User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Duff Man

If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.


Finally
 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Bort, nothing will make everyone happy. The more you try to please them the more they will want to take. Half of them are spoiled children.


+1
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Duff Man

If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.


As long as we have access to the same information that they have access to, this idea is well on its way to being a solution.
 
Winger
offline
Link
 
Bort, how were these testers chosen?
 
C37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Duff Man

If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.



Two more things:

1) reset SAs
2) tell us about the 80% of all winning teams proven to have cheated using the inside info. numbers don;t lie, there is confirmation as to the percentages
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachviking
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by coachviking



So what is the answer? We can't see the data or "understand it". What is the plan? We at least deserve to know who was doing the tests.


Hate to tell you but gart spilled the beans about having leaked info on builds and tactics from a tester. Any team he's a gm on is now tainted.


Damn Gart Really should have shared with us than.


figured you guys didn't need the help

but seriously, to call any team i'm on tainted, but not the teams that have testers (assuming i'm not a tester) is lulzy.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20

exactly, no one knows if testers are winning rediculous amounts of trophies, so how is that a legit arguement


Exactly, no one knows. So there is no way to know if they are or aren't unless some level of transparency is established.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
http://i.cdn.turner.com/si/pr/subs/swimsuit/images/09_bar-refaeli_10.jpg

Just for a nice change.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
]Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by The Duff Man


If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.



Only if we get to know everyone who ever was a tester also.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by kalkmanc

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by AdmWmsn



In my opinion:

1) This is Borts game, if you don't like it the GTFO you pussies. You think it's not fair, life is not fair.

2) if Bort sees a need for a few testers to help the game for everyone, then so be it.

3) For you whining, crying bastards, maybe your parents should have whipped you more often to show you that life isn't what you want but what it is.

4) This is a virtual game, not real life, if it upsets you that much, again I say GTFO.

5) If a few people have an advantage, so what, that means the largest portion have no advantage, so quit whining.

6) Again, life is what it is, maybe you should get a real one, you whining cocksuckers.


THANK YOU!







Apperently Bort doesn't agree with this.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PP
So create a full copy of each days events (builds, tactics, games, so on, and save it to another server for a set period....hell, even 24 hrs would probably make most ppl happy.


That is fine and well for the future if that's how we go about it, but I can't pull up data that's lost from the past. I don't know what to do about that. I could try and make "open" game pages, but without the info about what when into them and where the code was at when they ran, it's not very helpful. It'd be much more useful to have a tester blog or something to list daily tests & results.


If recreating the past requires serious effort, it's not necessarily that important. I'd rather see a commitment to openness in the future. But the processed information available from a blog doesn't promote trust as much as full access to the data that testers are seeing. It doesn't have to be pretty, just fully inclusive. I'm guessing people will mostly just want to know if their league opponents are testing things that specifically simulate their own teams.

And yeah, I'm sure there is no plan that will please everyone and in fact some people who will be impossible to please. But I think it's possible to reassure 95% of the playerbase with transparency and no significant additional resources.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20


exactly, no one knows if testers are winning rediculous amounts of trophies, so how is that a legit arguement


It's not. I just tend to ignore those types of arguments as it is a battle not worth fighting.

Cbarge, NP...just ignore him from now on, it's not worth it to argue.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Duff Man

If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.


This is all we ever would have asked for.
 
oaklandraider
OAK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by AdmWmsn


In my opinion:

1) This is Borts game, if you don't like it the GTFO you pussies. You think it's not fair, life is not fair.

2) if Bort sees a need for a few testers to help the game for everyone, then so be it.

3) For you whining, crying bastards, maybe your parents should have whipped you more often to show you that life isn't what you want but what it is.

4) This is a virtual game, not real life, if it upsets you that much, again I say GTFO.

5) If a few people have an advantage, so what, that means the largest portion have no advantage, so quit whining.

6) Again, life is what it is, maybe you should get a real one, you whining cocksuckers.


THANK YOU!




 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Duff Man

If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.


Ok, I agree with you here. Duff Man's a smart guy.

I could maybe come up with a game report or something for each game, that lists all player builds...and then figure out a way to make the game results open to outside viewing?

Would probably take a couple days to set up.

In the mean time, I can chat with the current testers and see who wants to stay on and be known as a tester, etc. I could give them forum titles if they want.


if you do this; why not just explain how SAs work; how a tackle is made or missed...etc etc

take away the advantage by telling us directly
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.