User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dacolts
BTW, Thanks Bort for looking into this...I know all these guys study film so close it's like you testing facility in this thread.

Keep up the good work!


Yes, thanks for looking into this Bort. The change was a bit...alarming.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by GoVikings16


Originally posted by Bukowski



But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.




But no, they shouldn't be as dumb as to make the same exact play on the ball every single down, no matter what the play dictates.


I think this will be the case.


Yeah, that's what I'm worried about.

Every time one of these changes come around, it seems to take away one attribute or Special Ability, every single time.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by GoVikings16

Originally posted by Bukowski


But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.


listen, he is saying that high vision and super vision need to have more value. It is the only category that is similar to defensive awareness in the Madden games, and we know how important intelligence on the field should be.


In my experience, vision and supervision currently offer great value. I don't think they need to be made MORE effective, or the pendulum would swing too far the other way...
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:37:55
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by GoVikings16


Originally posted by Bukowski



But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.


listen, he is saying that high vision and super vision need to have more value. It is the only category that is similar to defensive awareness in the Madden games, and we know how important intelligence on the field should be.


In my experience, vision and supervision currently offer great value. I don't think they need to be made MORE effective, or the pendulum would swing too far the other way...


yeah, I'm not saying they should be MORE value.

I'm saying with these changes, that they need to HOLD their value, which isn't always the case in situations like this.

These changes are essentially messing with the CBs ability to make a play on the ball, which is exactly what Super Vision is supposed to help with. So any change to the balance of that, will surely have some kind of effect on Super Vision.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:39:54
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by GoVikings16


Originally posted by Bukowski



But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.


listen, he is saying that high vision and super vision need to have more value. It is the only category that is similar to defensive awareness in the Madden games, and we know how important intelligence on the field should be.


In my experience, vision and supervision currently offer great value. I don't think they need to be made MORE effective, or the pendulum would swing too far the other way...


Maybe the higher the supervision, the higher "DYNAMIC" value is for coverage style for a CB. So the CB can choose, when supervision is triggered, the best coverage style...INT, INT w/help, PBU, or no play on the ball.


Perhaps this would still allow super vision to play a role in the game without being overpowering.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by GoVikings16


Originally posted by Bukowski



But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.



So you want your CB to know every time whether he can go for an INT or should just go for a PD!?!?!? Thats retarded. In RL, corners have to make their best guess. They don't "KNOW", however they can make a good guess. Sometimes that guess is wrong.


listen, he is saying that high vision and super vision need to have more value. It is the only category that is similar to defensive awareness in the Madden games, and we know how important intelligence on the field should be.


In my experience, vision and supervision currently offer great value. I don't think they need to be made MORE effective, or the pendulum would swing too far the other way...


i will respectively disagree with you on this. he nerfed these indirectly last season when he forced CBs to delay after the ball was thrown. this was one of those midseason changes he made last year.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by vrshah



Originally posted by Bort




Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


Yes, but will the coverage style settings be independent of coverage distance settings insofar as the sim perceives them?


Yeah, we definitely need this.

Bort, can you comment on this?


Coverage distance entirely determines how far away the player plays when following a player on his route. Style only determines what he does after the ball is in the air, or when he makes a read that the ball's about to be thrown.


But it seems that our CBs are playing off of the WR, even if we play Stick to WR Like Glue.

There was something that changed along the line, that prevented CBs from sticking too close to WRs.


At the end of the play, though, correct? Once the ball's in the air, the "style" code takes over.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


please include that last sentence in your announcement. Save yourself bug threads.

PS. thanks for the extra option Bort
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by tautology


In my experience, vision and supervision currently offer great value. I don't think they need to be made MORE effective, or the pendulum would swing too far the other way...


yeah, I'm not saying they should be MORE valuable.

I'm saying with these changes, that they need to HOLD their value, which isn't always the case in situations like this.


I hear you. We can only hope for the best.

This is why mid-season changes need a little more forethought and less frequency...

I spent over $1mill in team funds on equipment over the first 5-6 games to get my coverage where I wanted it. I don't want to have to start from scratch at this point....
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bukowski



Originally posted by vrshah




Originally posted by Bort





Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


Yes, but will the coverage style settings be independent of coverage distance settings insofar as the sim perceives them?


Yeah, we definitely need this.

Bort, can you comment on this?


Coverage distance entirely determines how far away the player plays when following a player on his route. Style only determines what he does after the ball is in the air, or when he makes a read that the ball's about to be thrown.


But it seems that our CBs are playing off of the WR, even if we play Stick to WR Like Glue.

There was something that changed along the line, that prevented CBs from sticking too close to WRs.


At the end of the play, though, correct? Once the ball's in the air, the "style" code takes over.


But why would it only take effect, when the ball was in the air?

If we want our CBs to stick to WR Like Glue, then that should be going on while the QB is trying to find an open WR.

It kind of defeats the purpose, if we let the WR stay open before the ball is thrown, even though we're playing on Stick to WR Like Glue.

I think that is a main concern of many CB owners. We should be able to lock the WR down, so that the QB can't even get to the WR, if the CB has the right attributes.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
i will respectively disagree with you on this. he nerfed these indirectly last season when he forced CBs to delay after the ball was thrown. this was one of those midseason changes he made last year.


Would it be possible to base it on D line code, for like the DE? Have the reaction time based on vision, With a similar/same forumula?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


please include that last sentence in your announcement. Save yourself bug threads.

PS. thanks for the extra option Bort

Yep!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by

i will respectively disagree with you on this. he nerfed these indirectly last season when he forced CBs to delay after the ball was thrown. this was one of those midseason changes he made last year.


Would it be possible to base it on D line code, for like the DE? Have the reaction time based on vision, With a similar/same forumula?


Yeah.. I would agree with this. It would keep Vision/Super Vision still relevant, and worthwhile.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I've added the coverage option in player tactics; about to make an announcement on it. Works as you'd expect in the few plays I've simmed so far - the CB heads right for the receiver when the ball's thrown, so he's in position to try and make the PD. I'll run some more to make sure and then load it up for tomorrow. It's really basic, though: basically a copy/paste job as a new "elsif" based on what medium used to do, so it should work fine I'm sure.


excellent!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.