User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by j10er

Originally posted by RAPB


...needs a little addition, for the issue doesn't occur if the pass got decent height in the "tick" it reaches the WR. It just happens if the tick is the same tick the ball would have hit the ground. So in this cases there's no diving catch possible.


This isn't necessarily true.

If, to use Bort's example from before, on tick 10 the ball is outside the range of the WR, then the WR can't attempt to catch it, obviously. If on tick 11, the ball is on the ground, the WR can't attempt to catch it either.

Now, you're assuming the ball is on the ground at the WR's feet on tick 11, but that isn't necessarily true. It could be, or it could be 3 feet past him. Or 5, or 8, or 10, etc., which would make the ball very catchable.

It's impossible to tell from the replay - have you ever seen the size of the ball??? It's like 10 feet long!


I see your point, but ticks are roughly each 2-3 yards pass travelling distance (that might increase on shorter passes, for the velocity should be higher at the beginning). So to be out of reach on tick 10, it has to be like 3+ feet away - which leaves a maximum of 6 feet for tick 11. Due to the ballistic curve, the ball had to be somewhat low on tick 10 already - otherwise he'd not hit the ground on tick 11 - but travel to tick 12. I consider a proper pass to have a rather shallow sink curve though.


Interesting.

How did you figure out how far the ball travels per tick? Are you just estimating or do you have a way to tell?

If you're correct, then I agree with you. It makes sense on one level, because you'd have to take stock of what's going on during a play fairly often, so ticks have to be pretty frequent.

As far as the sink curve, I suppose it would have to do with a number of factors, including passing distance, QB pass setting and QB strength, not to mention pass quality and the RNG. But I imagine the time the ball is in the WR's catching range is fairly short, no matter what type of pass it is.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
What if the tic's were just always doubled?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bort seems to think this would result in too high a completion %.

Not 100% sure why this would be the case, as a pass that is catchable should still be catchable, and one thats not would still not be catchable.

However if thats how it works, and the result is something like a 80% completion % then it shouldnt be allowed, as it will disrupt the ecosystem of GLB far too much.

 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Bort seems to think this would result in too high a completion %.

Not 100% sure why this would be the case, as a pass that is catchable should still be catchable, and one thats not would still not be catchable.

However if thats how it works, and the result is something like a 80% completion % then it shouldnt be allowed, as it will disrupt the ecosystem of GLB far too much.



Let's totally forget the fact that this fucks over people with fast players and High strength QB's.

Not to mention, players with mostly long passes, won't suffer that 80% completion "problem".
Last edited Sep 28, 2008 22:01:28
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Bort seems to think this would result in too high a completion %.

Not 100% sure why this would be the case, as a pass that is catchable should still be catchable, and one thats not would still not be catchable.

However if thats how it works, and the result is something like a 80% completion % then it shouldnt be allowed, as it will disrupt the ecosystem of GLB far too much.



Let's totally forget the fact that this fucks over people with fast players and High strength QB's.

Not to mention, players with mostly long passes, won't suffer that 80% completion "problem".


Right.

There has to be some kind of happy medium in this case, I really don't think a decent solution for everyone is that far out of reach.
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
GLB "proudly" displays the BETA tag, no? Fix the bug and tweak the % afterwards. The reality is that any "balance" that was created was based on early builds and will continue to require revision as players mature.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
GLB "proudly" displays the BETA tag, no? Fix the bug and tweak the % afterwards. The reality is that any "balance" that was created was based on early builds and will continue to require revision as players mature.


LOL... Yeah, that is a nice thought, isn't it?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bort has said he is looking for a way to 'fix' this, but he doesnt want it to then escalate into more 'bugs' elsewhere, and give yet more advantage to the exploiters out there.

Now I agree with you all, so dont get me wrong, but think carefully about the likely scenario suggested.

Basically the foundations of the passing game have always been wrong, and the passing game controls and calibrations in the Game have been based on that for 5 seasons.

Not to mention builds of every QB, WR and DB.

Some rough numbers to consider...

(QB) Quarterback (12170 already active)
(WR) Wide Receiver (21631 already active)
(TE) Tight End (10516 already active)

(CB) Cornerback (21257 already active)
(SS) Strong Safety (9697 already active)
(FS) Free Safety (9614 already active)

^^^ Thats how many individual players will be effected by this 'small change'.
(Not including HBs and FBs here)

I am sure some will be most happy that their WR can now catch a ball he has every right in catching, and it does make the most sense.

But if the passing game, and specifically the long passing game is restructured suddenly, thats how many different variable you have...

Nearly 85,000 players with various build differences and tactical options muddying the water.

