User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Winger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Winger
Why not a forum? Potentially there could be stickies with updates to testing, what's being tested, who's testing, etc. This can also be a place where questions are asked or tests could be requested.


Nobody like it?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Yea, missed.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 20:37:52
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by PP


One last time and I'm done


Bort

This is so simple to fix it's pathetic..............Open the test server to viewing, open the builds to viewing, open the D plays to viewing. Simply put, make the tests viewable by all and move on. Do that and no one has a right to bitch. The fuck up was creating the secret society. The next major fuck up was trying to sell that they weren't given an advantage. Ppl aren't that damn stupid. don't treat them like they are....and the "poor pitiful me, I'll be wrong whatever I do" thing isn't flying. Sorry to be so blunt, but you really fucked up here. Fixing it and moving on is the smartest thing you could do.

There...now feel free to ignore it again, as with every post I've made in this thread, and most I've ever made in any other


I said earlier that it's easier said than done. Much of the data is overwritten by updates, teams changing around, and whatnot. It wouldn't end up being of much use, or make any sense.


So create a full copy of each days events (builds, tactics, games, so on, and save it to another server for a set period....hell, even 24 hrs would probably make most ppl happy.

full transparency is the ONLY solution. I don't pretend to ever have been 1/16th of the programmer you are and I could pull it off. Sure, it creates more work for you, but work sometimes is the price of running a real business, and, like it or not, this has become a real business with real customers


That is fine and well for the future if that's how we go about it, but I can't pull up data that's lost from the past. I don't know what to do about that. I could try and make "open" game pages, but without the info about what when into them and where the code was at when they ran, it's not very helpful. It'd be much more useful to have a tester blog or something to list daily tests & results.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16
is that the extent of the testers' knowledge as well?
if they don't know anything about the players, aren't we most of the way there?
or is it the case that they know about the builds and we would need to be informed as well?

Everybody knows "this is the speed team" or "this is the passing team" etc. The thing is that the tactics used get modified and changed as we're focusing on testing different stuff.


okay, that's most of the way along to a blind study, which is comforting...

but i'm confused how this jives with tpat's much earlier comments about how he could test an HB with 10 in juke, etc.

are testers able to see the specific builds? or just the names of these prototype teams?
 
Apallyon
offline
Link
 
Hey.. to the morons counting Borts Millions... could you also provide a list of expenses.. or just STFU.... and stop showing how ignorant you are....

 
C37
offline
Link
 
norse viking guy .. 18 teams of inside info...
like I said, about 80% of the top winning teams have insider info being used against us
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by DL24


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by coachviking




Originally posted by Bort





Originally posted by PP






One last time and I'm done


Bort

This is so simple to fix it's pathetic..............Open the test server to viewing, open the builds to viewing, open the D plays to viewing. Simply put, make the tests viewable by all and move on. Do that and no one has a right to bitch. The fuck up was creating the secret society. The next major fuck up was trying to sell that they weren't given an advantage. Ppl aren't that damn stupid. don't treat them like they are....and the "poor pitiful me, I'll be wrong whatever I do" thing isn't flying. Sorry to be so blunt, but you really fucked up here. Fixing it and moving on is the smartest thing you could do.

There...now feel free to ignore it again, as with every post I've made in this thread, and most I've ever made in any other


I said earlier that it's easier said than done. Much of the data is overwritten by updates, teams changing around, and whatnot. It wouldn't end up being of much use, or make any sense.


So what is the answer? We can't see the data or "understand it". What is the plan? We at least deserve to know who was doing the tests.


You don't deserve to know anything.


You dont deserve to post. So shut up and stop the ass-kissing, please.


Why should Bort reveal his game model, he is using 30ish users to help and they gain a minuscule advantage, not that big of a deal tbh


Lying, manipulating, unfair advantages and trophies literally handed to a select few at the expense of others who have made him millions of dollars? Nothing wrong? What the fuck are you smoking?


So how does knowing a slight amount about the game (a game that is constantly changing)=Handing out trophies.
Please elaborate citing specific examples.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
If you can't recreate the past, the best you can do is full disclosure in the future.

List all of the future testers (don't need to tell us who was already testing...what is done is done)

Show the results from every game they test. We can see what they are doing, the builds and the results.

