User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1


But how is it fair to anyone in a lower league to see some newbie owner luck into a Pro team?

Pro leagues should have the best teams in them. AAA the best teams after that. When teams are gutted, they should start at the bottom, like everyone else did at the time.


This works only if we know teams will stick around. Sadly, I think we have a fair amount of proof that that isn't the case.

I don't have an issue with demoting teams, but I don't think it will stop much. It also requires a very long, and strictly enforced, definition of "gutted".



It'll stop more then you think. There will always be gutting though. As long as we have teams being run by a player managing 20-30 other individual people...gutting will be a part of the game.

it's a better, and at least fundamentally more fair, solution to what we have now, which is Pro and AAA leagues that look like wastelands, while teams in AA and A leagues that can compete with these teams languish and pray that they don't get a single unlucky game in the playoffs, and are stuck being a great team in a low division, while dozens of garbage teams are in more prestigious leagues.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by islander1



But how is it fair to anyone in a lower league to see some newbie owner luck into a Pro team?

Pro leagues should have the best teams in them. AAA the best teams after that. When teams are gutted, they should start at the bottom, like everyone else did at the time.


This works only if we know teams will stick around. Sadly, I think we have a fair amount of proof that that isn't the case.

I don't have an issue with demoting teams, but I don't think it will stop much. It also requires a very long, and strictly enforced, definition of "gutted".



It'll stop more then you think. There will always be gutting though. As long as we have teams being run by a player managing 20-30 other individual people...gutting will be a part of the game.

it's a better, and at least fundamentally more fair, solution to what we have now, which is Pro and AAA leagues that look like wastelands, while teams in AA and A leagues that can compete with these teams languish and pray that they don't get a single unlucky game in the playoffs, and are stuck being a great team in a low division, while dozens of garbage teams are in more prestigious leagues.




...until the next time.

We'll reset them, then people will gut mid/low level teams again, then in 3 seasons we'll hear "Fix gutting by reorganizing leagues".

It would seem that the better way to fix it would be to stop the gutting. I've suggested allowing Owners to decide to whom the team their selling will go, but I'm not sure if that'll catch on.
 
XiaominWu
offline
Link
 
If you build a guy into lvl 25+ and he's not very good (because you guessed wrong, sorry)...... there is so very little you can do about it, as levelling slows down so dramatically. I think a lot of agents get discouraged/bored at this point and leave the game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by XiaominWu
If you build a guy into lvl 25+ and he's not very good (because you guessed wrong, sorry)...... there is so very little you can do about it, as levelling slows down so dramatically. I think a lot of agents get discouraged/bored at this point and leave the game.


The fame system is designed to fix this in part I think. Basically, increasing the things that are gained from equipment (not bought equipment, sponsor equip) so that we have more freedom to change our players.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 

VT, let me put it like this.

Look at this thread. It contains a cross-section of players. Some who spend a lot of money, some who do not.

If this cross-section is ignored, what will that tell the people within said cross-section???????

While considering that, take a look at the myriad of other "HOT" topics of the day and consider who those issues are turning off.

Get the pic?

If you don't mind me asking, how old are you?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Make CPUs better suggestion thread.

LETS DO THIS!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=924667
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ming Sao

VT, let me put it like this.

Look at this thread. It contains a cross-section of players. Some who spend a lot of money, some who do not.

If this cross-section is ignored, what will that tell the people within said cross-section???????

While considering that, take a look at the myriad of other "HOT" topics of the day and consider who those issues are turning off.

Get the pic?



Sure, and I also understand that a very vocal 20 guys doesn't a ruined game make. Not that I disagree that there are a lot of fixes needed, but acting like a game that's 120 days old is beyond repair is overly-dramatic.

Originally posted by
If you don't mind me asking, how old are you?


How old do you think I am?
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Otega
The reality is, the system currently in place, for leagues, is inherently flawed. And there is no good solution to fix it.

-Leveling from 1-21 is too fast
-Leveling from 25 + is too slow
-There is little to no separation from AA to AAA to Pro, in terms of levels (with the exception of teams with players who have played since day 1, in essence giving them a level advantage that cannot be overcome due to the way you level at 25+)
-Expansion teams starting, at basically level 13.9, has killed any chance to relieve that lack of separation.
-There is no real motivation to get from AA to the Pro's, other than E-Fame.

The sad truth is that the entire game would need a serious overhaul in order to fix the problems it currently has. And that is something that I would assume 90% of the players would rage against.

