User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Even still... We should be able to adjust our defenses to whether the power back or a wide receiver is lined up in the backfield, or if a WR lines up in the TE2 spot, etc.


I tend to agree, it would be a brilliant setting to have.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
So far I've seen two things already potentially stopping the HB at QB2 thing working well:

1) Out of position penalty. Your 90 speed / 60 agility HB now has 54 speed 36 agi. Still too powerful? make it more harsh. That was 40%.
2) As said, simply limit it to QB.

Here's the situation we're in:
We have 2, legitimate QBs. Both can pass. One can run MUCH better than the other. If it's a QB run... guess which one we want in.

Just make the out of position penalty HUGE or simply disallow it all together.

There needs to be a way for teams to legitimately use this without opening up exploits to everyone else =/
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 21:57:32
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I can see a MAJOR exploit, imho...

Super duper major.

It will ruin the game.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Honestly, I can see a MAJOR exploit, imho...

Super duper major.

It will ruin the game.


That's what the other guy was claiming.

PM me
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 

All of these "special positon" pieces should probably just be limited to their own position with no possibility for out of position players to prevent exploits. Since the defense can't adjust (where they obviously could in real football if you saw extra FBs / TEs coming out, etc).... then make it so that you have to use the right position for all of them. And add QB.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu

All of these "special positon" pieces should probably just be limited to their own position with no possibility for out of position players to prevent exploits. Since the defense can't adjust (where they obviously could in real football if you saw extra FBs / TEs coming out, etc).... then make it so that you have to use the right position for all of them. And add QB.


+1
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu

All of these "special positon" pieces should probably just be limited to their own position with no possibility for out of position players to prevent exploits. Since the defense can't adjust (where they obviously could in real football if you saw extra FBs / TEs coming out, etc).... then make it so that you have to use the right position for all of them. And add QB.


Already been suggested...on several different occasions, by several different people thinking that they solved the problem

But yeah, I agree it will help the problem. If QB's start building 100% run for the specialized QB run plays, since teams could use pure passers for passing plays, then problems may occur.

A pure running QB may only be 75-80% as effective at running than a HB, but with the QB sweeps having an extra blocker compared to a HB sweep, the 20% advantage that a HB has quickly goes away.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Well without some sort of solution, this doesn't help the rushing type QBs much at all, which I thought was supposed to be a big "feature" of this round of updates. The only way to take advantage of the new rushing plays is by having only 1 QB on the team that can do both. If you have someone that can do both, they either can't have a backup, or their backup ALSO has to be able to do both.

Only thing I could think of to prevent that is to give a penalty to stats like it's an out of position player if their throwing scouting bar isn't >= their rushing scouting bar.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 22:19:04
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Well without some sort of solution, this doesn't help the rushing type QBs much at all, which I thought was supposed to be a big "feature" of this round of updates. The only way to take advantage of the new rushing plays is by either having only 1 QB on the team that can do both.


It does help the realistic scrambling QBs. "Scrambling QBs" have some throwing ability along with passing ability. "Rushing QBs" have zero throwing ability and are built like a pseudo-HB. Scrambling QB's can now run a few plays, where as before, they didn't have that choice. It is a huge step for Scrambling QB's that can throw well enough to get by, but can also run the ball when needed. These players can still start on the roster, and the OC can add some QB run plays in, and this update is all win-win for them.

What the update hasn't allowed is teams to have a 100% Pass QB, and a 100% Run QB, neither of them having the ability to do the other, but gaining full advantage of both of them by hotswapping whenever one of them is needed. To me, that is kind of lame. Same thing for the TE position, the FB position, and HB position. Teams can have a Receiving FB and HB in for pass plays, and blocking FB's along with running HB's for run plays. It completely eliminates the whole "hybrid" build idea. Why make a player that is capable of performing all of the position duties when you can specialize completely in one, and the team will sub in someone completely specialized for the other one when needed?
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
But you glazed over my point of...

What if you have a QB that CAN do both. Say he's your starter.
And a QB that is only pocket passer. This is your backup, lower level.

You can't have both in the depth chart and have QB run plays... without the lower level backup pocket passer QB doing horrible at them.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 22:28:39
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
The new Custom Slots for RB1 RB2 FB1 FB2 TE1 TE2 are a great idea, but I think having a third option would be very beneficial for Tight Ends.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
But you glazed over my point of...

What if you have a QB that CAN do both. Say he's your starter.
And a QB that is only pocket passer. This is your backup, lower level.

You can't have both in the depth chart and have QB run plays... without the lower level backup pocket passer QB doing horrible at them.


True...it's a risky move of course. I mean, no team will be logically running QB run plays 1/3 of the time unless some kind of cheesy exploit is found. It would just be an occasional thing, like 4th and short you might run a QB sneak or something.

Maybe "Pocket Passers" might need to get their speed and agility up past 15? So they are "capable" of doing QB runs, but don't really do great at them.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
It's just sad that we can't have a feature that would make sense because of the threat of people exploiting it... so instead of stopping the exploit somehow we just take out the feature for those teams that it would be useful for.

I had suggested one stop to the exploit perhaps... make them have a passing scouting bar more than their rushing scouting bar or take a huge out of position type penalty.

Anyway, bedtime, I'll check in tomorrow and see if theres any change in discussion
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 22:37:42
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
hah, well I'll remove my reply to your edited reply too then....

"."
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 22:38:29
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.