User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?


are you kidding me defensive ends are getting spoon fed their skills in natural SA's
dont even try to tell me how much it takes to make a good one

its prolly the easiest position to do it at
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?


are you kidding me defensive ends are getting spoon fed their skills in natural SA's
dont even try to tell me how much it takes to make a good one

its prolly the easiest position to do it at


Wrong again. As it is now, DEs are worthless without SAs, completely worthless.

They become worthless very quickly if points are put into SAs too early.

Also, the guy that made this thread is complaining about differences between this season and last, just be glad you didn't play against that DE last season. Just because someone is a higher level does not mean they have a good build. Most DE builds I see are complete crap.

OTs are a hell of a lot easier to make than a precision pass rushing DE.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?


So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.

OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.

This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.

Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.
 
Link
 
Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.

 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?


So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.

OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.

This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.

Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.


Finally, somebody gets it!
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.



I have a DE and an OT... I could easily switch my EQ around be a dominating speed rushing DE (61 str, 65 spd, 61 agi with out EQ and he has all the right pass rushing SAs), I just think it's ridiculous that there is really only 1 route available to build a successful pass rushing DE. Which in turn is making it so that their is only 1 route to build a successful tackle.

Strength isn't effective enough and speed/agility is too effective, that's the bottom line.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.


To be fair, I have no dog in either fight. I just know that what I saw in the initial post were several examples of a DE doing something not physically possible unless he's playing against a 6 year old. Problem is, he's playing against a good Tackle with a very realistic build.

The "Fix your build n00b" crowd might be as frustrating as the "whiners," as you call them.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 11:26:10
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.


dont get cocky id say its mostly because of the leagues you gm in are still a season or two behind the ones where these problems are commonly occuring
 
eholling
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica

Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.



I have a DE and an OT... I could easily switch my EQ around be a dominating speed rushing DE (61 str, 65 spd, 61 agi with out EQ and he has all the right pass rushing SAs), I just think it's ridiculous that there is really only 1 route available to build a successful pass rushing DE. Which in turn is making it so that their is only 1 route to build a successful tackle.

Strength isn't effective enough and speed/agility is too effective, that's the bottom line.


I agree with warlock here.

When you reach a point in a game where one opposing force can dominate another and there's no way to compensate or account for it, then you have an overpowered situation that should be corrected in the best interests of the game as a whole.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 12:36:51
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica

Holy hell. This group can be divided into 2 camps.

Camp 1. People who have high performing DEs and say everything is fine.

Camp 2. People who are getting whipped by high performing DEs (and don't have one of their own).


The fact is this. Just about every team I GM for gives up 1-2 sacks a game. VERY rarely will I see more than that. And this was WITHOUT the ability to hold in an extra blocker or move the TE. With these options, I am sure I'll be able to shut down MOST DEs. And significantly reduce the effectiveness of the rest.

If there is one thing I dislike more than anything else, it's the whine factor in this community. If something doesn't go your way, bitch and complain instead of figuring it out. Hell, I have a team I GM on which we built to TEST player builds. Find out what worked and what didn't. You'll never catch me in here screaming for a nerf. I'll figure out how to stop it, and I'll stop it.



I have a DE and an OT... I could easily switch my EQ around be a dominating speed rushing DE (61 str, 65 spd, 61 agi with out EQ and he has all the right pass rushing SAs), I just think it's ridiculous that there is really only 1 route available to build a successful pass rushing DE. Which in turn is making it so that their is only 1 route to build a successful tackle.

Strength isn't effective enough and speed/agility is too effective, that's the bottom line.


+1 for Warlock
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
If Speed is so important for OLinemen, and OT's especially, then why is it not even considered to be a minor attribute by Bort?

As one of my teammates brought up in our team forum, you have DE's gaining .5 into speed with each lvl up (up until lvl 23), but OT's are getting zilch!

 
Link
 
Interessting to see a level 33 OT blocks 3 level 37-38 at the same play and even pulls back a CB with over 80 speed who is running free to the QB.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=212454&pbp_id=1489015

 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Of course a warlock understands being overpowered ;x
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
Interessting to see a level 33 OT blocks 3 level 37-38 at the same play and even pulls back a CB with over 80 speed who is running free to the QB.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=212454&pbp_id=1489015


I actually think the tackle was blocking the DE, the LG was blocking the DT, and the CB got hung up on the LT/DE engagement. The graphical representation isn't that good, but that's what I'm guessing happened anyway.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 13:08:19
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.