But, if it were to happen, this is how it would need to be, IMHO
-No D leagues
-Expansion teams start with players at level 1, and are not allowed to boost in season 1 until the end of the regular season. This would put a premium on managing depth charts, playing time, etc IE LEARNING THE GAME.
-Depth Chats on those teams would be required to have a minimum of 1 starter and 1 backup, thus forcing teams to a) fill out their roster in the proper fashion of a football team and b) not allow for making maxing xp, and not winning, the goal.
-Gutted/sold teams would move down to the "A" level, while MORE than just the conference champions would be allowed to move up, creating better competition and parity at the higher levels by filling the voids. This is something that is sorely needed at this point.
-Owners would be forced to have multiple GM's, thus voiding out the "inactive" owner issues when it comes to teams getting stuck with no chance to keep their team winning because they can't change the AUI for O/D/, DC, etc.
-Gm's would stay as GM's, if a team is sold and taken over by the CPU, and have all the privileges they had previous, in order to work to keep the team afloat.
-Interim owners would be allowed, again, in the same fashion of the GM's.
-There would need to be more than monetary compensation for winning your league. I dunno what the motivation could be, but something other than a small trophy on your bio page (after all, there are tons of guys who deserve that trophy, then tons of people who had absolutely nothing to do with the team that won one, IE scotch cocks)
-League names need to be changed. No offense, but any reasonable adult can see that it's utterly ridiculous to think that somehow, any team in a league with "USA" are somehow automatically better than teams in other leagues.


Other than all that, i dunno what else can be done to keep people interested. When i search around the different forums, the one good thing I see is that there are a TON of owners and agents alike, who are passionate about football and about this sim. And that's the telling sign that a lot of people aren't just going to leave. But at the same time, steps need to be taken to insure long-term success and playability.

Just my humble opinions.



since it got skipped over entirely. I'm interested to hear thoughts about any of this.

You guys seem locked into 1 issue, when there are about 30 that need to be discussed.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by islander1




But how is it fair to anyone in a lower league to see some newbie owner luck into a Pro team?

Pro leagues should have the best teams in them. AAA the best teams after that. When teams are gutted, they should start at the bottom, like everyone else did at the time.


This works only if we know teams will stick around. Sadly, I think we have a fair amount of proof that that isn't the case.

I don't have an issue with demoting teams, but I don't think it will stop much. It also requires a very long, and strictly enforced, definition of "gutted".



It'll stop more then you think. There will always be gutting though. As long as we have teams being run by a player managing 20-30 other individual people...gutting will be a part of the game.

it's a better, and at least fundamentally more fair, solution to what we have now, which is Pro and AAA leagues that look like wastelands, while teams in AA and A leagues that can compete with these teams languish and pray that they don't get a single unlucky game in the playoffs, and are stuck being a great team in a low division, while dozens of garbage teams are in more prestigious leagues.




...until the next time.

We'll reset them, then people will gut mid/low level teams again, then in 3 seasons we'll hear "Fix gutting by reorganizing leagues".

It would seem that the better way to fix it would be to stop the gutting. I've suggested allowing Owners to decide to whom the team their selling will go, but I'm not sure if that'll catch on.


I agree with that suggestion. I agree the gutting is the problem of course.

However, I also think there needs to be a means in place to properly deal with it. It doesn't exist presently.

Thanks for the conversation, but I have to head out!
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Ming Sao


VT, let me put it like this.

Look at this thread. It contains a cross-section of players. Some who spend a lot of money, some who do not.

If this cross-section is ignored, what will that tell the people within said cross-section???????

While considering that, take a look at the myriad of other "HOT" topics of the day and consider who those issues are turning off.

Get the pic?



Sure, and I also understand that a very vocal 20 guys doesn't a ruined game make. Not that I disagree that there are a lot of fixes needed, but acting like a game that's 120 days old is beyond repair is overly-dramatic.

Originally posted by

If you don't mind me asking, how old are you?


How old do you think I am?




Oh, I think I see the mentality at large...


"Quit, be our guest. There will be a referral link responded to within the hour to take your place. Don't the the door hit you on the ass on the way out"


Close?
 
Tothehouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by XiaominWu

If you build a guy into lvl 25+ and he's not very good (because you guessed wrong, sorry)...... there is so very little you can do about it, as levelling slows down so dramatically. I think a lot of agents get discouraged/bored at this point and leave the game.


The fame system is designed to fix this in part I think. Basically, increasing the things that are gained from equipment (not bought equipment, sponsor equip) so that we have more freedom to change our players.



Yea but how much will it change it? Will you get additional equipment or will you be able to respend spent points? If its the prior that really doesnt do much. This is a HUGE problem. You get people excited and give them minimal information about how to build a good player. Then their player sucks and they get frustrated.

Again, what online game doesnt give its players information into how the games mechanics really work? How many succesful ones dont give players that information.

People get attached to players. If they build incorrectly there is nothign that can be done.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Otega
Originally posted by Otega

The reality is, the system currently in place, for leagues, is inherently flawed. And there is no good solution to fix it.

-Leveling from 1-21 is too fast
-Leveling from 25 + is too slow
-There is little to no separation from AA to AAA to Pro, in terms of levels (with the exception of teams with players who have played since day 1, in essence giving them a level advantage that cannot be overcome due to the way you level at 25+)
-Expansion teams starting, at basically level 13.9, has killed any chance to relieve that lack of separation.
-There is no real motivation to get from AA to the Pro's, other than E-Fame.

The sad truth is that the entire game would need a serious overhaul in order to fix the problems it currently has. And that is something that I would assume 90% of the players would rage against.

