User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Certain builds are too good and certain builds are ineffective.

Strength needs to be more important and agility (or speed) needs to be less important, at least for lineman IMHO. This doesn't have to be a huge disparity either, just some tweaks is all.

Also, work on the pathing of backfield blockers (it's unacceptable atm).

Lastly, stop allowing players to run through other players (if they have no choice, make it a jumping check or something).

Football is a game of angles, start making angles more important... if you're unable to, adjust attributes so that they simulate angles. The biggest issue with OTs TBPH, is that they can't shuffle to cut off angles. This is why super fast and agile DEs eat them for breakfast.

I'm not sure how to go about fixing this from a coding PoV, but maybe allow OTs to move laterally at a speed rating equal to the average of blocking and agility. Then adjust the pathing to have them form a pocket. At the bare minimum, it should take an outside angle rush of a DE 2.5 secs to reach the QB (2 secs for a fantastic build and 3 seconds for a bad build). The the OT should alter the time depending on how effective his build is (+1 sec for a fantastic build, +0 secs for a bad build). The only way to reach a QB sooner than 2 secs is through the inside IMHO.

First step should help a DE get better position (i.e. reduce the leverage of the OL on inside moves and improve the angle of the outside moves). Shed block should be more effective, probably by being the DE version of shock block (it should stun the OL momentarily). Remove one of the more worthless OL SAs and give them a spot blitz type of SA (which gives them a boost to speed and agility to get into position on blitzes).

I could go on and on, but I think you get the point.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
tardvoltron... ?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins


But of course, no one can ever, ever be wrong on teh internets. But I could very well be wrong on this legislation assignment for tomorrow. Good night, everyone.




No one has any idea what your point is except that you want to put all your points in blocking because you think that is most important in real life. If you aren't paying any attention to the sim and you want to do whatever you want to do, fine. Go do it. Just don't complain when it doesn't work.

Maybe someone feels vision is what separates good HB's from great HB's and loads up on vision. I would bet my life that that HB would suck. Not because vision isn't important, but that is just isn't the best way to go in this game. Bort determines what works best. Not you, not me.

And while blocking is very important, the difference between not being drafted and being a 1st round pick isn't strength or blocking technique. It is usually quickness (speed) and the body frame needed for the NFL. Or potential. You can teach technique and work on strength, but you can't teach speed and size.

There has to be more than 1 aspect that goes into making any football player. That is the point of having so many attributes.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
why youve just basically said every match up on the field needs to become a damned speed race welcome back to season 2 when speed was king
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=210664&pbp_id=1252929

as near as i can tell contact was made then with that kind of speed the defender was at least looking at -40/-50 strength not to mention the centers blocking is 75+ agility is softcapped and zero chance for a block

my question is was was no kind of strength check mad to determine the outcome
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=210664&pbp_id=1252929

as near as i can tell contact was made then with that kind of speed the defender was at least looking at -40/-50 strength not to mention the centers blocking is 75+ agility is softcapped and zero chance for a block

my question is was was no kind of strength check mad to determine the outcome


That play is nuts.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=210664&pbp_id=1252929

as near as i can tell contact was made then with that kind of speed the defender was at least looking at -40/-50 strength not to mention the centers blocking is 75+ agility is softcapped and zero chance for a block

my question is was was no kind of strength check mad to determine the outcome



what was his speed?
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 08:18:06
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
why youve just basically said every match up on the field needs to become a damned speed race welcome back to season 2 when speed was king


damned? why is speed damned?

I said that every match-up needs to be a match of speed, strength, and agility.

If you are too far behind in any of them, then you lose. And that is the way it should be.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
do you not see contact being made my question was for the point of impact if everything is gonna be a speed race on here im dome because the oline will be screwed by season 10 from naturals in speed to the defense
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Blocking should be the players ability to block. - The ability to engage a block, the ability to hold a block, the ability to deter SA's from triggering (think stopping swim moves for example) anything that has to do with stopping a player from getting to the QB and his ability to stop the opposing player from making a tackle. Blocking might even decrease the tackle ability from the guy who's engaged assuming in the sim they can still make a tackle while engaged.

Strength should be your linemen's ability to hold his ground on pass blocking or move players out of his way on run blocking.

Vision should be needed to more quickly determine who to block. At the snap you know who to block, this should be his ability to change based on whats going on around him. Right now this should do little unless there are blitz/stunts near the linemen. This should help him determine who to engage to stop the rush.

Agility should be the linemen 5 yard speed. Speed shouldn't be the factor. Agility should be the lineman's speed or his ability to increase the radius at which he can engage a block by moving.

Defensive linemen should have the ability to beat them however. Not just by running around them by pumped up attributes. They should have SA's like bull rush (+10% strength), rip (trigger + agi/speed), swim (low % trigger to beat clean), turning the corner (low % trigger to beat clean), spin under, etc.

Right now DE's have no choice but to go all Speed/Agi because just blowing around the OT works.

DE Pass Rusher Abilities

First Step - Okay speed boost off the line.
Change Direction - Okay agility boost all the time.
Shed Block - Hey a real SA, only issue is I can't tell when it happens and OT's blocking ability probably doesn't decrease it's effectiveness.
Tunnel Vision - Speed increase. What another? lol
Big Sack - Increase Fumble Chance and morale decrease. Okay. You would think the 5 point talent would help you pass rush better IMO.

Anyways it's a fun game overall.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 08:57:07
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
tardvoltron... ?


Ty?
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Madcow8me

tardvoltron... ?


Ty?


Any idea if Bort and Co. know of the server errors at this time?
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by Madcow8me


tardvoltron... ?


Ty?


Any idea if Bort and Co. know of the server errors at this time?


I'm not getting any server errors. o.O
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
check your inbox
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
check your inbox


Ahh, I see lol.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.