User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sachem
Well if you are going to call Catholics narrowminded for that you can call every other religion narrow minded. Do not forget that The Jews were persecuted, The Catholics were persecuted, the Muslims were persecuted, etc... Aldo do not forget that the Crusades had wars inbetween where muslims slaughtered Christians, and so on and so forth..
As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


But isn't humanities most favourable choice in life the one that makes him the happiest?
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
If you knew anything about Catholicism you would know that we actually have a very long prayer we say on Good Friday asking for those that do not believe to be given the strength to live properly and thereby enter the Kingdom. But hey Im in error so what would I know.

The real strength of your faith is to question it and see it as others see it. Maybe you should try some time.

To the guy who brought up Darwinism. Hey dont tar us all with the same brush. Im happy to be descended from, to quote South Park, a retarded monkey. Evolution is so much more sensible than "God put the dinosaurs in the ground 10000 years ago! Vote McCain!"....
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:02:32
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
I do consider myself a Darwinist and a Catholic.

The people you mentioned didnt have a choice, and yes Catholics are against hysterectomies. But those little things have nothing to do with being saved or not like this thread spoke about. I never said Catholics were dead on right about everything, i have jsut found that Catholics views to be the closest overall to my personal beliefs and the community i have found as a catholic has been great and very supportive.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
If you knew anything about Catholicism you would know that we actually have a very long prayer we say on Good Friday asking for those that do not believe to be given the strength to live properly and thereby enter the Kingdom. But hey Im in error so what would I know.



Cool. I would just like to extend my thanks to your church gang for thinking about us.

 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Ok bit of background for ya, I'm a catholic p much, done all my sacraments go to a catholic school and all that. I don't believe in God or any of that though. I don't have a problem with people who do. The problem with stuff like the prayer mentioned above is
that it's not giving them a blessing or anything like that. It's telling God to bring them over to Catholasism. thats what it means by living properly, it's your idea of properly not theirs.
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
Originally posted by Sachem

Well if you are going to call Catholics narrowminded for that you can call every other religion narrow minded. Do not forget that The Jews were persecuted, The Catholics were persecuted, the Muslims were persecuted, etc... Aldo do not forget that the Crusades had wars inbetween where muslims slaughtered Christians, and so on and so forth..
As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


But isn't humanities most favourable choice in life the one that makes him the happiest?


No being happy has nothing to do with being a GOOD person. It would make me happy to have the Benz i just saw some guy driving, but I am not going to go steal his car.

 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
Ok bit of background for ya, I'm a catholic p much, done all my sacraments go to a catholic school and all that. I don't believe in God or any of that though. I don't have a problem with people who do. The problem with stuff like the prayer mentioned above is
that it's not giving them a blessing or anything like that. It's telling God to bring them over to Catholasism. thats what it means by living properly, it's your idea of properly not theirs.


I also went thru catholic schools and never once in 16 years was I taught that you had to be catholic or even christian to be saved, it was always taught that living your life by good morals and helping your fellow man out was what counted. Perhaps i had more liberal schools because catholics and non catholics were all welcomed

 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sachem
Originally posted by cheese12

Originally posted by Sachem


Well if you are going to call Catholics narrowminded for that you can call every other religion narrow minded. Do not forget that The Jews were persecuted, The Catholics were persecuted, the Muslims were persecuted, etc... Aldo do not forget that the Crusades had wars inbetween where muslims slaughtered Christians, and so on and so forth..
As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


But isn't humanities most favourable choice in life the one that makes him the happiest?


No being happy has nothing to do with being a GOOD person. It would make me happy to have the Benz i just saw some guy driving, but I am not going to go steal his car.



thats just silly i meant like long term happy and reasonable you dickwad
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:06:33
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Guys, I am leaving the office so I have to go, but great conversation so far, i will check in later to see what everyone has to say. Talk to you all later.
 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sachem
Originally posted by cheese12

Ok bit of background for ya, I'm a catholic p much, done all my sacraments go to a catholic school and all that. I don't believe in God or any of that though. I don't have a problem with people who do. The problem with stuff like the prayer mentioned above is
that it's not giving them a blessing or anything like that. It's telling God to bring them over to Catholasism. thats what it means by living properly, it's your idea of properly not theirs.