They will be unable to abuse the system because whatever they do will be seen by the entire community. Whatever info they gain about skills and SAs will be seen by the entire community.

You may even get valuable input from the community that the tester missed when he was reviewing the game.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PP

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by PP



One last time and I'm done


Bort

This is so simple to fix it's pathetic..............Open the test server to viewing, open the builds to viewing, open the D plays to viewing. Simply put, make the tests viewable by all and move on. Do that and no one has a right to bitch. The fuck up was creating the secret society. The next major fuck up was trying to sell that they weren't given an advantage. Ppl aren't that damn stupid. don't treat them like they are....and the "poor pitiful me, I'll be wrong whatever I do" thing isn't flying. Sorry to be so blunt, but you really fucked up here. Fixing it and moving on is the smartest thing you could do.

There...now feel free to ignore it again, as with every post I've made in this thread, and most I've ever made in any other


I said earlier that it's easier said than done. Much of the data is overwritten by updates, teams changing around, and whatnot. It wouldn't end up being of much use, or make any sense.


So create a full copy of each days events (builds, tactics, games, so on, and save it to another server for a set period....hell, even 24 hrs would probably make most ppl happy.

full transparency is the ONLY solution. I don't pretend to ever have been 1/16th of the programmer you are and I could pull it off. Sure, it creates more work for you, but work sometimes is the price of running a real business, and, like it or not, this has become a real business with real customers


That is fine and well for the future if that's how we go about it, but I can't pull up data that's lost from the past. I don't know what to do about that. I could try and make "open" game pages, but without the info about what when into them and where the code was at when they ran, it's not very helpful. It'd be much more useful to have a tester blog or something to list daily tests & results.


So are you saying you'll do this in the future?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
Everybody knows "this is the speed team" or "this is the passing team" etc. The thing is that the tactics used get modified and changed as we're focusing on testing different stuff.

So does that mean they can go through with the passing team, run two games, one with 0 Field Gen, and one with 15 field gen? Or are they just stuck with the passing team that has 7 field gen?


yeah, that's the question i was trying to ask earlier.
 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by coachviking


So what is the answer? We can't see the data or "understand it". What is the plan? We at least deserve to know who was doing the tests.


Hate to tell you but gart spilled the beans about having leaked info on builds and tactics from a tester. Any team he's a gm on is now tainted.


Damn Gart Really should have shared with us than.
 
C37
offline
Link
 
and reset SPs and take away trophies and titles from the 80% of the teams that have won illegally
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
When do we get names?
 
AdmWmsn
offline
Link
 
In my opinion:

1) This is Borts game, if you don't like it the GTFO you pussies. You think it's not fair, life is not fair.

2) if Bort sees a need for a few testers to help the game for everyone, then so be it.

3) For you whining, crying bastards, maybe your parents should have whipped you more often to show you that life isn't what you want but what it is.

4) This is a virtual game, not real life, if it upsets you that much, again I say GTFO.

5) If a few people have an advantage, so what, that means the largest portion have no advantage, so quit whining.

6) Again, life is what it is, maybe you should get a real one, you whining cocksuckers.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Bort

I said earlier that it's easier said than done. Much of the data is overwritten by updates, teams changing around, and whatnot. It wouldn't end up being of much use, or make any sense.


Even if stored data isn't made available, making the current version of builds, individual tactics, and team tactics being used on the servers available along with the recent game replays would help. Read-only access to the test forum would help. Identifying who is involved with the process would help (and I think we've seen that there are many people willing to serve and be publicly identified as a game tester). It wouldn't be perfect but it would be transparent without requiring unreasonable effort that I know of (maybe more bandwidth to the data that's being opened up for public review, but that's about it). Doesn't even require the effort to turn all of that data into information in the form of a blog... we can trust the community as a whole to police it to the extent that they have any suspicion. I imagine after an initial spike there won't even be that much long-term interest.

It comes down to demonstrating a willingness and desire for fair and open access for everyone to the same pool of information. Even if it isn't perfectly fair, it shows reasonable measures to keep the playing field level and it's auditable at any time by someone who has the time to take a look at what's being tested (e.g., they can see what their upcoming playoff opponents have been looking at on the test server to make sure it isn't related to game preparation).


Like I posted earlier, I have no problem with doing a blog of results or whatever. That doesn't seem to be enough for some people, though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.