User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
porkies
offline
Link
 
I think you're mixing up during game and after game.
During game you can go down to really really low. Immediately after the game everyone is reset to 60.

Well, if you went below 60 you get reset to 60 that is.

One more edit, so you have to figure out what the incentive is to be at 100 energy at the begining of the game. Bort is working on figuring that in to the calculations currently.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 09:31:08
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
My first experience with the new energy system has been a little disappointing. My center basically split time with his back-up.

My guy played 47 plays, the CPU back-up played 41. My guy was level 12 at the time of the game and had a stamina of 30. The back-up is a Lvl 4, I don't know what his stamina is. Last season the split seemed much better for the two players in question - much closer to a 75/25 which I felt was pretty solid, actually.

I've been reading the threads about energy and stamina and it's pretty confusing - I appreciate the time and effort put into it and post this merely as feedback.

One of the big problems I'm seeing is that GLB seems to be making the EA Sports mistake of having a player basically gas out and then sit so the back-ups play the last part of the game when the actual game is on the line.

We do need back-ups involved in the game and depth needs to matter but starters have to play in the fourth quarter of football games. The system has to move towards having back-ups come in for a play every now and again, to spell the starter for a series at most or more likely a set of downs, but not just take over the position as the game goes on.

I went over the play-by-play and my center played the first half only - with the lone exception of a special teams play where he was on the kick return team.

It's one example and one game. Perhaps it's an anomaly. Thanks.



 
nightmare4145
offline
Link
 
what is your play intensity set at hard, normal, or relaxed? if you are playing on hard you will play harder buy tire out alot faster. I have found that normal works to keep you in for most of the plays if that is what you want. also if you find your energy going to fast have your owner or GM take you off of special teams to conserve it. hope this helps.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 09:34:58
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
mcnorth do you think it might be resolved with a different sub in/out setting?
I get the impression that the norm in GLB is to run the #1 into the ground almost, then bring in the #2 and run him into the ground, whereas in the real thing a player will come out for a couple of plays to catch his breath and then go back in.

I'm not an owner but can this be replicated using the current in/out system or are the intricacies lacking, so people go with their current setting as they have no choice?
Is it a case of everyone reading the forum that says "use xx/yy" so they do and nobody is experimenting anymore? For an early beta game with changes being made all the time, I'd think experimentation was key right now?

my 2p (or 4 cents if you prefer)
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the responses. Just trying to figure this out (like everyone else ).

I was playing on hard. That may be part of the problem - although the coach asked us to play on hard last year also. I'd assume my back-up was playing on hard also... do coaches control the level of play intensity of the CPU players. Maybe he's trying to screw me over, cagey CPU'er. lol

The team settings are apparently something to the affect of out at 50, back in at 75.

We're discussing this presently. Any suggestions?
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 09:40:58
 
moy23
offline
Link
 
I'm too lazy to read 18 pages so I will just ask....

Whats the general concensus, is it the owners settings or the players settings (hard/norm/relax) that are the biggest factor in starters not getting enough PT?

How big of a role is Stam playing in this? For instance - My level 7 HB is in on 38 plays for game 1, before next game I boost 5 on STAM... what can I expect the next game if all settings remain the same?
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 09:55:31
 
moy23
offline
Link
 
btw - I don't own a team so I don't even know what the owners can and can not set.
 
dudley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TundaKlap
Originally posted by dudley

Originally posted by Elijah wilgis


BROWN NOSERS.............................THIS SUCKS FOR EVERYONE WHO DOSENT HAVE AMAZING STAMINA......................


It's great for all the new players who are backups. It's adding more strategy to the game. It might need a tweak for D linemen, but other than that it makes it more realistic.




I'm late to the ballgame here, and without reading the other pages...

I think the rate you lose energy in the game is great. It allows depth on the chart. However for the time in between games you should be able to regenerate all your energy just fine. I know d-linemen got hit hard with this, and I understand they need to sub out a lot. Problem is, they're ready to go for the next game. If you drop below 70 every game while playing on normal intensity with decent sub in/out settings, you'll eventually run out of energy of the course of a few games.

The main thing in my mind is to have stamina actually do something. I don't understand why there even was a stamina bar the first season. It didn't do much of anything during the game or afterwards.
I can get behind what you're saying. A team in real life will run the crap out of the ball to wear the defense down so they're gassed in the fourth quarter, not for the next game.

 
hostyle
offline
Link
 
Stamina should always go back to 100 after every game. Injuries is whats going to make a team need depth from game to game. Energy should determine depth, quarter to quarter.
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I wouldn't mind guys wearing down a bit during the season - as long as everyone is - so what's the point of worrying about that too much really if it's a global thing, everyone is banged up...

What I want is stamina to tire out the starters and make them somewhat less effective based upon their position and stamina. What I don't want to see is the back-ups taking over entirely. It just doesn't happen like that.
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hostyle
Stamina should always go back to 100 after every game. Injuries is whats going to make a team need depth from game to game. Energy should determine depth, quarter to quarter.


Series to series would be even better.
 
crag79
offline
Link
 
Actually this is going to work out like it should if you can find the perfect setting you should end a game with about 68 energy. With 2 days of relaxed training you are back to 98% for the next game. Than another game where you go down to say 66 or so and gain back to 96%. Certain games will be more or less but by the end of the season you are down around 70-75% energy just like you would be IRL.
 
PhireHawk
offline
Link
 
I don't mind the new changes, don't get me wrong, but it needs to be re-thought.

A QB, for example, should not lose the same amount of energy as an Offensive or Defensive Lineman. Regardless of snaps.

Especially if it's a pocket passing QB.

That's just an example, it shouldn't be limited to just QBs. I've got 24 stamina on my guy, and he lost 40 stamina on 84 plays on Normal Intensity. He didn't get sacked at all, and was only hurried twice.

That's a little ridiculous, IMO
 
dudley
offline
Link
 
QB's don't lose energy as fast as D linemen. If you had a D lineman play 84 plays-even on relaxed he'd be crawling by the end. You might just have to invest in some stamina. 24's not much for a level 13 player.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PhireHawk
I don't mind the new changes, don't get me wrong, but it needs to be re-thought.

A QB, for example, should not lose the same amount of energy as an Offensive or Defensive Lineman. Regardless of snaps.

Especially if it's a pocket passing QB.

That's just an example, it shouldn't be limited to just QBs. I've got 24 stamina on my guy, and he lost 40 stamina on 84 plays on Normal Intensity. He didn't get sacked at all, and was only hurried twice.

That's a little ridiculous, IMO


I don't know why your QB lost so much energy. Our QB played on normal, played 68 snaps (most of anyone on our team) and only lost 9 energy. The only guy I know of on our team that lost 40 energy was a player with near-minimum stamina who played 48 snaps at DT against much higher level players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.