haha interesting thread
harshmellow
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=298067&pbp_id=3735106
That play comes u as 100% inside run when I put everything into the AI tester.
That play comes u as 100% inside run when I put everything into the AI tester.
UMBF
offline
offline
For the life of me, I cannot figure out why this play was called:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=355609&pbp_id=8861339
I double checked the situation with the O AI tester immediately after the game (and I'm the only one who touches the AI), and there are absolutely no outputs for that input that would result in a short HB pass. I've had my fair share of boneheaded AI mistakes...but I checked everything, not even trusting my own output names. There's absolutely no reason why it would have called that play.
Anyone else seeing playcall bugs?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=355609&pbp_id=8861339
I double checked the situation with the O AI tester immediately after the game (and I'm the only one who touches the AI), and there are absolutely no outputs for that input that would result in a short HB pass. I've had my fair share of boneheaded AI mistakes...but I checked everything, not even trusting my own output names. There's absolutely no reason why it would have called that play.
Anyone else seeing playcall bugs?
billthekill
offline
offline
Originally posted by UMBF
For the life of me, I cannot figure out why this play was called:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=355609&pbp_id=8861339
I double checked the situation with the O AI tester immediately after the game (and I'm the only one who touches the AI), and there are absolutely no outputs for that input that would result in a short HB pass. I've had my fair share of boneheaded AI mistakes...but I checked everything, not even trusting my own output names. There's absolutely no reason why it would have called that play.
Anyone else seeing playcall bugs?
GL getting a response. I have no f#*&ing idea why this is a sticky as there are only 2 possible outcome from posting here:
1. You will get ignored (Most likely senerio)
2. People will blame it on user error.
There is defenitely something wrong with the AI. Nobody wants to acknowledge it though.
For the life of me, I cannot figure out why this play was called:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=355609&pbp_id=8861339
I double checked the situation with the O AI tester immediately after the game (and I'm the only one who touches the AI), and there are absolutely no outputs for that input that would result in a short HB pass. I've had my fair share of boneheaded AI mistakes...but I checked everything, not even trusting my own output names. There's absolutely no reason why it would have called that play.
Anyone else seeing playcall bugs?
GL getting a response. I have no f#*&ing idea why this is a sticky as there are only 2 possible outcome from posting here:
1. You will get ignored (Most likely senerio)
2. People will blame it on user error.
There is defenitely something wrong with the AI. Nobody wants to acknowledge it though.
Last edited Jan 22, 2009 11:10:39
tonyjoynes
offline
offline
My last scrimmage game was a joke. We tried working on our passing game and had formations set up in the AI for each quarter and in the first quarter we were only suppose to pass out of the shotgun and shotgun 5 wide formation and somehow out of the 16 plays in that quarter, 7 where shotgun, 3 were 5 wide, 3 were strong I, 2 weak I and 1 I-form.
I had set tactics to stick to my AI at all times and the AI worked for the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th quarter like it was suppose to but the first quarter was all screwed up.
Now this was an easy game for us to find errors in the AI not following what it was suppose to. Just imagine the problems that go into other games that are more in depth but set up right.
I had set tactics to stick to my AI at all times and the AI worked for the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th quarter like it was suppose to but the first quarter was all screwed up.
Now this was an easy game for us to find errors in the AI not following what it was suppose to. Just imagine the problems that go into other games that are more in depth but set up right.
UMBF
offline
offline
Originally posted by billthekill
GL getting a response. I have no f#*&ing idea why this is a sticky as there are only 2 possible outcome from posting here:
1. You will get ignored (Most likely senerio)
2. People will blame it on user error.
There is defenitely something wrong with the AI. Nobody wants to acknowlegde it though.
Sadly, I think you're right. Its not always obvious, but I'm absolutely convinced there is a bug in the AI somewhere. This playcall is just one example.
GL getting a response. I have no f#*&ing idea why this is a sticky as there are only 2 possible outcome from posting here:
1. You will get ignored (Most likely senerio)
2. People will blame it on user error.
There is defenitely something wrong with the AI. Nobody wants to acknowlegde it though.
