User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
The bottom line is that (if there are bonuses to lower level players) this rewards teams that:

1. Donn't recruit well, or don't put effort into recruiting, and end up with low level players.
2. Don't boost, so don't put money in Bort's pocket.
3. Shouldn't win anyway. Because they are SEVERAL levels lower than the teams they are playing.
4. Are gutted by new owners and filled with their own low level players to super level - exploit.

The bottom line is that (if there are punishments to higher level players) this punishes:

1. GMs/Owners that earn a great reputation and recruit well.
2. Very good players on mediocre teams that aren't "pwing" anyone.
3. Good, high level teams that boost smartly that for some reason don't win a championship.
4. Teams/players that play against a gutted (or poorly managed) team.

 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
I have purchased a team and i got this one: gutted team. I had all difficulties you can imagine recruiting my players and they are low level against the average of the league. If we listen to you, i'm a bad owner because of my bad luck. Insulting!


Well, at least we know why you are arguing for this change.

You want free, easy leveling rather than putting in hard work and EARNING your great team.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Cedo

I have purchased a team and i got this one: gutted team. I had all difficulties you can imagine recruiting my players and they are low level against the average of the league. If we listen to you, i'm a bad owner because of my bad luck. Insulting!


Well, at least we know why you are arguing for this change.

You want free, easy leveling rather than putting in hard work and EARNING your great team.


Again insulting... i give many arguments and you just insult me without knowing what you are talking about.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy

Originally posted by Cedo


Originally posted by Sweet Daddy





Great, they'll be promoted. After a season of being punished by XP losses for playing against teams that may not have been built or managed as effectively.


That's not an argument. That's insulting the way some owners play the game. Everyone can't be the future champion! Some people will not have the lvl needed to play the championship but with the bonus, they will play better and then...



If it's true, how is it an insult? If some owners do not play the game to win, then they aren't playing within the spirit of the game. If a team cannot or will not build their team competitively, why should a team that does get punished?


Because there's some factors an owner don't control. Example, the recruitment process and the team he have paid for...

I have purchased a team and i got this one: gutted team. I had all difficulties you can imagine recruiting my players and they are low level against the average of the league. If we listen to you, i'm a bad owner because of my bad luck. Insulting!


That's not true. Who else controls the recruitment process other than the team owner and GMs? If you purchase a gutted team, why should the other owners in the league suffer for your choice?

I'm on two new teams this season. The owners of those teams knew that they were going on a waiting list to acquire the team. The teams they acquired were going to be full of CPU players, so they knew they would have to recruit people to fill those spots. Rather than waiting for the day to come, they have been recruiting for weeks now, to ensure that they fielded a full roster. Of course, there were some slots that still could not be filled, so they did more recruiting after they got the team.

Because they put in hard work, effort, and planning, both teams were fully staffed as of yesterday.

If you did not have the foresight to plan to fill your roster, then perhaps yes, you do fit the description that I've put out there of a poorly managed team.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
LOL pitifull. That's not arguing, not a debate.

I was trustfull because i though i could discuss with everyone but sadly we can't.

I'm stasified with my recruitment, in few season i will be promoted. I have done hours of recruitment day 32 (when i got the team) and get what i could. I was in the hardest league of GLB except USA for a AA level. Now with switching that's cooler. That's the info, you must know before insulting someone. Go learn how you must behave yourself.


Now for the discussion sake:


Originally posted by
The bottom line is that (if there are bonuses to lower level players) this rewards teams that:

1. Donn't recruit well, or don't put effort into recruiting, and end up with low level players.


or team that can't attract high level player.


Originally posted by
2. Don't boost, so don't put money in Bort's pocket.


Exact but if the game please them, they will boost eventually

Originally posted by
3. Shouldn't win anyway. Because they are SEVERAL levels lower than the teams they are playing.


That's not about winning, gaining some extra XP. That's about being rewarded to endure 100/0


Originally posted by

4. Are gutted by new owners and filled with their own low level players to super level - exploit.


Nothing to say, because gutting is illegal


Originally posted by

The bottom line is that (if there are punishments to higher level players) this punishes:

1. GMs/Owners that earn a great reputation and recruit well.


Yes they recruit "well" because players wants to go in lower league to win

Originally posted by

2. Very good players on mediocre teams that aren't "pwing" anyone.


Wrong depend of the system we will use. Average level of the team against average level of the league per example.