I also went thru catholic schools and never once in 16 years was I taught that you had to be catholic or even christian to be saved, it was always taught that living your life by good morals and helping your fellow man out was what counted. Perhaps i had more liberal schools because catholics and non catholics were all welcomed



My schools like that to, i never said you had to be catholic to be "saved" i just don't believe i need to be saved is all, that prayer was basically saying that worshipping God is the proper way to live, you can believe that if you want..... Just don't try to make me
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
Originally posted by Sachem

Originally posted by cheese12


Originally posted by Sachem



Well if you are going to call Catholics narrowminded for that you can call every other religion narrow minded. Do not forget that The Jews were persecuted, The Catholics were persecuted, the Muslims were persecuted, etc... Aldo do not forget that the Crusades had wars inbetween where muslims slaughtered Christians, and so on and so forth..
As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


But isn't humanities most favourable choice in life the one that makes him the happiest?


No being happy has nothing to do with being a GOOD person. It would make me happy to have the Benz i just saw some guy driving, but I am not going to go steal his car.



So you think gay people can't be good people...... And thats just silly i meant like long term happy and reasonable you dickwad


OK, name calling is childish so i wont respond to that. But no i didnt say gay people were bad, i just said that i didnt understand it from a anatomical standpoint, and that that is the only problem i have ever heard from the church concerning gay relations.
 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Yeah alright thats fair enough but i still think that the church has to learn to accept different stand points than it's own on issues like this a little better
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
The mass executions of Muslims back in the crusades narrow minded.


Things happen during times of war. The so-called "crusades" were in many ways a reaction to the spread of Islam. Were you to study the history of the spread of Islam, you would find that it was spread by the sword and not by convincing oration. That doesn't make everything that the "Christians" did ok--again, it merely provides as a broader context for what took place.

 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Ugh I try to be like awesome and kick ass and my alcoholic self and someone has to go say stuff like "your prayer is for God to convert us". Its not. That would be like against the whole freedom of choice thing. Its about just praying for everyone no matter what they believe. Im on youre side. Not the scary fundamentalist peoples'.

In truth part of it is the other Christians cant drink as much as us catholics so when we get to heaven we want plenty of atheists and stuff around to give us a challenge. Anyone thinks this is blasphemy - we have like patron saints of beer and vodka.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
Tiny fact here, the muslims where killing in war, the christians said the Muslims were barbaric yes? well then the Christians took back Jerusalem Killed every Muslim for miles around and washed the city in Muslim blood.... sounds as little barbaric to me... Does anyone know what Saladin washed the city in when he took it back? Rosewater

The christians were killed invading a land that wasn't theirs and during battles. The Muslims were killed in their own land, with with a large portion being executed outside of battles


well, a couple things:
- of the 40,000 non-christians slaughtered by the crusaders at jerusalem, most were jewish... but there were also a lot of oriental chrisitans, coptic christians, and muslims in the mix.
- indeed, what we think of 'muslim' now wasn't really a coalesced marker of identity then... most spoke in terms of 'saracens' or even 'moors'. point of fact: saladin was a kurd, not an arab.

the tribal arabs were traditionally quite war-like... and grouping under a common banner (in this case islam) turned them into a significant force. they had already crushed the sassanid (persian) empire and were vying with the seljuk turks for byzantine lands (which is why the emperor asked the pope for help in the first place).

however, it is a colossal mistake to assume that even their version of islam was somehow inherently violent... just as it would be a mistake to assume that christianity is inherently violent based on the actions of a bunch of illiterate crusaders (i.e. hadn't read the bible). unfortunately, all discussions of the crusades now have contemporary ramifications... which gets further distorted by the fact that people want things both ways. if you have a sophisticated enough view of christianity to properly parse between belief and believer, then you have to allow the same for islam.

and yes, on the whole, pan-arab civilization at that time was far more humanitarian than that of western europe. consider that the first hospitals were muslim... and they treated enemy wounded first.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.