Sadly, I think you're right. Its not always obvious, but I'm absolutely convinced there is a bug in the AI somewhere. This playcall is just one example.
zekester
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=315676&pbp_id=8964016
There were multiple instances of this occuring in this game.
My settings were a SS blitz in ALL pro set situations, downs 1-4, yds/go left blank, between my 20 and opp 20. The output box is 100% and and the AI box is ticked.
.
There were multiple instances of this occuring in this game.
My settings were a SS blitz in ALL pro set situations, downs 1-4, yds/go left blank, between my 20 and opp 20. The output box is 100% and and the AI box is ticked.
.
GoVikings16
offline
offline
Originally posted by harshmellow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=298067&pbp_id=3735106
That play comes u as 100% inside run when I put everything into the AI tester.
Its the new FB screen!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=298067&pbp_id=3735106
That play comes u as 100% inside run when I put everything into the AI tester.
Its the new FB screen!

SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Every person who thought it was a bug have been proven wrong so far.
If you want to be proven wrong, then PM me the plays that didn't work correctly and then give me GM access to view your AI and don't change your AI.
I really should start betting people $10 that I can find their error. If I did, I'd be up a bunch.
If you want to be proven wrong, then PM me the plays that didn't work correctly and then give me GM access to view your AI and don't change your AI.
I really should start betting people $10 that I can find their error. If I did, I'd be up a bunch.
Raid
offline
offline
Originally posted by zekester
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=315676&pbp_id=8964016
There were multiple instances of this occuring in this game.
My settings were a SS blitz in ALL pro set situations, downs 1-4, yds/go left blank, between my 20 and opp 20. The output box is 100% and and the AI box is ticked.
.
make sure to 0 out all blitzers not blitzing. MLB blitzed this play, it can get confused otherwise.
It will still happen from time to time, just like from time to time it will call a random cover 2 play with the same amount of CBs out there as WRs and a cover 2 (I'm guessing some safety setting in case the AI fucks up big and fails on play selection due to a loop or some other mistake in the programing.) but 0ing out all those other blitzers can help.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=315676&pbp_id=8964016
There were multiple instances of this occuring in this game.
My settings were a SS blitz in ALL pro set situations, downs 1-4, yds/go left blank, between my 20 and opp 20. The output box is 100% and and the AI box is ticked.
.
make sure to 0 out all blitzers not blitzing. MLB blitzed this play, it can get confused otherwise.
It will still happen from time to time, just like from time to time it will call a random cover 2 play with the same amount of CBs out there as WRs and a cover 2 (I'm guessing some safety setting in case the AI fucks up big and fails on play selection due to a loop or some other mistake in the programing.) but 0ing out all those other blitzers can help.
markhehe
offline
offline
OK....why do I set a gameplan? Its OK, we won...lol. Here's the deal:
Input- 1st/10/Ahead
Score- ahead between 8 and 100
Ball Spot- any to any
Down- 1st to 1st
Yards- left blank
Output-
33%- Outside handoff- Strong I
33%- Run Gut- Weak I
34%- Single Back- Slam
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=335144&mode=pbp
we passed almost every first down with the lead more than 8 points the entire game. Both boxes were checked to follow my gameplan exactly. The input was at the very top of the screen, so the sim would "see" it first. Any input from you guys would be great. thx
Input- 1st/10/Ahead
Score- ahead between 8 and 100
Ball Spot- any to any
Down- 1st to 1st
Yards- left blank
Output-
33%- Outside handoff- Strong I
33%- Run Gut- Weak I
34%- Single Back- Slam
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=335144&mode=pbp
we passed almost every first down with the lead more than 8 points the entire game. Both boxes were checked to follow my gameplan exactly. The input was at the very top of the screen, so the sim would "see" it first. Any input from you guys would be great. thx
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Every person who thought it was a bug have been proven wrong so far.
