User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
I kind of like the randomness xfactor thing...brings GLB back to the football any given sunday type ideology...just my nickel, since i'm out of pennies


According to Bort, we have it. He said something like players "randomly show up to play", implying that there's some kind of behind-the-scenes mechanism similar to streaky going on.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by DaMayan

About the beta part:
Part of a beta always is reporting of bugs and issue's. It's the developers responsibility to look at them and check if they are right or if it is just perception.
Even then both of those things are a problem that need adressing: if the perception is that something is wrong then (even if it is right) the user experience is deminished.

The whole reason for a beta is getting feedback and fix bugs or perception issue's. It's actually called an Alpha if your not ready for feedback and just want to keep developing on your own. Bort clearly listens and adjusts to bug-reports and general whining/testing. So he does want and use feedback. And we, the userbase, generally except and agree with what Bort does.

The only point here is that this issue has been reported as early as season 3 and only until it has grown to mythical proportions is it properly checked. This is clearly a trust issue for the userbase as even PT is now feeling let down.

...imho.


I can't speak for anyone else on this, but up until yesterday, here's what I heard as the definition of the "X-factor":

'something behind the scenes put in place which the end user both can't see and can't adjust to intentionally make one player better than the other, even with everything else being equal'

That's not a bug report, that's a conspiracy theory. Not only that, but THAT part is something Bort has said in the past isn't the case (the part where it would always make one better than the other).

Yesterday, Larry Roadgrader said, "hey, maybe it's there, but maybe there's a bug causing something like that to happen." That's when I took it seriously, checked it out, and got on it for real.




Jed,

I actually hear and understand (somewhat) the frustration that you have with the many, many shrill and unreasonable voices that cry and whine about groundless issues in these forums.

However, I would propose that when someone like Pierre raises an issue, more attention be paid.

There are folks around here who, believe it or not, actually have a much more thorough understanding of the boots-on-the-ground sim-level interactions than you, many of the testers, and yes, even Bort (whose knowledge is based on understanding the formulas and their theoretical output rather than a detailed study of watching what happens to a single dot as you make changes in their attributes, making more changes, studying closely, and repeating ad nauseum).

There are at least a few voices who are both very reasonable and incredibly knowledgable...and who are trying to make the game better for all of us, not whining about their own inability to succeed.

-taut


 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
I don't see how you can like x-factor.

It reminds me of Star Wars Galaxies. You couldn't be a Jedi unless you lucked into a naturally force strong character at the start, and that attribute was hidden and it took a while to figure out you had it. Most people couldn't be a Jedi if they tried. Jedi were awesome and clearly lots of people wanted to be Jedi.

In the end they ended up letting everyone who wanted to be a Jedi, because that system sucked.

But then I've never actually played that game.
 
SAINT615
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
No way man.

Are you really asking Bort to allow you to knowingly exploit a huge bug? Because it's not fair to you if you can't use the bug to whip other players?

Really?


It was brought to Bort's attention before this season started. He gave the 'working as intended' answer.

Are you saying you wouldn't have recruited bad ass players with Bort's winking endorsement?

Really?
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't mind an X-factor type deal, if it was something like this;

5% attributes in playoffs
5% attributes in close game (within 10 points)
2.5% attributes in home games
2.5 attributes in away games
5% attributes on 1st down
" " 2nd down
" " 3rd down

And stuff like this. And it will be randomized for each player created, without their knowledge. And owners who truly look at players before they recruit them, can find out eventually what X factor the player has.

Also, make it so kickers and punters always has one that will help them (so not 5% attributes on 1st down).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SAINT615
It was brought to Bort's attention before this season started. He gave the 'working as intended' answer.

Are you saying you wouldn't have recruited bad ass players with Bort's winking endorsement?

Really?


I don't recruit.

But if I did, I would have no problem with my "bad ass players" no longer benefiting from exploiting a bug.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Everything should be transparent IMO.

Every SA that fires, every time some big ugly LB yells at a pretty white Qb and his morale goes down, every time ANYTHING that requires a check or a dice roll...WE SHOULD KNOW. And, we should be able to see the rolls. This would eliminate most of the problems and allow for much easier balancing of this game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vagrant God
I wouldn't mind an X-factor type deal, if it was something like this;

5% attributes in playoffs
5% attributes in close game (within 10 points)
2.5% attributes in home games
2.5 attributes in away games
5% attributes on 1st down
" " 2nd down
" " 3rd down

And stuff like this. And it will be randomized for each player created, without their knowledge. And owners who truly look at players before they recruit them, can find out eventually what X factor the player has.

Also, make it so kickers and punters always has one that will help them (so not 5% attributes on 1st down).


Ugh, no IMO.
 
SAINT615
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
I don't recruit.

But if I did, I would have no problem with my "bad ass players" no longer benefiting from exploiting a bug.


I hate to use the 'unless you're an owner' line, but, clearly, you have no frame of reference here.

 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAINT615
Originally posted by fallingmercury

I don't recruit.

But if I did, I would have no problem with my "bad ass players" no longer benefiting from exploiting a bug.


I hate to use the 'unless you're an owner' line, but, clearly, you have no frame of reference here.



failingmercury fails
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vagrant God
I wouldn't mind an X-factor type deal, if it was something like this;

5% attributes in playoffs
5% attributes in close game (within 10 points)
2.5% attributes in home games
2.5 attributes in away games
5% attributes on 1st down
" " 2nd down
" " 3rd down

And stuff like this. And it will be randomized for each player created, without their knowledge. And owners who truly look at players before they recruit them, can find out eventually what X factor the player has.

Also, make it so kickers and punters always has one that will help them (so not 5% attributes on 1st down).


So the rest of us chumps get to pay $9 a season to boost a WR that automatically has 5% worse attributes in playoffs? No thanks.
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vagrant God
I wouldn't mind an X-factor type deal, if it was something like this;

5% attributes in playoffs
5% attributes in close game (within 10 points)
2.5% attributes in home games
2.5 attributes in away games
5% attributes on 1st down
" " 2nd down
" " 3rd down

And stuff like this. And it will be randomized for each player created, without their knowledge. And owners who truly look at players before they recruit them, can find out eventually what X factor the player has.

Also, make it so kickers and punters always has one that will help them (so not 5% attributes on 1st down).


i'd prefer it be some randomized thing where you have all those bonuses and it be in a range of 0% to 8% to attributes and all of those bonuses add up to a total 25% or 30% so everyone would have the same total amount of bonuses but it would allow for differentiation of builds that no one would be able to know about unless they watched the footage and experimented with the players...
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
There are at least a few voices who are both very reasonable and incredibly knowledgable...and who are trying to make the game better for all of us, not whining about their own inability to succeed.


There are, I hadn't seen Pierre as one until very recently. Now I know.
Edited by Jed on Sep 2, 2009 15:40:10
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
failingmercury fails


Maybe your FACE fails.

No srsly, not everyone is a turd looking to win through bug exploitation. Some folks are interested in playing a high-quality sim.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
As I think more about this. I see one flaw in hidden X factors. They could make bug reporting very hard. I really think Bord needs some sort of sim debugging system on the back end. That way if he does have some randomness added to the sim he can quickly debug a replay or game to determine if the random x factor is working correct or if there is actually a bug.

My point is, if there has always been an x factor, and it was never considered when troubleshooting bugs. How do we know we have not been chasing our tails with the test servers and every found bug?

Still, I like the idea of an X factor. I would only suggest some tool for ruling out the random code other than assuming.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.