User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
kazana
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

Closest runner up that didn't make it.

Originally posted by Bort
2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

Team sales should be allowed. If the team is not sold to a current GM, or another player who explicitly wants to remain in the league, the team gets disbanded.
When a team is disbanded, it should move to the lowest tier, either randomly, or to the lowest tier with the highest average level (in order to level out potential imbalances).
Thinking about it again, I believe the bottom tier would actually be decided by the "trail" of closest runner-ups that get promoted. So nothing revolutionary should be going on there, actually.

Originally posted by Bort
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

Good thing, even though it will present a disadvantage to teams who have played them previously. However, I can't see a fairer version of handling these situations.

Originally posted by Bort
4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

Won't be a problem if the new owner is on stand-by and wants to claim his option of remaining in the league.

Originally posted by Bort
5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

There should be a claiming period. If the team's GMs don't want it, it should be offered to the next player in the waiting list.

I believe, in a team hand-over, all contracts should be reduced to the end of the current season to avoid people being tied up in teams they don't want to be part of, or may have been pushed down the depth chart due to the new owner bringing aboard his own players. If a team gets completely disbanded, or the new owner chooses to start from the lowest tier, all current players should become free agents, and the new owner takes ownership from the next season onward.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 07:33:19
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
1. I think that the next highest ranked runner up moves up. It could either alternate from the two feeder leagues or take the highest record.

2. Team should go CPU managed (players could still strategize to set the individual settings, then disband at the end of the season. I would be interested to see how many teams this happens to in the middle of a season. If it is only a few, maybe mods could contact the players and ask for someone to gm the team, setting tactics only, for the remainder of the season.

3. How is this that different then a zombie team with all the players cut or the owner & gms being inactive?

4. If they are good owners they will rise up quickly. Or they could offer to buy teams that they gm on. Also, in a system like this the talented teams in the BBB leagues would turn over VERY quickly. If we assume in USA for example that every conference will have one team sold, then the BBB leagues as a whole will see 30 EXTRA teams promoted, on top of standard promotions, which is just less than one per conference. That means the top two teams in every conference would be moving up every season. I also think this may ba a short term issue. As the site stabilizes you will see less owner turnover and more GM dedication, making them more likely to take over the team.

5. See #2 above. The gm could take "ownership" of the team for the rest of the season. It would cost them nothing, they already have some responsibilities on the team so a little more is not a big deal, and they may change their mind and want to buy the team.

 
derek1222
offline
Link
 
Create a clone team to take the place of the team that drops down for the rest of the season. Create an all CPU team ran by CPU with same level (maybe same stats) and actually have the CPU's level and use the points it levels with... could work but may be way too hard to program..
 
David Bean
offline
Link
 
1. I don't think it matters a whole lot--go with something easy to program. Choose the best record of all the four conference championship losers. Or choose one randomly. They are getting to move up based upon another team randomly being sold, so adding a little more luck and random chance won't affect the fairness of the process.

2-5. Allow a potential owner to state if they are interested in a team in a higher division. Given teams sold back to one of these owners. Let them decide if they want to keep it where it is or move down to the lower division. Don't let them make any roster or financial moves until they make this decision. If they decide to move down, count all the games against this team as wins (those already played and those to be played). Future opponents get a scrimmage game against them where XP is still assigned.
 
sew3663
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by derek1222
Create a clone team to take the place of the team that drops down for the rest of the season. Create an all CPU team ran by CPU with same level (maybe same stats) and actually have the CPU's level and use the points it levels with... could work but may be way too hard to program..


+1

This is how other games do this. That way, every new team owner starts in the same situation financially and league-wise.

It isn't too hard to program, just put CPU players on the team (allow real players to stay as if it were a D league team, they can sign new contracts if the want, or stay with the team for exp), then let the team "fall" in the natural course of promotion/relegation to one of the lowest 2 league divisions (for whichever region). Make it so new team owners can only get teams in the lowest 2 league divisions. You'll need many more teams available to keep the waiting list short.

