User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
You've also squashed any discussion of the original idea because no one will be willing to sort through a dozen pages of you whining. Thanks. I've lost all respect for you for the tactics you've employed here. You've essentially filibustered the thread to your own ends.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 08:28:52
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Tactics? I'm opposed to the OP idea as I quoted and bolded that portion of your OP, explaining why. That the idea on its own is gonna only cause more problems. The idea per se is good, but it should not be implemented on its own on top of the already unstable foundation. It's on topic with your OP.

Are you only after people who agree with the idea and want to add stuff to it? Or are you ALSO ok to have people explain their reasons why they dont like the idea?
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
He continues to get 25XP per day and 90 XP per game on his way to level 32 and so on. However, at the same time he is getting 100 Prestige XP per day and 600 Prestige XP per game towards Prestige Level 2 and so on. By the time the player hits Player Level 32, he'll probably be somwhere are Prestige Level 6 or 7. Boosting will continue to effect Player level but will have no effect on Prestige Level.

Each gain in prestige level will give the player Prestige Skill Points to assign to Prestige attributes.


The bolded bits are imo problematic as outlined in your OP and as further discussed by those contributing to the thread in agreement with your idea.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Explain to me, Drifter, how this idea will help GLB? What are the effects of it GLB-wide? What are the pros and cons? Does it help fix any disparity in the game or create more of it?
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
The only issue I have with it is that there are no performance Boosters for HBs (except Future Coach, since everyone can use Vision). There are a lot of Boosters for Defense, and a few for QBs/WRs, but not any for HBs.

You could make one that makes defenders more likely to bite on an Elusive HBs juke, or make one where a spin is more likely to break a tackle. For Power HBs there could be a Booster that increases how often their SA's are used, or one that lets then drag defenders for a few yards if only 1-2 guys are trying to bring him down.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I dont care if Bort implements your idea to the letter. Because then we can fast forward a couple of months to all the mayhem, arguing, problems, and vicious circle of nerfings that will occur. Just like the current attributes already have caused 4 seasons of constant problems, headaches, arguing, and vicious circle nerfings.

Let's just ignore all the big problems and focus on pandering to the poor vets who are bored that they have to wait so long to level up. Who are seeing their players being caught up to by lower level players and disliking that, wanting to have some new way to further distance their players from those below them.

Everyone always says about people who have ruined players due to tweaks, "oh well tough, waa waa boo hoo, if you dont like that your level 25 player sucks now then retire him and start again". Well, the same could be applied here really. Everyone knew from the get-go that leveling up dries up as your player gets older. That players would catch up. If you dont like that then retire your level 28 player and start again so you can have 600 XP per game.

 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Kcirdor

I dunno, I know exactly what you are saying and you're very convincing. This idea can only be part of a total package repec of the entire game itself. 4 seasons of data should be more than enough data accumulated to hammer out the last few issues with BETA.. Then we can all get our respecs and start "fresh" in Zeta... then 4 seasons of Zeta we can begin Omega. Then hopefully we can go live.


Well, at least there are people out there that acknowledge and see what im getting at. Like Xiong Yoshi said, the odds are no matter how much 'we' make compelling arguments for things and against things, it's in the hands of bort and if he chooses to band-aid things towards going live and having a game falling short of its potential, then that's for him to deal with. There's absolutely zero 'ego' here from me. Nothing to do with my own ideas or anything. Parity > disparity. Money > less money. Noobs > vets. Etc.


noobs should have to struggle up the ranks. and be put into lower leagues. People can be given the option to get a team but have one season to make it to the median. Then they get relegated. No questions asked.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kcirdor

noobs should have to struggle up the ranks. and be put into lower leagues. People can be given the option to get a team but have one season to make it to the median. Then they get relegated. No questions asked.


Ideally. But GLB doesnt want that. They want people/friends to be allowed to buy teams, and fill up their teams with their own tens of hundreds of players. Whether it's pro-league owners bringing in level 10 players that they and friends own. Or BBB team owners who bring in level 30 players they own. And, always having the ability to create new level 1 players to eventually replace their retiring players. To have a free market etc.

On these points I agree with GLB.


Last edited Aug 27, 2008 09:01:38
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Explain to me, Drifter, how this idea will help GLB? What are the effects of it GLB-wide? What are the pros and cons? Does it help fix any disparity in the game or create more of it?


