Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by RAPB
...needs a little addition, for the issue doesn't occur if the pass got decent height in the "tick" it reaches the WR. It just happens if the tick is the same tick the ball would have hit the ground. So in this cases there's no diving catch possible.
This isn't necessarily true.
If, to use Bort's example from before, on tick 10 the ball is outside the range of the WR, then the WR can't attempt to catch it, obviously. If on tick 11, the ball is on the ground, the WR can't attempt to catch it either.
Now, you're assuming the ball is on the ground at the WR's feet on tick 11, but that isn't necessarily true. It could be, or it could be 3 feet past him. Or 5, or 8, or 10, etc., which would make the ball very catchable.
It's impossible to tell from the replay - have you ever seen the size of the ball??? It's like 10 feet long!
I see your point, but ticks are roughly each 2-3 yards pass travelling distance (that might increase on shorter passes, for the velocity should be higher at the beginning). So to be out of reach on tick 10, it has to be like 3+ feet away - which leaves a maximum of 6 feet for tick 11. Due to the ballistic curve, the ball had to be somewhat low on tick 10 already - otherwise he'd not hit the ground on tick 11 - but travel to tick 12. I consider a proper pass to have a rather shallow sink curve though.
Interesting.
How did you figure out how far the ball travels per tick? Are you just estimating or do you have a way to tell?
If you're correct, then I agree with you. It makes sense on one level, because you'd have to take stock of what's going on during a play fairly often, so ticks have to be pretty frequent.
As far as the sink curve, I suppose it would have to do with a number of factors, including passing distance, QB pass setting and QB strength, not to mention pass quality and the RNG. But I imagine the time the ball is in the WR's catching range is fairly short, no matter what type of pass it is.
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by RAPB
...needs a little addition, for the issue doesn't occur if the pass got decent height in the "tick" it reaches the WR. It just happens if the tick is the same tick the ball would have hit the ground. So in this cases there's no diving catch possible.
This isn't necessarily true.
If, to use Bort's example from before, on tick 10 the ball is outside the range of the WR, then the WR can't attempt to catch it, obviously. If on tick 11, the ball is on the ground, the WR can't attempt to catch it either.
Now, you're assuming the ball is on the ground at the WR's feet on tick 11, but that isn't necessarily true. It could be, or it could be 3 feet past him. Or 5, or 8, or 10, etc., which would make the ball very catchable.
It's impossible to tell from the replay - have you ever seen the size of the ball??? It's like 10 feet long!
I see your point, but ticks are roughly each 2-3 yards pass travelling distance (that might increase on shorter passes, for the velocity should be higher at the beginning). So to be out of reach on tick 10, it has to be like 3+ feet away - which leaves a maximum of 6 feet for tick 11. Due to the ballistic curve, the ball had to be somewhat low on tick 10 already - otherwise he'd not hit the ground on tick 11 - but travel to tick 12. I consider a proper pass to have a rather shallow sink curve though.
Interesting.
How did you figure out how far the ball travels per tick? Are you just estimating or do you have a way to tell?
If you're correct, then I agree with you. It makes sense on one level, because you'd have to take stock of what's going on during a play fairly often, so ticks have to be pretty frequent.
As far as the sink curve, I suppose it would have to do with a number of factors, including passing distance, QB pass setting and QB strength, not to mention pass quality and the RNG. But I imagine the time the ball is in the WR's catching range is fairly short, no matter what type of pass it is.






























