User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1

You don't see 255-0 scores in the NFL, yet few seem to complain about their lack of realism.



Actually, there are plenty of threads where folks have awoke this year to realize that 116-ZERO outcomes are ruining the usefulness of stats.

 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=10553

Another game with 7 interceptions thrown... by the Philadelphia Pushovers, one of the best teams in all of Goal Line Blitz.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
im glad i read this thread because now i know what not to do with my qb thank you so very much
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Bort's response answered one question - Apparently there is no difference for it having been a Play Off game as opposed to a Regular Season game.


I didn't see him answer that question...? Where is it here?

Ok, I looked over their players and tactics. They have some "aura" and "trash talk" guys on their team. They also gameplanned against the pass. Their secondary is very good. Their D-Line is also good. Jake pariah led the league in sacks and come in second for hurries. They have some o-line guys with 7+ in pancake skill and very good strength.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: low confidence can cause problems for every single player on the field when things are going wrong. Playing with low morale is like playing with low energy. If both are low, you're really in trouble!

Yes, 10 INT's is a lot, but it's not impossible. Some of them could have been PD's or incompletions, but the random number generator didn't go your way.

One selected game out of over 1000 per day does not mean everything is broken; everybody runs on the same code, same server. It just means you got unlucky. Somebody else probably got very lucky the other way in your stead. Also, comparing outcomes to games earlier in the season doesn't always work to figure out how it will go in the second matchup. Teams improve, boost, bring in new players, etc.

And no, we do not offer refunds just because a game didn't go your way.
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
guys guys we are all forgetting my post lol it makes the most sense

maybe Bort is an alien and plays Alien football.....

seriously you ever heard of street football or pick up games etc.....come on American football that we see on T.V. isn't the only football games out there


saying that though I do agree that sim was a bit ya know....not that great
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by wombat killer



Just because it happened doesn't mean it is a good thing. Maybe the "death spiral" is so unrealistic it needs to be looked at. Or maybe other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it.



Possibly, but then how worthless would Confidence be?
This thread has more or less proven the worth of confidence. We remove the need to have confidence, a QB needs 3 stats? Throwing/Strength/Vision?
If his QB had only 29 throwing, and had this bad of a game, would we be asking the sim to be changed so that 29 throwing at level 25 is enough?

Its our job as the players to try to find the good builds. Lesson to be learned is that confidence AT TIMES, is more important than any other stat. How important it is? I dont know.


I didn't say it shouldn't have an impact. Of course it should. My comment about other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it wasn't about stats. It was about being able to pull a very poorly performing player.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Wow, after looking at the records for NFL & NCAA for interceptions I'm thinking the 10 today wasn't completely unreasonable. If Favre (a future HOFer) could throw 6 in a game, then some lowly lv25 could easily throw 10. Sorry guy, but I've changed my tune. Now if a solidly built lv40 had done this, I'd questions the SIM, but at this point as Bort said, there were 1000 games/day and the odds were with us for at least one record to be broken. I bet if we scoured all the games we could find a few more with 7+ INTs. Personally I learned the complete value of confidence earlier this season as our kicker went 0-5 in our two 17-14 losses...one game he went 0-3 in regulation and we lost in overtime. Sucks to be us. Reality is that our kicker had a confidence level in the mid 20's (he was a lv5 kicker). Alas he'll improve, and so will your QB if he concentrates on his confidence.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Ken1


You don't see 255-0 scores in the NFL, yet few seem to complain about their lack of realism.



Actually, there are plenty of threads where folks have awoke this year to realize that 116-ZERO outcomes are ruining the usefulness of stats.



People only complain because of the trophies.

See, the difference between GLB and the NFL is that GLB has hard methods of player evaluation. Two players can be exactly the same in build, and should perform identically in the same situation. It doesn't matter that one person's stats are significantly better the previous season. It was because of the team, not the individual player, as the skill sets are the same.

On the other hand, there are no guarantees in the NFL. You can't give a number rating to a player's vision in real life football. How do you know their confidence?

To always try to compare them is stupid.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi




As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



Yeah there was. There have been many games with tons of interceptions.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=46818

7 interceptions.

And yes, 52 stamina may not be greedy, but it's stupid. People have already said that your QB has a crap build. Deal with it.



If this game purports to sim (American) football, there's simply no justifying a 10 interception game in the PLAYOFFS. If "the build" were the problem, an accurate sim would have prevented us from ever reaching that game.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Serenity



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.



Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?



Not even "bad" PLAYOFF QB's throw TEN in a game. Not in the pros, not in college.

Today's sim was a bad joke.



It hasn't even happened in the NFL that a QB not good enough to make the playoffs (or a team starting such a QB) has thrown 10 interceptions in a game.

Tim Couch, the Browns' first first-round draft pick after Cleveland got the franchise again, who was a huge bust but got 5 seasons of trying and failing to play well, never threw 10 interceptions in a game.

He threw 21 interceptions in his worst *season* for interceptions. Given above records for turnovers in a game that are posted, I can say with certainty that he never threw above 7 (and probably never threw above 4 or 5) in a game.

And we're talking about a bad QB (probably among the worst 10% of QB's who started in the NFL for 3 or more years) on a bad team (in those days). He couldn't even get a backup job after the Browns released him.

This happening in a Beta, I'd call understandable. This not being seen as a problem by some, not so understandable.


You clearly do not get it. The reasoning has already been explained out in the thread.

You don't see 255-0 scores in the NFL, yet few seem to complain about their lack of realism.

The fact is that clearly there's no QB in the NFL that's bad enough to throw 10 interceptions in a game (and the coach wouldn't let the QB stay in the game), as the players have to be pretty good already to make the NFL.


Okay, I'll concede that point.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever


You don't see 255-0 scores in the NFL, yet few seem to complain about their lack of realism.



Are you being serious? You think people aren't complaining about massive blowouts?
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Bort's response answered one question - Apparently there is no difference for it having been a Play Off game as opposed to a Regular Season game.


I didn't see him answer that question...? Where is it here?



When he said that there were 1000's of sims done every day with no changes... if there was a significant difference between a playoff game, and a regular one, then this statement would be false.

Originally posted by
One selected game out of over 1000 per day does not mean everything is broken; everybody runs on the same code, same server.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 18:40:05
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Checkmate187

I bet nobody will underestimate confidence again.



Today's sim makes the "playable cheerleaders" suggestion seem like a good one--its every bit as reasonable as a playoff QB tossing nine picks in a game before his backup comes in to throw a tenth.


Just so you know... I would be upset too. Our team had a game earlier in the season that I just did not understand. Not as extreme as your example, but certainly a head scratcher.

Obviously I don't know the algorithms involved with confidence and in-game morale, but to my untrained eyes it seems like it might have a bit more influence than one might anticipate.

But as Bort said also, with a random number generator there is always the possibility of getting a few bad rolls in a row (or ten).

Hang in.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi





As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



Yeah there was. There have been many games with tons of interceptions.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=46818

7 interceptions.

And yes, 52 stamina may not be greedy, but it's stupid. People have already said that your QB has a crap build. Deal with it.



If this game purports to sim (American) football, there's simply no justifying a 10 interception game in the PLAYOFFS. If "the build" were the problem, an accurate sim would have prevented us from ever reaching that game.



Looking at your season you guys lived off the run alot. The run got shot down and finally forced you to pass alot.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
you just need to retire that guy let him go run marathons
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.