both of the offensive line ALGs are useless, great...
sborats
offline
offline
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by sborats
i don't get it?
I just created a few players this season I want to keep long term. What is the down side to them if I don't retire and start over?
I get concerned that all these changes will just end up making the players and league about what level the team is (i.e. games pretty much all decided before they are played). Am I wrong?
if you currently have players - and you LIKE their current Majors/Minors - then there really is no downside.
the UPSIDE to changing - is that you'll get an archetype exclusive special ability - and you'll get potential (depending on archetype) bonuses to existing SA's (and potential penalty to existing SA).
So our season 14 created dots when they select an Archetype (next season) will not get an archetype exclusive special ability? That doesn't make sense, they are selecting an archetype.
not sure where I misled you - yes - an existing player who chooses to choose an archetype WILL get access to their exclusive SA
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by sborats
i don't get it?
I just created a few players this season I want to keep long term. What is the down side to them if I don't retire and start over?
I get concerned that all these changes will just end up making the players and league about what level the team is (i.e. games pretty much all decided before they are played). Am I wrong?
if you currently have players - and you LIKE their current Majors/Minors - then there really is no downside.
the UPSIDE to changing - is that you'll get an archetype exclusive special ability - and you'll get potential (depending on archetype) bonuses to existing SA's (and potential penalty to existing SA).
So our season 14 created dots when they select an Archetype (next season) will not get an archetype exclusive special ability? That doesn't make sense, they are selecting an archetype.
not sure where I misled you - yes - an existing player who chooses to choose an archetype WILL get access to their exclusive SA
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
pottsman
offline
offline
Originally posted by sborats
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
both of the offensive line ALGs are useless, great...
no, ur useless
both of the offensive line ALGs are useless, great...
no, ur useless
sborats
offline
offline
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by sborats
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
So, I dont see much motivation for agents to keep players than plan to boost, custom equip, etc that were created in S12-S14?
It seems by their 10th season or so ... they would be the "bad" builds compared to the S15 created players?
Originally posted by sborats
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
So, I dont see much motivation for agents to keep players than plan to boost, custom equip, etc that were created in S12-S14?
It seems by their 10th season or so ... they would be the "bad" builds compared to the S15 created players?
Timetoshine-Metta
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
no, ur useless
not as useless as having my 3rd major as confidence...pff
no, ur useless
not as useless as having my 3rd major as confidence...pff
pottsman
offline
offline
Originally posted by sborats
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by sborats
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
So, I dont see much motivation for agents to keep players than plan to boost, custom equip, etc that were created in S12-S14?
It seems by their 10th season or so ... they would be the "bad" builds compared to the S15 created players?
They won't be as efficient, but their majors will often still be higher, they'll have more VAs, and in general more SPs to deal with. I'm definitely keeping my S13 guy.
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by sborats
Doesnt it mean the S14 created player will level up on crap attributes in his 1st season (like throwing for HB) wherea the S15 created player will not level up on crap attributes in his 1st season? Thus making the S14 creating players (and S12 adn S13) being fails (as the S15 created meaningful attributes will be better allocated).
Yes, the S14 will still have the bad attribute, but gain in it in S14. In S15, he will be able to use the archetype, so throwing stops increasing. The S15 dot will have more efficiency, but he will also always be a lower level (assuming max boosts/XP), and most well built S14 dots won't miss a beat when compared to S15s.
So, I dont see much motivation for agents to keep players than plan to boost, custom equip, etc that were created in S12-S14?
It seems by their 10th season or so ... they would be the "bad" builds compared to the S15 created players?
They won't be as efficient, but their majors will often still be higher, they'll have more VAs, and in general more SPs to deal with. I'm definitely keeping my S13 guy.
simpathia
offline
offline
Catch22 for Prez!
Rarely has a change on GLB been handled so well:
- well thought through
- announced well in advance
- well communicated
- virtually no impact to existing dots
- a 300FP "we apologize for the inconvenience" gift
- a bail-out FP-return option
Well done Catch!
Rarely has a change on GLB been handled so well:
- well thought through
- announced well in advance
- well communicated
- virtually no impact to existing dots
- a 300FP "we apologize for the inconvenience" gift
- a bail-out FP-return option
Well done Catch!
F8n4tune
offline
offline
Originally posted by KINGCHEEZ DTD
Originally posted by Viscount
I like the idea, but I wish we could also have our own custom archetypes so that we'd be able to choose our player's major or minor attributes, and bonus or penalty SAs.
JACKPOT$$$$$$$
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
Originally posted by Viscount
I like the idea, but I wish we could also have our own custom archetypes so that we'd be able to choose our player's major or minor attributes, and bonus or penalty SAs.
JACKPOT$$$$$$$
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by F8n4tune
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
Being able to select whatever major/minors you want would result in extremely powerful builds. All OL would be Strength/Blocking/Agility. All DL would be Strength/Agility/Speed. All HBs would be Speed/Agility/Strength/Carrying. All WRs would be Speed/Carrying/Catching/Agility with minors of Jumping/Strength/Vision/Confidence. I mean giving you the ability to CHOOSE your ALGs would be crazy, and result in extremely similar builds.
