User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort's...dead? - Offseason Event Extravaganza Introduction/Rules
Page:
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joeami
Oh man, you are really throwing me curve balls.

I DID send an answer to who I think is the correct person, aka PM #2. So, what happens now? I get the second sentence, but it seems to contradict the first.

The second paragraph makes plenty of sense, but probably should have been stated a bit more clearly, I think.


I think he's saying there is no penalty for sending to the wrong mod unless that mod was waiting for the answer to another clue. Example:

Mod 1 is waiting for the answer to "2+2=?" (Hereafter Question 2)
Mod 2 is waiting for the answer to "What do you sit on?" (Hereafter Question 1)

You send the correct response to question 1 to Mod 1, and so he reads 2+2 = Chair, so you lose the possibility for that card in the future.

However, the not the best way to handle that particular rule imo, but whatever works.

Edit: *Waits for reply to see if he has to edit all this out because it was incorrect*
Edited by FYNBYAC on Jan 23, 2010 00:40:34
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FYNBYAC
I think he's saying there is no penalty for sending to the wrong mod unless that mod was waiting for the answer to another clue. Example:

Mod 1 is waiting for the answer to "2+2=?" (Hereafter Question 2)
Mod 2 is waiting for the answer to "What do you sit on?" (Hereafter Question 1)

You send the correct response to question 1 to Mod 1, and so he reads 2+2 = Chair, so you lose the possibility for that card in the future.

However, the not the best way to handle that particular rule imo, but whatever works.


Understand that completely, but this sentence is what screws me over: If you never sent an answer to who you now deem the correct person, all should be fine.

I DID send that answer, now what? Or is Mat talking about my first submission?
Edited by joeami on Jan 23, 2010 00:41:01
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Pretty sure he means that as long as you didn't answer incorrectly to the correct mod (meaning you PMed the right answer to the wrong person and not vice versa), then you'll be fine on the current question.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joeami
Oh man, you are really throwing me curve balls.

I DID send an answer to who I think is the correct person, aka PM #2. So, what happens now? I get the second sentence, but it seems to contradict the first.

The second paragraph makes plenty of sense, but probably should have been stated a bit more clearly, I think.


Yeah it was hard to type out clearly. ib4 weird example

PM1 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModA
PM2 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModB

In your situation you sent your answer of fish to ModA. But ModA may have been looking for an answer of 'dog'. And as such, later when you need to send 'dog' to ModA, it won't be considered correct, because you've already answered incorrectly.

You can however, still send the answer of 'fish' to ModB, which may be exactly what he is looking for. He'll then reward you w/ clue/storyline continuation/etc.
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Yeah it was hard to type out clearly. ib4 weird example

PM1 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModA
PM2 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModB

In your situation you sent your answer of fish to ModA. But ModA may have been looking for an answer of 'dog'. And as such, later when you need to send 'dog' to ModA, it won't be considered correct, because you've already answered incorrectly.

You can however, still send the answer of 'fish' to ModB, which may be exactly what he is looking for. He'll then reward you w/ clue/storyline continuation/etc.


My post with hypotheticals was clearly better
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Yeah it was hard to type out clearly. ib4 weird example

PM1 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModA
PM2 -> Answer of 'fish' to ModB

In your situation you sent your answer of fish to ModA. But ModA may have been looking for an answer of 'dog'. And as such, later when you need to send 'dog' to ModA, it won't be considered correct, because you've already answered incorrectly.

You can however, still send the answer of 'fish' to ModB, which may be exactly what he is looking for. He'll then reward you w/ clue/storyline continuation/etc.


Got it. If/when it comes down to having to go back to ModA, am I completely screwed at that point, or is there another way to pick up the story (like the forum posts)? Or, do I get the next clue, but not the card?
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FYNBYAC
My post with hypotheticals was clearly better


TBH, I liked both
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joeami
Got it. If/when it comes down to having to go back to ModA, am I completely screwed at that point, or is there another way to pick up the story (like the forum posts)? Or, do I get the next clue, but not the card?


There are "breaks", aka the story is not one huge continuation where everything is linked. Meaning you can most definitely pick back up story, and potentially still "win". You're never completely screwed in this game.
Edited by Mat McBriar on Jan 23, 2010 00:47:26
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
There are "breaks", aka the story is not one huge continuation where everything is linked. Meaning you can most definitely pick back up story, and potentially still "win".


Alright. So, for an example, this first story might have 3 clues to it. Tomorrow's clue might have another 3 clues attached to it, but a completely different storyline. Correct?
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Hence why they cut off after only X clues tonight.

Good system imo, gives people who were in at the start an advantage (more possibilities to eliminate scenarios) while not forcing people to be in at the beginning to win.
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FYNBYAC
Hence why they cut off after only X clues tonight.

Good system imo, gives people who were in at the start an advantage (more possibilities to eliminate scenarios) while not forcing people to be in at the beginning to win.


The thing is people can catch up. The moderators are looking for specific answers and have been trained (like dogs ) to respond to that answer with the story line. SO, someone on the last day of the competition could possibly catch up and put it all together at once. I just hope we get to see all of the cards involved so we don't start guessing random things like Bort's dog did it with the metal cleats behind the kicker's locker.
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joeami
The thing is people can catch up. The moderators are looking for specific answers and have been trained (like dogs ) to respond to that answer with the story line. SO, someone on the last day of the competition could possibly catch up and put it all together at once. I just hope we get to see all of the cards involved so we don't start guessing random things like Bort's dog did it with the metal cleats behind the kicker's locker.


No need to worry about that, Mat has said a few times that there will eventually be a list or otherwise revelation of all the locations, suspects, and murder weapons.
 
Iron Maiden
offline
Link
 
So basically..with the cards....we'll lock down on who the killer is, where he did it(crime scene), and what he did it with(weapon)?
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iron Maiden
So basically..with the cards....we'll lock down on who the killer is, where he did it(crime scene), and what he did it with(weapon)?


Yep. If you're able to collect all of the cards, and then compare it with the list, you'd know which cards are the ones in play. However, some people might be good at guessing and once they see the list, will guess randomly, and possibly, correctly.
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Yep. The more you know, the better your chance at solving the crime, just like in reality.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.