User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > "Missing" Intense Training Combos
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
There's no strength and agility either.

Anyway, I still suggest the two drop down methods of just the 14 listed attributes in each one. And letting people choose any combination they want. Other means (like higher costs and less bonus etc) can be applied to 'unwanted' combinations. But at least people have the freedom to choose to build, and the interface would be neat and simple.

Sorry for repeating it, but it's an emphatic better method.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by mia1994

There are really very few combinations which can't be reconciled by a real drill.

but there are combos that bort doesn't want


i'm really curious what those combos are... and why Bort doesn't want them.
 
Link
 
I'm guessing Bort doesn't want Strength+Agility, otherwise it would be in by now.

Funny, I trained all of my guys today, and a good number of them used Speed+Agility because it was the best option. A large number of them would have used Strength+Agility had it been available.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Is there strength+jumping, jumping+agility?

If not, I know why those and strength+agility are not in.
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
STR/JUMP is leg press
 
GG
offline
Link
 
any jumping+agility?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Is there strength+jumping, jumping+agility?

If not, I know why those and strength+agility are not in.


Why?
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Because physical attributes are the key component in building a player. Strength, jumping, agility, speed, stamina. Because this game is very much about athletes. Physical freaks. A level 1 QB with 12 throwing---you still see them throwing the ball well. RBs with 12 carrying still carry the ball. OL with 12 blocking still block. Etc. But an OLman with 12 strength gets destroyed. A RB with 12 agility is useless. A DT with 12 strength is a pushover. Etc. But that higher level of physical/athletic prowess is what separates players from others. Especially when you factor in SAs that give boosts to those physical attributes.
Last edited Sep 19, 2008 22:12:24
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
^
which is a deeper issue... one that isn't completely masked merely by disallowing certain key training combos.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
^
which is a deeper issue... one that isn't completely masked merely by disallowing certain key training combos.


True, it is a deeper issue, and something which i think can be addressed by creating a new attribute model/system and a new SA process that focuses more on FOOTBALL SKILLS than boosts to PHYSICAL ATTRIBUTES.

But I guess this is why Bort wants certain combinations removed. To prevent too fast a growth for players.
Last edited Sep 19, 2008 22:29:45
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Is there strength+jumping, jumping+agility?

If not, I know why those and strength+agility are not in.


Speed + Agility is wind sprints

Don't think there's a jumping + agility tho
 
Perok
offline
Link
 
strength training options aren't useful.

no strength/speed?

that would be chute sprints... (with the parachute)
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Bort made this thread meaningless a couple pages ago.

His statement that combos were of only a few choices purposefully so as to handicap 'intense' training vs. normal training means that to make a suggestion is of no use unless we know and understand Bort's view and determination to minimize the effectiveness of intense training.

For the first dozen or so pages I could not concieve a reason that simply 2 choices were made in training intense. Bort explained that he doesn't want people surfing the intense wave endlessly.

Everyone here is wasting their time. All Bort's posts should be moved to the beginning of the thread. It would have saved me a half hour of useless reading.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by GG

Is there strength+jumping, jumping+agility?

If not, I know why those and strength+agility are not in.


Speed + Agility is wind sprints

Don't think there's a jumping + agility tho


Jumping+agility if its not there is a good example of too fast a growth. Agility greatly helps jumping. So if you can just boost those two up very high by training them both, it creates a big advantage....high acceleration player who can jump even more. That kind of player can get away with lower stamina, vision, catching, etc. But a player with 80 catching and only 20 agility and 20 jumping is not very effective.

Clearly that refers to a WR, and jumping+agility is now far more decisive in a game for WRs. So if he wants to leave jumping+agility out that would be the reason....due to the season 4 tweaks he's done to help WRs be better. (IMO)
Last edited Sep 19, 2008 22:40:02
 
mia1994
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.


There are three potentially substantial drawbacks to training intense (1) you can't train daily, (2) it costs more, (3) you can't go to the advanced store. You can tweak #2 a little, but the real draw should be #3. If the store was really useful, then its draw is the motivation not to train intense.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.