User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Really? Want to show me where? Want to show me where He says "if you dont believe in me youll perish"? Im going to bet He doesnt. Ohh he says (I paraphrase by the way) "Only through me can you enter the kingdom of heaven". That doesnt literally mean "you must believe that I am the one true God or youre screwed". It means "hey this is how you should live your life - do that and youre cool".

Imagine a hypothetical island thats never heard of Christ. Everyone is nice to everyone and helps the poor and the sick and theyre considerate etc. They worship the monkey god "rasputaboo". One day missionaries arrive. They decide "well stick with Rasputaboo. This Jesus guy has the right idea but weve lived the way He asks without worshiping Him for centuries and our monkey god is working out fine. Thanks though. Must have been a tough journey - here have something to eat". You honestly think God wouldnt let those people into heaven because even though they were leading the life He asks of us they worship a monkey?

Yeah youre real open minded! By the way im a practicing Catholic. See it is possible to believe in Jesus and think that others can be right too.
 
colonelghost
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by EmpYllek

Actually its incredibly narrow minded and frankly insulting to humanity as a whole to say that unless you believe that Jesus is your saviour you cant go to heaven. Plus Jesus never said that once anywhere in the bible. He said "i am the way" and all that stuff but that doesnt mean "Believe in me or perish". It means to live your life as a good person in line with His teachings.

An atheist or a Muslim or a Hindu or whatever can lead a good life and be a good person and get into heaven. To claim otherwise is just being ignorant.


I'm glad you know for sure the rules to get into heaven. You must be the only person on the planet who does.

I think God will decide that.... not you, me, a pastor, or pope. I just go by what is said in the Bible.


Narrow minded = liberal talk for anyone who doesn't want to accept their way of thinking.

As an atheist, Muslim, or Hindu, you are free to believe whatever you want, it won't bother me at all. I'm just telling you what myself and most Christians believe. Don't tell us that our beliefs are wrong and then tell us that we are narrow minded for not believing what you do. LOL.


The narrow-mindedness comes from Christians saying that if you don't believe in Jesus Christ, you are going to hell, and there is no deviation. You can't say "well colonelghost is a good man, lives a good life, makes people happy, does the morally right thing, he's okay". Instead, I could be the nicest more moral man in the world, but if I don't believe in Jesus then I am to burn in hell?

There are many different religions, what makes you think Christianity is the right way?

anyways, as a sidenote I personally don't believe in an afterlife, in any religious texts. I believe that when we die, we die - finished, the end.
 
colonelghost
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Really? Want to show me where? Want to show me where He says "if you dont believe in me youll perish"? Im going to bet He doesnt. Ohh he says (I paraphrase by the way) "Only through me can you enter the kingdom of heaven". That doesnt literally mean "you must believe that I am the one true God or youre screwed". It means "hey this is how you should live your life - do that and youre cool".

Imagine a hypothetical island thats never heard of Christ. Everyone is nice to everyone and helps the poor and the sick and theyre considerate etc. They worship the monkey god "rasputaboo". One day missionaries arrive. They decide "well stick with Rasputaboo. This Jesus guy has the right idea but weve lived the way He asks without worshiping Him for centuries and our monkey god is working out fine. Thanks though. Must have been a tough journey - here have something to eat". You honestly think God wouldnt let those people into heaven because even though they were leading the life He asks of us they worship a monkey?

Yeah youre real open minded! By the way im a practicing Catholic. See it is possible to believe in Jesus and think that others can be right too.


+1000000
 
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Really? Want to show me where? Want to show me where He says "if you dont believe in me youll perish"? Im going to bet He doesnt. Ohh he says (I paraphrase by the way) "Only through me can you enter the kingdom of heaven". That doesnt literally mean "you must believe that I am the one true God or youre screwed". It means "hey this is how you should live your life - do that and youre cool".



John 3:18
"...but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God."

