User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by tautology


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by The Lurker




Originally posted by lukin83





1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.


You don't think teams (as well as players) will start to gravitate to the weaker regions because it gives them a better shot at the WL?

As an owner, I want a shot at playing against the best competition GLB has to offer and will do what it takes to get there (WSI did the same thing this past off-season by moving to USAPL). I would be shocked if the weaker regions don't surge up the ranks because of the opportunity to represent their region in the WL.


That's not unique to your system. That would be an inherent GLB movement regardless of whether the Lukin system is adopted or not. So how is it an argument in favor of your system over any other?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by beenlurken


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by The Lurker




Originally posted by lukin83





1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


You guys continue to fail at seeing the longterm picture... sure, some regions (like USA) are stronger now but if you look 5,6,7 seasons down the line once the regions start to even out this should not be a problem. There will not be a perfect solution for the short term. The above solution is the best one that takes the future into account (assuming that with the addition of the WPL that all the regions will eventually equal out).


Exactly! Give this a few seasons and I think we will see that the regions below the WL will start to even out. With USAPL being the coveted league right now, there is a log jam of good teams in USA AAA and USA AA. If the WL is the new coveted league and OPL gets just as much of a shot of berthing the future WL champ as USAPL (1 in 4 chance), OPL suddenly is more appealing that it once was. As a result, recruiting becomes easier for OPL owners and parity occurs.


Think long term.


The advent of the WPL will make USA no longer the coveted league. Teams will want out if they had the option to get out.


Yes, exactly.
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by RandomBeast

I think some kind of playoff between non-playoff (#9-12) teams in WPL converences and league runner-ups should occur. I think winning a pro league deserves automatic admission to WPL and those should replace the bottom 8 teams. But to prevent teams from yo-yoing back and forth between WPL and Pro when they are better than the rest of their pro conference, but not quite WPL playoff material, some playoff should happen.

If you truly want the WPL to eventually be the top 32 teams (or some close approximation) you can't arbitrarily demote 16 teams that may be better than the 16 you are replacing them with.

Pro champs get in
Pro runner-ups get a chance to make their case by beating a non-playoff WPL team (chosen at random)
Demote to your previous league, bumping down as necessary (gutted teams will absorb a lot of this I think)


lol soccer idea?


not really, soccer would be playoffs among non pro champions to determine who fills the spots in the WPL. No soccer league I know of has a playoff between current members of a league and potential members, but that is the best way to determine who is stronger in the quest to find the "top 32"
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
I have two ideas. Either or both may have been suggested. Both are based on the bottom 8 teams from each conference relegating from the WPL each season.

First, the bottom 16 teams relegate to their respective Pro Leagues. Where possible, they will also relegate into their old conference. The assumptions is that there will be enough CPU/gutted teams in each Pro league to handle whatever demotions come about. If there are insufficient CPU/gutted teams, the team(s) with the worst regular season record will drop down one level (based on inverse seeding). Enough teams will be demoted from the Pro league to ensure all league championship participants have room to promote. Extra demotions will work down the entire tree (Pro-->AAA-->AA-->Uncapped Minors) to make room in each tier (as needed).

Pros: Teams remain in their "home" region. Upper leagues get stronger due to bottom feeder teams relegating.
Cons: Number of teams relegating from Pro (and maybe AAA) unknown.

Second, participants in the WPL choose their preferred region for demotion (rated in order of preference 1-8). Based on current tie-breakers teams are demoted to their league of choice. If a team's first choice is not available, they will be put into the first available region.

Pros: Teams have a chance to choose their region. Upper leagues can become more diverse.
Cons: Teams not guaranteed to return "home".

In either case, if a WPL team goes CPU or guts, it drops as usual. If a WPL playoff team goes CPU or guts they are dropped to the appropiate level and the the top non-playoff team takes its place (reduce relegation from WPL and avoid any complaints about which Pro level team to promote).
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
lol soccer?

a system that works IRL?

anyone?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by tautology



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by The Lurker





Originally posted by lukin83






1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.


You don't think teams (as well as players) will start to gravitate to the weaker regions because it gives them a better shot at the WL?

As an owner, I want a shot at playing against the best competition GLB has to offer and will do what it takes to get there (WSI did the same thing this past off-season by moving to USAPL). I would be shocked if the weaker regions don't surge up the ranks because of the opportunity to represent their region in the WL.