That's hilariously untrue, but it is funny that you've been posting the same b.s. for months.
In any case, I'll add my whining to the list of ignored (both by the sim and subsequently by the staff) AI. Today in 3rd and less than 4 against a play out of the I formation, all three LBs were supposed to blitz with the safeties in Cover 0. The Defensive AI Tester confirmed that it should have been the intended play-call for that situation, and I checked the AI to make sure that I had the max # of blitzers at 3 and each of the LBs on 100. Yet during the play in question (http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=316197&pbp_id=10482694), none of the LBs blitzed and the safeties dropped in Cover 2, resulting in an easy first down.
Every person who thought it was a bug have been proven wrong so far.
That's hilariously untrue, but it is funny that you've been posting the same b.s. for months.
In any case, I'll add my whining to the list of ignored (both by the sim and subsequently by the staff) AI. Today in 3rd and less than 4 against a play out of the I formation, all three LBs were supposed to blitz with the safeties in Cover 0. The Defensive AI Tester confirmed that it should have been the intended play-call for that situation, and I checked the AI to make sure that I had the max # of blitzers at 3 and each of the LBs on 100. Yet during the play in question (http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=316197&pbp_id=10482694), none of the LBs blitzed and the safeties dropped in Cover 2, resulting in an easy first down.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
That's hilariously untrue, but it is funny that you've been posting the same b.s. for months.
In any case, I'll add my whining to the list of ignored (both by the sim and subsequently by the staff) AI. Today in 3rd and less than 4 against a play out of the I formation, all three LBs were supposed to blitz with the safeties in Cover 0. The Defensive AI Tester confirmed that it should have been the intended play-call for that situation, and I checked the AI to make sure that I had the max # of blitzers at 3 and each of the LBs on 100. Yet during the play in question (http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=316197&pbp_id=10482694), none of the LBs blitzed and the safeties dropped in Cover 2, resulting in an easy first down.
Give me GM access and I'll find out why it did that.
That's hilariously untrue, but it is funny that you've been posting the same b.s. for months.
In any case, I'll add my whining to the list of ignored (both by the sim and subsequently by the staff) AI. Today in 3rd and less than 4 against a play out of the I formation, all three LBs were supposed to blitz with the safeties in Cover 0. The Defensive AI Tester confirmed that it should have been the intended play-call for that situation, and I checked the AI to make sure that I had the max # of blitzers at 3 and each of the LBs on 100. Yet during the play in question (http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=316197&pbp_id=10482694), none of the LBs blitzed and the safeties dropped in Cover 2, resulting in an easy first down.
Give me GM access and I'll find out why it did that.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Give me GM access and I'll find out why it did that.
I already know why it did that. The sim doesn't always follow the play-calling. 99.9% of the time it does, but like any programming, there are bugs.
And for the record, on other 3rd & shorts later in the game out of the same offensive formation, all three LBs did blitz. It only screwed up once.
Give me GM access and I'll find out why it did that.
I already know why it did that. The sim doesn't always follow the play-calling. 99.9% of the time it does, but like any programming, there are bugs.
And for the record, on other 3rd & shorts later in the game out of the same offensive formation, all three LBs did blitz. It only screwed up once.
Last edited Jan 28, 2009 00:29:19
Samythe41
offline
offline
Early in the season, I noticed blitzing MLB when playing the 42 resulted in leaving the HB free.
I decided to remove all MLB blitzes from my settings.
Here's what happened last game :
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=295571&pbp_id=11476049
I tested the AI, the output should have been LOLB blitzing, not the MLB.
Of course, Def Ai was enabled.
I think this is a bug.
I decided to remove all MLB blitzes from my settings.
Here's what happened last game :
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=295571&pbp_id=11476049
I tested the AI, the output should have been LOLB blitzing, not the MLB.
Of course, Def Ai was enabled.
I think this is a bug.
Last edited Jan 29, 2009 06:16:05
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























