User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by j10er

Originally posted by vtech9


this play pissed me off to right at the start of the game. This is my CB, and I KNOW he is set to Close/Aggressive coverage, so why is he playing 10 yards off of the damn WR?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105103&pbp_id=2044554


Once again, Prevent Defense. Talk to your DC - has nothing to do with personal settings.


I AM THE DC. THERE WAS NO PREVENT IN OUR SETTINGS. I know because I set them.


I won't tell you how to run your business and I won't explain why you are in prevent, but that is a Prevent defense.
 
phazool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by j10er

Originally posted by vtech9


this play pissed me off to right at the start of the game. This is my CB, and I KNOW he is set to Close/Aggressive coverage, so why is he playing 10 yards off of the damn WR?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105103&pbp_id=2044554


Once again, Prevent Defense. Talk to your DC - has nothing to do with personal settings.


I AM THE DC. THERE WAS NO PREVENT IN OUR SETTINGS. I know because I set them.


You were definitely playing cover-4 based on the actions of your players. The outside corners dropped to cover the deep zones. The slot corner took one short zone and one linebacker took the other (the proof of this is the way the slot corner passed off the deep receiver on the right side to the deep zone corner and picked up the player running a short route). Your other linebacker blitzed-meaning you had 2 players to cover the 3 offensive players running short/medium routes.

Cover 4 is also known as the prevent defense.
 
vtech9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phazool
Originally posted by vtech9

Originally posted by j10er


Originally posted by vtech9



this play pissed me off to right at the start of the game. This is my CB, and I KNOW he is set to Close/Aggressive coverage, so why is he playing 10 yards off of the damn WR?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105103&pbp_id=2044554


Once again, Prevent Defense. Talk to your DC - has nothing to do with personal settings.


I AM THE DC. THERE WAS NO PREVENT IN OUR SETTINGS. I know because I set them.


You were definitely playing cover-4 based on the actions of your players. The outside corners dropped to cover the deep zones. The slot corner took one short zone and one linebacker took the other (the proof of this is the way the slot corner passed off the deep receiver on the right side to the deep zone corner and picked up the player running a short route). Your other linebacker blitzed-meaning you had 2 players to cover the 3 offensive players running short/medium routes.

Cover 4 is also known as the prevent defense.


I know what it is, what I'm saying is that it never should have happened.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by phazool

Originally posted by vtech9


Originally posted by j10er



Originally posted by vtech9




this play pissed me off to right at the start of the game. This is my CB, and I KNOW he is set to Close/Aggressive coverage, so why is he playing 10 yards off of the damn WR?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105103&pbp_id=2044554


Once again, Prevent Defense. Talk to your DC - has nothing to do with personal settings.


I AM THE DC. THERE WAS NO PREVENT IN OUR SETTINGS. I know because I set them.


You were definitely playing cover-4 based on the actions of your players. The outside corners dropped to cover the deep zones. The slot corner took one short zone and one linebacker took the other (the proof of this is the way the slot corner passed off the deep receiver on the right side to the deep zone corner and picked up the player running a short route). Your other linebacker blitzed-meaning you had 2 players to cover the 3 offensive players running short/medium routes.

Cover 4 is also known as the prevent defense.


I know what it is, what I'm saying is that it never should have happened.


I don't know if this is the same thing, but let me put it this way.

In the old sims, in order to blitz the ROLB and MLB... the defense AI had to call that zone blitz with the RE moving back into coverage. That's just how it was, because that was the only play in the inventory to use for that kind of blitz.

You called for something in this game (I don't know what so you'll have to figure it out yourself)... and that play call overrode your coverage call.

Last edited Aug 7, 2008 20:00:32
 
phazool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by phazool

Originally posted by vtech9


Originally posted by j10er



Originally posted by vtech9




this play pissed me off to right at the start of the game. This is my CB, and I KNOW he is set to Close/Aggressive coverage, so why is he playing 10 yards off of the damn WR?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105103&pbp_id=2044554


Once again, Prevent Defense. Talk to your DC - has nothing to do with personal settings.


I AM THE DC. THERE WAS NO PREVENT IN OUR SETTINGS. I know because I set them.


You were definitely playing cover-4 based on the actions of your players. The outside corners dropped to cover the deep zones. The slot corner took one short zone and one linebacker took the other (the proof of this is the way the slot corner passed off the deep receiver on the right side to the deep zone corner and picked up the player running a short route). Your other linebacker blitzed-meaning you had 2 players to cover the 3 offensive players running short/medium routes.

Cover 4 is also known as the prevent defense.


I know what it is, what I'm saying is that it never should have happened.


Seems like if that was the case then you wouldn't have been complaining that your CB ignored individual tactics, but that the sim ignored your AI settings.

But, as kinglehr said, you need to check your AI settings, and have them double-checked by someone else if you don't find the problem. It's easy to set up conflicting calls or click the wrong thing, or miss a box, whatever.
 
Clinton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by pureenergy

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92313&pbp_id=1574705

I mean come on. This is getting dumb.


what is the confidence of your CB there?