Now if you changed the passing game and made it a lot more reliable, and much easier to gain a large chunk of yards, what do you think will happen to the tactics in the sims?

And the builds of those involved.

As we have people complaining about how easy it is to get a sack, what happens if more teams want to go pass first?

All the OTS become Pass protection builds, which effectively ends the need and effectiveness of the running game.

If Bort ever fine tunes it back again, these build issues still cripple the running game, but the passing game is poorer as well.

Cue uproar and non stop complaints about an over powering defense.

Its no win.

This is not even considering the disadvantage the Defense is currently at, given the bugs in DB coverage which stem from a very similar problem, being that builds have progressed beyond the sims capabilities.

And the suction blocking of O-Line, the unnatural blocking of WRs etc.

To then contemplate 'Fine tuning' while its live is another bad move, as this will lead to all those players not knowing from one game to the next why their production changed, and how to build their player to correct a problem that may not exsist for more than that one game.

I whole-heartidly agree that it needs fixing.

But there is no way to make everyone happy, and its not like there is a way to fix it and only penalise the exploit builds, which would be fine by me

So we have to hope Bort knows what he is doing, and trust that he will find a solution to our problem that doesnt ruin the game for Defensive players, and teams set up to run the ball.

Not an easy task, and not one that will be fixed anytime soon.

It seems likely now that most 'play specific' bugs that have been reported are down to the sim not being set up to deal with current builds levels.

See the threads about DB coverage, Pitch plays etc...

All are routed in players moving faster than the the sim can calculate, or faster than the plays was designed to accomadate.

Take FB lead blocking.

HBs got too fast and agile, so FBs couldnt be expected to lead block for them, as to do so meant they would have no Strength or Blocking, so Bort puts in a HB pause, which ruins the play for anyone who built their FBs and HBs in unison.

The play is rolled back, and many were happier, while a few were not.

That was a very simple problem, and look how difficult it is to find a perfect answer, or even a happy consensus.

So again I'll say this.

Post suggestions about how to fix it, that is a great help.

But try to avoid saying it must be fixed now, and its destroying GLB as it stands, because the truth is, we just are not in a position to know how it will effect GLB if it is fixed.

Only Bort is, so we gotta take his word for it, a try to help where we can.


Last edited Sep 28, 2008 23:39:39
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Bort has said he is looking for a way to 'fix' this, but he doesnt want it to then escalate into more 'bugs' elsewhere, and give yet more advantage to the exploiters out there.

Now I agree with you all, so dont get me wrong, but think carefully about the likely scenario suggested.

Basically the foundations of the passing game have always been wrong, and the passing game controls and calibrations in the Game have been based on that for 5 seasons.

Not to mention builds of every QB, WR and DB.

Some rough numbers to consider...

(QB) Quarterback (12170 already active)
(WR) Wide Receiver (21631 already active)
(TE) Tight End (10516 already active)

(CB) Cornerback (21257 already active)
(SS) Strong Safety (9697 already active)
(FS) Free Safety (9614 already active)

^^^ Thats how many individual players will be effected by this 'small change'.
(Not including HBs and FBs here)

I am sure some will be most happy that their WR can now catch a ball he has every right in catching, and it does make the most sense.

But if the passing game, and specifically the long passing game is restructured suddenly, thats how many different variable you have...

Nearly 85,000 players with various build differences and tactical options muddying the water.

Now if you changed the passing game and made it a lot more reliable, and much easier to gain a large chunk of yards, what do you think will happen to the tactics in the sims?

And the builds of those involved.

As we have people complaining about how easy it is to get a sack, what happens if more teams want to go pass first?

All the OTS become Pass protection builds, which effectively ends the need and effectiveness of the running game.

If Bort ever fine tunes it back again, these build issues still cripple the running game, but the passing game is poorer as well.

Cue uproar and non stop complaints about an over powering defense.

Its no win.

This is not even considering the disadvantage the Defense is currently at, given the bugs in DB coverage which stem from a very similar problem, being that builds have progressed beyond the sims capabilities.

And the suction blocking of O-Line, the unnatural blocking of WRs etc.

To then contemplate 'Fine tuning' while its live is another bad move, as this will lead to all those players not knowing from one game to the next why their production changed, and how to build their player to correct a problem that may not exsist for more than that one game.

I whole-heartidly agree that it needs fixing.

But there is no way to make everyone happy, and its not like there is a way to fix it and only penalise the exploit builds, which would be fine by me

So we have to hope Bort knows what he is doing, and trust that he will find a solution to our problem that doesnt ruin the game for Defensive players, and teams set up to run the ball.

