User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
And that has to do with exactly what? Obviously you're not gonna stick around USA Pro if you arent willing to boost, its the highest level of competition there is. How is that related to FP contracts? You think that every person in USA Pro who boosts has his boosts paid for by the team's owner? The whole Bort comment just shoots a hole in your theory. The admins had a voice(and the final say so) in this decision with the mods. Dont you think that if it was some kind of conspiracy between the mods and admins to keep their teams at the top that Bort's players would have had their boosts taken care of too? Why not, according to you he was in on the whole thing too.

You're losing sight of the original issue you said you had a problem with.



I never said that.


The issue is:

What's the difference between giving the money to a player on your team and a FA? There isn't a difference. Both are ways to keep/acquire good players.

One difference is that one player...people knew they missed out on (the FA). The other player....they didn't even know that they could have had him.

So obviously players like Morgan are only going to complain about what they can see.

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill


The intent was to make it less visible in recruiting, so that those people who cant offer FPs for signing with them dont get drowned out by those who can, making it near impossible to sign people. At least this way, people have to go out of their way to do it, and its not gonna be plastered in every FA post, so the field remains fairly level when you go through the official routes to recruit.


If you ban ALL FP transactions, it will level the playing field even more. As of right now, if you have the good players, you can give them FP to keep them. These players will not become FAs and thus all new owners will be effectively shut out from EVER being able to sign them.

If you ban ALL FP transactions, this will also be against the rules, thus giving everyone a fair shot at landing better players.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider



So obviously players like Morgan are only going to complain about what they can see.



How can I complain about something I don't see? LOL

Am I supposed to complain that some team is giving out FP Contracts but when asked for proof be like well I don't have any.

But I agree with you with the statement of giving players already on your team as the same as giving a FA FP. Players wont want to leave if they get FP, but if they see a coach who quit giving FP, they will be on the first ship out.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by hud



Originally posted by ACES




I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.


However, if the player who receives those flex points at a later time ever wants to blackmail you, he can say that you gave him the points as a condition that you re-sign. At that point you are screwed. If 2 such players that you gave FP's to banned together because they don't like your gameplans, they could have you permanantly banned.


They would have to have some kind of proof. Proof they wouldn't have.


They never said that proof was required. They said they would take it on a case by case basis. Accusations against certain owners (me) would definitely be enough IMO.


Now you just sound paranoid.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The ONLY REASON why this is an issue is because teams want to improve. Short of waiting 10-12 seasons until the Tim Hapers / early testers players start to decline, there doesn't seem to be any way to put together the TOP team in this game.

And to make it even more unfair, you allow a policy where Tim Harper can pay to keep his level 27 and 28 players together, but you don't allow us to pay to try to take them away from him.

You make policies to allow the early testers to keep their mulitple teams, then no one else is allowed.

You make policies to allow early players to keep their farm teams even though it was implied from the beginning that it was "against the spirit of the game".

Then you even make policies to penalize high level players for leaving PRO. I'm a Pro team and I benefit GREATLY from that rule, but I think it is BS. Who cares if high level players want to play in low leagues?? Guess who this helps the most though? USA PRO and early testers of course.

I guess it sure helps to be friends with the owner/developer when it comes to making rules.....


If you want to make rules to protect the monopoly/chokehold that USA Pro (and 2/3 of the MODS) have on this game right now, then just say so. I'll come back in 10-12 seasons when I have a fair chance.....

....otherwise, stop cracking down on the little guys who are trying to improve and instead crack down on the guys who have dominated the game for the first 3 seasons and will continue to do so for the forseeable future.


Hey Steelers, I apologize. I did not understand where you were coming from. I really thought you had a problem with the rule other than the fact that you want to have the option to be the best. I truly hear where you are coming from man. I understand that from other games. Why play if you have to settle for second best no matter how much effort and work you put in? It does sucks, and I dont know the answer. think about a competitive guy who runs across the game today, he loves the concept and the game play, but how long will it take him to get to the top? Who knows. It sucks even worse for him. I do understand that totally, but I feel obligated to defend a couple of things.

First, there are non alpha guys doing real well in the USA pros, so it is not an absolute. And I imagine that in at least two seasons, an owner of a non alpha team with mostly non alpha players will win the USA pro.

