User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by Animalmother


Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by datongw


Originally posted by Bort


That's a good idea, and basically what I was proposing with having some of the current testers give up their teams/players.
There will now be hate put on the idea because those "interns" could possibly play the game someday and use their knowledge.

Not some, all Bort. Can't so something half ass. This is a business you are running, be professional about it, do it right and restore your credibility and the game's credibility.

I'm saying that those that don't want to give up their team would be removed...

What about their players and the teams they GM?


i am 100% against having the testers give up their teams:
- they could still communicate inside information to their friends = nothing solved
- inside information hasn't resulted in success in the past => removing teams irrelevant


Then the only real answer is that all testers could never know anything about the game and never have access to it, etc.

"Inside info" is a concern as long as any tester has ever logged into the live site.


Not completely, but don't you see that there is a lack of integrity if you allow them to know the inside info???

Why can't you just let them analyze data... they don't need to know that TEAM A is better in RED ZONE FREAK.. they just need to know that there could be statistical differences to look for.. and find them
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by tshizzle


Originally posted by Nuge20





I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


Exactly. This is the "Young Technology Generation" after all.


I would be willing to say that most HS kids are smarter when it comes to CPUs and overall business than at least one of their parents...most HS educations involve some sort of business training whether it come from an economics/accounting class or from an english teacher
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS

Originally posted by CONN CHRIS





Stuff has to be tested. While the complaints about unfair advangages and business models et cetera are reasonable, the bottom line is that the best testers will always be those involved in the sim up to thier eyeballs - that's us.

All the blogs and whatnot are nice sounding but are just additional administrative drags, how about this:

1) Number of testers is fixed
2) A lottery or some sort of application process is put in place to get new testers
3) Half the testers are swapped out each season
4) All testers are announced publicaly
5) They have their own forum with access ending when their stint is up. That way their will always be 1/2 the squad with a season of experience that help the new testers along in the forum


Edit: Yes, those that are in testing will be a bit ahead of the curve on stuff for the period that they are testing. So be it, that's the prize they get on a temp basis for doing valuable work for the rest of us. People will still hate that but it's fair and good testing is a must.



Good idea / bad idea and why - anybody?


It's a bad idea to have people chosen by lottery, because one can get people who don't know anything about the game or people looking for exploits they can use.

Bort chose people who he felt knew their way around and who had earned some trust from him.


Maybe by application only then?

It accomplishes the testing that is needed by utilizing those best able to give good opinions (us). It doesn't eliminate potential good testers because no one has to give up their team. It would be open and while it would give temp. advantages to some, the chairs would rotate and theoretically everyone would have a chance at it if they wanted.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
games in development are going to be tested. New additions to game are going to be tested.

Transparency is the real issue, not the fact that people are testing. This thread is 163 pages (and counting) long b/c this was kept secret instead of being made public from the get-go.

offer still stands to help with this piece.
 
Link
 
Customer Service should be the #1 priority period. The customer is always right.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Then the only real answer is that all testers could never know anything about the game and never have access to it, etc.

"Inside info" is a concern as long as any tester has ever logged into the live site.


Split them into two groups.

One group makes builds
One group tests the builds, not being able to see them, just picking from a number on a list.
The original group does not know what number their build is.

If problems are reported, you can easily look at the build. Switch up the groups occasionally.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Bort, why not make it mandatory that testers have open builds to personal players? Seems reasonable to me, afterall they are usually open when trying to sign on with another team.


Ah ha. Good idea.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Modok

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tshizzle



Originally posted by Nuge20






I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


wow...you dont see jrry get pissed that often. I am kinda turned on.


You gotta wait a few more months Modok.

Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tshizzle



Originally posted by Nuge20






I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


Damn kids!


You forgot get off my lawn.



Why, you playing hard to get?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by tshizzle


Originally posted by Nuge20





I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


You're doing it wrong. It's called experience. And at 17 you don't have any.


What would you know Krwynn? You don't know me.

 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


"Inside info" is a concern as long as any tester has ever logged into the live site.


Which is why in a game where everyone is supposed to have an equal playing field the testers either are employees, or everyone has the ability to be a tester.

It's not an issue in cooperative games, but this is a player vs player game, and as such human nature will take over and testers will have a reason to keep their testing results to themselves (of course after reporting bugs and the like).

In Cooperative games the incentive is to share the information.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Bort

This is so simple to fix it's pathetic..............Open the test server to viewing, open the builds to viewing, open the D plays to viewing. Simply put, make the tests viewable by all and move on. Do that and no one has a right to bitch. The fuck up was creating the secret society. The next major fuck up was trying to sell that they weren't given an advantage. Ppl aren't that damn stupid. don't treat them like they are....and the "poor pitiful me, I'll be wrong whatever I do" thing isn't flying. Sorry to be so blunt, but you really fucked up here. Fixing it and moving on is the smartest thing you could do.
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort

Then the only real answer is that all testers could never know anything about the game and never have access to it, etc.

"Inside info" is a concern as long as any tester has ever logged into the live site.


Split them into two groups.

One group makes builds
One group tests the builds, not being able to see them, just picking from a number on a list.
The original group does not know what number their build is.

If problems are reported, you can easily look at the build. Switch up the groups occasionally.


Thank god, a good idea!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Modok


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by tshizzle




Originally posted by Nuge20







I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


wow...you dont see jrry get pissed that often. I am kinda turned on.


You gotta wait a few more months Modok.

Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by tshizzle




Originally posted by Nuge20







I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


Damn kids!


You forgot get off my lawn.



Why, you playing hard to get?


Well statutory rape is still a crime.

 
byrongame21
offline
Link
 
A blog detailing testing results by servers helps solve this problem. it was recommended before and i believe Bort acknowledged this, but anything else other than that?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tshizzle



Originally posted by Nuge20






I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


and therein lies the root of most of these problems. this is a guy that is "important" in the GLB community, has pull, etc - and hes in fucking high school....

not that its your fault obviously, but no one thats 15, 16, 17 yrs old has any fucking clue about service and responsibilty to the paying public. fuck your mom still washes your little panties when you shit them by mistake - and you are in here giving business opinions, SIGH



You know what man, I have been on the same side you're on this entire time and I have to say go fuck yourself. Because I am 17 I somehow lack the sense of knowing that you should have resposibility to your paying public or in order to succeed you have to keep your customers happy? Seriously, go fuck yourself. Age is only a number, you could be 50 and I could only be 17 and I could still know more about business than you. So stop with the elitist bull crap.


You're doing it wrong. It's called experience. And at 17 you don't have any.


What would you know Krwynn? You don't know me.



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.