This isn't forcing you into a cookie cutter, it's giving you the chance to make more diverse builds. Can you pick a Speedster WR and make him a power guy? Yup. Sure, you wouldn't get as much strength on him, but you could easily get him to 100+ speed and I'm assuming 68+ strength with the way the ALGs are set up. There are countless ways to get more out of these builds. People are complaining about the cookie cutter aspect, but what do you call the current "types"? All players get the same skills, and there is no encouraging diversity.
Now, you get another level of strategy added to the game, and can build a player on another level of efficiency than you could've before. Is it similar to the way we are now? Yes, and they never said it wasn't, but now they're giving you bonuses, changes, differences, etc. It's more diversity, more choices. People love choices.
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
Being able to select whatever major/minors you want would result in extremely powerful builds. All OL would be Strength/Blocking/Agility. All DL would be Strength/Agility/Speed. All HBs would be Speed/Agility/Strength/Carrying. All WRs would be Speed/Carrying/Catching/Agility with minors of Jumping/Strength/Vision/Confidence. I mean giving you the ability to CHOOSE your ALGs would be crazy, and result in extremely similar builds.
This isn't forcing you into a cookie cutter, it's giving you the chance to make more diverse builds. Can you pick a Speedster WR and make him a power guy? Yup. Sure, you wouldn't get as much strength on him, but you could easily get him to 100+ speed and I'm assuming 68+ strength with the way the ALGs are set up. There are countless ways to get more out of these builds. People are complaining about the cookie cutter aspect, but what do you call the current "types"? All players get the same skills, and there is no encouraging diversity.
Now, you get another level of strategy added to the game, and can build a player on another level of efficiency than you could've before. Is it similar to the way we are now? Yes, and they never said it wasn't, but now they're giving you bonuses, changes, differences, etc. It's more diversity, more choices. People love choices.
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/stats?playerId=12485
Nope, he had 0 yards passing and 81 yards rushing. Anyways...back on topic.
Archetypes.
So he's basically not a QB anymore.
He's a wasted draft pick, like Ted Ginn. And don't even get me started on the COLLEGE level offensive coordinator we have rather than a pro-style attack. Its hard being a Dolphin fan these days.
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/stats?playerId=12485
Nope, he had 0 yards passing and 81 yards rushing. Anyways...back on topic.
Archetypes.
So he's basically not a QB anymore.
He's a wasted draft pick, like Ted Ginn. And don't even get me started on the COLLEGE level offensive coordinator we have rather than a pro-style attack. Its hard being a Dolphin fan these days.
Ryiotgear
offline
offline
RIP Level 4-28 Cap Minor Leagues
Welcome GLB's Baby Boom Generation - our season 15 dots
Overall I love the change, I just really wish they would change the archtype conversion for players less than 120 olds. They need to use a reverse engineering formula to give back the lost ALGs to give people a little more incentive to keep their players. With the increased flex refund they've only put incentive on one side of the equation (retire your player), but have made it almost a snap decision to retire your dot with no way to re-coup those seasons of lost archtype ALGs.
Welcome GLB's Baby Boom Generation - our season 15 dots

Overall I love the change, I just really wish they would change the archtype conversion for players less than 120 olds. They need to use a reverse engineering formula to give back the lost ALGs to give people a little more incentive to keep their players. With the increased flex refund they've only put incentive on one side of the equation (retire your player), but have made it almost a snap decision to retire your dot with no way to re-coup those seasons of lost archtype ALGs.
Eagle0415
offline
offline
Catch22
Personally i feel there are agents out there like myself that just spent a lot of money in creating a entire team this season. And i feel i am now gonna be punished with retiring all my players to restart this over. Meaning i lose 10% of flex that i did not plan on losing for at least 10 seasons. I feel i should be allowed to retire my players with full return to do this as my players will hit the 40 days in a season i doubt i will win anything.
Eagle0415
Personally i feel there are agents out there like myself that just spent a lot of money in creating a entire team this season. And i feel i am now gonna be punished with retiring all my players to restart this over. Meaning i lose 10% of flex that i did not plan on losing for at least 10 seasons. I feel i should be allowed to retire my players with full return to do this as my players will hit the 40 days in a season i doubt i will win anything.
Eagle0415
nixa37
offline
offline
Originally posted by F8n4tune
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.
I've said that twice in one of these threads , my thinking is they want everything to stay the same but just look different if you follow what i'm saying. Hell they may as well just wipe this thing and make it even imo , but we know why that won't happen , too much flex available.
I've NEVER been one on this bandwagon of it's all about money , but I am now. If they TRULY want no more cookie cutter builds than I as a builder should be able to choose ANYTHING I want(within a certain position) with no penalties to train and build my player. To me this is even more cookie cutter.
But I hang just like the rest of you.
How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























