Originally posted by Sulfadias0
It is a well known FACT that the debris from the WTC complex was scooped and moved to land fills and broken down without ANY forensic testing EVER done. Clearly the removal of EVIDENCE because if investigators were to take a look at the metal and debris they would find traces of explosives and thermite use in the controlled demolitions. And I have interviewed witnesses, 911 1st responders, and spoken with in person and on the phone with professors from all across the United States. As long as they weren't discredited physics professors who spent the nineties pushing cold fusion, I am impressed. As for the FACT that the debris was removed without forensic testing, I would like a cite for that. Not that I question your integrity, but everyone, myself included, picks up FACTS that we believe that sometimes don't have evidential backing. For example, Dr. W. Gene Corley, one of principle investigators of the collapse, appears to disagree with you on that. He represented the American Society of Civil Engineers in tesifying before the House of Representatives, stating that,
"[t]here has been some concern expressed by others that the work of the team has been hampered because debris was removed from the site and has subsequently been processed for recycling. This is not the case. The team has had full access to the scrap yards and to the site and has been able to obtain numerous samples. At this point there is no indication that having access to each piece of steel from the World Trade Center would make a significant difference to understanding the performance of the structures."
His testimony can be found at "
http://www.asce.org/pdf/3-6-02wtc_testimony.pdf", and the quote above is on page 6.
So, I would like to see your source.
Originally posted by Sulfadias0
Answer this one question: Why did WTC Build 7 collapse?
You know.. the steel framed building that had 2-3 small fires burning in the structure and was NOT hit by plane that was "pulled" on Larry Silverstein's command.
This alone is the smoking gun that 9/11 was an inside job. Explain the collapse of this building. You do realize that no steel frame building has collapsed due to fire before or AFTER 9/11?
I'm all ears.
Let's start with the fact we agree on. WTC7 collapsed hours after the Twin Towers and was never hit by a plane. I also agree that the building did not collapse solely from fire, although the weakening of the structural steel in the building due to high temperatures was the proximate cause of the collapse.
WTC7 was hit by a large amount of debris from the two towers that had already collapsed. This resulted in quite a bit of damage to the penthouse levels, which took the brunt of the falling debris and significant damage to the southwest corner of the building. A picture that I have always found striking can be found on page 17 of the Federal Building and Fire Safety Investigation of the World Trade Center Disaster: Part 2C.
http://wtc.nist.gov/pubs/WTC%20Part%20IIC%20-%20WTC%207%20Collapse%20Final.pdfYou can see significant structural damage along that corner. www.911myths.com has some other photographs and video stills of the damage to the building (
http://www.911myths.com/html/wtc7_damage.html) for those who are interested, but I am trying to avoid relying directly on information from debunking sites as a courtesy to Sulfadias0.
Evidence also suggests that there were considerably more than two fires in the building, although some of them did burnt out prior to the collapse of the building. Page 20 of the NIST report cited above notes that signs of fire were seen, at various times in the early afternoon, on floors 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, and multiple floors in the 20's and 30's. It should be noted that floor 5 had no windows, so it would have been difficult to ascertain directly if there were fires on this floor; the lack of the reports of fires on this floor is not, in itself, telling.
According to the NIST Report cited above, between floors 5 and 7 was a transfer system that distributed load among the various support columns in the building. Unfortunately, floor 5 also housed a series of generators fed through pressurized lines by two sixty thousand gallon containers of diesel. The NIST reports thus concludes that central support columns, particularly columns 79, 80, and 81, and presumably the transfer system, were weakened by intense fires fed from this diesel fuel. This is supported by the reports of fires on floors 6, 7, and 8. Eyewitness reports confirm the lack of water in the building, presumably due to the damage from the collapse of the other two towers, so the sprinkler system would not have been available to reduce the impact of the fires. (See
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110462.PDF)So, my understanding of the collapse is that when the columns in the penthouse region finally failed, the vertical force damaged the transfer system, and this localized failure of the structure, unsupported by the transfer trusses, overloaded neighboring columns, allowing the failure to spread horizontally through the structure. This fits with the observed pattern of collapse, which took around eight seconds to progress from the east side of the roof to the west side.
I should point out that I am no structural engineer, so I relied heavily on the report cited above. My understanding of the exact mechanism of the collapse is shaky at best, but the physics of it make sense: weakened steel at a key point in the building was being subjected to unusual stresses due to the debris damage, which led to a progressive failure of the structure. If someone else is more knowledgeable, feel free to correct any mistakes I have made. What I do know, however, is that few, if any, qualified structural engineers have read this report and spoken out against it, leading me to believe it is at least facially plausible.
As for the "pull it" thing, are you really arguing that Larry Silverman confessed to blowing up his building on national TV? Please find me some evidence that anyone uses the term "pull" for a controlled demolition that doesn't involve pulling a smaller building down with cables. From the context, it is clear that he is talking about the efforts to save the building, with "pull it" referring to the squad working to save the building. The fire chief called him out of courtesy to inform him that they were withdrawing the squad, as the building couldn't be saved, and he agreed. Inartfully spoken, but a confession? That is a stretch.
So, that is my take on it, heavily informed by NIST. Your turn to tell me what happened that day.
Edited to fix two typos. What can I say, I was potty trained at gunpoint.