User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Dee

Originally posted by wombat killer




Just because it happened doesn't mean it is a good thing. Maybe the "death spiral" is so unrealistic it needs to be looked at. Or maybe other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it.



Possibly, but then how worthless would Confidence be?
This thread has more or less proven the worth of confidence. We remove the need to have confidence, a QB needs 3 stats? Throwing/Strength/Vision?
If his QB had only 29 throwing, and had this bad of a game, would we be asking the sim to be changed so that 29 throwing at level 25 is enough?

Its our job as the players to try to find the good builds. Lesson to be learned is that confidence AT TIMES, is more important than any other stat. How important it is? I dont know.


I didn't say it shouldn't have an impact. Of course it should. My comment about other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it wasn't about stats. It was about being able to pull a very poorly performing player.


Yup, and it makes sense to be able to pull a HB after 3 fumbles, or a QB after 4 ints. I'd agree with settings like that going in.

Something like that will probably come in when Injuries come in, and having minor injuries you can play through, but with stat loss. Settings needed to choose how much of a stat loss your willing to take before sitting the injured player (and like you said, sitting poor performers)
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi





As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



Yeah there was. There have been many games with tons of interceptions.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=46818

7 interceptions.

And yes, 52 stamina may not be greedy, but it's stupid. People have already said that your QB has a crap build. Deal with it.



If this game purports to sim (American) football, there's simply no justifying a 10 interception game in the PLAYOFFS. If "the build" were the problem, an accurate sim would have prevented us from ever reaching that game.




Seriously, give it up, blow your $20 on crack, and go have a better time then, there is nothing wrong with the sim that Bort isn't already fixing, your QB build was freaking brutal, I'm surprised he had the confidence to put on the pads let alone get on the field, Yes, I know, 15 picks all season, now 10 in one game, boohoo this isn't football yadda yadda yadda, DESPITE EVERYONE HAVING SHOWN YOU STATS THAT PROVE, HELLO, YES IT IS FOOTBALL, you are now just crying over something stupid. How in the hell did this turn into a 17 page thread anyways,


 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
How in the hell did this turn into a 17 page thread anyways,




By folks smarter than yourself discussing and debating the finer points of a game attempting to simulate American football and the pitfalls associated with it in its current state.

 
Dee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
How in the hell did this turn into a 17 page thread anyways,


Because this thread is fun, shows a record being broken, and puts new life into confidence for me.

Despite Bort saying confidence is important, I still undervalued it. Never again
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



FYI - My MLB has higher confidence than your QB.
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
Everyone take a deep breath. I'm on the team as well but I want the steamroller to stop a second. We made our point, we don't want the game resimmed. But I think Larry has pointed out there are some major problems in the coding that need to be ironed out before the drapes are hung on the windows if you get my meaning.

I think the complaints wouldn't be so vehement if people weren't spending so much money on this game. Once that started, call it beta all you want, but you opened yourselves up to a whole new level of scrutiny.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi




As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



FYI - My MLB has higher confidence than your QB.


My level 13 QB has higher throwing and comparable confidence/vision. EDIT - and I *still* regularly throw interceptions cause the RNG hates me.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 18:45:57
 
Link
 
What you guys aren't understanding is that our gameplan, I'm speaking on behalf of the Miami Perfection, we played against the pass because we knew that's how you would beat us. Our run defense is pretty good as our defensive line is lead by Jake Pariah and those who are in USA AA#1, know that he's no slouch, probably best defense player in USA AA#1. We have a great middle linebacker who guards the run and solid outside linebackers who can play the pass. Our cornerback position is EXTREMELY deep and because of our overall good front seven, they make turnovers year in and year out.

Look, I feel for you guys losing big time... We went out the first round to an eight season last year in the playoffs because we threw tons of interceptions but we took it in stride because we had no other choice.

Asking for a refund or a re-sim is a complete disrespect to the opposition because I spent a few hours scouting your team and had a pretty indepth analysis that other Perfection members can vouch for. Did you guys deserve to lose like you did? No. But give us credit instead of acting like the game just screwed you over completely.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by sjmay

How in the hell did this turn into a 17 page thread anyways,




By folks smarter than yourself discussing and debating the finer points of a game attempting to simulate American football and the pitfalls associated with it in its current state.



Well that and you crying over and over again, BUT ITS A PLAYOFF GAME, like that was going to make people say, omg, hey wait, its a playoff game,

You played Miami the 3rd game of the season, let's assume you guys were boosted and they werent, then what, 14 games later you play them again, and they boosted, and well we already know how the build of your QB is, let's say half the team has brutal builds like that, so 14 games later, you play a boosted Miami team who may or may not have bettered their roster, they sure as hell had better builds, and then you wonder what happened and demand a refund,

You are laughable at best, pathetic more than likely,

Yes, I know, but he threw 10 picks in a game, the sky has to be falling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Bort's response answered one question - Apparently there is no difference for it having been a Play Off game as opposed to a Regular Season game.


