User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Tman2008
offline
Link
 
Give players who are lower level much more experience points for playing much higher level players say 25% more for each level higher they play and 25% less for players playing lower level players. This will help close the gap faster and deter players from only joining winning teams. Think about it. How much does a veteran learn against terrible rookies?

so if level 13(A) plays against level 25(B)

25% in this scenario players could catch up to 10 level in one season.
player A (normal 44 plays 280 XP)*(12*0.25) = 720 XP

player B (normal 44 plays 170 XP)*1/(12*0.25) = 57 XP

20% playing play 13 levels lower.
player A (normal 44 plays 280 XP)*(12*0.20) = 672 XP

player B (normal 44 plays 170 XP)*1/(12*0.20) = 71 XP

(7 levels different)
player C (level 16) (normal 44 plays 230 XP)*(7*0.20) = 322 XP

player D (level 23) (normal 44 plays 160 XP)*1/(7*0.20) = 114 XP


I don't think it should be less than 20%/level to detour players form joining championship teams.

Anyone can win with championship players of equal level to their opponents. (with equal morale)That's why we have tactics.

This would be the only way to make it worthwhile to take over a gutted team while most GMs take over new teams against even level opponents.

food for thought
Tman
Last edited Jul 25, 2008 13:11:34
 
pontiacnutt
offline
Link
 
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

Create a pool of CPU coaches/GM's each with different styles & tendencys after a certain length of time of inactivity a CPU coach is randomly chosen & put in place, bringing his play books & settings with him.(you can use this as test for data) If the owner signs in within 10-days his team reverts back to his ownership, no-harm/no-foul. If not the CPU coach keeps it competitive till a new owner comes in. (fair to theplayers on the team)

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?[

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 17:46:39
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally I wasn't for this idea... but right now, I wish it was in effect already. Move my team down a few ladders!
 
Link
 
Something has to be done. I Got my team during playoffs of season 2. Couldnt trade or release players. Old owner maxed out some salaries with huge bonuses. I went into offseason loosing 90% of players my payroll depleted because i had to pay all those high salaries and a crappy stadium. I also didnt have a grace period because mine was when I couldnt do anything.
Last season i was able to slap together a team and squeaked into playoffs but lost 12 players this offseason. But still didnt have the finances to do anything during season as far as trades or signing high level players as i couldnt afford bonus.
This past offseason was a nightmare as we have sent out offers to just about everyone on market and have signed a total of 3 players. I actually had to trade more of my cash I dnt have to get 3 of my own players to try and fill depth. Its really sad that we were looking forward to being competitive this season but cant even get low level guys to join us and now season looks bleak.
There is no way a team like mine can compete for players like a team 3-4 deep in depth and sitting on 40 mil or a team that has had its cap removed. I can imagine that by next offseason teams like mine are gonna start folding faster then they are now. What did we have over 1000 teams added this off season. so thats another 1000+ teams fighting for those 20 decent FA next year. Right now its set up for the rich to get better and everyone else kiss there asses as thats all you can see from behind. I have invested alot into game and find it a shame that the rules are not protecting all teams.
I went to go offer a contract to a FA but saw a GM looking for same player, like I had a chance then. GM'S SHOULD NOT OWN TEAMS, WAY TO UNFAIR. I bet there isnt a GM with a crappy team
Something really needs to be done about this unless thats the plan for 50% of teams to fold every year. I have seen a bunch do it already.
Also if it doesnt change and we cant keep more then 3 players on team I will be forced to drop team as I wont be able to come close to a 40 man roster and really dont want to use CPU players in South American AAA very competitive league.
I pay the same price as everyone else to own a team but am not playing on same playing field. Between myself and my GM's we have probably put 120+ hours into it this offseason to see all our offers go to players signing with AA teams that have caps removed. ITS OUT OF CONTROL.
 
