User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Please stop with the averaging level idea - It's a terrible idea, but even if it wasn't - this isn't the thread for it.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
There's no reason to start a new thread about something that is already being discussed here and is merely a passing conversation.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I think it's valid in this thread in a way because the thread has touched on negatives with the OP idea, how it shouldnt just come in on its own without something also trying to address creating a parity at base levels etc.

So, anarcho is providing that idea. It may not be part of the think-tank of the OP, but i would vote "no" to the OP idea and it being premature of bort to endorse it without looking at the base parity ideas---because the OP idea is going to create more disparity.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I think it's valid in this thread in a way because the thread has touched on negatives with the OP idea, how it shouldnt just come in on its own without something also trying to address creating a parity at base levels etc.

So, anarcho is providing that idea. It may not be part of the think-tank of the OP, but i would vote "no" to the OP idea and it being premature of bort to endorse it without looking at the base parity ideas---because the OP idea is going to create more disparity.


I rarely agree with you, but I do here.

The other stuff isn't so bad... the cap-raising stuff? That's going way too far. You haven't considered the problems with that... firstly, if you raised the cap by 1, from 48 to 49, you should be getting an additional half a point into the skill, not a full point. Anyway, the way you have it set up now will mean that people will easily hit above 100 base in skills in the near future, which is extremely problematic.

One interesting side effect is that it will promote early boosting, right when you hit level 28. I'm undecided whether this is good or bad for the game.

There has to be another way to keep interest in the game amongst high-leveled players without resorting to something like this. I think the endorsements/fame stuff could really help.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
GG - Ok, if you want to give relavence to the averaging level idea discussion purely because it touches upon the notion that level differences are too great... then I'll be 100% honest with you, the averaging level idea actually MAKES THE PROBLEM WORSE.

Sound counter-intuitive? Follow the logic as best you can:

1) What are levels? Levels measure difference in abilities of various Players. A measurement of their attained experiences and abilities if you will. Right?

2) What are level disparities? Basically, a measure of the difference in abilities between Players of differing levels.

Still following me? I hope so, that's pretty basic stuff.

3) Why are level disparities bad? This is the tricky one - hopefully you are able to get this one right. Level disparities are not bad in themselves. To repeat: level disparities are not bad.. the only time that level disparities become a problem is when Players of different levels are put into a situation where they must compete for the same goals. If there is a colinear relationship between the chances of success and the difference of levels - then it becomes unbalanced to have the Players compete against each other. Did you answer it correctly? If not, go back to question 1 and start over. If you did get this far, then proceed to step 4.

4) Why would the level averaging idea make level disparities worse? The reason the averaging levels idea makes disparities worse is because the idea implies that it is ok for Players of different levels to compete against each other, without actually bringing them into parity as far as abilities are concerned.

5) Still following? Now for the real doozy: How can the idea in the OP be used to actually reduce the problems associated with level disparities? As presented - it can't.. but if you make a slight modification, allowing these Advanced skills to ONLY be used in Pro Leagues, then all of a sudden the idea becomes an incentive for higher level Players to play in the Pro leagues. The Power level difference between a level 32 and a level 12 is completely immaterial if they are playing in completely different leagues. Do parents worry about whether their child is able to compete against a Pro-ball player? Of course not, as long as the child is able to compete against other children, that is the important thing.

With that being said - I find myself only able to support the OP's idea if it leads to greater stratification between the different leagues. Any idea that just increases the abilities of higher level Players, without simultaneously creating more stratification, is an idea that should be tarred and feathered immediately.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
There has to be another way to keep interest in the game amongst high-leveled players without resorting to something like this.


This is a good point too. All this idea is doing is pandering to vets and making them get a bigger advantage over lower levels (even slightly lower levels). All it is is just giving people 5 pts to add to their attributes once every three days. Thats not creating a whole new level of interest for vet players. Just more chore of adding 5 and falling asleep. And these new attributes themselves are gonna end up like the existing base attributes where people spread misinformation around, people follow cookie-cutter prestige attributes, and one day Bort having to nerf/tweak prestige attributes after all these bugs and complaints start happening among the prestige attributes.

If there's to be any advanced SA or second tier of attributes to be implemented, it should be focused on a free form buffet style where players choose certain areas to specialize in out of a choice of things that they spend the rest of their career developing. But before all this, it is imperative that ideas centered around parity at the base levels is first devised.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
If there's to be any advanced SA or second tier of attributes to be implemented, it should be focused on a free form buffet style where players choose certain areas to specialize in out of a choice of things that they spend the rest of their career developing.