I'm not so sure confidence is a factor. My CB has low confidence but his agility and speed make him a mobile wonder averaging 5 to 10 tackles a game at only level 10. His stamina is even crap. For some reason he just is able to stick with the receivers.

Could it be that SA's have become miss calculated and things like First Step and Close Coverage are out of whack?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaRealest

You're STILL complaining?!


The AI still sucks.
 
GridironGuru
offline
Link
 
I think I found the problem with the CBs giving so much room.

Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by NYUfresh

question, the "coverage distance" setting, will it over-ride the individual tactics of how close to cover a man, or is it meaning how deep you cover a man or something?


It's how deep the safeties are playing, mostly (or CB's in zone). Really only affects players who are playing zone; not man.



If your coverage setting is at medium like mine was in the plays I posted, it gives way too much space to the receivers. I'm moving it to short to see if it corrects it.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GridironGuru
I think I found the problem with the CBs giving so much room.

Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by NYUfresh


question, the "coverage distance" setting, will it over-ride the individual tactics of how close to cover a man, or is it meaning how deep you cover a man or something?


It's how deep the safeties are playing, mostly (or CB's in zone). Really only affects players who are playing zone; not man.



If your coverage setting is at medium like mine was in the plays I posted, it gives way too much space to the receivers. I'm moving it to short to see if it corrects it.


Good find/analysis.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Enkidu98

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=94786&pbp_id=2078404

Mid 60's Speed, Just under 50 Agility, low 40's vision

Not the only example of this sort of play. Close Coverage/Aggressive per coach. I have coverage on the WR but then seem to freeze horribly.

Is this the result of Pump Fakes, or are the offensive tweaks/coverage tweaks a little too much.

Just not sure why the player just stands there.


pump fake.


Gotcha Bort,

That's pretty brutal. I can see being briefly stunned and allowing the receiver to get a catch, but to stand there dumbfounded is a bit too much, especially if you watch how often that happened in the game. The CB should miss the opportunity for an interception for sure, and it should turn into a reception, but cornerbacks at our level of play shouldn't just all of a sudden forget how to tackle or recover fast enough to get on their man.

I don't mind giving up receptions at all, its the standing their drooling and looking like a complete idiot for a second or two while the receiver takes off running.

Last edited Aug 8, 2008 06:44:30
 
phazool
offline
Link
 
That's exactly what should happen if you're playing close/aggressive and bite hard on a good pump fake. Your CB tried to jump a route but guessed wrong and got beat bad. That is far more realistic than what was going on before. There are plays like that in the NFL all the time.

That's appropriate risk/reward-you play aggressively in the hopes of shutting down a receiver or getting a pick, but you should be taking the chance that you are going to be beaten badly sometimes by the competition. Good corners should get beat when they're playing ultra-aggressively if you're looking for a realistic sim.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
There is getting beat and then there is standing their completely ineffectively for a significant amount of time. I don't mind being beat. I mind being beat and then standing their drooling for a few seconds before doing anything else.

I talked to the QB for the other team. He's got a _significant_ Pump Fake skill. Which is cool, just think maybe Bort wants to look at its effectiveness because it completely neutralises the corners and I do not think the intent was to be that significant.

Again. I don't mind getting beat. I understand my CB can't and shouldn't be 'perfect'. I do think that the length of time spent 'confused' is far too long.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
The way it is in GLB: a pump fake causes the DB to freeze, then the ball is thrown, the ball is caught, and the WR takes off running, then the DB unfreezes.

They way it is in reality, and the way it should be in GLB: a pump fake fools a CB BEFORE the ball is thrown. By the time the ball IS thrown, the CB is already recovering. The WR is more likely to be open, but the CB can still participate in the rest of the play.

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
The possible issue is that Borts "reaction" delay hits the CB multiple times one that one play. He suffers a delay reacting to the WR. Then a delay reading the Pump Fake, then a delay reading the pass and a delay reading the WR again. Or something.

One mistake can kind of steamroll into a more severe mistake.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
The way it is in GLB: a pump fake causes the DB to freeze, then the ball is thrown, the ball is caught, and the WR takes off running, then the DB unfreezes.

They way it is in reality, and the way it should be in GLB: a pump fake fools a CB BEFORE the ball is thrown. By the time the ball IS thrown, the CB is already recovering. The WR is more likely to be open, but the CB can still participate in the rest of the play.



Exactly.

I would say play should go like this in general terms.

Sim determines receiver that is most open twice. The First time a pass is not attempted but a pump fake is. This has a chance to freeze the defenders or cause them to start moving towards the chosen target of the pump fake. Then a second pass attempt is made after determining which receiver is most open after the effects of the pump fake. But by this time all defenders should be unfrozen.

Defenders that are fast and already moved towards the direction they thought the play was going, will be hampered if their agility etc does not allow them to make a quick recovery. But they shouldn't remain just standing there. Defenders with Adequate agility and speed should be able to recover slightly. They will likely give up more yardage on the play by having been fooled, but they wont be removed from the play entirely for several tics before 'waking up'.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.