User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
superdolph
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dinien
Bort Do it. Anything that makes players less of the cookie cutters that they are beginning to be is worth it.


yes this
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
bort hasn't even put his own suggestion into epic suggestions?
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
sounds great for the game

Players should be able to move up and down in weight, maybe since there is no training value for 1 pt, how about 1 pt use to train to give your player a + or - toward x number of pounds for his weight
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
-1, this is a bad idea Bort...jk.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Each "weight class" would also factor into blocking, breaking blocks, and tackling, as bonuses


Had another idea for this. It seems like Brandon Jacobs has better luck at being a power runner, than Warrick Dunn.

Maybe this "wieght class" thing could be tied to certain specific SAs as well? In the Jacobs example above Power Through comes to mind: "The runner puts his head and shoulders down and drives his body through defenders. This skill allows the players to break through tackles, even more than Lower the Shoulder. This skill depends on strength and size to be effective. For a strong rusher, it can break a lot of tackles. Additional Levels: Increases the chance of using the skill successfully, and increases the bonus to break tackles.

Maybe for Blockers: Get Low "The Get Low skill lets this player lower his center of gravity and push a defender backward more easily. This skill is very important for players on teams who rush a lot. Additional Levels: Increases the bonus to pushing defenders. Um maybe having more "gravity" to lower would help the skill?

Foundation perhaps? "This player has a strong lower body and is harder to move and get around when he is pass blocking. This skill is very important for players on teams that pass a lot. Additional Levels: Increases the resistance to being pushed around."

For the D-line, The Wall comes to mind: "This player is very hard to push backward when run blocking. The Wall skill gives him a bonus to standing his ground when blockers try to push him back. This skill can help keep holes from opening up in the line, making rushing difficult. Additional Levels: Increases the bonus to avoiding being pushed back."

Maybe also Big/Monster Hit: "Put a powerful hit on the ball carrier. The Big Hit skill increases the chance of causing fumbles and reduces the morale of the player being tackled. This skill is important for strong, powerful tacklers. Repeated Big Hits will make tackling your demoralized opponent much easier. Additional Levels: Increases the chance of causing a fumble." Even in the secondary, seems like there should be a difference between the 185 pound FS laying a "Big Hit" and the 225 pound SS doing the same. Then there's the "Monster Hit" from the 250 pound Linebacker, compared to the "Big Hit" of a 330 pound DT. I'm not sure which would be worse for my morale... but I guess if I had to choose which "Big Hit" to take, I'd pick the little 185 pound guy.


So, basically I'm suggesting that weight class be used as a bonus to the base chance of a SA working or giving a bonus to it's effect when it does work.




Last edited Nov 30, 2008 11:07:32
 
Link
 
great idea bort, especially classOMG weight
 
SoxPhan21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car, so I thought I'd post it here so as not to forget and see what people thought:

Currently, everybody basically has the same base speed value for what 100 speed will get you. It's modified by height/weight a little, along with acceleration, but not a huge amount.

So here's the idea for a new attribute:

Each player has a "weight class," or whatever we want to call it, defined by how heavy they are and what position they are.

Each "weight class" would have a base max speed and acceleration value that having 100 speed gets you. We could convert this into 40 times or something to make it easy to understand, and base it on top NFL combine scores for various positions.

Each "weight class" would also factor into blocking, breaking blocks, and tackling, as bonuses.

We figure out the base weight classes for each player currently in the game, and put it on their profile page for reference.

For instance, you could have something like:

Class lightweight < 160 lbs : base 3.75s 40, -20% block/break block penalty
Class middleweight 161-190 lbs : base 4.0s 40, -10% block/break block penalty
Class light heavyweight 191-225 lbs : base 4.25s 40, +0% block bonus
Class heavyweight 225-260 lbs : base 4.5s 40, +10% block bonus
Class super heavyweight 261 - 300lbs : base 4.75s 40, +20% block bonus
Class OMGweight 301+lbs : base 5s 40, +30% block bonus

etc. etc.

Here's the part that I think could be kinda interesting: You could adjust your weight class through training or special skills (perhaps veteran abilities?). Maybe you're in the middleweight class but you want to move down to lightweight to be faster, so you choose a skill to do so, etc.

Something like this could make it so we could show calculated 40 times for different players, etc. on their profile. It'd let you know what you're getting for your weight or lack of it, too.


If so my CB is a light heavyweight
my P is a middleweight
my G is a OMGweight (Yes!)
my OT is a super heavyweight
my C is a OMGweight
and I am a light heavyweight!
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
has anyone seen a player lighter than 180 on a non k/p?

 
Gizizza
offline
Link
 
Instead of having weight classes, why not have "hidden" speed/strength/acceleration caps for each player, as a random part of rolling?

Part of the problem is that speed/strength/agility is not directly proportional to height and/or weight. Some guys just have intrinsically better body mechanics.
 
Link
 
Sounds like another good on paper suggestion that 2 days after implementation will get 500 threads started to go back to the original way. Someone said it before and I will reiterate This Idea was crap when it came out months ago by a random guy but since this game is full of sheep. It is now glorious.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardwscollins
Sounds like another good on paper suggestion that 2 days after implementation will get 500 threads started to go back to the original way. Someone said it before and I will reiterate This Idea was crap when it came out months ago by a random guy but since this game is full of sheep. It is now glorious.


Other than the "everyone will either be as big or as small as possible" exploit idea (which could be fixable in any number of ways), what exactly are the problems with this? Size is an integral part of football... it should be represented here in some way.
 
Gizizza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardwscollins
Sounds like another good on paper suggestion that 2 days after implementation will get 500 threads started to go back to the original way. Someone said it before and I will reiterate This Idea was crap when it came out months ago by a random guy but since this game is full of sheep. It is now glorious.


Here's an idea: why don't you actually explain your reasons for your opinion.

Calling the idea "crap" is crappy; you're quite the critic.

If we're sheep, please lead us to the promised land with a glorious explanation, oh messiah.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
No wonder my college coach wanted me above 190.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
No wonder my college coach wanted me above 190.


Did you get slower when you put on weight?
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
has anyone seen a player lighter than 180 on a non k/p?



Some WRs have been under 180 - few and far between, of course.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/8826
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 13:07:41
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.