awalker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbid
Something has to be done. I Got my team during playoffs of season 2. Couldnt trade or release players. Old owner maxed out some salaries with huge bonuses. I went into offseason loosing 90% of players my payroll depleted because i had to pay all those high salaries and a crappy stadium. I also didnt have a grace period because mine was when I couldnt do anything.
Last season i was able to slap together a team and squeaked into playoffs but lost 12 players this offseason. But still didnt have the finances to do anything during season as far as trades or signing high level players as i couldnt afford bonus.
This past offseason was a nightmare as we have sent out offers to just about everyone on market and have signed a total of 3 players. I actually had to trade more of my cash I dnt have to get 3 of my own players to try and fill depth. Its really sad that we were looking forward to being competitive this season but cant even get low level guys to join us and now season looks bleak.
There is no way a team like mine can compete for players like a team 3-4 deep in depth and sitting on 40 mil or a team that has had its cap removed. I can imagine that by next offseason teams like mine are gonna start folding faster then they are now. What did we have over 1000 teams added this off season. so thats another 1000+ teams fighting for those 20 decent FA next year. Right now its set up for the rich to get better and everyone else kiss there asses as thats all you can see from behind. I have invested alot into game and find it a shame that the rules are not protecting all teams.
I went to go offer a contract to a FA but saw a GM looking for same player, like I had a chance then. GM'S SHOULD NOT OWN TEAMS, WAY TO UNFAIR. I bet there isnt a GM with a crappy team
Something really needs to be done about this unless thats the plan for 50% of teams to fold every year. I have seen a bunch do it already.
Also if it doesnt change and we cant keep more then 3 players on team I will be forced to drop team as I wont be able to come close to a 40 man roster and really dont want to use CPU players in South American AAA very competitive league.
I pay the same price as everyone else to own a team but am not playing on same playing field. Between myself and my GM's we have probably put 120+ hours into it this offseason to see all our offers go to players signing with AA teams that have caps removed. ITS OUT OF CONTROL.


word.
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Just have Bort run all the teams that get sold!
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


1) I think you would move up the highest place team in the conference still remaining. For example, if 1 moved up because it won the conference, then 2 moves up as well. If 1 was upset, then it moves up along with the conference winner. This rewards regular season performance.

2) Allow the GM 72 to make an evaluation of the team and if he wants to keep it, charge him 400FP for the transfer. If there are multiple GMs, you have to go with the first one on the list.

3) BAD. Everyone in USA PRO east is guaranteed to stay in PRO because there are two gutted teams. In the West, a VERY good team is going to get relegated.

4) Don't put out so many teams Or figure out a way to add teams above the A level.

5) Open it up to the players of the team, put in a voting thread, winner gets team for 400FP.
 
MR. ULLA
offline
Link
 
There are some xcellent ideas here!

Yes this def. needs to happen in one form or another. Some policy needs to be implemented to super-relegate gutted and "new" teams if they are (or become) UN-competitive.

For example: Over in SA AAA#1 Alpha, there is a recently sold back team (Caracas Lions)that has some guys interested in "slow-building" We are looking at lvl 1's competing against an average level 24's. Everyone has a right to run their team how they see fit so I have no argument with the slow tactic, but I have to tell you that it not fun for anybody in the interim. Nobody on that team has a chance at even sniffing a win for 3 season and it throws the competitive balance out of whack for all other teams in the conference...Granted its an extreme example but one that ahould be able to be "taken care of" by Admin.

Just my .02

-U
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MR. ULLA
There are some xcellent ideas here!

Yes this def. needs to happen in one form or another. Some policy needs to be implemented to super-relegate gutted and "new" teams if they are (or become) UN-competitive.

