User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by chriscuster

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by chriscuster



Now, should we maybe just go ahead and do something about stadium size at the same time?

Do people with larger stadiums make too much more than people with small stadiums?

Does size really matter?

Does the new playoff revenue sharing system fix any of the revenus disparities that stadium differences cause?

Should we go ahead and give everybody a roughly equal stadium too?

(not sarcasm.....really asking.)


Revenue sharing is at least part of the answer to your question.

Teams with home playoff games under the current system have larger stadiums in large part because of huge playoff revenue.

A revenue sharing system would allow lower seeded teams to invest the shared revenue into their stadium as well, thus closing the gap.


Do we need to share revenue with non playoff teams?

And is this going to be GLB wide profit sharing? We are all competting for the same FA's after all. So every team in all of GLB needs to make roughly equal money? Pro league money roughly equal to 2nd year expansion money?

It just doesn't make sense. And playoff revenue sharing does nothing to really address the financial disparity. It's a government type solution....do SOMETHING even if it does NOTHING to actually solve the real problem.


1. I would like a small portion of playoff revenue to go to non-playoff teams, but I can understand and respect those who wish to keep playoff revenue sharing to just playoff teams.

2. Revenue sharing isn't about everyone having the same, and it certainly needn't be GLB-wide. The point of revenue sharing is to increase competitiveness on a league level. You interjecting a greater scheme is nothing more than a bait tactic.

3. So, are you finally admitting/agreeing that financial disparity is a problem?


1. Would probably need to do that if we are giving hand outs.

2. No, because indirectly we ARE all competing with each other since we dip into the same FA pool.

3. Yes, but I think eventualy promotion/relegation will even out the playing field without resorting to taking money away from the home teams.

 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by chriscuster


Now, should we maybe just go ahead and do something about stadium size at the same time?

Do people with larger stadiums make too much more than people with small stadiums?

Does size really matter?

Does the new playoff revenue sharing system fix any of the revenus disparities that stadium differences cause?

Should we go ahead and give everybody a roughly equal stadium too?

(not sarcasm.....really asking.)


Revenue sharing is at least part of the answer to your question.

Teams with home playoff games under the current system have larger stadiums in large part because of huge playoff revenue.

A revenue sharing system would allow lower seeded teams to invest the shared revenue into their stadium as well, thus closing the gap.


Do we need to share revenue with non playoff teams?

And is this going to be GLB wide profit sharing? We are all competting for the same FA's after all. So every team in all of GLB needs to make roughly equal money? Pro league money roughly equal to 2nd year expansion money?

It just doesn't make sense. And playoff revenue sharing does nothing to really address the financial disparity. It's a government type solution....do SOMETHING even if it does NOTHING to actually solve the real problem.


1.) Just a little bit. My plan calls for 20% of tickets sales to be dispersed among non-playoff teams. It's actually very little in the end, but it does somewhat decrease the financial disparity.

2.) Again with the slippery slope argument. Is that all you got?

3.) It absolutely addresses it. People that get home playoff money will get less therefore will be less able to create a HUGE financial gap by building stadiums so fast. People that make the playoffs will get a little more money to stay competitive and those who miss the playoffs get just a little as you have to maintain some level of incentive for making the playoffs.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Hell yeah.

Lets do it.

Global Revenue Sharing.

All of the playoff teams kick 30% of their money in, all the 5-8s get an equal share.

I'm hoping the Pro money would be enough to make the 5-8 from a capped league each get paid more than the teams that were hosting them.
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
I think eventually the promotion/relegation system will even things out without going into a profit sharing scheme. Teams that aren't competitive will get dropped, into leagueswith other teams who aren't competitive, THEN they can host playoff games.

Profit sharing is not the way to handle league disparity. Promotion and relegation is.

 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by chriscuster


Now, should we maybe just go ahead and do something about stadium size at the same time?

Do people with larger stadiums make too much more than people with small stadiums?

Does size really matter?

Does the new playoff revenue sharing system fix any of the revenus disparities that stadium differences cause?

Should we go ahead and give everybody a roughly equal stadium too?

