User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by javablanco
I have to ask... why would system maintenance be scheduled during the last night of trades? Couln't it have been scheduled for today. I was online trying to wheel and deal with time left before the trade deadline kicked in, and wham... the site shutdown.


He probably didnt think many people would be making trades - it is double chemistry at the moment.
 
pnewtonjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gtbice
Originally posted by Stefan

I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr
Originally posted by gtbice

Originally posted by Stefan


I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.



Sounds like someone who's had some practice with shady trades! This rule doesn't really hurt anyone except someone who wants to abuse other owners. The game is still in a major learning curve, expansion teams with new first time owners are prime targets for the weak minded that enjoy messing with people! If people didn't abuse others rules like these wouldn't be necessary. If you look at all the rules changes you'll find most are to limit abuse!

 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr
Originally posted by gtbice

Originally posted by Stefan


I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.


let me dumb it down for you:

1: A team owner has his own players on a team
2: Team owner's players have long contracts
3: team owner advertises players with long contracts
4: Owner seeks offers for best money or players
5: team owner has a collection of random offers
6: team owner then quickly resigns his players to shorter expensive contracts
7: Team owner accepts best offer and screws the partner.

Get it? got it? good!

Edit: this is what was happening, Bort found the best and easiest way to fix it.
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 13:28:15
 
Toric
offline
Link
 


let me dumb it down for you:

1: A team owner has his own players on a team
2: Team owner's players have long contracts
3: team owner advertises players with long contracts
4: Owner seeks offers for best money or players
5: team owner has a collection of random offers
6: team owner then quickly resigns his players to shorter expensive contracts
7: Team owner accepts best offer and screws the partner.

Get it? got it? good!

Edit: this is what was happening, Bort found the best and easiest way to fix it.


Oh damm people will do anything ....
 
Raider Nation
offline
Link
 
I think the trade revokation option is great. Some owners will do anthing to win. Bunch of cheaters.
 
pnewtonjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gtbice
Originally posted by pnewtonjr

Originally posted by gtbice


Originally posted by Stefan



I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.


let me dumb it down for you:

1: A team owner has his own players on a team
2: Team owner's players have long contracts
3: team owner advertises players with long contracts
4: Owner seeks offers for best money or players
5: team owner has a collection of random offers
6: team owner then quickly resigns his players to shorter expensive contracts
7: Team owner accepts best offer and screws the partner.

Get it? got it? good!

Edit: this is what was happening, Bort found the best and easiest way to fix it.


As I said, without being a dick like you, if that was the problem then fix it in an appropriate way, not with another hole for assholes to abuse the game. The trade revoke option was already taken away for a reason.
 
OilersNut
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr
Originally posted by gtbice

Originally posted by pnewtonjr


Originally posted by gtbice



Originally posted by Stefan




I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.


let me dumb it down for you:

1: A team owner has his own players on a team
2: Team owner's players have long contracts
3: team owner advertises players with long contracts
4: Owner seeks offers for best money or players
5: team owner has a collection of random offers
6: team owner then quickly resigns his players to shorter expensive contracts
7: Team owner accepts best offer and screws the partner.

Get it? got it? good!

Edit: this is what was happening, Bort found the best and easiest way to fix it.


As I said, without being a dick like you, if that was the problem then fix it in an appropriate way, not with another hole for assholes to abuse the game. The trade revoke option was already taken away for a reason.


Maybe, if a player is re-signed, all trade offers involving the player is automatically revoked (similar to what happens if team is sold back to GLB)

 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Havent read past this page, but i dont understand why OilersNut's suggestion wasnt the original course of action to begin with. Allowing trade revocation may work to solve this issue, but then it opens the door for other problems.

Having all trade offers for a given player cancel if that player resigns a contract, solves this problem, and doesnt cause any other potential issues that i can see.
 
NTNSTY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Havent read past this page, but i dont understand why OilersNut's suggestion wasnt the original course of action to begin with. Allowing trade revocation may work to solve this issue, but then it opens the door for other problems.

Having all trade offers for a given player cancel if that player resigns a contract, solves this problem, and doesnt cause any other potential issues that i can see.


That's what I was thinking - I wonder why this wasn't a 'better' or at least simpler option.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Raider Nation
I think the trade revokation option is great. Some owners will do anthing to win. Bunch of cheaters.


