Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by JimVenice
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Booboo Laaug
Really though. Religion is about teaching a strong sense of morales, and I like that. If that was God's will, so be it. If some random crazy madman wrote all that up - more power to him. One way or another though, we were created. Technicalities, sure.
But you can instill a sense of morality without religion. Not to mention, I'd argue that the religions don't really instill morals anyway.
10 Commandments are morally sound I believe.
Didn't really say they weren't. I'm not saying a code of ethics aren't present in the Bible, because they are.
The thing is that morality has to go a little beyond a black and white rule. It is about knowing what is right and making a decision to do what's right. See, religious doctrine like the 10 commandments already make the decision for you. "Thou shall not kill". There is no moral decision to be made there. The decision is already made for you. That's not morality. That's just following the rules which is not the same thing. In fact, for almost every rule you can find a circumstance where breaking the rule is at the very least not immoral and even possibly moral.
You need to read the whole Bible to understand how it properly lays down morality. The Old Testament provides these laws and rules for living a good life, with the ten commandments being the centerpiece. The New Testament explains why these things should be upheld and concentrates on it being the heart that causes morality in a person, not following the law.
Regardless, it still takes the decision out of the hand of the person which isn't morality.
Are you really making a moral decision if you don't kill somebody because the Bible says not to do it? No, you are doing it because you were told not to. Now, it doesn't take religion to know that killing someone is wrong because most people are have an innate sense of right and wrong but that's what is really at work here.
Not to mention that again...for most rules there are exceptions that aren't immoral. Take the biggie...Thou shall not kill. Hard and fast rule in the Bible, right? I mean, as far as I know the Bible doesn't say "Thou shall not kill except...". But are there times when killing someone could arguably amoral or even possibly moral? Sure. The thing is there is no black and white rules that cover everything. Things like the Ten Commandments are a great starting point but when it comes down to it real morality can't really be taught from a book.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 23:13:45