 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Youre seriously going to take that LITERALLY? Christianity is not about an arbitrary statement of "I believe" or "I dont believe". Its about doing the right thing as opposed to being a dick. THAT is the belief Jesus talks about. The belief in good itself. Theres a reason he tells parables. He wants us to think about things and decide for our selves.

Yeah if you dont believe in God youre losing something which those of us who do believe in Him have. You lose the strength of faith (not that you cant have strength through other things just not that strength - you know what I mean) sure but if youre leading your life properly then someone who is the embodiment of love isnt going to judge you on whether you had faith. In many ways its more commendable for someone who doesnt believe in God or heaven or hell to be a good person. It would be so easy if you didnt believe to just be selfish and ignore everyone else.

No doubt youll think this is nonsense and come out with some crap about how catholics are evil too and blah blah blah. This is why you never get in an argument with a Republican....

EDIT : For what its worth the Catholic version of that passage merely says that those who dont believe have already been judged. Kind of meaning that those who dont believe dont get the same chance to repent at the end sort of thing. If theyve led a good life though - then whos to say that the judgement that has already been made isnt a good one?
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 15:36:46
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
Originally posted by Blitz81

Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet


There is nothing in this world that can make me believe in a mythic being that only exists as a weapon against the very dumbest of people to control them. The people in power in religious circles continue to use scare tactics as well as outdated morality as to hold plenty af naive people enslaved in mind.

You have your right to believe in any cock-a-mainy thing there ever was though, you guys just believe in the oldest going fraud that is out there.


I don't think morality is ever outdated!


But morality shifts! Something become acceptable in one time, isnt or is more so later. Do you wear only two types of thread? In leviticus this is a stoning offense if you arent.


It was a stoning offense, but not by christians, not trying to be a smartass, jsut saying that wasn't a christian law.
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by EmpYllek

Really? Want to show me where? Want to show me where He says "if you dont believe in me youll perish"? Im going to bet He doesnt. Ohh he says (I paraphrase by the way) "Only through me can you enter the kingdom of heaven". That doesnt literally mean "you must believe that I am the one true God or youre screwed". It means "hey this is how you should live your life - do that and youre cool".



John 3:18
"...but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God."



EmpYllek said it well, and I too am a Catholic, that verse is not taken literally by any Catholics that I have been taught by. And again like EmpYllek said, nowhere does it say how he has been judged.
In my studies and from my experiences all real religions follow the same core ideas and morals, if you act right as a human being you will be "saved" and if not well then you will be "damned", althought I don't like those terms either, but I digress.

 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by colonelghost
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by EmpYllek


Actually its incredibly narrow minded and frankly insulting to humanity as a whole to say that unless you believe that Jesus is your saviour you cant go to heaven. Plus Jesus never said that once anywhere in the bible. He said "i am the way" and all that stuff but that doesnt mean "Believe in me or perish". It means to live your life as a good person in line with His teachings.

An atheist or a Muslim or a Hindu or whatever can lead a good life and be a good person and get into heaven. To claim otherwise is just being ignorant.


I'm glad you know for sure the rules to get into heaven. You must be the only person on the planet who does.

I think God will decide that.... not you, me, a pastor, or pope. I just go by what is said in the Bible.


Narrow minded = liberal talk for anyone who doesn't want to accept their way of thinking.

As an atheist, Muslim, or Hindu, you are free to believe whatever you want, it won't bother me at all. I'm just telling you what myself and most Christians believe. Don't tell us that our beliefs are wrong and then tell us that we are narrow minded for not believing what you do. LOL.


The narrow-mindedness comes from Christians saying that if you don't believe in Jesus Christ, you are going to hell, and there is no deviation. You can't say "well colonelghost is a good man, lives a good life, makes people happy, does the morally right thing, he's okay". Instead, I could be the nicest more moral man in the world, but if I don't believe in Jesus then I am to burn in hell?

There are many different religions, what makes you think Christianity is the right way?

anyways, as a sidenote I personally don't believe in an afterlife, in any religious texts. I believe that when we die, we die - finished, the end.