That's not unique to your system. That would be an inherent GLB movement regardless of whether the Lukin system is adopted or not. So how is it an argument in favor of your system over any other?


Because agents will want to bring their players to the weaker regions because it will be easier to promote to the WL from there. I am not sure I understand your question, as that seems pretty obvious to me.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
I have two ideas. Either or both may have been suggested. Both are based on the bottom 8 teams from each conference relegating from the WPL each season.

First, the bottom 16 teams relegate to their respective Pro Leagues. Where possible, they will also relegate into their old conference. The assumptions is that there will be enough CPU/gutted teams in each Pro league to handle whatever demotions come about. If there are insufficient CPU/gutted teams, the team(s) with the worst regular season record will drop down one level (based on inverse seeding). Enough teams will be demoted from the Pro league to ensure all league championship participants have room to promote. Extra demotions will work down the entire tree (Pro-->AAA-->AA-->Uncapped Minors) to make room in each tier (as needed).

Pros: Teams remain in their "home" region. Upper leagues get stronger due to bottom feeder teams relegating.
Cons: Number of teams relegating from Pro (and maybe AAA) unknown.

Second, participants in the WPL choose their preferred region for demotion (rated in order of preference 1-8). Based on current tie-breakers teams are demoted to their league of choice. If a team's first choice is not available, they will be put into the first available region.

Pros: Teams have a chance to choose their region. Upper leagues can become more diverse.
Cons: Teams not guaranteed to return "home".

In either case, if a WPL team goes CPU or guts, it drops as usual. If a WPL playoff team goes CPU or guts they are dropped to the appropiate level and the the top non-playoff team takes its place (reduce relegation from WPL and avoid any complaints about which Pro level team to promote).


Nobody cares what you think.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by beenlurken



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by The Lurker





Originally posted by lukin83






1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


You guys continue to fail at seeing the longterm picture... sure, some regions (like USA) are stronger now but if you look 5,6,7 seasons down the line once the regions start to even out this should not be a problem. There will not be a perfect solution for the short term. The above solution is the best one that takes the future into account (assuming that with the addition of the WPL that all the regions will eventually equal out).


Exactly! Give this a few seasons and I think we will see that the regions below the WL will start to even out. With USAPL being the coveted league right now, there is a log jam of good teams in USA AAA and USA AA. If the WL is the new coveted league and OPL gets just as much of a shot of berthing the future WL champ as USAPL (1 in 4 chance), OPL suddenly is more appealing that it once was. As a result, recruiting becomes easier for OPL owners and parity occurs.


Think long term.


The advent of the WPL will make USA no longer the coveted league. Teams will want out if they had the option to get out.


Yes, exactly.


Im sure if Bort gave AAA teams the option to pick where they want to go in AAA the balance of AAA power would immediately switch and parity would exist more so than it does now.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by Bort


I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.


Bort, look at it this way. For every team that a region has extra in the WL, that is one extra AAA team that was called up the Pro league.

IF there is a mass demotion, that's simply sending those extra AAA teams back down. Think of all the extra recruiting and media revenue they were able to receive while they were in the Pro league instead of AAA?


ITT: Spin zone

Can I post this when the bitch threads show up of "why did I get demoted when I finished 9th place!?"


The bottom line is that there is absolutely NO WAY to accomplish the WL without slighting SOMEONE.

Either owners get displaced when demoted, regions are inadequately represented, or pro teams get unfairly demoted in the event of a mass WPL demotion to one region.

We have to pick one. Personally, I think I'd like to play the odds. If you choose random placement upon demotion, a large percentage of teams will likely end up in regions they aren't supposed to be in. If you inadequately represent regions, then the WPL means next to nothing because it isn't the "best of the best". If you choose to unfaily demote a pro team to AAA, that is something that would likely only happen in a very rare circumstance.

Why not play the odds and have maybe one team every few seasons slightly disappointed in the fact that they were moved from the Pros to AAA (when in all fairness there will be more AAA in the Pros anyway, so it's kind of a wash), rather than potentially upsetting a great deal of people consistently because they get displaced or the system is inherently unbalanced?

Another way to deal with random placements could be to give team owners an option during the off season before demotion happens. A simple check box or drop down menu asking if they have a preference to their old region, if they want a random region, or potentially (if it isn't exploitable) asking to be moved to a different region.