How will it help.....GG, get a player over level 30 and see how much fun it is. It's called giving players who reach the point where leveling barely even happens anymore something to do. And guess what, it took those of us who are there less than 4 seasons to do so. So that means over half a player's career will be spent at the timeframe being referred to here. That's quite a bit.

Effects of it GLB-wide....Those over level 30 will actually have something to do, people can actually differentiate their players more and have more to do with their players. People under level 30 will get to level 30 within 4 seasons and reach that point and be happy to have something to do.

Pros....covered above.

Cons....Short-term, there would be a slightly larger disparity between those over and under level 30. Long-term, players who are level 30 will most likely be playing players who are mostly close to their level. I hope Bort goes with the idea to move sold teams to the bottom tier, which will eliminate teams of level 3's facing level 35's. And hopefully he'll put in sportsmanship penalties which will keep higher-level players out of lower leagues. But without things like that, it'll strengthen the difference between low and high-level players.

Disparity.....covered above. Bort already has 2 great ideas to prevent it, it's just hopefully a matter of time to put them in place.

Originally posted by Dianwei32
The only issue I have with it is that there are no performance Boosters for HBs (except Future Coach, since everyone can use Vision). There are a lot of Boosters for Defense, and a few for QBs/WRs, but not any for HBs.


That's why Bort asked for other ideas
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
It wont differentiate players from one another because there are going to be 1 or 2 prestige abilities that everyone of a certain position will sink their points into. It is just going to be another status quo with the rich getting richer.

The "slight" disparity will actually double what it is now -- which I do not see how anyone could say it is a good thing. Since prestige levels will be gained relatively fast (compared to normal levels) what ground people were making with people in the plateau of XP are now losing ground via prestige XP. If the XP system increased the XP required per level, instead of XP gained depending on level you would see a whole different scenario where parity would slowly be achieved by lower levels closing the gap -- however now once people hit 28 it is a stalemate in terms of relative level.. however with this suggestion once people hit 31 they start to pull away even further from the people just below them.

Parity wont be achieved through those two (though they will help a bit), but if someone wants to bring a level 45 P14 (prestige 14) to a BBB league and wreck shit up ultimately there is nothing stopping them, especially if they are on their decline of stats anyways so they are not earning XP. Nonetheless, that talk should probably be saved for another thread.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 09:43:39
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
edit: whoops, hit quote instead of edit
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 09:43:20
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by otto_g_2k8

This is an absolutely fantastic idea. I like Bort's Idea of it being VETERAN Special Abilities rather than calling it prestige. I also think it would be best if these SAs were not position specific, but SAs that apply to ALL positions. I'm thinking a "Veteran SA Tree" that is entirely about mental attributes.

Here is my take on it:

GENERAL MECHANICS:
There would be FIVE SAs on the veteran tree and the SP cost of these would work exactly like the current trees as far as the SP cost to build them up. You could not put any points into the Veteran SA Tree until you reached LVL 25. (this way there is no need to keep track of separate XP or "Prestige Levels" ... instead you just use the Five SPs you get for leveling up to build them if you choose) I chose LVL 25, since this is the point in time when a player really slows down and starts to get a little dull to manage. Also, the previous level (24) you just had the excitement of upgrading your equipment, and this will make that first really slow "level-up" really worth it!

VETERAN SPECIAL ABILITIES:
1. LOCKER ROOM LEADER: This player knows just what to say and when to say it. He also inspires his teammates with his tireless work ethic. Anytime this player steps on the field, his teammates play just a little harder as they don't want to let him down. (think Ray Lewis or Teddy Brushci)
2. FOOTBALL SMARTS: This player has seen it all and knows what to do about it. When this player is on the field, he will recognize what the other team is doing and call out adjustments/audibles if his teammates are not in position to make the play. (Think Mike Singletary)
3. AWE: This players reputation precedes him. Younger players (perhaps 5 levels lower, or perhaps anyone who doesn't have this ability themselves) are starstruck when competing against him and make more mental mistakes. Also effects refs, who, when a call is close, will give this player the benefit of the doubt. (Think Deion Sanders)
4. CLUTCH PLAYER: This player plays his best when the game is on the line. While others fear the pressure, he thrives on it. (think Roger Staubach or John Elway)
5. CHAMPION (or perhaps PLAYOFF PRO): This player doesn't feel the pressure of the playoffs, but rather his performance actually increases as the stakes get higher. (think Otto Graham or Joe Montana)((also activates in regular season games where the playoffs are on the line))

I think by having the "Veteran Special Abilities" the same for all positions and having it cost SP in the same fashion as the current SA trees, it will make those 5 SPs that you get after waiting half a season to level up WAY more useful and worth waiting for.