(not sarcasm.....really asking.)



They did that in the beginning did they not? We all started with the same stadium. And you need to read a little more of what is being posted. I don't remember ANYONE stating that everyone should get the same amount of money from playoff revenue. Your incorrect statements are obviously aimed and skewing the true debate here. Good Job of it too!



But NOW, do we need to even out the stadium size? THAT is what causes financial disparity, NOT teams not sharing playoff revenue. That's a drop in the bucket.

And what about NON playoff teams? They are going to fall even further behind?




You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!

 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr

You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



Blaming successful teams for making too much money is a gross oversimplification of facts.

A LOT of poor teams pissed their money away chasing victories they failed to achieve. They invested in Free Agents rather than their stadium. The playoff teams were able to make the investment pay off by winning. Then it snowballed.

Once upon a time, all teams were equal, now they are not. Don't assume that the wealthy teams are at fault.
If anything, the waelthy teams should be praised, and the poor teams should be scolded.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by chriscuster


Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Originally posted by chriscuster




Now, should we maybe just go ahead and do something about stadium size at the same time?

Do people with larger stadiums make too much more than people with small stadiums?

Does size really matter?

Does the new playoff revenue sharing system fix any of the revenus disparities that stadium differences cause?

Should we go ahead and give everybody a roughly equal stadium too?

(not sarcasm.....really asking.)


Revenue sharing is at least part of the answer to your question.

Teams with home playoff games under the current system have larger stadiums in large part because of huge playoff revenue.

A revenue sharing system would allow lower seeded teams to invest the shared revenue into their stadium as well, thus closing the gap.


Do we need to share revenue with non playoff teams?

And is this going to be GLB wide profit sharing? We are all competting for the same FA's after all. So every team in all of GLB needs to make roughly equal money? Pro league money roughly equal to 2nd year expansion money?

It just doesn't make sense. And playoff revenue sharing does nothing to really address the financial disparity. It's a government type solution....do SOMETHING even if it does NOTHING to actually solve the real problem.


1. I would like a small portion of playoff revenue to go to non-playoff teams, but I can understand and respect those who wish to keep playoff revenue sharing to just playoff teams.

2. Revenue sharing isn't about everyone having the same, and it certainly needn't be GLB-wide. The point of revenue sharing is to increase competitiveness on a league level. You interjecting a greater scheme is nothing more than a bait tactic.

3. So, are you finally admitting/agreeing that financial disparity is a problem?


1. Would probably need to do that if we are giving hand outs.

2. No, because indirectly we ARE all competing with each other since we dip into the same FA pool.

3. Yes, but I think eventualy promotion/relegation will even out the playing field without resorting to taking money away from the home teams.



1. Not handouts. It is simply changing the way playoff money is distributed. I don't think its a "handout" for any team who has worked to make the playoffs in a competitive league to be rewarded in GLB currency for their success.

Now I will admit the sharing of revenue with non-playoff teams is a kind of handout, but IMO it will improve league competitiveness, and is worth sacrificing for.

2. We are competing from the same pool, but we still are only competing with teams in our league, who, under relegation/promotion, league location and now, revenue sharing, will have roughly the same benefits as other teams in their leagues. Notice I did not say "the same", as there should be significant rewards for success, but the current system is too significant. It is, in fact, overpowering at a league level.

3. Promotion and relegation will play a significant hand in evening things out at a high league level, but eventually things will get out of hand again because the top 4 teams will continually get richer. Significantly richer. Prohibitively richer.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Scrogz
I've been of the opinion we have needed some kind of revenue sharing from the start. Anyone can look at the system in place now and see that teams who can max their stadium in 4 seasons is a broken situation. Especially with nothing else to spend their money on.

I really believe it's too late to fix the current situation.

Since I have had to learn to deal with this situation and live with these rules for 4 seasons I am not a fan of seeing them changed now.

I don't care if they give money to play off teams and other teams in the league. however, the day they start taking home play off money away from teams is the last day I ever consider buying a Flex point.

Like many of us I have contributed a decent amount of cash to this game, lived with the drastic changes and adapted but, quite frankly, I have had about enough. This change would probably be it for me. I'd still keep my players and play but I would not continue to own a team or boost my players.

