User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chad13
This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!

Very bad analogy. This is like Tom Brady not improving when he goes and plays against the Boston High School Goof Balls. You improve by playing against people who challenge you; not by playing far below your talent level.

 
Zeke0123
offline
Link
 
I have a HUGE problem with this not being implemented in Pro...My team might get hit with this a little and that might hamper the teams ability to compete if/when we get there..this should go across the board completely or not at all.
 
lalonghorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Originally posted by lalonghorn

Two comments:

2) No matter how little of an impact you say it will have, the unknown aspect of the formula will cause a disproportionate effect on higher-level players' willingness to go to leagues if they're above the median level. For instance, is a level 16 player going to want to play in a level 13 median league? Even if the formula costs that player 1 XP a game (or even 0 XP per game), there's no way for them to know that since they don't know the formula. As far as they can tell, it could cost them double digit XP per game, which could add up over the course of a long season.


Bingo he will sign with a team comparable to his level. It will discourage High levels from signing with lower tier teams. Awesome job pointing out an example of how it will work whether you wanted to or not.

IMO I think that player would not even be close to being effected


My point is actually that if the MEDIAN player in the league is a level 13 then there will obviously be a number of players ABOVE and BELOW the median, including 3 levels below (level 10) and three levels above (level 16). In theory, a level 16 player shouldn't be affected by the new formula b/c he would probably be around one or fewer standard deviations away from the median. But because of the uncertainty factor, he'd be unwilling to sign with a team in that league, even if he wouldn't be affected at all. My point is that if we don't know the cutoff (in a level 13 league, is it a level 16, a level 18, a level 20?), then none of the above-median players (level 14 and up) are going to want to take the chance of signing.
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Originally posted by Maksim

This has ruined the game!

Dont think I am on a team alot higher than anyone else because its far from true. However all this leveling the playing field is a joke, its a game! Someone has to lose, If you wanted everyone on a level playing field you should have just random generated players and assigned them to users where they gain no XP and never level up. THATD BE FAIR!

I know you have lost 4 customers amongst me and my friends because of the constant changes making it bad to win!


Bye gonna miss ya


Im not leaving just not gonna put another buck into this game as it will only penalize me more.

 
- L -
offline
Link
 
I say instead of tweaking XP, super high level superstars get hit with a morale penalty because he should be ashamed of playing against scrubs. Also, maybe the higher level guys could simply cost a lot more to sign, so that a BBB team without that many seats can't afford him? An owner can sign a level 22 CB at half his money if he wants, but he has to make sure everyone else can get paid too....
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by chad13

Originally posted by FBGProfessor


Originally posted by chad13



I feel sorry for teams that get promoted into Pro leagues. Even if a AAA team has Pro league level talent, their higher level players are gonna lose out on experience and when they get promoted, their talent will no longer be pro league caliber since their exp (which should have been the same as pro league) gets nerfed and makes the talent gap even larger.

No. This is incorrect. They will gain XP the same as anyone else when they get promoted.



No your incorrect. I was saying that during their season in AAA, their elite players will have their xp cut back while the Pro League players won't. After getting promoted, the (former) AAA players will get the same xp gain but they've lost out on that previous season which puts them at a immediate disadvantage.

You are speaking out of ignorance: you don't know what the median levels are. So it is quite possible that the player playing AAA won't suffer any such penalty.



And your speaking out of fact? Don't say "I assume that your assumption is wrong since it is merely speculation."
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Bigmo6967

Originally posted by LJ


this is my first complaint against something bort has added, ive DEDICATED my players to the Krakow Outlaws, And the Northwest Nighthawks.

Yes im a higher level been in Outlaws since first season and nighthawks since beginning of second. Now im faced with the dilema... Either get released now and abandon these teams i promised to stay with and take the hit in EXP. or move.

sure i could move but these guys i gotten quite close to its just not that easy, ill feel bad if i did it now. And also i paid to be the level i am and now ill be penalized for this to bring me straight back down with the non paying kiddie? uh uh i dont think so

so because of this, Im leaving my teams cause if i dont i woulda wasted 200+ dollars to get ahead of these others.


Not gonna affect players who have signed and built up with the teams they are with. Bort sadi that was part of the formula


I haven't seen one thing that said it wouldn't penalize players who built together. Because all it takes is a season of relegation to end up a league lower, with players above the median, all suddenly suffering experience lost for a finite amount of time until the welfare parity-enabler puts them on par.

And we do this in the spirit of fairness. Well then why bother boosting to gain a competitive edge. That is after all the draw to this site and the current enabler of the game itself because as much as I'm positive Bort loves working on this site, he isn't going to pay heavily for the privilege of listening to us bitch.


Bort made a comment addressing that situation specifically.
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
I like it. If you basically take the opinion that the devs aren't out to screw anyone but people who try and take advantage of the system and you don't, you have nothing to worry about.

