User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SpreadThePink
offline
Link
 
Supposedly Thorn is on top of this.


This guys AI didn't work or something, and he is blaming the sim for the loss. I would rather not sit around our forum and listen to this the rest of the season, so it would be nice to clear this up in a reasonable amount of time.




Originally posted by BearBryant

I am not whining good game Wingmen, but we will meet in the playoffs. I am just stating neither our Offense or our Defense AI was followed and Thom has already acknowledged that and are trying to figure out what happened now. Not any ones fault but the sim.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1513049&page=1







Last edited Nov 26, 2008 16:14:52
 
SpreadThePink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
I noticed that my AI sometimes changes a play designed to be a short into a medium.
My output is

play-type = basic
formation = singleback
distance=short
primary=WR
TE adj = basic
HB adj=block
FB adj=block
rusher = HB
FB DC = FB
HB DC=HB
TE DC =TE

The outcome is Single Back WR short Curls left (a medium WR pass with the HB not staying in pass protection)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=236102&pbp_id=574158


I had someone check my AI and could not find any mistake.
1) I have this short WR pass from the singleback formation in my playbook
2) auto-adjust is turned off
3) The AI correctly identify the input (checked with the tester + another output under the input which can be recognized uniquely)

I has this issue twice in my last game, and even though the outcome was good I don't like the play we run (since I wanted more protection and shorter routes).

Suggestion that I have heard:
1) setting play-type=basic setting make the AI ignore other fields.
2) not setting "follow my AI exactly" may cause some surprises.

I would like to see a Management comment about this issue, since I already went through the the OC forum and could not find a clear answer.



play type = pass


Also, the example(link) you are showing might not be what you meant to show.
 
Little Dragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpreadThePink
Supposedly Thorn is on top of this.


This guys AI didn't work or something, and he is blaming the sim for the loss. I would rather not sit around our forum and listen to this the rest of the season, so it would be nice to clear this up in a reasonable amount of time.




Originally posted by BearBryant


I am not whining good game Wingmen, but we will meet in the playoffs. I am just stating neither our Offense or our Defense AI was followed and Thom has already acknowledged that and are trying to figure out what happened now. Not any ones fault but the sim.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1513049&page=1









I posted it once why are you making out like I spamming this everywhere? I just said the AI was not followed on defense and offense. It was posted here and is being taken care of right here. No need to bash me! and yes that is one example that play is not even called on 4th down and inches it is a HB blast and that sure isnt the HB blast play that is sweep which no OC is in his right mind would call on 4 and short.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 17:48:30
 
SpreadThePink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpreadThePink
Supposedly Thorn is on top of this.


This guys AI didn't work or something, and he is blaming the sim for the loss. I would rather not sit around our forum and listen to this the rest of the season, so it would be nice to clear this up in a reasonable amount of time.




Originally posted by BearBryant


I am not whining good game Wingmen, but we will meet in the playoffs. I am just stating neither our Offense or our Defense AI was followed and Thom has already acknowledged that and are trying to figure out what happened now. Not any ones fault but the sim.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1513049&page=1











bump
 
FoF
offline
Link
 
maybe its because your team is gay
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpreadThePink



play type = pass


Also, the example(link) you are showing might not be what you meant to show.


Thanks for the answer, my apologies to not noticing it earlier (from some strange reason my computer marked that nothing new in this thread).

Here is the correct play (I always copy the wrong link):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=236102&pbp_id=5741586

I am using "play-type = basic" to choose between run/pass according to my basic AI. As far as I understand this should not effect other field that I set like HB pass block.

Am I wrong ?
Last edited Dec 3, 2008 22:09:48
 
bgdave
offline
Link
 
My AI is set to 100% follow my gameplan and never deviate.

Our Defensive settings should have had us in Dime cover 2 man, or another dime or nickel defense when they line up 3 WR's, instead, it lines up one WR completely uncovered against a 4-3.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8385396
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8386556
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8386844
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8387077
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8388201
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214131&pbp_id=8388443


I even ran each play through the AI tester with the exact same setting after I saw this and it said we should have been 100% in my chosen Dime or Nickel D...every time. Yet when it is actually simmed in a game, my advanced D AI settings went out the window. There are several plays where this happened in the exact same situation, easily over 200 yards of passing due to a glitch. Sim just screwed us. There is zilch in our settings to have us in 4-3 against 3 WR's, EVER.


It also did this to us once a a 5 Wide offensive formation. Complete BS. You Bort... owe me one dollar, minimum.
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
Offense AI was totally off last game.

Here is my settings:

Input
Own Goal to Opponent Goal
1 to 3 down
Everything else is blank / use basic settings

Output
100%
Pass
Single Back
Short
Everything else is blank / use basic settings



In my playbook, I only had 4 total short pass plays:
Short WR: Quick Slants (Shotgun 5WR)
Short TE: TE Drag (Shotgun)
Short HB: HB Screen (Single Back)
Short FB: FB Texas (Pro Set)



I only have overrides in the 4th quarter. So, in the 1st to 3rd quarter, by rights it should run the HB Screen (Single Back) on every single play.



Results of game:
Quick Slants (Shotgun 5WR) was played 29 times.
HB Screen (Single Back) was played 7 times.
Various random plays was ran ~7 times.



I double checked everything. This is my 3rd season as OC/DC and I got a lot of experience. I am used to the 5-10 random plays not in the offense AI that occurs on every game. It seem that everyone know about this and most including myself has excepted this. What happend in the game above is not exceptable.

There was only 1 possible outcome with the input/output: HB Screen


There is clearly something wrong with the programming part that has not been address. Usually, It's the odd play that occurs ~10 times a game. In this game my play ran correctly 7 out of 43 chances. That is an error rate of 84%. More over 67% of the time it ran one particular play (Quick Slants Shotgun 5 WR) that while was in the playbook, it was not in the Offense AI.