Second, stopping FP contracts is not a mod's initiative. this was Bort's intent from the beginning. We just had no power to enforce blatant disregard for this issue. If someone was offering FP contracts on the boards, we would lock or delete the thread, but we didn't feel we had the power to go further. These rules were approved by the admins to help in that regard. they are not perfect, but now with official word, we can help curb something Bort doesnt want to the best of our ability.

Third, I think you go to far when you question Bort's intent and bias when it comes to the early guys. I dont mind you question us for putting ideas in his ear that help us, but Bort is not a weak man. And he loves this game, has poured himself into for longer than most imagine, and wants it to be fun and playable for all who come along. Hell, Daggers even compared it to his own baby as I remember. If it has happened that we have unfair advantages, it is not because Bort wanted it that way, it is because he was doing what he thought was best when the issue arose. Just as an example, take the multiple teams. When the game started Bort had no clue that there would be so many who wanted to own a team so quickly. so we didnt have a rule about owning more than one team. when the shortage came at first, he didn't think it was right to strip people who had paid for and worked on teams. In hind sight, maybe he should have. But it is too late at this point. So to imply that "he just did it for his buds" is not taking into account the history of the game and also is a pretty harsh statement to make about bort. Slam those you consider his buds all you want, I dont know all of their motives.

Finally, I am not sure that battling this issue is gonna do anything for your disappointment in the overall situation. Again, I dont know the answer, but you are probably gonna have to battle it in another format, this one is come and gone. I am sure there are some viable ideas out there, I dont go to the suggestions much. But it is probably time to focus on this issue in a positive way.

Thanks for confronting this problem again, in my arrogance, i overlooked it completely in this FP contract issue.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The ONLY REASON why this is an issue is because teams want to improve. Short of waiting 10-12 seasons until the Tim Hapers / early testers players start to decline, there doesn't seem to be any way to put together the TOP team in this game.

And to make it even more unfair, you allow a policy where Tim Harper can pay to keep his level 27 and 28 players together, but you don't allow us to pay to try to take them away from him.

You make policies to allow the early testers to keep their mulitple teams, then no one else is allowed.

You make policies to allow early players to keep their farm teams even though it was implied from the beginning that it was "against the spirit of the game".

Then you even make policies to penalize high level players for leaving PRO. I'm a Pro team and I benefit GREATLY from that rule, but I think it is BS. Who cares if high level players want to play in low leagues?? Guess who this helps the most though? USA PRO and early testers of course.

That is why I keep arguing: I want a chance to win the whole thing, or I don't want to play. Others feel the same way.

We're giving you a little time to straighten things out, but I'm not putting another penny in until I see that I have a chance to own the best team in the league in less than 10-12 season. Otherwise, we are just filler teams to help pay for the USA Pro Teams and the only league that seems to matter in this game. I guess it sure helps to be friends with the owner/developer when it comes to making rules.....


If you want to make rules to protect the monopoly/chokehold that USA Pro (and 2/3 of the MODS) have on this game right now, then just say so. I'll come back in 10-12 seasons when I have a fair chance.....

....otherwise, stop cracking down on the little guys who are trying to improve and instead crack down on the guys who have dominated the game for the first 3 seasons and will continue to do so for the forseeable future.


I still think you are/were WRONG SI - but you've not been banned yet, which shows that no action is being taken against cheats. Like it or not, that's what you are according to the current 'rule'.

But then again, I also agree TOTALLY with what you're saying about the likes of Tim Harper and the number of apla testers and mods that quite obviously have a conflict of interest by having players in the game that 'just happen' to be some of the highest ranked and most successful players out there........

I also agree that this game is 'dominated' by a handful of agents who, by their association with the mods/admins/alpha testers get away with just about anything and everything.

But last time I looked, you were closely associated with these players, so I'm guessing they'll have passed on some of their knowledge too?? And perhaps the fact that you're even still here is because of YOUR association with these people?? I wonder if someone like me would still be here if I'd cheated like you??

My big dissapointment comes because, despite numerous PMs, the admins of this game are still claiming to know nothing about what's going on......
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
If it has happened that we have unfair advantages, it is not because Bort wanted it that way, it is because he was doing what he thought was best when the issue arose.

