User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
But you glazed over my point of...

What if you have a QB that CAN do both. Say he's your starter.
And a QB that is only pocket passer. This is your backup, lower level.

You can't have both in the depth chart and have QB run plays... without the lower level backup pocket passer QB doing horrible at them.


Technically, you can.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
care to elaborate...?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
It's just sad that we can't have a feature that would make sense because of the threat of people exploiting it...


Meh...if it would "make sense" or not is debatable. I mean, it isn't often that teams will put a specific QB in for specific plays. That would be a DC's wet dream.

Edit:
Additional upgrades are needed to the Defensive Tactics before the offensive tactics can get too "good".
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 22:41:09
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
I realize it's college FB, but its exactly what Florida did with tebow a couple years back. They'd put him in and he would usually run but could pass too. I realize in that case the defense could adapt... but the defense can't adapt to seeing you put in your blocking TE or your power HB or anything else, so don't see how this is any different for QB.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Edit:
Additional upgrades are needed to the Defensive Tactics before the offensive tactics can get too "good".


I definitely agree here. My reason for the discussion is of course that we're in exactly the situation I described a few posts back. High level that can run in addition to pass, and a lower level that isn't so good at running.

Oh well, as I mentioned a min ago, bedtime, I'll catch up on the thread tomorrow.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
I realize it's college FB, but its exactly what Florida did with tebow a couple years back. They'd put him in and he would usually run but could pass too. I realize in that case the defense could adapt... but the defense can't adapt to seeing you put in your blocking TE or your power HB or anything else, so don't see how this is any different for QB.


I'm not entirely against it...as long as it is restricted per position. Like only QB's are allowed in the QB slots. That would be great leaps and bounds and get rid of some of the lame things somewhat.

I just don't like the idea of the offense being 100% effective at passing the ball, and 100% effective at QB runs without the defensive having a way to adapt. The same could be said about the HB/FB/TE slots as well, but I think that the QB position has a bigger impact, since the QB sweeps look like they could be brutal with a decent running QB, and teams still being able to maintain 100% passing effectiveness seems unfair unless the defense some form of counter against it.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Maybe we're in a unique situation. Our rushing QB is actually even a better passing QB according to scouting bars than our backup, who can't rush well.

We'd probably do much better not having a backup at all with how the changes are now.

Bed. For real this time.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
care to elaborate...?


Sure.

You can force starters in certain situations...
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
I heard there was a 40% penality for QB playing at any other position. Damn, My guy could easily play WR/HB even tho his catching is really low that's his problem right there no need to give him a 40% bogus.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by turnit643

No 'Single Back Big' plays anymore Bort?


There was only 1 before, and I didn't get around to adding more to it, so I took it out for now. I plan to keep expanding the play selection, though, so it'll come back!


Want 2TEs!
 
NickyNapoleon
offline
Link
 
OK first off if you think teams dont bring in rushing QB's see Florida Gators Tebow's freshman year. The wildcat offense is something I want to run. If I am willing to put my HB in at QB and give up all passing why kill it? Just figure out how to make him throw like a girl! Secondly the two TE suggestion is a good one what if I want to run an unbalanced OL, or want to put both TE's on one side?

All this I hope comes in time, but the defense needs to get better quickly or the offensive stats are going to be out of control this year. The LB drops have got to stop, and they need to read and react better
 
scott_theener
offline
Link
 
I agree. I want a chance to try something new and that would be the start, even with smaller beginnings like running the option, wr reverse, hb pass, direct snap to x, etc.
 
Peacesells
iBuying
offline
Link
 
I put this in its own thread but may get more attention here.

With all the new Offensive AI choices I'd like be able to create all the OUTPUTS I need then be able to copy them to individual INPUTS. This would save a ton of time re-typing each output for each down/distance input.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.