I understand it's a "beta" game but there is a limit to the amount of cash i will spend on the game in the current environment of drastic changes.

I actually support wiping it all and starting over with a full flex refund. That's really the only way you can fix the situation.


I love how people say I will not spend this or that if this is changed or not changed. Does anyone really look at the big picture? If it is about the money then will more people stop buying flex without changes like this or if they do make changes like this. It is impossible to please everyone. Do I agree that there have been WAY too many changes recently some I totally disagree with and others that have some merit. Yes I do. That being said this suggestion is not one of those changes. The gutting problem and the need to realign, etc would be partly resolved by this suggestion. I mean parity and revenue sharing (or salary cap) take your pick is why many professional sports are more successful. If more fans understood the behind the scenes efforts in professional sports they would realize this is important for the long-term success of many teams. I mean would the NFL like it if 8 of the 32 teams had to be sold and the new owners could do nothing with the team and had no income coming in from having poor support and no revenue sharing then had to sell and continue in that pattern forever?

I have made other decent suggestions on her (this thread) and others and continue to get ignored or berated or belittled, etc. I have spent ALOT of money on this game and I have also adapted and am now in a position to profit from the current system. Even with that in mind I am still in support of some sort of revenue sharing to involve the playoff teams ONLY. I feel it is important and a much better change then some of the others that have taken place recently.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Why do you seriously think that home playoff teams deserve so much money? Seriously man, I had a team go 20-0 in it's first season and we are now set for life because we can afford to max upgrade our stadium for two seasons. Sure, we worked hard and built a great team, but you act like there's not some degree of randomness involved in sims let alone schedules. I played on a team last season that went 10-6 despite being a great team. This league is extremely competitive and this season there are 12 teams that can beat anyone in the league. 4 of those teams will receive nothing, and another 4 will receive virtually nothing. We got very lucky last season because we got the 6th seed, won the first round of playoffs and the 7 seed upset the 2 seed so we got a home playoff game. I guess we EARNED that in your mind? The 5th seed also won their first playoff game, they got $200k. We got $4M. Or maybe the fact that I've seen teams lose their 4th seed because they play the other conference's #1 in the week 16 game while the 5th seed jumps them beating some schlub at the bottom of the other conference. Do they deserve it? I've seen so many wonky sims and if you really think that the best teams always win then maybe this system of rewarding the top so greatly makes sense. I just don't see how anyone can seriously think that the best teams always win or that they always "deserve" more.


+ 1



+2 (basically what I am trying to say)
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Around 2:1 would make more sense to me. Quite frankly I think home teams make too much money for the playoffs. And this is coming from one.


As I said earlier in thread like page 13 a 70/30 split or 65/35 split makes the most sense and all concessions going to hometeam. I did math in my original post and we are talking about a 720k reduction in money per game (if you were making 3 million) if you made 9 million a game we are talking about a reduction of approximately 2.16 million.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Crushr


You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



Blaming successful teams for making too much money is a gross oversimplification of facts.

A LOT of poor teams pissed their money away chasing victories they failed to achieve. They invested in Free Agents rather than their stadium. The playoff teams were able to make the investment pay off by winning. Then it snowballed.

Once upon a time, all teams were equal, now they are not. Don't assume that the wealthy teams are at fault.
If anything, the waelthy teams should be praised, and the poor teams should be scolded.


And now you are missing the point. You've seen the math done here today. The top 4 teams make over 25 times the amount that the lower 4 seeds do. How is that equitable? I am not blaming them for being successful. But part of their success in most cases can be attributed to having had home playoff games that infused enough cash into their budget so that they could then upgrade more sections in the offseason than the the other 12 teams in the league could. That problem just reinforces itself each season. Mostly the same teams in the playoffs because they can afford to make trades for higher level players that their opponents can touch because they haven't had the financial boom of a home playoff game. I just can't understand the opposition here. Sure you may get 200k less maybe 400k less.. but considering what you already get paid, is it really THAT big of a deal?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by Crushr



You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



Blaming successful teams for making too much money is a gross oversimplification of facts.

