User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gizizza


Here's an idea: why don't you actually explain your reasons for your opinion.

Calling the idea "crap" is crappy; you're quite the critic.

If we're sheep, please lead us to the promised land with a glorious explanation, oh messiah.




I did not call it crappy. I said it was good on paper. I also reiterated what someone else said. That before Bort suggested it this Idea was considered dumb. So go back to school. Take a little reading comprehension and STFU.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardwscollins

I did not call it crappy. I said it was good on paper. I also reiterated what someone else said. That before Bort suggested it this Idea was considered dumb.


Yes, and WHY was it considered dumb? I can't imagine there's no way to make this work.

 
Link
 
It could easily work. However without the ability to respec players built prior to this change it is going to have mass amounts of threads started to go back to the the old system.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Maybe allow a one time size only respec to everyone when this comes out? I understand the concerns about everyone going as large or small as possible, but that's really on implementation, not on the basic soundness of the idea.

There was also the mention of allowing players to make changes to their weight... maybe a once an offseason thing, limited to a small range? (i.e. Players can only go up or down one weight class... can't go from 300+ to 160 or vice versa.)
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Made it on page 18!
 
Duckboy
offline
Link
 















+1
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
still not in epic?

low self-esteem imo
 
DM
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
still not in epic?

low self-esteem imo


actually, epic suggestions is meant to be for a seperate section so Bort can see it. If this is already on the top of his head, theirs no need to seperate it
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MonkeyMan
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Seriously, tell me how this is different from someone spending a little more on strength or a little more on speed?

The Elusive Guy thats a bit faster but easier to tackle cause he's 160lbs.

The Elusive Guy thats a bit slower but harder to tackle cause he's 200lbs.

Where's the difference from:

The Elusive Guy thats a bit faster but easier to tackle cause he spent more on speed.

The Elusive Guy thats a bit slower but harder to tackle cause he spent more on strength.



True.. i like the way it is.


+1

Bort, if you really don't want a bunch of LBs that are as fast as WRs, there are two things that coulda/should happen:
-Gameplay which accurately reflects the importance of speed for WRs, and accurately reflects the importance of things other than speed for LBs (most notably tackling)
-automatic level gains should have better reflected the position (Currently DEs and safeties gain speed faster than WRs, and LBs aren't far behind.)

Also, keep in mind that there are more LBs in the NFL that run sub 4.6 40s than there are WRs that run sub 4.4 40s...
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 19:17:17
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 18:54:09
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Great idea Bort...could possibly be a normal training option. Go on a diet and it decreases your players overall weight by x%
 
PapaCJ
offline
Link
 
though a good idea GLB it makes things complicated
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Lol at this being random, Bort.
 
kixinas
offline
Link
 
i love it!
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
I really don't like to see Bort throwing stuff like this out there at this time. If we were starting GLB from scratch today, I think this would be an idea seriously worth considering. But this a pretty enormous change you are talking about that will fundamentally change the balance of different builds in GLB. We already have a situation where the underlying simulator is changing at the same time as people are developing their builds and it's difficult to tell if any given 'problem' is coming from the simulator or something funky people are doing with their builds. You implement a change this big and you are basically throwing out 9 months of learning how to get a reasonable balance between different elements of the game. Something like this, which could have substantial unexpected consequences will probably create a variety of new mismatch opportunities that it will take months and multiple seasons to figure out. First of all, not all the mismatch opportunities will be apparent right away. But secondly, it will take a while for people to start taking advantage of them before they can even be identified.

There is already a limitation to people's ability to build a strong/fast and agile player; you only have so many stats. And the game is getting more realistic incrementally. I still think we have issues in the edge rush situation and I think their is not enough motivation to build strong LB, but this is not the right way to address those problems- you would theoretically introduce far more.

Finally, I just have to say that adding another wrinkle like this to the game for it's own sake is just a bad idea. People are already frustrated by the fact that players they've invested in can be significantly nerfed by updates. But when those changes are needed just to get the game to a reasonable place, that's a sacrifice that just has to be made. This, on the other hand, just isn't necessary and would risk nerfing a lot of builds.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.