Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1
But how is it fair to anyone in a lower league to see some newbie owner luck into a Pro team?
Pro leagues should have the best teams in them. AAA the best teams after that. When teams are gutted, they should start at the bottom, like everyone else did at the time.
This works only if we know teams will stick around. Sadly, I think we have a fair amount of proof that that isn't the case.
I don't have an issue with demoting teams, but I don't think it will stop much. It also requires a very long, and strictly enforced, definition of "gutted".
It'll stop more then you think. There will always be gutting though. As long as we have teams being run by a player managing 20-30 other individual people...gutting will be a part of the game.
it's a better, and at least fundamentally more fair, solution to what we have now, which is Pro and AAA leagues that look like wastelands, while teams in AA and A leagues that can compete with these teams languish and pray that they don't get a single unlucky game in the playoffs, and are stuck being a great team in a low division, while dozens of garbage teams are in more prestigious leagues.
Originally posted by islander1
But how is it fair to anyone in a lower league to see some newbie owner luck into a Pro team?
Pro leagues should have the best teams in them. AAA the best teams after that. When teams are gutted, they should start at the bottom, like everyone else did at the time.
This works only if we know teams will stick around. Sadly, I think we have a fair amount of proof that that isn't the case.
I don't have an issue with demoting teams, but I don't think it will stop much. It also requires a very long, and strictly enforced, definition of "gutted".
It'll stop more then you think. There will always be gutting though. As long as we have teams being run by a player managing 20-30 other individual people...gutting will be a part of the game.
it's a better, and at least fundamentally more fair, solution to what we have now, which is Pro and AAA leagues that look like wastelands, while teams in AA and A leagues that can compete with these teams languish and pray that they don't get a single unlucky game in the playoffs, and are stuck being a great team in a low division, while dozens of garbage teams are in more prestigious leagues.






