This solves 2 problems. 1) New team owners who have been given teams in crappy financial shape. All new owners gain a team with a certain amount of money, a certain stadium size, and a bunch of CPU players to fill out the roster waiting for real players to sign up. 2) Higher leagues will actually be better than lower leagues. Teams that are ownerless will fall to the bottom fast, and those who promote will actually deserve to be up there instead of promoting because of quitting teams.
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
I think it would be fine to drop teams to the bottom. But I think there's another possibility that I think would address these concerns:

1) Shorten player contracts to end in the offseason at the point the team is sold and
2) Give the owner the one time choice of staying in the league or dropping to any lower league in the offseason. If he has committed players, he can stay put. Or if he can recruit some mid-level guys, there's no reason to drop him to BB or whatever the lowest level league is at that point.
 
sew3663
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mpowell
I think it would be fine to drop teams to the bottom. But I think there's another possibility that I think would address these concerns:

1) Shorten player contracts to end in the offseason at the point the team is sold and
2) Give the owner the one time choice of staying in the league or dropping to any lower league in the offseason. If he has committed players, he can stay put. Or if he can recruit some mid-level guys, there's no reason to drop him to BB or whatever the lowest level league is at that point.


But that still reshuffles leagues manually EVERY SEASON... that takes time and screws the normal promotion of teams that actually deserve it.
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sew3663
Originally posted by mpowell

I think it would be fine to drop teams to the bottom. But I think there's another possibility that I think would address these concerns:

1) Shorten player contracts to end in the offseason at the point the team is sold and
2) Give the owner the one time choice of staying in the league or dropping to any lower league in the offseason. If he has committed players, he can stay put. Or if he can recruit some mid-level guys, there's no reason to drop him to BB or whatever the lowest level league is at that point.


But that still reshuffles leagues manually EVERY SEASON... that takes time and screws the normal promotion of teams that actually deserve it.


I'm really not seeing how complicated this is. If a team decides to drop, their is some automated system for determining who moves up. So in some league, 3 teams will move up instead of 2. It's like a 'you got lucky' card, but you were also pretty deserving if you were in your conference final, even if you lost.

As for the the financials being different, it's really tough to be in a worse situation financially. Maybe just provide the opportunity for a complete reset on the financials and I think you would take care of any concerns. I don't really care if a new owner has some small, unimportant advantage with a slightly better situation coming in. As other pointed out, it would be nice to be able to preserve a team if the new owner just doesn't have time and somebody new is willing to come in and take over.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
my solution to who moves up is have a game for all the marbles.. Tell two teams they have to face each other in a scrimmage to see who gets the promotion.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kcirdor
my solution to who moves up is have a game for all the marbles.. Tell two teams they have to face each other in a scrimmage to see who gets the promotion.


Kinda hard to do when you have 32 3rd place BBB level teams to move up one spot
 
sois
offline
Link
 
New idea:

Have league average level play a factor in ranking the teams. For example, if there is an opening in Pro, have the third place finisher from the league with the highest average level get promoted.

 
Rozman1621
offline
Link
 
Taking over a junk team.....

Recently I bought one of those junk teams that someone dismantled - I don't want to complain - but it SUX. For starters, the new owner is trust right into things without ANY learning curve. Then you are trying to recruit players in mid season - yeah - good luck.

1) At the END of the season, the team will be put into the bottom tier. This means maybe more than 2 teams in a conference get promoted at the end of the season.

2) Any player that wants to be released should have the option to do that themselves (within 48 hours of new ownership). Give the new owner a chance to see behind the scenes to get some practive until the end of the season. Since you can only own one team now, every new owner is a complete rookie - so it will be nice to see a game or two that doesn't matter before the next season starts.

3) Do not send teams down mid season - wait until the end of the season.