Thats not really what i find narrow minded about christianity....... I more find the hatred of gay men. The mass executions of Muslims back in the crusades narrow minded. Yeah
 
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Youre seriously going to take that LITERALLY? Christianity is not about an arbitrary statement of "I believe" or "I dont believe". Its about doing the right thing as opposed to being a dick. THAT is the belief Jesus talks about. The belief in good itself. Theres a reason he tells parables. He wants us to think about things and decide for our selves.

Yeah if you dont believe in God youre losing something which those of us who do believe in Him have. You lose the strength of faith (not that you cant have strength through other things just not that strength - you know what I mean) sure but if youre leading your life properly then someone who is the embodiment of love isnt going to judge you on whether you had faith. In many ways its more commendable for someone who doesnt believe in God or heaven or hell to be a good person. It would be so easy if you didnt believe to just be selfish and ignore everyone else.

No doubt youll think this is nonsense and come out with some crap about how catholics are evil too and blah blah blah. This is why you never get in an argument with a Republican....

EDIT : For what its worth the Catholic version of that passage merely says that those who dont believe have already been judged. Kind of meaning that those who dont believe dont get the same chance to repent at the end sort of thing. If theyve led a good life though - then whos to say that the judgement that has already been made isnt a good one?



You're entitled to believe anything you wish. You can even convince yourself that what you believe is consistent with Catholic teaching and/or Christian teaching. Many would not agree with you in that regard. John 3:3 says "Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God." You've done enough reading to know that there's no shortage of similar verses. If you're comfortable convincing yourself that belief in Jesus is optional, you're welcome to follow that path. But you would be in error to call that option consistent with Catholic/Christian doctrine.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12

I more find the hatred of gay men.



That's not a Christian doctrine.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cheese12
Thats not really what i find narrow minded about christianity....... I more find the hatred of gay men. The mass executions of Muslims back in the crusades narrow minded. Yeah


the "mass executions of Muslims" pale in comparison to the slaughter of jews and (other) christians during the crusades. most of the marauding armies (if you could call them that) didn't even leave europe before committing a few atrocities.
 
Sachem
offline
Link
 
Well if you are going to call Catholics narrowminded for that you can call every other religion narrow minded. Do not forget that The Jews were persecuted, The Catholics were persecuted, the Muslims were persecuted, etc... Aldo do not forget that the Crusades had wars inbetween where muslims slaughtered Christians, and so on and so forth..
As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.
 
cheese12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by cheese12

Thats not really what i find narrow minded about christianity....... I more find the hatred of gay men. The mass executions of Muslims back in the crusades narrow minded. Yeah


the "mass executions of Muslims" pale in comparison to the slaughter of jews and (other) christians during the crusades. most of the marauding armies (if you could call them that) didn't even leave europe before committing a few atrocities.


Tiny fact here, the muslims where killing in war, the christians said the Muslims were barbaric yes? well then the Christians took back Jerusalem Killed every Muslim for miles around and washed the city in Muslim blood.... sounds as little barbaric to me... Does anyone know what Saladin washed the city in when he took it back? Rosewater

The christians were killed invading a land that wasn't theirs and during battles. The Muslims were killed in their own land, with with a large portion being executed outside of battles

And i see your point about other 'Christians killing other christians in Europe.... really shows off the sanctity of the religon
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 15:55:51
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sachem

As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


wait, an instrumentalist argument? sounds like someone's veering close to the starting points of darwinism.

quick question: should sterile men be allowed to have sex? what about women who are infertile or post-menopausal? are you against the performance of hysterectomies?
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sachem

As for the gay thing, I dont know what you want to hear, I took human anatomy, I don't see gay sex fulfilling the point of reproductive organs and from what I have heard that is the problem the church has with it. But again i Digress.


Maybe god had a little look in on his project and realised that going the way it was that there was a danger of over population. With this in mind he used his god powers to zap in a few gays to bring order and balance back to the world. No doubt he told one of his new apostles and nobody is listening.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.