I agree with this statement.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Level disparities are not bad in themselves. The only time that level disparities become a problem is when Players of different levels are put into a situation where they must compete for the same goals. If there is a colinear relationship between the chances of success and the difference of levels - then it becomes unbalanced to have the Players compete against each other.


I totally agree with your point here. I would never argue against that. It's very deep and philosophical and I agree. But we come to the problem here where GLB does not want to restrict the player market, or restrict friends from having their own team and bringing in all their players....be it a pro team bringing in level 10's, or a BBB team bringing in level 30s. And I totally agree with GLB on this point. There needs to be a free player market, no level caps on teams/leagues, and all these band-aid measures trying to "discourage" a free market whilst endorsing a free market.

Originally posted by
Why would the level averaging idea make level disparities worse? Because the idea implies that it is ok for Players of different levels to compete against each other, without actually bringing them into parity as far as abilities are concerned.


Well, this is why I dont think the level averaging idea is THE way to go ultimately. It's still kind of a band-aid measure. The ONLY answer is a re-do/re-spec in creating a new player creation module. However, as Bort and others always suggest that Bort wont do anything drastic, then it's worth listening to ideas then that might work around the current system. It's NOT ideal, and there are enough band-aids.


Originally posted by
How can the idea in the OP be used to actually reduce the problems associated with level disparities? As presented - it can't.. but if you make a slight modification, allowing these Advanced skills to ONLY be used in Pro Leagues, then all of a sudden the idea becomes an incentive for higher level Players to play in the Pro leagues.


You made this suggestion before in this thread and I agree that what you added is a better parameter than what the OP initially had. So that's fine. But this whole idea, if it becomes implemented just for all these vet pro-leaguers, just to ease their boredom, then that's still very insincere of GLB to jump at this idea but continue to neglect the noob and back-ups and the core problems in the game. Which surely have to be priority #1. Also, if this were just for pro-leaguers, what kind of domino effect will this have on the rest of the leagues? It doesnt address the GLB-wide disparities, and actually would force more teams to sign nothing but the highest level players in AAA, AA, A, BBB, etc. And what happens to players who are all level 31 but playing in BBB league? They cant 'unlock' their prestige abilities and add to them whilever they're not in pro-league. Think how many level 30s will exist in the near future? There are not enough players to go around for Pro-league. So there's gonna be more disenchantment with all these level 30 players whittling away in A5 league or BB4 league unable to get a gig in pro-league. Losing seasons worth of potential prestige XP. Also, it doesnt stop disparity occuring in the pro-leagues because there's all these back-ups not getting enough snaps to earn as much prestige XP as starting prestige players.



 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG

All it is is just giving people 5 pts to add to their attributes once every three days. Thats not creating a whole new level of interest for vet players. Just more chore of adding 5 and falling asleep.

And these new attributes themselves are gonna end up like the existing base attributes where people spread misinformation around, people follow cookie-cutter prestige attributes, and one day Bort having to nerf/tweak prestige attributes after all these bugs and complaints start happening among the prestige attributes.


EXACTLY what I've been saying.

We already have SAs that plain don't work ('return specialist' anyone?) and others that no-one seem to know whether they're working or not. Add that to base attributes that keep getting chopped and changed and, again, no-one really knows what does what from one season to the next and everyone wants to add yet another set of Sas into the equation??

Seriously??

Fix the game first and foremost. Get the current attributes and SAs working 100% (or as near as dammit, given the normal error parmeters) and THAT ALONE might help keep people interested.

Once that's done, then make looking after the senior players a priority with all the bells and whistles you can throw at them - but PLEASE make sure these bells and whistles work before just adding them to the current mess.

There are LOTS of brilliant ideas being thrown into the mix - all of which would enhance the game no end.

But throwing more into the mix in its current state is like the old saying - like trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Well I agree with you 1VBChaos. That was a well-stated post.

 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
GG - you are right.. even my limiter for the idea (that the abilities are only available in the PRO league) would do little to change the mechanic as exists today.. level 28's playing against level 16's in AAA league.

But Let's say that the OP is implemented with the PRO stipulation.. It's atleast a step in the right direction. There is no doubt that vet players will get some sort of new abilities/options/something, probably multiple somethings, and I just want to make sure that the groundwork is laid to place those somethings where they belong - in the upper leagues. If Bort et al become wrapped up in the notion of increasing the power of high level Players, without giving any thought to the problem of level disparities - it gets ugly, fast.