Not an easy task, and not one that will be fixed anytime soon.

It seems likely now that most 'play specific' bugs that have been reported are down to the sim not being set up to deal with current builds levels.

See the threads about DB coverage, Pitch plays etc...

All are routed in players moving faster than the the sim can calculate, or faster than the plays was designed to accomadate.

Take FB lead blocking.

HBs got too fast and agile, so FBs couldnt be expected to lead block for them, as to do so meant they would have no Strength or Blocking, so Bort puts in a HB pause, which ruins the play for anyone who built their FBs and HBs in unison.

The play is rolled back, and many were happier, while a few were not.

That was a very simple problem, and look how difficult it is to find a perfect answer, or even a happy consensus.

So again I'll say this.

Post suggestions about how to fix it, that is a great help.

But try to avoid saying it must be fixed now, and its destroying GLB as it stands, because the truth is, we just are not in a position to know how it will effect GLB if it is fixed.

Only Bort is, so we gotta take his word for it, a try to help where we can.




I'm going to use one of your cards here.

Beta
 
dsl20
offline
Link
 
You cant please all of the people all of the time. That's just life. Now, with that said, this is a beta game, and the goal was, and should be to fix game play problems. This game isn't about 1 season of football, or even 5 seasons. It should be to get the game right, so it stands the test of time.

People are going to be mad that their kick ass super build isn't setting the game on fire anymore. Oh well. For everyone of these guys there will be current players that understand that its for the good of the game, and will adapt. There will also be many FUTURE players that wont know these changes ever happened, but will like the games accuracy. Weather Bort decides to make these changes mid season, or during the off season, they must be made to ensure the overall quality of the game.

Changing something that isn't broken (QB strength) to try to "quick fix" another part of the game is setting a bad precedent, and in the end will hurt the game far more then it will help.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Bort has said he is looking for a way to 'fix' this, but he doesnt want it to then escalate into more 'bugs' elsewhere, and give yet more advantage to the exploiters out there.

Now I agree with you all, so dont get me wrong, but think carefully about the likely scenario suggested.

Basically the foundations of the passing game have always been wrong, and the passing game controls and calibrations in the Game have been based on that for 5 seasons.

Not to mention builds of every QB, WR and DB.

Some rough numbers to consider...

(QB) Quarterback (12170 already active)
(WR) Wide Receiver (21631 already active)
(TE) Tight End (10516 already active)

(CB) Cornerback (21257 already active)
(SS) Strong Safety (9697 already active)
(FS) Free Safety (9614 already active)

^^^ Thats how many individual players will be effected by this 'small change'.
(Not including HBs and FBs here)

I am sure some will be most happy that their WR can now catch a ball he has every right in catching, and it does make the most sense.

But if the passing game, and specifically the long passing game is restructured suddenly, thats how many different variable you have...

Nearly 85,000 players with various build differences and tactical options muddying the water.

Now if you changed the passing game and made it a lot more reliable, and much easier to gain a large chunk of yards, what do you think will happen to the tactics in the sims?

And the builds of those involved.

As we have people complaining about how easy it is to get a sack, what happens if more teams want to go pass first?

All the OTS become Pass protection builds, which effectively ends the need and effectiveness of the running game.

If Bort ever fine tunes it back again, these build issues still cripple the running game, but the passing game is poorer as well.

Cue uproar and non stop complaints about an over powering defense.

Its no win.

This is not even considering the disadvantage the Defense is currently at, given the bugs in DB coverage which stem from a very similar problem, being that builds have progressed beyond the sims capabilities.

And the suction blocking of O-Line, the unnatural blocking of WRs etc.

To then contemplate 'Fine tuning' while its live is another bad move, as this will lead to all those players not knowing from one game to the next why their production changed, and how to build their player to correct a problem that may not exsist for more than that one game.

I whole-heartidly agree that it needs fixing.

But there is no way to make everyone happy, and its not like there is a way to fix it and only penalise the exploit builds, which would be fine by me

So we have to hope Bort knows what he is doing, and trust that he will find a solution to our problem that doesnt ruin the game for Defensive players, and teams set up to run the ball.

Not an easy task, and not one that will be fixed anytime soon.

It seems likely now that most 'play specific' bugs that have been reported are down to the sim not being set up to deal with current builds levels.

See the threads about DB coverage, Pitch plays etc...

All are routed in players moving faster than the the sim can calculate, or faster than the plays was designed to accomadate.

Take FB lead blocking.