4) At the end of the season, the team become a rookie team - the new owner will have ot accept the fact they can't put their own players on the team for 1 season. It is more important for the team to get on track - if you want to own a team, you just have to accept that fact.

5) At the end of the season, every player who was on the team will have their contract set to expire at the end of the season. Once the team resets to a bottom tier team, the new owner can sign all the ex-players if they qualify, and if they want to come back.



I'm sure 99% of the time, the new owner is taking over a team that is terrible (I know I was). We lost our first game 199-0 because I had 75% CPU players. Yeah - that is exactly the kind of crap I want to step into. Then you CANNOT sign any LVL 20+ players to compete within the conference, so your team continues to spiral out of control. Then you have to beg to get any LVL 12+ guys on your team.

Bort, basically, your expecting a new owner to take over the crap from the previous owner, and it really sux being in that position. Dropping the new team to bottom rung at least gives the new owner a chance to start from scratch....sure there are some holes to plug, but more and more new owners are going to say "screw it" if you don't let them start from scratch.

If an owner wants an established team, they should have to pay a few more "bucks" for it - vs starting from scratch. Think of it like buying an expansion team or buying the Dolphins. Even though the Dolphins suck right now, they are worth more than an expansion team because they have established themselves over the years with their fans. Make sense?





 
Tman2008
offline
Link
 
I think a tier system for leagues should be used. What I mean is to move new teams to lets say AA-4 Zeta teams move up from Zeta to Alpha and from Division 4 to 3 in a sequential order. This way new teams get to play teams at their level and learn the game the way it should be. Teams could be rated by points for/against or level of players on their teams which would make more sense. A program that would calculate average player levels and rate team accordingly makes the most sense then tactics will be the dividing line not who got their teams first and signed the high level players.

Everybody gets good competition this way= more fun for everyone which is what this game should be about.

So each Tier/Division would be tougher as they reach number#1

So teams would be moved from their divisions to groups like this

Example of rankings
1. Eastern Asia#1 Alpha Average level 19.9 Last year's record W-234 L-72
2. Eastern Asia#1 Zeta average level 18.1 Last year's record W-166 L-101
3. Eastern Asia#2 Alpha average level 17.4 Last Year's record W-152 L-128
4. Eastern Asia#2 Zeta average level 16.4 Last Year's Record W-147 L-142

this would continue down the line in each division till AA#4 Zeta being the lowest
8. Eastern Asia#4 Zeta Average Level 10.2 Last year's record W-32 L-224

Teams would have an extra challenge to look forward to which would be moving to the high divisions.

I think it would work.
Tman
Last edited Jul 24, 2008 14:06:41
 
dumpyloser
offline
Link
 
it would be good to have a down time between the sale and the purchase. (kind of like a trade pending thing) and during this 1-2 day downtime, the players on that team can vote on whether to disband or remain where they are. (this helps the teams who REALLY want to stay together. once they decide they will either go into 1 of 2 categories. (new team at bottom tier, or remain the same with new ownership). Then put an option in the waiting list like a check box of whether or not to accept disbanded teams or whether or not to accept capped teams. to me, this solves all of the problems to the questions bort brought up (not about to read 17 pages) on the first page except who will fill in the disbanded's position.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Give a bigger FP refund to owners who keep a team intact by selling to a GM.

Always give GMs the option to take over an abandoned team, and take care of abandoned teams quickly.

Put more safeguards in place against gutting - perhaps a flag sent to customer support if certain activity is happening with a team, ie, wholesale trades/cuts within a certain timeframe.

And with totally gutted teams - let them change leagues upon request - give the new owners some flexibility in where the team ends up - capped or uncapped.

Frankly, I think over time the disparities between the the non-cappped leagues will start to disappear, as more "senior" users start to drop out of the game, as high level players start to disperse (I think we're seeing that now with L20+ players who have been backups wanting to move to starting jobs) etc, etc.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.