User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.


That's what I'm saying. Use some common sense when building your player. Do you think a HB with 30% strength will never fumble?

Also, you still never answered the stamina question.


39 stamina and i split carries with a power back
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Let me ask you power backs a question, what if someone told you that you HAD to pump up agility to break tackles that strength wouldn't do it alone, how would you respond?
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.


lol too bad you still don't see my point. let me see if I can give a good analogy. I don't know if you have ever played everquest or not but.. in everquest necromancers main stats were intelligence, and stamina. primary stats increased power pool for your class and each class had 2 primary stats. necromancers were highly unbalanced because their primary stats not only increased their power pool but stamina also increased their over all health. 2 for the price of 1. they were eventually nerfed....


I do understand what you're saying, and we're not over powered. You just think that since we don't fumble as much we're too over powered. We don't have the break aways elusive backs have unless we're at the soft cap with the Elusive backs skills... Yes, I get we have 2 for 1, but our 2 for 1 don't get us the break aways and TDs your 1 gets you.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Let me ask you power backs a question, what if someone told you that you HAD to pump up agility to break tackles that strength wouldn't do it alone, how would you respond?


My agility is already close to soft cap... Big deal I'd say. I didn't neglect anything. What it comes down to is this Vandiar, We power backs KNOW that you have to have good speed and agility to be sucessful. You elusive backs figured "what the hell, I might fumble every now and again but big deal, i'd rather be a badass and get TDs all the time". Now that the competition has gotten better to stop the power backs the elusive backs are suffering from no fault but their own.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2

Originally posted by Schaffer05


Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.


lol too bad you still don't see my point. let me see if I can give a good analogy. I don't know if you have ever played everquest or not but.. in everquest necromancers main stats were intelligence, and stamina. primary stats increased power pool for your class and each class had 2 primary stats. necromancers were highly unbalanced because their primary stats not only increased their power pool but stamina also increased their over all health. 2 for the price of 1. they were eventually nerfed....


I do understand what you're saying, and we're not over powered. You just think that since we don't fumble as much we're too over powered. We don't have the break aways elusive backs have unless we're at the soft cap with the Elusive backs skills... Yes, I get we have 2 for 1, but our 2 for 1 don't get us the break aways and TDs your 1 gets you.


I don't think you are over powered at all or should be nerfed. I think carrying should have a higher modification for fumble protection boost since both builds need it though.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:38:41
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2

Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.


You're not?
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2


Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.


You're not?


lol it was sarcasm dude..
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
I personally think it's fine the way it is, and not just because I'm a power back... If I was elusive I'd have 70 speed, 60 agility and 48 str and working on carrying to 48. You built wrong and aren't well rounded like you should be. Fix your build rather than "fixing" the game.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I personally think it's fine the way it is, and not just because I'm a power back... If I was elusive I'd have 70 speed, 60 agility and 48 str and working on carrying to 48. You built wrong and aren't well rounded like you should be. Fix your build rather than "fixing" the game.


Yeah your right I am built wrong, averaging 7.8 yards per carry this season. How about adding a higher modification to carrying.. that would fix the problem for everyone. Why do power backs have to have such a significant advantage over elusive backs? and how many times do I have to state that I have 49 carrying.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Let me ask you power backs a question, what if someone told you that you HAD to pump up agility to break tackles that strength wouldn't do it alone, how would you respond?


39 stamina is pretty good, but only 6 fumbles is also.

And I have a power back and an elusive back. Agility does help break tackles, and I know that already, as should most power backs.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:46:23
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Yeah your right I am built wrong, averaging 7.8 yards per carry this season. How about adding a higher modification to carrying.. that would fix the problem for everyone. Why do power backs have to have such a significant advantage over elusive backs? and how many times do I have to state that I have 49 carrying.


Did I not earlier state that Elusive backs are better running backs because when they get in the open field they dominate? You're proving my point that you have the same advantage over us that we have over you. If you don't want to fumble, yes you're built wrong. No you're not going to fumble when a shitty CB hits you (except occasionally because yea it does happen) But when that hard hitting SS rips your head off don't be surprised when you fumble. You've got great carrying, but you don't have the strength to take the big hits from the head hunters.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I personally think it's fine the way it is, and not just because I'm a power back... If I was elusive I'd have 70 speed, 60 agility and 48 str and working on carrying to 48. You built wrong and aren't well rounded like you should be. Fix your build rather than "fixing" the game.


But your not an elusive back. you don't need speed AND agility that high to be effective, just strength. In which strength has multiple benefits. none of our primary stats have multiple benefits. There are more benefits in building a power back than an elusive back. Fix them!!
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:49:09
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
But your not an elusive back. you don't need speed AND agility that high to be effective, just strength. In which strength has multiple benefits. none of our primary stats have multiple benefits. There are more benefits in building a power back than an elusive back. Fix them!!


You're wrong... If I didn't have my speed and agility as high as I do I'd be worthless on the toss plays, I'd get stopped by the LBs every time and when I do break a tackle, it would take me 3 seconds just to get back up to full speed, by which time I'd already be tackled by that SS coming from across the field 2 seconds ago.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Power backs do need a lot of speed and agility to be effective against any defense that is at least decent much less good.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Power backs do need a lot of speed and agility to be effective against any defense that is at least decent much less good.


so 50 and 44 is considered a lot? So basically what everyone is trying to say here is I need to soft cap 2 stats to prevent fumbling, where power backs really only need to soft cap 1 because the other stat is a primary stat of theirs and it is essential to their build. What a crock of ..
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 16:06:56
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.