Originally posted by
3. Good, high level teams that boost smartly that for some reason don't win a championship.


Sometimes that "some reason" is just they don't want to. For others, is because there's a lot of great teams in the league and so the average will be high so no penalty. Theother case is a large gap between top teams and low teams. All this top teams will get malus so no problem! After a promotion, they will gain bonus because they will be low level to the higher league.

Originally posted by
4. Teams/players that play against a gutted (or poorly managed) team.


Depends of the way is calculated see before (league average is the best wayto make calculation to bonus)
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 10:27:19
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


That seems to be what people want in general.

Although, I don't think they would just "rush for USA." They'd just rush for the higher tier leagues and stay away from the low ones. Lv 1's and 2's aren't going to care where they play, but high level guys will. Hmm...isn't that the idea we're trying to accomplish?


Then whats the point in staying loyal to the teams you start out with? There is also no point in moving teams up and down at the end of the season if the players are just going to leave once they get to a higher lvl. I just think this will hurt all leagues in many different ways.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jcdawg23
Originally posted by Bort



That seems to be what people want in general.

Although, I don't think they would just "rush for USA." They'd just rush for the higher tier leagues and stay away from the low ones. Lv 1's and 2's aren't going to care where they play, but high level guys will. Hmm...isn't that the idea we're trying to accomplish?


Then whats the point in staying loyal to the teams you start out with? There is also no point in moving teams up and down at the end of the season if the players are just going to leave once they get to a higher lvl. I just think this will hurt all leagues in many different ways.


If you move up, you will gain XP bonus or not. if you go down normally that's because you don't have the level so you will have no penality.
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 10:42:41
 
LordMortis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I was thinking something like average levels, weighted toward starters, or something along those lines. I agree that it might be more realistic if it was based on the guy you were facing, but it might be hard to deal with, especially for a position like K or P or QB who doesn't have a set opponent.


While I like the idea, especially as I have just aquired a team that is abouut to be thrown to the sharks , The one power gamer exploit you have to worry about is the maintenance of huge roster of level one bench players.

To eliminate or reduce this exploit, I'd do some sort of math voodoo that you do that compares who actually played in the game how much and not who the starters or bench were. Compare the sum of the players*individual_level*plays_played or some such thing.

 
Dravz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise

This.

Penalizing XP in any way is just stupid, especially for something outside your control.
 
JBrown5390
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dravz
Originally posted by Serenity

I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise

This.

Penalizing XP in any way is just stupid, especially for something outside your control.



I like the Idea. It will even out the leagues.
 
crazymorg
offline
Link
 
the average level in Canada AA #3 is 10.7ish

i just looked at the top 8 teams...every starter except maybe 5 guys are above that

if you dont use just the starters in the average...this idea is flat out stupid and youre screwing over every player and team

especially the ones that arent in the USA...why dont you just put a big middle finger on top of the league
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Levels could be based on:
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


Of the two, I like this one better. Weighing the team level towards starters (heavily) is probably going to be a must. I've already seen a team stock up on a bunch of lvl 4 punters in anticipation of this to try and bring their level down.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dravz
Originally posted by Serenity

I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise

This.

Penalizing XP in any way is just stupid, especially for something outside your control.


It isn't outside your control.

If you're high level, don't join a new team, especially in a lower league.

If it's not a new league, look around at the other teams' starting lineups. If your player's much better than most of them, don't join the league.

I already do that in an opposite direction when I get a FA offer. Even if my player seems like a starter on the team he's joining, if he isn't as good as other starters in the league, I figure the team won't keep him as a starter.
 
wollfrnd
offline
Link
 
I still say that this is all an over reaction.

Don't cap things.
Don't penalize players for signing with lower league teams.
Don't reward players for only signing with higher league teams.

There is already fix in place.

Its called the promotion/relagation system....
You just have to give it a couple of seasons to self-correct.
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
I'm 100% with wollfrnd; the whole point of the promotion/relegation system is to address this very issue. Why not give it a few seasons to work before jumping in with both guns blazing?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.