I wouldn't have used this in my argument if I was hud. Bort is notorious for being far too nice and letting people get away with things he shouldn't (look at Doryano & the Africa 'riots' of last offseason, for example, that was Bort's doing), so the argument boils down to "If we've got a huge advantage...well Bort didn't mean it!"

In effect, it does nothing to stop the image that moderators & alphas get preferential treatment, because Bort's got a history of being too nice to people and letting things slide when he shouldn't when he feels like he 'owes' them.

Originally posted by hud
We just had no power to enforce blatant disregard for this issue. If someone was offering FP contracts on the boards, we would lock or delete the thread, but we didn't feel we had the power to go further.

But the rule 'only' consists of:
1) Closing a topic (mods already do this)
2) Suspending a user (mods already do this)
3) Forwarding a situation to admins for further investigation (mods already do this)

...so why did you need a separate, loophole-filled rule? Every step of the process is something the moderators already are capable of doing and if the admins are truly in favor of it, who's going to call you on the issue? The only people that'll even know it's happening are the ones doing it, and since you're trying to curb their usage what better way than a sudden, unexpected forum ban and a couple nasty PMs from admins telling them not to do that?

I absolutely positively hate to post a PM on the forums, but I really think it needs to be seen, out in the open.
Sorry Thorn. I would ask you for permission first but who knows what'll happen in the next 48 hours between now and when you get back to me ()?
Emphasis mine.
edit: please dont post PMs.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 02:59:35
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Whether bort is too nice or not is besides the point. The problem is with questioning his motive. tough choices are made every day, and sometimes you dont like the result.

The power we did not have is your number 2: suspension, when it comes to FP contracts being offered. that is what we can do now. this policy was posted so that community knows it.

as for Thorns input, did you not see that it was posted from the very beginning that Bort signed off on these rules.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
...it was posted from the beginning that "all admins" signed off on the rules, and then Thorn comes and says the rules aren't even done. Which is it, are these the rules as a couple mods say or are there rules coming but they aren't done having the kinks worked out as an admin says?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
I think a lot of these concerns can be easily fixed with a World Championship Tournament. By allowing the winners of every pro league a chance to compete for the "best in the game" title, it won't matter as much how hard it is to get into USA Pro because someone could still "win" the game by going through one of the 7 other regions. By doing this, USA Pro will be EQUAL to every other Pro region, thus it won't matter as much.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
I think a lot of these concerns can be easily fixed with a World Championship Tournament. By allowing the winners of every pro league a chance to compete for the "best in the game" title, it won't matter as much how hard it is to get into USA Pro because someone could still "win" the game by going through one of the 7 other regions. By doing this, USA Pro will be EQUAL to every other Pro region, thus it won't matter as much.


I think we've gone beyond proving who is and who isn't the best team in the game.

I'm sure at some point in the not too distant future the game will even out a little, but you've still got a dominating minority who have used their alpha tester status to an UNFAIR advantage that is now being overlooked, due to rules only being put in place retrospectively.

I think alpha testers need to be playing on a completely different server to 'test' - not 'compete'. I think mods need to do just that - moderate - until such time that they can collectively prove that they aren't using their staus to gain an advantage (you see, once the brown stuff hits the air conditioning, you all catch a bit of it - so I guess you need to thanks TH for now being collectively branded as potentially dishonest).

And I think the game needs to show complete integrity, otherwise it'll implode quicker than even I thought it would.

 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
I still think you are/were WRONG SI - but you've not been banned yet, which shows that no action is being taken against cheats. Like it or not, that's what you are according to the current 'rule'.

But then again, I also agree TOTALLY with what you're saying about the likes of Tim Harper and the number of apla testers and mods that quite obviously have a conflict of interest by having players in the game that 'just happen' to be some of the highest ranked and most successful players out there........

I also agree that this game is 'dominated' by a handful of agents who, by their association with the mods/admins/alpha testers get away with just about anything and everything.

But last time I looked, you were closely associated with these players, so I'm guessing they'll have passed on some of their knowledge too?? And perhaps the fact that you're even still here is because of YOUR association with these people?? I wonder if someone like me would still be here if I'd cheated like you??

My big dissapointment comes because, despite numerous PMs, the admins of this game are still claiming to know nothing about what's going on......


