User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > About to process compensation package
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by dkgojackets



I heard gturtle has a plan he likes.


DO I EVER


Originally posted by Gturtle


Here's how I'd solve the problem-

Total flex points spent for boosting all players owned by a given agent in the CPL during seasons 2 or 3, take that number, double it, give it back to the agent.




How to handle who gets it- Player must have played in the CPL for at least 8 games of the season or post-season to qualify



How to prove who qualifies- error on the side of caution. In order to qualify for the compensation, players must PM a dummy account set up by Bort, with links to players who qualify and their game logs. Someone checks the game log, looks for the ticker "MIA" (the current ticker displayed for Dong Energy in the Canada Pro East) or the ticker "TOR" (ticker for Toronto Renegades, who were in Canada Pro West for Season 2.) Make an announcement, and to prevent people from wasting your time, make it a seven day forum ban for attempting to qualify if you don't.


There, you are awarded FP based upon how many players you have that were affected. You are also awarded FP based upon how many seasons they were affected for. Most of all, you've established a clear cut off point, and a clear way to qualify yourself for compensation.



That sounds like it would literally take weeks to sort through...which would certainly not help people feel any better. I don't think 7 day forum bans wouldn't keep people from being friggin annoying and sending players who had nothing to do with it.

It would probably be quicker to write a script to parse the database for the same sort of data, but it would still take a while.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Wanderer
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by


I really dont think the builds are a big deal since they were from so long ago and are useless now.


This seems to be a point of confusion for some reason. People keep mentioning the builds when ^^^ is clearly right. It's not the builds that irritate most people, it's that they were playing in a league that wasn't throwing striaght dice.


Yeah, I'd have to agree. Sure, it sucks that several players on Dryden were compromised, but we universally agree we're more pissed off about the season 2 playoff game versus Dong when they totally messed up our tactics (damn FB passes!). I'm sure CCC would agree, as they lost to them during the previous game with similar results.

But regardless, it is much appreciated that Bort is taking the time to make things right.


This is amazingly key. Let's (I'm assuming Borts working with us on this) not rush to get this done. I've already lost a player over this, and I'm likely to lose more, but let's take the time to get this right as opposed to rushing to a speedy solution.
 
verus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, sorry guys, I haven't really been available much the last day or so - my PC has been giving me problems with friggin blue screens every few minutes. Kinda makes it hard to get any work done... I think I found the prob tho - one of my RAM sticks seems to have gone bad.

Anyways...the problem I had is that it's hard to track down who's been in and out of CPL, on and off teams, etc for the past 3 seasons. I figured that the team ownership extension, etc, would kinda have a trickle down to the rest of the players on the teams. Maybe I shouldn't study Reaganomics?

Also, somehow I didn't manage to get a copy of the builds that were posted on the dong site, either...don't know how I managed to miss it? I have most of the other stuff. I'm pretty sure Ash has a copy, though?

In any case, what would make everyone happy? 1000 FP's to people who were on the exposed builds list? 1000 FP's to every player who's currently in CPL? I didn't have any intention of being a jerk to anybody like some people seem to think...


A set amount to everyone who hasn't already received compensation seems fair. 1000 FP seems rather a lot, but I've been constantly shocked by your generocity in this. While it's possible to find fault in your execution of the compensation thing, I don't think anyone can fault your intention.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

That sounds like it would literally take weeks to sort through...which would certainly not help people feel any better. I don't think 7 day forum bans wouldn't keep people from being friggin annoying and sending players who had nothing to do with it.

It would probably be quicker to write a script to parse the database for the same sort of data, but it would still take a while.



Yeah, that idea requires a lot of foot-work, but it does the best job of getting appropriate compensation to the people who deserve it (imo, of course)

Essentially any compensation plan will work, as long as there's a way to prove that you qualify for it. There just needs to be a way to stop joe average FFA poster from attempting to abuse it.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
for logistic purposes it pretty much has to be a universal script, although there is certainly room for manual adjustment in some cases. It should be based upon how much people spent on players in cpl, not just some arbitrary amount across the league. And honestly I know I care about my team and the time Ive put into the game more than everyone else (they can argue their own battles) and really think that in season 3 we clearly got directly screwed more than anyone. Wont speak for season 2 or other teams gripes.
 
kidcolin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
one of my RAM sticks seems to have gone bad.


they've got pills for that now
 
Wanderer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kidcolin
Originally posted by

one of my RAM sticks seems to have gone bad.


they've got pills for that now



LOL.

I can see Trout players with negative flex point balances shortly...
 
kidcolin
offline
Link
 
I think Gturtle's solution is a bit tedious and probably unrealistic. It's not just lots of foot-work, it's an admin nightmare.

Just a baseline to all of CPL seems easier and more appeasing. I admit it's probably fairer for guys with multiple players to receive more FP, assuming they spent more FP. I agree with verus that 1K seems a lot, but that's coming from me who spends 300FP a season.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Depending on how difficult it would be to script:

Everyone who currently has a player in CPL who has not yet received compensation, receives the equivalent for 3 boosts of that player in flex points. This would be allocated on a per player basis rather than per user basis, so the guys with more players receive more.

I can't see any glaring flaws in this one, but then I'm quite bad at errorchecking my own stuff so...
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Depending on how difficult it would be to script:

Everyone who currently has a player in CPL who has not yet received compensation, receives the equivalent for 3 boosts of that player in flex points. This would be allocated on a per player basis rather than per user basis, so the guys with more players receive more.

I can't see any glaring flaws in this one, but then I'm quite bad at errorchecking my own stuff so...


Players who are in the CPL this season who weren't in it previous seasons.

Players who aren't in the CPL this season who were in it previous seasons.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by Vando

Depending on how difficult it would be to script:

Everyone who currently has a player in CPL who has not yet received compensation, receives the equivalent for 3 boosts of that player in flex points. This would be allocated on a per player basis rather than per user basis, so the guys with more players receive more.

I can't see any glaring flaws in this one, but then I'm quite bad at errorchecking my own stuff so...


Players who are in the CPL this season who weren't in it previous seasons.

Players who aren't in the CPL this season who were in it previous seasons.


Of course, the second case could be handled on a per-individual basis.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Players who are in the CPL this season who weren't in it previous seasons.

Players who aren't in the CPL this season who were in it previous seasons.


This is where the real headache is - sorting out who moved in/out of CPL, and when, etc.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
I really don't think there are many of those cases. Certainly they're not the ones posting here claiming they aren't getting the compensation they deserve.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 12:14:31
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
I really don't think there are many of those cases.


yeah but finding those cases would be a lot of work
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by Vando

I really don't think there are many of those cases.


yeah but finding those cases would be a lot of work


Pretty sure this would be a case of 'ignore them until it becomes an issue'.

You can spend a world of time coming up with and implementing an elegant solution that covers everything first time, or you can spend a little time on a workmanlike solution that leaves a few gaps, and wait for people to put their hands up and say 'hey, what about me?'

The trick is to make the workmanlike solution good enough, it doesn't have to be perfect.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 12:20:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.