For example: Over in SA AAA#1 Alpha, there is a recently sold back team (Caracas Lions)that has some guys interested in "slow-building" We are looking at lvl 1's competing against an average level 24's. Everyone has a right to run their team how they see fit so I have no argument with the slow tactic, but I have to tell you that it not fun for anybody in the interim. Nobody on that team has a chance at even sniffing a win for 3 season and it throws the competitive balance out of whack for all other teams in the conference...Granted its an extreme example but one that ahould be able to be "taken care of" by Admin.

Just my .02

-U


That team is run by a mod, tpaterniti, and is stocked completely with level one players... owned by extremely experienced GLB agents. My feeling is that all the agents on that team know that they aren't going to win, or even come close, so... what the hell are they doing on this team in the first place? Why is it populated with all brand-new, no D-League experienced, level 1's? Why is that sort of team in a AAA league where, just like ULLA said, the average level on the competitive teams is around 24? Something about this just does not make sense.
 
gambrinus843
offline
Link
 
I would say you should move up the team that lost the conference finals game in that conference, and if two teams from the same conference go you move up the team that lost to the conference championship the round before, that way the teams would have a line of succession that is predetermined based on success in the playoffs that keeps in line with the conference winners already moving up. I think that the CPU should maintain the team through the rest of the season if it is a midseason sale and then the players be released on day 40 . So that they are FA's on day 40. I agree that it is a shame for a good team to be disbanded due to the owner selling, but it puts everyone on an even playing field to start. I dont think it is fair for most of the Team owners to start from scratch and have to battle to fill a roster with the FA madness and then every once in a while a lucky owner hits the jackpot and inherits a stacked team and needs very little recruiting and conversely an unlucky owner inherits a mess of a team with players he is not interested in keeping and can cause some bad blood by releasing players and having to deal with that whole ordeal. If everyone started with a blank team and the same stadium and financial structure that is the best way to make all franchises equal and put the success of the team on the current owner, not the luck of the draw with what team you inherit.
 
gambrinus843
offline
Link
 
I would however be ok with it staying together as long as it stays in the hands of a GM who has been with the team for over 1 season, this would be like an inheritance if the owner died and his child got the franchise, rather than a sale, so a GM with one season of work should still be allowed to retain the franchise if they want because they are already involved and there would not be a new relationship being forged with new ownership.
 
rimfalk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
...there should not be teams full of lvl. 23+ players in USA BBB.


If an owner has build up a team in BBB-league
- will you MAKE him sell his players ???

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=551

...this team is in the Pro-league of Oceania (just an example)
More than 40 teams in BBB would beat this team 10 out of 10 times

If you want the Pro-league to be THE BEST
- let it be a chance for team elsewhere to join
I love my BBB-league, but wouldn´t mind move to Oceania Pro-league
- if this pro-league always is filled with players that wish to be there

Last edited Jul 31, 2008 11:48:20
 
Trigg
offline
Link
 
May I suggest some kind of screening process for new owners? Seems the problem is alot of the owners don't realize how much work it is to get and keep a team compeitive.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:00:28
 
Buck Nutty
offline
Link
 
I think there should be a few options when your Buying a team ...

I want a Capped New Team ...
I Want a Gutted Team ...
I want a Pro League Team ...
Do Not care ...

And another option below this ...

Stick to my settings ...
I don't care give me a team ...


I know I set my buying setting to leagues that have yet to be made cause I want to start with a capped team to learn more and such. If I get a gutted team I know I will be screwed trying to jump into that kinda mess is hard. BUT some people Like that. Lets say You have a team that is sold and then no one wants it for a full season then I would drop it down to the capped league Dump all the players after paying them Let them go back to FA (they will get a team NP).

Now you say well how do we determine where the fill in team comes from ...

That part to me is simple. You already have something in place right now for winning teams and losing teams too move them around. So why not measure up the Teams that lost the championship and move one of them up. Team A 15-1 PAllowed 200 PAgainst 200
Team B 15-1 PA 200 PA 250. Team B moves Up OR you could simple make them play a scrimmage game durning the off season to determine who goes where

Ok other options.