A LOT of poor teams pissed their money away chasing victories they failed to achieve. They invested in Free Agents rather than their stadium. The playoff teams were able to make the investment pay off by winning. Then it snowballed.

Once upon a time, all teams were equal, now they are not. Don't assume that the wealthy teams are at fault.
If anything, the waelthy teams should be praised, and the poor teams should be scolded.


And now you are missing the point. You've seen the math done here today. The top 4 teams make over 25 times the amount that the lower 4 seeds do. How is that equitable? I am not blaming them for being successful. But part of their success in most cases can be attributed to having had home playoff games that infused enough cash into their budget so that they could then upgrade more sections in the offseason than the the other 12 teams in the league could. That problem just reinforces itself each season. Mostly the same teams in the playoffs because they can afford to make trades for higher level players that their opponents can touch because they haven't had the financial boom of a home playoff game. I just can't understand the opposition here. Sure you may get 200k less maybe 400k less.. but considering what you already get paid, is it really THAT big of a deal?


Because I took over a lousy resold team 3 seasons ago, and busted my ass to get in to the position to potentially host playoff games. No one gave me anything. I accomplished it all by myself. Now that I am here, I have to share my money with others. I may even have to share my revenues with the team that hosted playoff games last season that I replaced in the top4.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Tito I took over a team that was in poor shape myself halfway through a season. It had spent almost all the initial ticket sales money on signing new players. Oh the problem was they were giving out bonuses to CPU players thinking they were better then human players of lower level. To end my long story I too built my team up to now benefit from the system in place. As I have said many times I am still in support of what is best for the most teams yet not hurting those in top 4 seeds TOO much to do it. Sometimes you make individual sacrifices for the good of something larger and more important.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Tito I took over a team that was in poor shape myself halfway through a season. It had spent almost all the initial ticket sales money on signing new players. Oh the problem was they were giving out bonuses to CPU players thinking they were better then human players of lower level. To end my long story I too built my team up to now benefit from the system in place. As I have said many times I am still in support of what is best for the most teams yet not hurting those in top 4 seeds TOO much to do it. Sometimes you make individual sacrifices for the good of something larger and more important.


If you can set up a system to make sure that the teams receiving the money spend it on seats and not on players or equipment, I am all for it.

I don't need to send teams envelopes of money so they can give 250k to level 12 WRs.

 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by Crushr




You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



Blaming successful teams for making too much money is a gross oversimplification of facts.

A LOT of poor teams pissed their money away chasing victories they failed to achieve. They invested in Free Agents rather than their stadium. The playoff teams were able to make the investment pay off by winning. Then it snowballed.

Once upon a time, all teams were equal, now they are not. Don't assume that the wealthy teams are at fault.
If anything, the waelthy teams should be praised, and the poor teams should be scolded.


And now you are missing the point. You've seen the math done here today. The top 4 teams make over 25 times the amount that the lower 4 seeds do. How is that equitable? I am not blaming them for being successful. But part of their success in most cases can be attributed to having had home playoff games that infused enough cash into their budget so that they could then upgrade more sections in the offseason than the the other 12 teams in the league could. That problem just reinforces itself each season. Mostly the same teams in the playoffs because they can afford to make trades for higher level players that their opponents can touch because they haven't had the financial boom of a home playoff game. I just can't understand the opposition here. Sure you may get 200k less maybe 400k less.. but considering what you already get paid, is it really THAT big of a deal?


Because I took over a lousy resold team 3 seasons ago, and busted my ass to get in to the position to potentially host playoff games. No one gave me anything. I accomplished it all by myself. Now that I am here, I have to share my money with others. I may even have to share my revenues with the team that hosted playoff games last season that I replaced in the top4.



I get it.. This whole thing is about YOU! You obviously do not care about anyone else in this game and have no sympathy for others who are now enduring what you had to endure. Its great people like you that make this country great(sarcasm just in case you don't get that either). Its attitudes like yours that are so self centered that they really shouldn't be shared with others. Seriously, that is the best argument against rev sharing you have????
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.