The problem is actually there's only 1/16 team who go up: 6%...
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
AgentTBC
offline
offline
And after 5 seasons there have been 5 teams. After 10 seasons 10 teams. It's a self-correcting problem.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by wollfrnd
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
FairForever
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by wollfrnd
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
That's the problem. Not enough teams are promoted.
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
Originally posted by wollfrnd
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
That's the problem. Not enough teams are promoted.
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by AgentTBC
And after 5 seasons there have been 5 teams. After 10 seasons 10 teams. It's a self-correcting problem.
And to promote, teams will have to keep bringing in ringers to play against opposing ringers and all...how about we make it costly for ringers, with some provisions to help teams stay together.
Regardless of what mechanism one supports, this will not be self-correcting.
At the least, higher leagues should offer a bit more experience than lower ones.
But even more needs to be done, IMO, to make it costly for ringers to sign with low level teams. And as always, I ask Bort to ignore those who insist things aren't broken, because they are. Find the best solution-- this is a good one, as is a soft level cap on new arrrivals-- and implement it, ignoring the "anyone can sign anywhere" people.
And after 5 seasons there have been 5 teams. After 10 seasons 10 teams. It's a self-correcting problem.
And to promote, teams will have to keep bringing in ringers to play against opposing ringers and all...how about we make it costly for ringers, with some provisions to help teams stay together.
Regardless of what mechanism one supports, this will not be self-correcting.
At the least, higher leagues should offer a bit more experience than lower ones.
But even more needs to be done, IMO, to make it costly for ringers to sign with low level teams. And as always, I ask Bort to ignore those who insist things aren't broken, because they are. Find the best solution-- this is a good one, as is a soft level cap on new arrrivals-- and implement it, ignoring the "anyone can sign anywhere" people.
Linker2596
offline
offline
I think if you want to do this then you have to have no penalty for high lvl players and if you use the average league lvl then you use only starters. If you play against better competition then you learn more thus more experience. For all the people who say that bad recruiters gain advantage from this I say that the xp gain will be small enough that low lvls won't be able to catch up for a season or two. If you can't recruit well then your players will get good faster than another team, but even if they gain 2 lvls in the time another a high lvl player gains 1 the high lvl player's team will do better that season.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by wollfrnd
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
That's the problem. Not enough teams are promoted.
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
Agreed fully. Bort recognizes this, obviously; and doesn't implement any of his ideas because there's a large enough minority that doesn't want anything done to have within-league parity, and there will always be those opposed to any specific solution.
I really want Bort to ignore those who deny the problem, and then among people like you, me, and a number of others who recognize a problem exists, enact one of his solutions that satisfy most of the problem-recognizers.
For me, if it allows teams of non-ringers to stay together without much penalty, it's fine. This one can be made to work that way, and so it should and be implemented; or the soft level cap should.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by wollfrnd
I still say that this is all an over reaction.
Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.
There is already fix in place.
Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
Only 1/16 of teams promote, and only 1/8 relegate. That's not nearly enough to self-correct.
That's the problem. Not enough teams are promoted.
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
Agreed fully. Bort recognizes this, obviously; and doesn't implement any of his ideas because there's a large enough minority that doesn't want anything done to have within-league parity, and there will always be those opposed to any specific solution.
I really want Bort to ignore those who deny the problem, and then among people like you, me, and a number of others who recognize a problem exists, enact one of his solutions that satisfy most of the problem-recognizers.
For me, if it allows teams of non-ringers to stay together without much penalty, it's fine. This one can be made to work that way, and so it should and be implemented; or the soft level cap should.
Cedo
offline
offline
Having a high rate of promotion relegation is fun! Look at the playoff contender, that's funny to try to be in the 8th, that will be the same to avoid to be in the last 4...
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 13:10:33
AgentTBC
offline
offline
Originally posted by FairForever
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
What? No, that's not ridiculous it's the way it should work. Most teams shouldn't get promoted because most teams can't and shouldn't be able to play at the highest level. Promoting/relegating more than one team per conference every season would lead to massive shifts in the leagues and no stability, rivalries, etc. We *want* a large measure of stability within the leagues with a slow shift of better teams to a higher league and worse teams to a lower one.
People seem to have no patience. Why shouldn't it be the case that lots of teams are never promoted or relegated? All that means is that they are playing in the correct league for their skill level.
The short fact is most teams are gonna go through a whole generation (10 seasons) without getting promoted. That's ridiculous.
What? No, that's not ridiculous it's the way it should work. Most teams shouldn't get promoted because most teams can't and shouldn't be able to play at the highest level. Promoting/relegating more than one team per conference every season would lead to massive shifts in the leagues and no stability, rivalries, etc. We *want* a large measure of stability within the leagues with a slow shift of better teams to a higher league and worse teams to a lower one.
People seem to have no patience. Why shouldn't it be the case that lots of teams are never promoted or relegated? All that means is that they are playing in the correct league for their skill level.
PierreThomas
offline
offline
I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.
If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?
If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cedo
LOL pitifull. That's not arguing, not a debate.
You say this to someone while simultaneously claiming that you are being insulted and attacked?
Ridiculous.
Look, take the BBB10 league I GM in:
The average level of players is around 10.7
Bort mentioned a few different options. The first was player vs. league level. If, say, the cutoff was 8 levels above league average for the penalty, it would take a level 19 to even be punished, and they would only be punished for two or three games before the league average catches up a bit and he is no longer 8 above. This is not enough to detract "drop down pwners." If it is a gradated system that punished everyone above league average accord to how far they are above, many innocent players who are 2 or 3 above average are going to be punished. And eventually, everyone will be exactly the same. What's the point of even trying to make good players then?