Zeta conference has one team who wins the conference (Team A)and one team that almost made it (team B) Team A is now moving up to the next step in Zeta conference well the next step up lost a team so simply move Team B Up and Tell Team A not to cry about it cause nothing matters really until your in the Pro leagues Everyone is trying to get there.

How ofton does a Pro league get gutted ? Acully I do not think this matters cause there are so many owners who are willing to pick up a gutted pro team that if you had the options above that I mentioned you would not have to drop them all the way down.


In the end it does not matter what is done some people will like it others will not and someone will cry about it. Think about what works the best and cleanest way and go with it That is just my thought on this.
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 08:55:30
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rozman1621
Taking over a junk team.....

Recently I bought one of those junk teams that someone dismantled - I don't want to complain - but it SUX. For starters, the new owner is trust right into things without ANY learning curve. Then you are trying to recruit players in mid season - yeah - good luck.

1) At the END of the season, the team will be put into the bottom tier. This means maybe more than 2 teams in a conference get promoted at the end of the season.

2) Any player that wants to be released should have the option to do that themselves (within 48 hours of new ownership). Give the new owner a chance to see behind the scenes to get some practive until the end of the season. Since you can only own one team now, every new owner is a complete rookie - so it will be nice to see a game or two that doesn't matter before the next season starts.

3) Do not send teams down mid season - wait until the end of the season.

4) At the end of the season, the team become a rookie team - the new owner will have ot accept the fact they can't put their own players on the team for 1 season. It is more important for the team to get on track - if you want to own a team, you just have to accept that fact.

5) At the end of the season, every player who was on the team will have their contract set to expire at the end of the season. Once the team resets to a bottom tier team, the new owner can sign all the ex-players if they qualify, and if they want to come back.



I'm sure 99% of the time, the new owner is taking over a team that is terrible (I know I was). We lost our first game 199-0 because I had 75% CPU players. Yeah - that is exactly the kind of crap I want to step into. Then you CANNOT sign any LVL 20+ players to compete within the conference, so your team continues to spiral out of control. Then you have to beg to get any LVL 12+ guys on your team.

Bort, basically, your expecting a new owner to take over the crap from the previous owner, and it really sux being in that position. Dropping the new team to bottom rung at least gives the new owner a chance to start from scratch....sure there are some holes to plug, but more and more new owners are going to say "screw it" if you don't let them start from scratch.

If an owner wants an established team, they should have to pay a few more "bucks" for it - vs starting from scratch. Think of it like buying an expansion team or buying the Dolphins. Even though the Dolphins suck right now, they are worth more than an expansion team because they have established themselves over the years with their fans. Make sense?







This was almost exactly what i was about to post. Each team that is acquired mid-season is dropped to the bottom once we hit the off-season, and all player contracts expire. Each league above them promotes an extra team(starting with the 3rd place team) until you get back to the initial league.

This allows the new owners a little time to see how things work, and get prepared for their first real season as an owner, makes sure that no higher level players get stuck on a new team with a new owner they didnt sign with, and overall will make all the leagues moving upward stronger. You shouldnt be able to start out as a new owner in a pro league and just spiral downward until you finally catch up. It is causing a lack of competitiveness in every league they take part in, and NO ONE ive seen is happy when it happens. It would also put all new owners on the same level of competition, and make them work their way up, just like almost everyone else had to.

Im pretty sure the whole intent of Bort's original idea was to keep things as competitive as possible, and this would do exactly that for EVERYONE involved. Some teams will get lucky and move up without winning their conference, but ill take that all day long over having another gutted team on my schedule at the start of the season, and im sure anyone else who wants a competitive game would too.

I dont see anything negative that would come from doing things this way, except for the fact that it doesnt really address teams that are gutted mid-season being cupcakes for the rest of that season. I really dont see any way to feasibly take care of that issue though until the off-season, as it would require moving teams up/down during the season which isnt a good idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.