Has he done it since this has been posted? Kinda doubt it.

And conflict of interest? wtf?
Our players are highly rated because of the fact that we've spent a lot of time playing the game. I'm sure there are alpha testers who don't have very good players, so it has nothing to do with that. And the mods generally have good players because of the fact that we became mods by knowing a lot about the game.

If you look mods and alpha testers are generally very willing to pass along advice to other player such as yourself.

I have a feeling the reason you aren't getting a response from the admins on some issues is because you're full of it.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The ONLY REASON why this is an issue is because teams want to improve. Short of waiting 10-12 seasons until the Tim Hapers / early testers players start to decline, there doesn't seem to be any way to put together the TOP team in this game.

And to make it even more unfair, you allow a policy where Tim Harper can pay to keep his level 27 and 28 players together, but you don't allow us to pay to try to take them away from him.

You make policies to allow the early testers to keep their mulitple teams, then no one else is allowed.

You make policies to allow early players to keep their farm teams even though it was implied from the beginning that it was "against the spirit of the game".

Then you even make policies to penalize high level players for leaving PRO. I'm a Pro team and I benefit GREATLY from that rule, but I think it is BS. Who cares if high level players want to play in low leagues?? Guess who this helps the most though? USA PRO and early testers of course.

That is why I keep arguing: I want a chance to win the whole thing, or I don't want to play. Others feel the same way.

We're giving you a little time to straighten things out, but I'm not putting another penny in until I see that I have a chance to own the best team in the league in less than 10-12 season. Otherwise, we are just filler teams to help pay for the USA Pro Teams and the only league that seems to matter in this game. I guess it sure helps to be friends with the owner/developer when it comes to making rules.....


If you want to make rules to protect the monopoly/chokehold that USA Pro (and 2/3 of the MODS) have on this game right now, then just say so. I'll come back in 10-12 seasons when I have a fair chance.....

....otherwise, stop cracking down on the little guys who are trying to improve and instead crack down on the guys who have dominated the game for the first 3 seasons and will continue to do so for the forseeable future.


Insider I don't like you and you don't like me...ok lets not start a flame war but I do agree with some of this. It is hard to catch up because the Alpha Testers had a jump on everyone BUT the Alpha Testers and Mods will sometimes leave US Pro or Canada Pro...I got Asheme's RB on my team and I have been talking to quite a few mods that are friends of mine who may bring over some players. You have to build friendships and connections with those guys then maybe they'll help you out!
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity

If you look mods and alpha testers are generally very willing to pass along advice to other player such as yourself.

I have a feeling the reason you aren't getting a response from the admins on some issues is because you're full of it.


A couple of the mods are great and have posted their player build guides, etc - superb stuff and I don't have a problem with it.

But please don't insult the intelligence of other players, myself included, by saying that 'inside info' isn't passed around about the game engine - I mean, we have Laggo and the other associated 'friends' making rather accurate posts about the game engine specifics all the time - are they all just really good guesses??

Oh - and someone more cynical than me might wonder why you've taken to a personal attack with the last comment?? Bit close to the truth for you, was I?? Or is it just to make up for a lack of any intelligent response from you??

I'd retalliate in kind, but then you'd probably decide to ban me just to show how 'ub3r 1337' you are.

Pathetic!!
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Serenity


If you look mods and alpha testers are generally very willing to pass along advice to other player such as yourself.

I have a feeling the reason you aren't getting a response from the admins on some issues is because you're full of it.


A couple of the mods are great and have posted their player build guides, etc - superb stuff and I don't have a problem with it.

But please don't insult the intelligence of other players, myself included, by saying that 'inside info' isn't passed around about the game engine - I mean, we have Laggo and the other associated 'friends' making rather accurate posts about the game engine specifics all the time - are they all just really good guesses??

Oh - and someone more cynical than me might wonder why you've taken to a personal attack with the last comment?? Bit close to the truth for you, was I?? Or is it just to make up for a lack of any intelligent response from you??

I'd retalliate in kind, but then you'd probably decide to ban me just to show how 'ub3r 1337' you are.

Pathetic!!



LOL I am still trying to find a post initiated by Laggo that had some sort of useful information lol
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.