Another option Bort suggested is players vs. player. There is a team that was gutted in my league and filled with a bunch of level 1 players of the owner. So, now my whole team is supposed to take a hit because of that asshole? No way. That punishes innocent people and rewards jerkoffs.
Another option was just to reward lower level players. This is a terrible idea because it makes boosting pointless. If you boost and another player doesn't, they will get bonuses and catch up any way. Bort will lose thousands, if not tens of thousands, of dollars that way. Plus it is a terrible exploit for those that want to "super-level."
This idea is completely horrible and can not stand.
LOL pitifull. That's not arguing, not a debate.
You say this to someone while simultaneously claiming that you are being insulted and attacked?
Ridiculous.
Look, take the BBB10 league I GM in:
The average level of players is around 10.7
Bort mentioned a few different options. The first was player vs. league level. If, say, the cutoff was 8 levels above league average for the penalty, it would take a level 19 to even be punished, and they would only be punished for two or three games before the league average catches up a bit and he is no longer 8 above. This is not enough to detract "drop down pwners." If it is a gradated system that punished everyone above league average accord to how far they are above, many innocent players who are 2 or 3 above average are going to be punished. And eventually, everyone will be exactly the same. What's the point of even trying to make good players then?
Another option Bort suggested is players vs. player. There is a team that was gutted in my league and filled with a bunch of level 1 players of the owner. So, now my whole team is supposed to take a hit because of that asshole? No way. That punishes innocent people and rewards jerkoffs.
Another option was just to reward lower level players. This is a terrible idea because it makes boosting pointless. If you boost and another player doesn't, they will get bonuses and catch up any way. Bort will lose thousands, if not tens of thousands, of dollars that way. Plus it is a terrible exploit for those that want to "super-level."
This idea is completely horrible and can not stand.
oldskool
offline
offline
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
random rambling whineThen come up with something better.
random rambling whineThen come up with something better.
Sweet Daddy
offline
offline
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
random rambling whineThen come up with something better.
There is something better. The way things are.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
random rambling whineThen come up with something better.
There is something better. The way things are.
Cedo
offline
offline
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Cedo
LOL pitifull. That's not arguing, not a debate.
You say this to someone while simultaneously claiming that you are being insulted and attacked?
Ridiculous.
What's your point i don't get it. I told that because that was personnal attack not even a slighty debate... Look at my answers i always debate and discuss. Attacking someone you don't even know is a pity!
Originally posted by
Look, take the BBB10 league I GM in:
The average level of players is around 10.7
Bort mentioned a few different options. The first was player vs. league level. If, say, the cutoff was 8 levels above league average for the penalty, it would take a level 19 to even be punished, and they would only be punished for two or three games before the league average catches up a bit and he is no longer 8 above.
Who said this? lvl 9
i agree with you that doesn't make sense at all! My point would be 5-6 max
Originally posted by
Another option Bort suggested is players vs. player. There is a team that was gutted in my league and filled with a bunch of level 1 players of the owner. So, now my whole team is supposed to take a hit because of that asshole? No way. That punishes innocent people and rewards jerkoffs.
Agreed if someone do something like that. I don't know but paying for doing such idiotic move...
Originally posted by
Another option was just to reward lower level players. This is a terrible idea because it makes boosting pointless. If you boost and another player doesn't, they will get bonuses and catch up any way. Bort will lose thousands, if not tens of thousands, of dollars that way. Plus it is a terrible exploit for those that want to "super-level."
No way! We talk about a +10/+15% bonus! For a whole season we gain 8 level in average ( my count and depends of your level) that woul be 800 XP... not even a lvl... Plus you level up and plus the difference between high level non boosting and boosting will increase. So boosting will must move up to high leagues otherwise they will be penalized! CQFD (What we must demonstrate)
Originally posted by
This idea is completely horrible and can not stand.
Desagree
Originally posted by Cedo
LOL pitifull. That's not arguing, not a debate.
You say this to someone while simultaneously claiming that you are being insulted and attacked?
Ridiculous.
What's your point i don't get it. I told that because that was personnal attack not even a slighty debate... Look at my answers i always debate and discuss. Attacking someone you don't even know is a pity!
Originally posted by
Look, take the BBB10 league I GM in:
The average level of players is around 10.7
Bort mentioned a few different options. The first was player vs. league level. If, say, the cutoff was 8 levels above league average for the penalty, it would take a level 19 to even be punished, and they would only be punished for two or three games before the league average catches up a bit and he is no longer 8 above.
Who said this? lvl 9
i agree with you that doesn't make sense at all! My point would be 5-6 maxOriginally posted by
Another option Bort suggested is players vs. player. There is a team that was gutted in my league and filled with a bunch of level 1 players of the owner. So, now my whole team is supposed to take a hit because of that asshole? No way. That punishes innocent people and rewards jerkoffs.
Agreed if someone do something like that. I don't know but paying for doing such idiotic move...

Originally posted by
Another option was just to reward lower level players. This is a terrible idea because it makes boosting pointless. If you boost and another player doesn't, they will get bonuses and catch up any way. Bort will lose thousands, if not tens of thousands, of dollars that way. Plus it is a terrible exploit for those that want to "super-level."
No way! We talk about a +10/+15% bonus! For a whole season we gain 8 level in average ( my count and depends of your level) that woul be 800 XP... not even a lvl... Plus you level up and plus the difference between high level non boosting and boosting will increase. So boosting will must move up to high leagues otherwise they will be penalized! CQFD (What we must demonstrate)
Originally posted by
This idea is completely horrible and can not stand.
Desagree
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