Anybody got a clue what I did wrong? This seems like a mistake in the programming.



 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
- - Defensive AI Not Followed - -

Here's my thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1785757

Examples:

I Formation 3rd Down: 416C1MMBC
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663381

I Formation: 43C1MSRC*RO&LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663160
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663241

Strong I: 43C1MSRS*M&LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663205

Pro Set: 43C1MSRS*LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663489

Shotgun3: 335C2MSPW*RO&M
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1664282


I don't want to give away everything about my tactical setting but you can see that none of my settings were followed. Something went very very wrong.

Can anyone help?
-Larsonite
Last edited Jan 3, 2009 06:48:43
 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larsonite
- - Defensive AI Not Followed - -

Here's my thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1785757

Examples:

I Formation 3rd Down: 416C1MMBC
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663381

I Formation: 43C1MSRC*RO&LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663160
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663241

Strong I: 43C1MSRS*M&LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663205

Pro Set: 43C1MSRS*LO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1663489

Shotgun3: 335C2MSPW*RO&M
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=296510&pbp_id=1664282


I don't want to give away everything about my tactical setting but you can see that none of my settings were followed. Something went very very wrong.

Can anyone help?
-Larsonite


So I just found out that my Tactics didn't go through because there is a window before that game that locks all Tactics. That totally BS because I have never seen a Disclaimer or Warning for this. I want a Re-Sim because I was on time with my tactics and it is up to the people who run this game to make sure that I fully understand that conditions I am playing with. Had I known about this Blockage Time before a Simi I would have been able to set my tactics ON TIME!

I want a RE-SIM!
-Larsonite
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larsonite

So I just found out that my Tactics didn't go through because there is a window before that game that locks all Tactics. That totally BS because I have never seen a Disclaimer or Warning for this. I want a Re-Sim because I was on time with my tactics and it is up to the people who run this game to make sure that I fully understand that conditions I am playing with. Had I known about this Blockage Time before a Simi I would have been able to set my tactics ON TIME!

I want a RE-SIM!
-Larsonite



To get a re-sim, you would need something pretty drastic. Not putting your tatics in on time will not qualify.

I am pretty sure my game was due to errors by the makers yet, I don't expect a re-sim.

 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by billthekill
Originally posted by Larsonite


So I just found out that my Tactics didn't go through because there is a window before that game that locks all Tactics. That totally BS because I have never seen a Disclaimer or Warning for this. I want a Re-Sim because I was on time with my tactics and it is up to the people who run this game to make sure that I fully understand that conditions I am playing with. Had I known about this Blockage Time before a Simi I would have been able to set my tactics ON TIME!

I want a RE-SIM!
-Larsonite



To get a re-sim, you would need something pretty drastic. Not putting your tatics in on time will not qualify.

I am pretty sure my game was due to errors by the makers yet, I don't expect a re-sim.



I just think the clock is misleading. Apparently sims happen at a different time then listed and I'm sure that tactics and depth charts are locked in before the sims even take place. I just think the clock is misleading and should be accurate or in larger increments of time. ie. by hour

Still, I've been here since Season 1 and have never heard (until now) that the clock is not accurate. I guess a re-sim is out of the question but I guess I can always set up a scrim.
-Larsonite
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by billthekill
Offense AI was totally off last game.

Here is my settings:

Input
Own Goal to Opponent Goal
1 to 3 down
Everything else is blank / use basic settings

Output
100%
Pass
Single Back
Short
Everything else is blank / use basic settings



In my playbook, I only had 4 total short pass plays:
Short WR: Quick Slants (Shotgun 5WR)
Short TE: TE Drag (Shotgun)
Short HB: HB Screen (Single Back)
Short FB: FB Texas (Pro Set)



I only have overrides in the 4th quarter. So, in the 1st to 3rd quarter, by rights it should run the HB Screen (Single Back) on every single play.



Results of game:
Quick Slants (Shotgun 5WR) was played 29 times.
HB Screen (Single Back) was played 7 times.
Various random plays was ran ~7 times.



I double checked everything. This is my 3rd season as OC/DC and I got a lot of experience. I am used to the 5-10 random plays not in the offense AI that occurs on every game. It seem that everyone know about this and most including myself has excepted this. What happend in the game above is not exceptable.

There was only 1 possible outcome with the input/output: HB Screen


There is clearly something wrong with the programming part that has not been address. Usually, It's the odd play that occurs ~10 times a game. In this game my play ran correctly 7 out of 43 chances. That is an error rate of 84%. More over 67% of the time it ran one particular play (Quick Slants Shotgun 5 WR) that while was in the playbook, it was not in the Offense AI.


Anybody got a clue what I did wrong? This seems like a mistake in the programming.





Bump.

I know I should get shot for bumping my own thread.


I'm trying to make sense of this. In some of the outputs, I had "use basic settings". Does this overide the formation that was in the AI? (Single Back).



 
fred@es21
offline
Link
 
I want to call a "Big I" formation, however the sims will sometimes call a 3WR shotgun or Pro set. This setting is confirmed by the testing and I haven't adjusted the playbook. Im not sure how could this happen. One thing worth to mention is I have call to run left, don't know whether this matter or not.
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fred@es21
I want to call a "Big I" formation, however the sims will sometimes call a 3WR shotgun or Pro set. This setting is confirmed by the testing and I haven't adjusted the playbook. Im not sure how could this happen. One thing worth to mention is I have call to run left, don't know whether this matter or not.


The "Big I" formation has not been implemented yet. I assume the AI will completely ignore that output.



Last edited Jan 6, 2009 00:29:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.