But that's the whole point, this doesn't eliminate cheaters.

So here's my example. I want to hurt the top team in my league, so I pick out that guy's best player and I send him an offer he can't refuse for my top 3 players, except beforehand I tell my players I'm not really trading them.

So we do the trade, and then after 1 hour I cancel it. My players don't care about the message because they knew what was going on, but now the player on the other team is upset that his owner tried to trade him, and when his contract runs out this year now the owner can't resign him because he's pissed and to get back and him he will sign as a FA with my team.
 
Matrims
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Originally posted by Raider Nation

I think the trade revokation option is great. Some owners will do anthing to win. Bunch of cheaters.


But that's the whole point, this doesn't eliminate cheaters.

So here's my example. I want to hurt the top team in my league, so I pick out that guy's best player and I send him an offer he can't refuse for my top 3 players, except beforehand I tell my players I'm not really trading them.

So we do the trade, and then after 1 hour I cancel it. My players don't care about the message because they knew what was going on, but now the player on the other team is upset that his owner tried to trade him, and when his contract runs out this year now the owner can't resign him because he's pissed and to get back and him he will sign as a FA with my team.


I guess some owners will have to go back to having that one thing, whats its called again.....oh yeah, player loyality. lol
 
Lidd
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure the "trade revocation" option solved the issue of changing contracts on pending trades. It still seems like you could make an offer have it accepted wait an hour, so it can't be revoked, and then change the players contract. Is that correct?
Last edited Jul 7, 2008 08:59:09
 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lidd
I'm not sure the "trade revocation" option solved the issue of changing contracts on pending trades. It still seems like you could make an offer have it accepted wait an hour, so it can't be revoked, and then change the players contract. Is that correct?


changing contracts during pending trades wasn't the issue, since before, players would advertise, have a stock of offers piled up, then resign the players then accept. That's why you always need to be cautious when trading for players, when they own a team. The majority of players who own teams are stand up guys, but there are definitely a few bad seeds.
 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr
Originally posted by gtbice

Originally posted by pnewtonjr


Originally posted by gtbice



Originally posted by Stefan




I'd recommend perhaps a limit on the number of retracted trades allowed in a season, as I can see players who are just messed around offering really lopsided trades and retracting them over and over just to mess with people.


Sounds like a personal problem, don't try and complicate things any further, it was put in because owners were trading players who they thought had long contracts, then were resigned real quick to contracts that ended on day 40 of the current season. People will cheat any way they can, but I prefer to have some little annoying brat go around and pretend to trade his players instead of someone who is going to screw you because of a last minute changed contract.



If that's the problem then just don't let a player sign a new contract while a trade is pending that involves the player.



If the problem is that people are getting ripped off with expiring contracts or inactive players, there is no reason to baby lazy owners by giving a one hour window for deceitful people to abuse (the ability to retract trades was already taken out once for a reason) trading only because other owners are either too stupid or too lazy to do their job. I'm sorry if that is too blunt for some of you, but that is exactly the problem - if owners actually did their homework before making a trade they wouldn't get ripped off.


let me dumb it down for you:

1: A team owner has his own players on a team
2: Team owner's players have long contracts
3: team owner advertises players with long contracts
4: Owner seeks offers for best money or players
5: team owner has a collection of random offers
6: team owner then quickly resigns his players to shorter expensive contracts
7: Team owner accepts best offer and screws the partner.

Get it? got it? good!

Edit: this is what was happening, Bort found the best and easiest way to fix it.


As I said, without being a dick like you, if that was the problem then fix it in an appropriate way, not with another hole for assholes to abuse the game. The trade revoke option was already taken away for a reason.


Didn't mean to sound like a dick, but no one seemed to get what was going down, you were just the last post at the time when I quoted. I don't see any issues with the trade revoke, deals fall through all the time, a time limit is a good idea IMO, but I have seen a lot of idiots make deals based on level, then go and take a second look and realize the player is junk/expiring contract or something. I for one and am in favor of the revoke, it gives a little more protection to the newbie owners who are just trying to get the hang of this a second chance, before they get ripped off by shady owners/gms.
Last edited Jul 7, 2008 09:35:20
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.