Anyways, the OPs idea is one which exists outside of the current leveling system - that means it is easy to toggle depending on the league the Player is in. It also advances at a different rate than the standard leveling does, which means that it reduces the impact of leveling, once a Player reaches a threshold. In that way, it is very similar to your 200 idea. the difference being that your 200 idea reduces the impact of leveling at level 1, where this one doesn't reduce until level 31.

Anyways, I'm supporting the idea because I see potential for it to solve a lot of issues with the game... or maybe it won't do anything of the sort. Have to wait to learn more info about how Bort envisions it could be implemented. Without knowing his intentions - all this speculation is really worthless banter.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Xiong Yoshi...

Like I said, your parameter is better than not having that parameter. Just that it still has problems too. But, like you also said, Bort has mentioned interest in the OP idea (premature imo) and might take the crux of the idea and make it better. Wait and see what he has in mind. But it would still be very insincere how this idea gets pushed to the priority list and implemented before addressing the core problems of the game first like 1VBChaos stressed. There are bigger core problems than vets being bored. That might be #2 or #3 on the list.
 
Magnitude
offline
Link
 
I like this. It saves the tedious nature of the game from becoming worse.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by otto_g_2k8
This is an absolutely fantastic idea. I like Bort's Idea of it being VETERAN Special Abilities rather than calling it prestige. I also think it would be best if these SAs were not position specific, but SAs that apply to ALL positions. I'm thinking a "Veteran SA Tree" that is entirely about mental attributes.

Here is my take on it:

GENERAL MECHANICS:
There would be FIVE SAs on the veteran tree and the SP cost of these would work exactly like the current trees as far as the SP cost to build them up. You could not put any points into the Veteran SA Tree until you reached LVL 25. (this way there is no need to keep track of separate XP or "Prestige Levels" ... instead you just use the Five SPs you get for leveling up to build them if you choose) I chose LVL 25, since this is the point in time when a player really slows down and starts to get a little dull to manage. Also, the previous level (24) you just had the excitement of upgrading your equipment, and this will make that first really slow "level-up" really worth it!

VETERAN SPECIAL ABILITIES:
1. LOCKER ROOM LEADER: This player knows just what to say and when to say it. He also inspires his teammates with his tireless work ethic. Anytime this player steps on the field, his teammates play just a little harder as they don't want to let him down. (think Ray Lewis or Teddy Brushci)
2. FOOTBALL SMARTS: This player has seen it all and knows what to do about it. When this player is on the field, he will recognize what the other team is doing and call out adjustments/audibles if his teammates are not in position to make the play. (Think Mike Singletary)
3. AWE: This players reputation precedes him. Younger players (perhaps 5 levels lower, or perhaps anyone who doesn't have this ability themselves) are starstruck when competing against him and make more mental mistakes. Also effects refs, who, when a call is close, will give this player the benefit of the doubt. (Think Deion Sanders)
4. CLUTCH PLAYER: This player plays his best when the game is on the line. While others fear the pressure, he thrives on it. (think Roger Staubach or John Elway)
5. CHAMPION (or perhaps PLAYOFF PRO): This player doesn't feel the pressure of the playoffs, but rather his performance actually increases as the stakes get higher. (think Otto Graham or Joe Montana)((also activates in regular season games where the playoffs are on the line))

I think by having the "Veteran Special Abilities" the same for all positions and having it cost SP in the same fashion as the current SA trees, it will make those 5 SPs that you get after waiting half a season to level up WAY more useful and worth waiting for.



No SA tree. No specific position related "Perks". That's one area I agree strongly with GG on. There's already too much tunnel vision in creating players. This idea works withing the existing system to provide more branching out. Let's not continue with that.

Also, normal SPs need to stay completely separate from the VP points. The issue is with the too-slow accumulation of SPs at higher levels. Making new trees work off the same SP system doesn't solve the problem.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I think it's valid in this thread in a way because the thread has touched on negatives with the OP idea, how it shouldnt just come in on its own without something also trying to address creating a parity at base levels etc.

So, anarcho is providing that idea. It may not be part of the think-tank of the OP, but i would vote "no" to the OP idea and it being premature of bort to endorse it without looking at the base parity ideas---because the OP idea is going to create more disparity.



Bort has looked at base parity and said it's not feasible without blowing up the whole system and he's not willing to do that. Give it up. I was willing to let you vent in here but now you are just taking advantage of the fact that this is a stickied thread to pursue your own agenda - which has already been rejected.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.