But, if it were to happen, this is how it would need to be, IMHO
-No D leagues
-Expansion teams start with players at level 1, and are not allowed to boost in season 1 until the end of the regular season. This would put a premium on managing depth charts, playing time, etc IE LEARNING THE GAME.
-Depth Chats on those teams would be required to have a minimum of 1 starter and 1 backup, thus forcing teams to a) fill out their roster in the proper fashion of a football team and b) not allow for making maxing xp, and not winning, the goal.
-Gutted/sold teams would move down to the "A" level, while MORE than just the conference champions would be allowed to move up, creating better competition and parity at the higher levels by filling the voids. This is something that is sorely needed at this point.
-Owners would be forced to have multiple GM's, thus voiding out the "inactive" owner issues when it comes to teams getting stuck with no chance to keep their team winning because they can't change the AUI for O/D/, DC, etc.
-Gm's would stay as GM's, if a team is sold and taken over by the CPU, and have all the privileges they had previous, in order to work to keep the team afloat.
-Interim owners would be allowed, again, in the same fashion of the GM's.
-There would need to be more than monetary compensation for winning your league. I dunno what the motivation could be, but something other than a small trophy on your bio page (after all, there are tons of guys who deserve that trophy, then tons of people who had absolutely nothing to do with the team that won one, IE scotch cocks)
-League names need to be changed. No offense, but any reasonable adult can see that it's utterly ridiculous to think that somehow, any team in a league with "USA" are somehow automatically better than teams in other leagues.


Other than all that, i dunno what else can be done to keep people interested. When i search around the different forums, the one good thing I see is that there are a TON of owners and agents alike, who are passionate about football and about this sim. And that's the telling sign that a lot of people aren't just going to leave. But at the same time, steps need to be taken to insure long-term success and playability.

Just my humble opinions.



since it got skipped over entirely. I'm interested to hear thoughts about any of this.

You guys seem locked into 1 issue, when there are about 30 that need to be discussed.


I think changing league names is ridiculous. I think most of your other ideas have at least some merit. And I think the whole idea will never happen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
-Leveling from 1-21 is too fast


Agree, but not a big issue

Originally posted by
-Leveling from 25 + is too slow


Agree, bigger then from 1-21 imo.

Originally posted by
-There is little to no separation from AA to AAA to Pro, in terms of levels (with the exception of teams with players who have played since day 1, in essence giving them a level advantage that cannot be overcome due to the way you level at 25+)


This will fix itself, excepting gutting, as we pass year 10.

Originally posted by
-Expansion teams starting, at basically level 13.9, has killed any chance to relieve that lack of separation.


Yeah, that level cap, and the methods around it didn't sit well with me either.

Originally posted by
-There is no real motivation to get from AA to the Pro's, other than E-Fame.


Oh man I agree, but this is getting fixed.

As for the fixes, most of them seemed nonsensical or useless.

Originally posted by
-Gm's would stay as GM's, if a team is sold and taken over by the CPU, and have all the privileges they had previous, in order to work to keep the team afloat.


This would be better if it said "could take over upon the owner's departure".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ming Sao
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Ming Sao



VT, let me put it like this.

Look at this thread. It contains a cross-section of players. Some who spend a lot of money, some who do not.

If this cross-section is ignored, what will that tell the people within said cross-section???????

While considering that, take a look at the myriad of other "HOT" topics of the day and consider who those issues are turning off.

Get the pic?



Sure, and I also understand that a very vocal 20 guys doesn't a ruined game make. Not that I disagree that there are a lot of fixes needed, but acting like a game that's 120 days old is beyond repair is overly-dramatic.

Originally posted by


If you don't mind me asking, how old are you?


How old do you think I am?




Oh, I think I see the mentality at large...


"Quit, be our guest. There will be a referral link responded to within the hour to take your place. Don't the the door hit you on the ass on the way out"


Close?


Pretty much, or not at all.
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
thunder you are wrong on the income issues...teams that have huge playoff cash immediately (unless they are stupid) sink that money into sections and seats...one trip the playoffs opens a wide gap for that season and all seasons after it...

im a seat/section building fool and a cheap salary approach guy...i believe in building early to be ready for big needs late...teams that dont finish in the top 4 are screwed after the 1st season in the league and that gulf only widens...you may choose not to believe it is true because you dont want to see it...but trust me it is an issue...im not sure you can pin the problems in GLB to any one item...but if i had to flag the top 2 issues that wrecked GLB i would say....

1. Playoff income disparity issues
2. Team rollouts with reckless abandon

so before the next offseason lets change some things...

1. Divide the playoff money and have a shared system like NCAA or just kill the revenues and only give the bonus money to the teams...

2. Stop adding new teams and create an ebay system for owners to sell teams to guys who want to be owners...let the current owner make an FP profit and charge him a commission of 20% to 40% of the sale price so GLB rakes the FP into the till...you can also charge the buyer 200 FP for the right to bid etc...that should slow down the incentive to gut because owners are enhancing FP accts by doing the value building etc.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.