stamina + blocking/tackling/throwing/carrying/kicking/punting
- vision + blocking/tackling/catching/carrying/
- confidence + blocking/tackling/throwing/catching/kicking/punting
- blocking + speed/jumping/stamina/vision/confidence
- tackling + stamina/vision/confidence
- throwing + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence
- catching + strength/speed/agility/stamina/confidence
- carrying + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/vision
- kicking + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence
- punting + speed/agility/jumping/stamina/confidence

that's a lot of additional combos (which is the point)... and if i'm understanding the concern undergirding the decision to avoid certain combos, i'm not seeing anything in that list that's any worse than speed+agility (which is currently allowed). another thought would be to do three lists (since 'Physical Attributes' are also split into 'Mental Attributes' on skill_points.pl)...

not an entirely serious suggestion, but i'm just throwing it out there. and yeah, this takes away from the "realism" of naming the training activities, but... how realistic is it for a player to do nothing but sled drills between each game?


very good idea! i like it!
 
Link
 
Additional Types of Return Drills:
Carrying and Vision
Carrying and Agility
Carrying and Speed
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.