HBs got too fast and agile, so FBs couldnt be expected to lead block for them, as to do so meant they would have no Strength or Blocking, so Bort puts in a HB pause, which ruins the play for anyone who built their FBs and HBs in unison.

The play is rolled back, and many were happier, while a few were not.

That was a very simple problem, and look how difficult it is to find a perfect answer, or even a happy consensus.

So again I'll say this.

Post suggestions about how to fix it, that is a great help.

But try to avoid saying it must be fixed now, and its destroying GLB as it stands, because the truth is, we just are not in a position to know how it will effect GLB if it is fixed.

Only Bort is, so we gotta take his word for it, a try to help where we can.




Your 5 seasons of the same bug argument is also completely moot considering that this wasn't a problem until WRs began to reach a certain speed - now that they are moving fast enough that it IS a problem, it needs to be fixed, pure and simple. This game will die very very fast if the only way to have an effective passing game is to have slower recievers - soon every corner will be faster than the recievers he's covering and nobody will get open and defenses will rule the galaxy. No matter how you slice it, there will be an advantage one way or another - the only way Bort can truly build his sim is the way he has always done - by trying to add realism at every opportunity.

The bottom line - he needs to make a change to address this, and he needs to do it soon.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
The problem is not simply WR speed.

Its a combination of the sequence error, QB build, WR build and individual and team tactics.

Complex problem, needing a complex answer, or a well thought out answer at least.

Your also missing one of the other problems is that it is already apparent that faster more agile CBs are unable to cover slower less agile WRs.

There are problems everywhere and they all need fixing, and they are all interlinked.

The only way to fix them all requires a lot of people accepting that the couple hundred dollars they spent was wasted (In their eyes).

Personally I always want the most realistic sims possible, so I hope a miracle fix pops up that keeps everyone happy.

If not, for the time being I will take a slightly lower Pass completion % for a minority of people (Me included) over a large pass completion % increase for everybody.

I say for the time being, because I am willing to accept that the problem is now more complicated than just the initial bug in the sequencing.

I am also aware that the fraustrations felt by all GLBers at constant change is more prevailent with each change, if its good or bad.

While I agree this fix would be very good and is much needed, I know from experience that at least half the people will complain simply because its another change.

When Bort says this fix will work, then the fix should be introduced.

Until then all thats happening now is more people joining what is a very valid discussion to complain about lots of things specific to their own build or team without looking at the wider picture.

I do see lots of people in this thread whos only intention is to try to bring to light a fix that would help the community at large, and its because of them that anything will be done to fix this issue.

Not because more people complain loudly without knowing what the exact issue is, and how it effects related issues.
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 00:47:37
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
and how it effects related issues.


Nobody will completely understand that until it's implemented.

Regardless of what happens there needs to be an announcement yesterday. When is going to fix this problem and what can some of the repercussions be. These things must be seen by the users before a change is even made.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

and how it effects related issues.


Nobody will completely understand that until it's implemented.

Regardless of what happens there needs to be an announcement yesterday. When is going to fix this problem and what can some of the repercussions be. These things must be seen by the users before a change is even made.


This is my arguement that players are constantly kept in the dark on most issues that we bring up... We constantly hear "we are looking at it", but It seems to never get looked at hard enough.

I pointed something out the other Day to Bort and he said "it's only been three days", well... that was 8 days ago.... I like GLB, but the S.I.M. structure as I see it, cannot keep up with the advancement and strength of attributes. It appears to me that Like Mike Rogers is saying this problem affects many and most all aspects of the S.I.M. The structure seems to be at a crossroads, either it can be repaired, or it will continue to get worse and worse because the initial set up and parameters of the game were done wrong.

I would rather see Bort make the changes now that need to be made. Continued turning of the back to problems will yield bigger problems in the future. Possibly problems that will steer me away from the game altogether.

I would much rather these problems be corrected now, even if it means a temporary step backwards then to see no action from Bort.

Mike Pointed out the problems with the faster CB's... I could link multiple plays to this as well, but feel that my efforts to point out bugs and major problems get flamed and its not worth my time to do so anyway. Nothing seems to get done, but everything seems to be talked about forever.

Last season it was the LB's pathing, and I linked about 20 plays and everyone including Bort jumped on me... What happened... it was fixed.. It was a problem.. I don't come on here just to complain, I come to the bug forum to help speed the recovery of the game. GLB has serious issues and is heading for a crash as players get faster and increase attributes.. This is not just a speed issue.. If pump fake was working too well, Instead of nerfing it, why not have a counter to it in the defensive players attributes, Vision, Super Vision, etc...
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 01:55:12
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Does anyone know what the plan is moving forward? Has anything changed yet or not?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.