User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #4 > USA AA #4 Power Rankings - Season 3
Page:
 
khayos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Naked Force
10, with 3 losses that total by 30 points.

cape cod, 2 losses that are by 78 ...math lesson over.


Cmon now, you know that a win is a win. With the way the system generates, things can get lopsided very quickly.
 
Naked Force
offline
Link
 
oh i'm not disagreeing with your point, but the system itself is mathematical. I am just explaining why it is what it is
 
khayos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Naked Force
oh i'm not disagreeing with your point, but the system itself is mathematical. I am just explaining why it is what it is


So if I won 2 games by 156 points and you won 5 games by 15 points, I'm better?
 
joemiken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RayRay99
Also, just as a heads up I will be in Vegas from the 25th-30th, so after tonight's rankings there won't be any for 3 games. Hopefully by then they will be more accurate


Things will get a lot clearer by then. We play NY, then have a huge game against the Fins.
 
honz
offline
Link
 
What is up with the Spartans? Tough early schedule? Hopefully you guys get it together for the playoffs after you boost.

No way you guys are only the 9th best team in the West.
 
Naked Force
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by khayos
Originally posted by Naked Force

oh i'm not disagreeing with your point, but the system itself is mathematical. I am just explaining why it is what it is


So if I won 2 games by 156 points and you won 5 games by 15 points, I'm better?


highly improbable, but this early in the season this ranking means nothing, there should even be separate east and west because we don't even play the same teams
 
Naked Force
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by honz
What is up with the Spartans? Tough early schedule? Hopefully you guys get it together for the playoffs after you boost.

No way you guys are only the 9th best team in the West.


our D is really solid without boosting but our O-line is just getting bitch slapped being 3 levels down
 
Dyslexia
offline
Link
 
Denton almost beat us unboosted - we got a lot of breaks to keep them out of the end zone.

Not looking forward to playing them again.
 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
These rankings are not completely useless. They offer a simple snapshot of what your team is doing in relation to the others at this point in the season. Yes, a lopsided win will skew the numbers slightly, but that is dependent upon how score differential is weighted. Besides, any kind of data crunching can be useful in some way.

Thanks for doing this, RayRay!
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
I think its safe to say I wont be checking these rankings till the last game of the season..

They are obviously quite worthless until late season.

Denton at 10 with 3 loses? Sooneers drop to 18 after a lose to a very tough team?

Come on now.


Anyway, where the peeps that did the ones we used last season? They were actually worth checking out DURING the season..


I would do the rankings like last year except I am too busy game planning for a team this season. The writeups took a lot of time and work, I applaud anyone that takes the time to do them.
 
Gambit26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bgm1969
These rankings are not completely useless. They offer a simple snapshot of what your team is doing in relation to the others at this point in the season. Yes, a lopsided win will skew the numbers slightly, but that is dependent upon how score differential is weighted. Besides, any kind of data crunching can be useful in some way.

Thanks for doing this, RayRay!


+1

and I will probly be doing a power ranking after tomorrow's games, for those of you who like a different type of PR.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
I always really like baumusc & Gambit's PRs...Nothing at all against the current system (and appreciate the work, btw), but #s are just cold and boring to me. I've always preferred a human opinion.
 
Naked Force
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I always really like baumusc & Gambit's PRs...Nothing at all against the current system (and appreciate the work, btw), but #s are just cold and boring to me. I've always preferred a human opinion.


We love to argue in the AA 4
 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I always really like baumusc & Gambit's PRs...Nothing at all against the current system (and appreciate the work, btw), but #s are just cold and boring to me. I've always preferred a human opinion.


That's cool. Sawedust does a great power ranking involving numbers and a nice write up for East Europe AAA#2. Stop in and check that out sometime. Wish I had the time and ability to put something as cool as that together.
 
joemiken
offline
Link
 
I've been messing with a formula to rank the teams for the past week and this is what I've come up with.

1. Margaritaville (6-0)
2. Cincinnati (6-0)
3. Bel Air (6-0)
4. Atlantis (5-1)
5. Seattle (5-1)
6. Alabama (4-2)
7. New York (5-1)
8. Indianapolis (5-1)
9. Spokane (5-1)
10. Brooklyn (5-1)
11. Cape Cod (4-2)
12. Jacksonville (3-3)
13. Austin (3-3)
14. Dallas (3-3)
15. Oklahoma (4-2)
16. Denton (3-3)
17. College Station (4-2)
18. Chicago (3-3)
19. Lexington (3-3)
20. Buffalo (2-4)
21. Washington (2-4)
22. Dirty South (2-4)
23. Bloomington (2-4)
24. Boston (2-4)
25. San Antonio (1-5)
26. Pittsburgh (1-5)
27. Minnesota (1-5)
28. Proctorville (1-5)
29. Athens (0-6)
30. Incredible (0-6)
31. Indiana (0-6)
32. Baltimore (0-6)

I'll post a link to a Google Spreadsheet of it tonight, but here's the basic formula I use.

NEVERMIND...here's the spreadsheet on Google Docs
http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=pe3244f92Jsmz56PNBqmbIQ

I create a score from each game for every team. Let's take the Cincinnati/Chicago game to start the season. Cincy won the game 36-6. I take the margin of victory and either multiply it by the number of wins the losing team has (3) or divide it by the number of wins the winning team had to give each team a score for the game. So Cincinnati's score from that game would be 90 (+30 margin X 3 Chicago wins) and Chicago's score would be -5 (-30 margin/6 Cincy wins). I take the scores from every game on the team's schedule and divide them by 16 (# of games in the season). I then take the # of wins the team has, divide them by the number of games played this year and multiply that by 10. This is added to the scoring total to give a power #. Just to give an idea, M'ville has over 43 pts, Cincy has 28, Bel Air has 27, and Atlantis has just under 23. This formula will change during the year and actually benefit teams that have lost close games to high win teams and penalize for big losses to low-win teams as the season progresses. I'm working on making individual cell formulas that will be easy to update as the season progresses. I don't want to have to go back and refigure the scores each week. lol
Last edited Jun 24, 2008 14:26:00
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.