I didn't see him answer that question...? Where is it here?



When he said that there were 1000's of sims done every day with no changes... if there was a significant difference between a playoff game, and a regular one, then this statement would be false.

Originally posted by

One selected game out of over 1000 per day does not mean everything is broken; everybody runs on the same code, same server.


I thought you would respond like that, and here is my response - he didn't say the "1000 per game" wasn't changed for the playoffs, did he? "Everyone runs on the same code, same server."

I don't understand your reasoning for why that statement could point to anything being false.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi




As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



FYI - My MLB has higher confidence than your QB.



*laughs* What's up, CE?

 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by sjmay


How in the hell did this turn into a 17 page thread anyways,




By folks smarter than yourself discussing and debating the finer points of a game attempting to simulate American football and the pitfalls associated with it in its current state.



Well that and you crying over and over again, BUT ITS A PLAYOFF GAME, like that was going to make people say, omg, hey wait, its a playoff game,

You played Miami the 3rd game of the season, let's assume you guys were boosted and they werent, then what, 14 games later you play them again, and they boosted, and well we already know how the build of your QB is, let's say half the team has brutal builds like that, so 14 games later, you play a boosted Miami team who may or may not have bettered their roster, they sure as hell had better builds, and then you wonder what happened and demand a refund,

You are laughable at best, pathetic more than likely,

Yes, I know, but he threw 10 picks in a game, the sky has to be falling.


I believe a few of our secondary boosted before the game, a couple of the offensive linemen. For those who are wondering...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
What you guys aren't understanding is that our gameplan, I'm speaking on behalf of the Miami Perfection, we played against the pass because we knew that's how you would beat us. Our run defense is pretty good as our defensive line is lead by Jake Pariah and those who are in USA AA#1, know that he's no slouch, probably best defense player in USA AA#1. We have a great middle linebacker who guards the run and solid outside linebackers who can play the pass. Our cornerback position is EXTREMELY deep and because of our overall good front seven, they make turnovers year in and year out.

Look, I feel for you guys losing big time... We went out the first round to an eight season last year in the playoffs because we threw tons of interceptions but we took it in stride because we had no other choice.

Asking for a refund or a re-sim is a complete disrespect to the opposition because I spent a few hours scouting your team and had a pretty indepth analysis that other Perfection members can vouch for. Did you guys deserve to lose like you did? No. But give us credit instead of acting like the game just screwed you over completely.



First of all, you're a valued opponent--we've enjoyed our rivalry with you.

But you're incorrect in that no VALID American football sim includes 10 interceptions in a playoff game.

Nobody (that I've seen) has asked for the game to be resimmed. I could live with a 45-0 loss. But I'll never concede that 10 picks in a playoff game is anything other than a HUGE wakeup call to coding that needs serious repair.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by killertoad
Everyone take a deep breath. I'm on the team as well but I want the steamroller to stop a second. We made our point, we don't want the game resimmed. But I think Larry has pointed out there are some major problems in the coding that need to be ironed out before the drapes are hung on the windows if you get my meaning.

I think the complaints wouldn't be so vehement if people weren't spending so much money on this game. Once that started, call it beta all you want, but you opened yourselves up to a whole new level of scrutiny.


Great post all the way around.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by GridIronKing34

What you guys aren't understanding is that our gameplan, I'm speaking on behalf of the Miami Perfection, we played against the pass because we knew that's how you would beat us. Our run defense is pretty good as our defensive line is lead by Jake Pariah and those who are in USA AA#1, know that he's no slouch, probably best defense player in USA AA#1. We have a great middle linebacker who guards the run and solid outside linebackers who can play the pass. Our cornerback position is EXTREMELY deep and because of our overall good front seven, they make turnovers year in and year out.

Look, I feel for you guys losing big time... We went out the first round to an eight season last year in the playoffs because we threw tons of interceptions but we took it in stride because we had no other choice.

Asking for a refund or a re-sim is a complete disrespect to the opposition because I spent a few hours scouting your team and had a pretty indepth analysis that other Perfection members can vouch for. Did you guys deserve to lose like you did? No. But give us credit instead of acting like the game just screwed you over completely.



First of all, you're a valued opponent--we've enjoyed our rivalry with you.

But you're incorrect in that no VALID American football sim includes 10 interceptions in a playoff game.

Nobody (that I've seen) has asked for the game to be resimmed. I could live with a 45-0 loss. But I'll never concede that 10 picks in a playoff game is anything other than a HUGE wakeup call to coding that needs serious repair.



It's obvious that you will never concede that even though Brett Favre through 6 in a PLAYOFF GAME,
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.