Those teams that don't care, get randomly placed. Those that do care only go back to their own league. Of course there is the issue of teams that pick random and end up in the same league as those who were originally from that region. Then you'd have an issue with an extra Pro team moving down, OR you could just process the location of the teams that want their old regions FIRST, then the teams that have no preference. That way you have a more balanced representation of teams without stepping on any toes. I'm sure there are SOME owners who wouldn't care about switching leagues or who may even prefer it.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by RandomBeast


I think some kind of playoff between non-playoff (#9-12) teams in WPL converences and league runner-ups should occur. I think winning a pro league deserves automatic admission to WPL and those should replace the bottom 8 teams. But to prevent teams from yo-yoing back and forth between WPL and Pro when they are better than the rest of their pro conference, but not quite WPL playoff material, some playoff should happen.

If you truly want the WPL to eventually be the top 32 teams (or some close approximation) you can't arbitrarily demote 16 teams that may be better than the 16 you are replacing them with.

Pro champs get in
Pro runner-ups get a chance to make their case by beating a non-playoff WPL team (chosen at random)
Demote to your previous league, bumping down as necessary (gutted teams will absorb a lot of this I think)


lol soccer idea?


not really, soccer would be playoffs among non pro champions to determine who fills the spots in the WPL. No soccer league I know of has a playoff between current members of a league and potential members, but that is the best way to determine who is stronger in the quest to find the "top 32"


Italian Serie A/B has teams competing over who gets to play in Serie A next season. What I have proposed some pages back, is that the #2 team gets to play the winner of the PRO conference game, to determine who gets to play in the WL next year. If the newly crowned PRO league conference champion can't beat the #2 team from WL, that PRO team shouldn't get promoted!
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83


Nobody cares what you think.


meanie
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by RandomBeast


I think some kind of playoff between non-playoff (#9-12) teams in WPL converences and league runner-ups should occur. I think winning a pro league deserves automatic admission to WPL and those should replace the bottom 8 teams. But to prevent teams from yo-yoing back and forth between WPL and Pro when they are better than the rest of their pro conference, but not quite WPL playoff material, some playoff should happen.

If you truly want the WPL to eventually be the top 32 teams (or some close approximation) you can't arbitrarily demote 16 teams that may be better than the 16 you are replacing them with.

Pro champs get in
Pro runner-ups get a chance to make their case by beating a non-playoff WPL team (chosen at random)
Demote to your previous league, bumping down as necessary (gutted teams will absorb a lot of this I think)


lol soccer idea?


not really, soccer would be playoffs among non pro champions to determine who fills the spots in the WPL. No soccer league I know of has a playoff between current members of a league and potential members, but that is the best way to determine who is stronger in the quest to find the "top 32"


He's calliing it the soccer ideer, cause that's where Havoc referenced it being from earlier in this thread. So yes, do this. FUTBOL MEXICANO meets FOOTBALL AMERICANO! Ole~
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
If the WPL exists, USAPL will no longer be considered the premier league. Nobody disputes that premise. We get it.

What I DON'T get is why you think this is only going to happen if we adopt YOUR demotion system.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by beenlurken




Originally posted by Bort





Originally posted by The Lurker






Originally posted by lukin83







1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


You guys continue to fail at seeing the longterm picture... sure, some regions (like USA) are stronger now but if you look 5,6,7 seasons down the line once the regions start to even out this should not be a problem. There will not be a perfect solution for the short term. The above solution is the best one that takes the future into account (assuming that with the addition of the WPL that all the regions will eventually equal out).


Exactly! Give this a few seasons and I think we will see that the regions below the WL will start to even out. With USAPL being the coveted league right now, there is a log jam of good teams in USA AAA and USA AA. If the WL is the new coveted league and OPL gets just as much of a shot of berthing the future WL champ as USAPL (1 in 4 chance), OPL suddenly is more appealing that it once was. As a result, recruiting becomes easier for OPL owners and parity occurs.


Think long term.


The advent of the WPL will make USA no longer the coveted league. Teams will want out if they had the option to get out.


Yes, exactly.


Im sure if Bort gave AAA teams the option to pick where they want to go in AAA the balance of AAA power would immediately switch and parity would exist more so than it does now.


I am glad someone understands that this would actually create more parity across GLB as a whole. Eventually (it may take a few seasons) that parity will progress all the way up to the WL.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
really whats wrong with the soccer idea Bort
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.