My second favorite part is people who have a problem with reading comprehension. He's talking about EARNING XP. Will that affect how you players perform in a game? Only in the long haul. If you are a high level player in a league full of low-level players, your leveling progress will be slowed and those other players will start catching you. Your competition is going to be leveling faster than you are and your teammates are going to be leveling faster than you are.

To simplify: If you are have a player who is significantly higher than than the other players in our league, on a play by play basis you are going to earn less XP than another player the same level playing in a league where he is not significantly higher.

Pardon my french, but its fucking brilliant.

So go ahead, stack that team. And all those higher level players will start leveling EVEN SLOWER.

I am beside myself with joy, it hits Joe Sandbag where it hurts!!!! IN LEVELING!
 
hexone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Bigmo6967

Originally posted by LJ


this is my first complaint against something bort has added, ive DEDICATED my players to the Krakow Outlaws, And the Northwest Nighthawks.

Yes im a higher level been in Outlaws since first season and nighthawks since beginning of second. Now im faced with the dilema... Either get released now and abandon these teams i promised to stay with and take the hit in EXP. or move.

sure i could move but these guys i gotten quite close to its just not that easy, ill feel bad if i did it now. And also i paid to be the level i am and now ill be penalized for this to bring me straight back down with the non paying kiddie? uh uh i dont think so

so because of this, Im leaving my teams cause if i dont i woulda wasted 200+ dollars to get ahead of these others.


Not gonna affect players who have signed and built up with the teams they are with. Bort sadi that was part of the formula


I haven't seen one thing that said it wouldn't penalize players who built together. Because all it takes is a season of relegation to end up a league lower, with players above the median, all suddenly suffering experience lost for a finite amount of time until the welfare parity-enabler puts them on par.

And we do this in the spirit of fairness. Well then why bother boosting to gain a competitive edge. That is after all the draw to this site and the current enabler of the game itself because as much as I'm positive Bort loves working on this site, he isn't going to pay heavily for the privilege of listening to us bitch.


My exact scenerio
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke0123
I have a HUGE problem with this not being implemented in Pro...My team might get hit with this a little and that might hamper the teams ability to compete if/when we get there..this should go across the board completely or not at all.


Wow if this ever got implemented in pro leagues ... mark that day down as the day GLB started its decline.
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by chad13

This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!

Very bad analogy. This is like Tom Brady not improving when he goes and plays against the Boston High School Goof Balls. You improve by playing against people who challenge you; not by playing far below your talent level.



My SS (level 20 in USA BBB#6) had his team lose in the 1st round of the playoffs. Does it sound like Tom Brady playing against a H.S. team? Why should he be penalized? He's obviously playing against competition good enough to beat his team.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:06:51
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
I haven't seen one thing that said it wouldn't penalize players who built together.

Go back and re-read the thread then, Bort has commented twice already saying just that.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by seven7

Originally posted by Dudeamis


Originally posted by djfivenine



This is not the right area to target Bort!
I know this game has a big problem with the higher level team always winning. But averaging out the levels of the teams is NOT the answer.
It is the ability to give us more options for TACTICS!
3-4 defense, cover 2 defense, spread offense, power running offense, option offense.
Blitz options, special substitutions, better predictions for the other team's strategy.

If those things are implemented, teams will start winning because their owner and coordinators are smarter and they out witted the other team.

I, for one, will not feel good beating a higher level team if I knew this rule was the reason.


seriously this new rule is a waste of your time. Try making the game better instead of nerfing good recruiters.

so you think a lv 8 going up against a lv 19 is fair? just because you recruited better? i don't own a team yet , all i have is players and i want to see an even playing field for us all , no sense in higher players beating up on the low league guys at all =( lets keep this game balanced and maybe it'll be more fun for us all.


Yes its fair because that lvl 19 could've been recruited just as easly by the other team. Is it fair that the Pats have Randy Moss? Is it fair that the Chargers get LT? This is basically the same as the NFL making the rule that the best players in the league have to sit out of the game more, to make it far to the other teams.


Fake money penalties mean nothing here. Neither does chemistry hits to most players. I would doubt Randy Moss would play on an arena team now would he? Thats kinda the equivalent of some playing there high level guys in low level league intentionally just to stroke their own egos.
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
But wait, if I dont win every game, I'm not gonna get my cyber bitches and hoes, and nobody in the cyber world will fear my player "Hits Yomomma"

This is crap, I'm going to go play WoW and pwnzor some noobs cause I am L33T!


sorry, it had to be said again, because I still hear the same arguments about it being unfair they cant run a level 20 RB against a level 5 Defense
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
I'm betting a lot of the people in this forum can't grasp why in other games using early levels to gain experience is always terribly inefficient.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.