Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by DaMayan
About the beta part:
Part of a beta always is reporting of bugs and issue's. It's the developers responsibility to look at them and check if they are right or if it is just perception.
Even then both of those things are a problem that need adressing: if the perception is that something is wrong then (even if it is right) the user experience is deminished.
The whole reason for a beta is getting feedback and fix bugs or perception issue's. It's actually called an Alpha if your not ready for feedback and just want to keep developing on your own. Bort clearly listens and adjusts to bug-reports and general whining/testing. So he does want and use feedback. And we, the userbase, generally except and agree with what Bort does.
The only point here is that this issue has been reported as early as season 3 and only until it has grown to mythical proportions is it properly checked. This is clearly a trust issue for the userbase as even PT is now feeling let down.
...imho.
I can't speak for anyone else on this, but up until yesterday, here's what I heard as the definition of the "X-factor":
'something behind the scenes put in place which the end user both can't see and can't adjust to intentionally make one player better than the other, even with everything else being equal'
That's not a bug report, that's a conspiracy theory. Not only that, but THAT part is something Bort has said in the past isn't the case (the part where it would always make one better than the other).
Yesterday, Larry Roadgrader said, "hey, maybe it's there, but maybe there's a bug causing something like that to happen." That's when I took it seriously, checked it out, and got on it for real.
Jed,
I actually hear and understand (somewhat) the frustration that you have with the many, many shrill and unreasonable voices that cry and whine about groundless issues in these forums.
However, I would propose that when someone like Pierre raises an issue, more attention be paid.
There are folks around here who, believe it or not, actually have a much more thorough understanding of the boots-on-the-ground sim-level interactions than you, many of the testers, and yes, even Bort (whose knowledge is based on understanding the formulas and their theoretical output rather than a detailed study of watching what happens to a single dot as you make changes in their attributes, making more changes, studying closely, and repeating ad nauseum).
There are at least a few voices who are both very reasonable and incredibly knowledgable...and who are trying to make the game better for all of us, not whining about their own inability to succeed.
-taut