No SA tree. No specific position related "Perks". That's one area I agree strongly with GG on. There's already too much tunnel vision in creating players. This idea works withing the existing system to provide more branching out. Let's not continue with that.

Also, normal SPs need to stay completely separate from the VP points. The issue is with the too-slow accumulation of SPs at higher levels. Making new trees work off the same SP system doesn't solve the problem.


I think it does solve the problem, since these "VETERAN SAs" would have a very strong effect on the players performance. When you hit LVL 25 and get those five SPs, are you going to pointlessly add to your Speed Stat and get an increase of only one or two points? Or ... are you going to put those five points into building up your veteran SAs. I personally find the game enjoyable for my LVL 25 CB still. Having spent a couple seasons building him to where he is now, my main fun with him is the GAMES. I plan on taking him to a team that is on the verge of being a winner, and be able to stand out as a star on that team. Wouldn't it be nice to be able to pump some points into "LOCKER ROOM LEADER" and make the whole team better?

The "Prestige Level" (while a fantastic idea) system would be really hard to implement with existing players, whereas the "Veteran SA Tree" could be added and everyone would be on the same footing with it. When first added, NO-ONE would have any points in it. If you have a LVL 30 player and you boost him, you all the sudden have something really fun to do with those points. (and if you do boost, it will work just as well as a retroactive fix for that tree) I tried to make the "Veteran Special Abilities" completely different than anything in the current SA trees and universal to all positions, so that it would be something that specifically would address boredom at the high levels, and encourage high level players to continue boosting and being active.

NOTE regarding GGs "parity" suggestions:
Why on earth would we want to even out teams that are unequal in levels? That would destroy the whole point of getting to those high levels. It would also create even more "slow build" teams and gutted teams full of level 1 players, since it would just even out the matchup. Personally I love the fact that there is disparity between teams, and I think the current Promotion/Relegation system is designed to slowly but surely get every team in the league they belong in. My only issue with the current system, is that when someone takes over an existing team that has been gutted, they shouldn't have to remain in a league they can't compete in. I've seen some great ideas to deal with this already, so I won't address that any further.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Jed...

The pros above are okayish, but a lot of what bort has already planned for season 5 addresses that without having to give players another tier of levels.

The cons above are quite significant (imo). Enough to take a slowly-slowly approach with developing the OP far more before implementing it sooner than later. Like I emphasize, slapped on top of the current system of disparity is going to cause major problems (imo).

I am interested to see where Bort tweaks drifter's idea and tailors it to address all those cons. I'll only give my honest objective opinion, like i always do, and if Bort turns this idea into something stable then I'll say so and endorse it. But the current OP idea and how it would be slapped on top bothers my sense of fair play and concerns about the possible effects.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Remember the rigid stance by GLB just weeks ago? "It's important that new/noob players are able to catch up to vet players, and they will! It's not impossible, it will only take a few seasons, everything will be fine, it's important to ensure there's parity over time."

What happened to that? I 'fear' that this idea is just going to destroy all that even more. Also because when they get there and realize all the big problems requiring nerfing of prestige attributes and then all the complaints about needing prestige re-specs because their builds are further ruined by the constant tweaks/nerfs occuring in prestige builds.

 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Remember the rigid stance by GLB just weeks ago? "It's important that new/noob players are able to catch up to vet players, and they will! It's not impossible, it will only take a few seasons, everything will be fine, it's important to ensure there's parity over time."

What happened to that? I 'fear' that this idea is just going to destroy all that even more. Also because when they get there and realize all the big problems requiring nerfing of prestige attributes and then all the complaints about needing prestige re-specs because their builds are further ruined by the constant tweaks/nerfs occuring in prestige builds.



The "Veteran SA Tree" that I proposed won't. I support the concept proposed by Drifter, just not his specific idea of how to implement it. Say you have a LVL 25 CB who has reached the soft cap on speed. He puts his next five SPs into LOCKER ROOM LEADER (winding up with a score of 3 in that SA) and actually (in essence) raises up by a slight bit the Basic Attributes of the players around him. (would be a great reason for this player to go to a team that is struggling against tough competition and help them out) Also, since this thread is about making the game more interesting for HIGHER LEVEL players, it really shouldn't be filled with talk about creating parity. I think you should start a completely different thread for that, and let this thread be about perfecting the idea presented by Drifter.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 10:07:03
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.