User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kcirdor
I dunno, I know exactly what you are saying and you're very convincing. This idea can only be part of a total package repec of the entire game itself. 4 seasons of data should be more than enough data accumulated to hammer out the last few issues with BETA.. Then we can all get our respecs and start "fresh" in Zeta... then 4 seasons of Zeta we can begin Omega. Then hopefully we can go live.


Well, at least there are people out there that acknowledge and see what im getting at. Like Xiong Yoshi said, the odds are no matter how much 'we' make compelling arguments for things and against things, it's in the hands of bort and if he chooses to band-aid things towards going live and having a game falling short of its potential, then that's for him to deal with. There's absolutely zero 'ego' here from me. Nothing to do with my own ideas or anything. Parity > disparity. Money > less money. Noobs > vets. Etc.
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
This is an absolutely fantastic idea. I like Bort's Idea of it being VETERAN Special Abilities rather than calling it prestige. I also think it would be best if these SAs were not position specific, but SAs that apply to ALL positions. I'm thinking a "Veteran SA Tree" that is entirely about mental attributes.

Here is my take on it:

GENERAL MECHANICS:
There would be FIVE SAs on the veteran tree and the SP cost of these would work exactly like the current trees as far as the SP cost to build them up. You could not put any points into the Veteran SA Tree until you reached LVL 25. (this way there is no need to keep track of separate XP or "Prestige Levels" ... instead you just use the Five SPs you get for leveling up to build them if you choose) I chose LVL 25, since this is the point in time when a player really slows down and starts to get a little dull to manage. Also, the previous level (24) you just had the excitement of upgrading your equipment, and this will make that first really slow "level-up" really worth it!

VETERAN SPECIAL ABILITIES:
1. LOCKER ROOM LEADER: This player knows just what to say and when to say it. He also inspires his teammates with his tireless work ethic. Anytime this player steps on the field, his teammates play just a little harder as they don't want to let him down. (think Ray Lewis or Teddy Brushci)
2. FOOTBALL SMARTS: This player has seen it all and knows what to do about it. When this player is on the field, he will recognize what the other team is doing and call out adjustments/audibles if his teammates are not in position to make the play. (Think Mike Singletary)
3. AWE: This players reputation precedes him. Younger players (perhaps 5 levels lower, or perhaps anyone who doesn't have this ability themselves) are starstruck when competing against him and make more mental mistakes. Also effects refs, who, when a call is close, will give this player the benefit of the doubt. (Think Deion Sanders)
4. CLUTCH PLAYER: This player plays his best when the game is on the line. While others fear the pressure, he thrives on it. (think Roger Staubach or John Elway)
5. CHAMPION (or perhaps PLAYOFF PRO): This player doesn't feel the pressure of the playoffs, but rather his performance actually increases as the stakes get higher. (think Otto Graham or Joe Montana)((also activates in regular season games where the playoffs are on the line))

I think by having the "Veteran Special Abilities" the same for all positions and having it cost SP in the same fashion as the current SA trees, it will make those 5 SPs that you get after waiting half a season to level up WAY more useful and worth waiting for.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 00:22:45
 
Jordache
offline
Link
 
+1000000 Great post.
 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by otto_g_2k8
This is an absolutely fantastic idea. I like Bort's Idea of it being VETERAN Special Abilities rather than calling it prestige. I also think it would be best if these SAs were not position specific, but SAs that apply to ALL positions. I'm thinking a "Veteran SA Tree" that is entirely about mental attributes.

Here is my take on it:

GENERAL MECHANICS:
There would be FIVE SAs on the veteran tree and the SP cost of these would work exactly like the current trees as far as the SP cost to build them up. You could not put any points into the Veteran SA Tree until you reached LVL 25. (this way there is no need to keep track of separate XP or "Prestige Levels" ... instead you just use the Five SPs you get for leveling up to build them if you choose) I chose LVL 25, since this is the point in time when a player really slows down and starts to get a little dull to manage. Also, the previous level (24) you just had the excitement of upgrading your equipment, and this will make that first really slow "level-up" really worth it!

VETERAN SPECIAL ABILITIES:
1. LOCKER ROOM LEADER: This player knows just what to say and when to say it. He also inspires his teammates with his tireless work ethic. Anytime this player steps on the field, his teammates play just a little harder as they don't want to let him down. (think Ray Lewis or Teddy Brushci)
2. FOOTBALL SMARTS: This player has seen it all and knows what to do about it. When this player is on the field, he will recognize what the other team is doing and call out adjustments/audibles if his teammates are not in position to make the play. (Think Mike Singletary)
3. AWE: This players reputation precedes him. Younger players (perhaps 5 levels lower, or perhaps anyone who doesn't have this ability themselves) are starstruck when competing against him and make more mental mistakes. Also effects refs, who, when a call is close, will give this player the benefit of the doubt. (Think Deion Sanders)
4. CLUTCH PLAYER: This player plays his best when the game is on the line. While others fear the pressure, he thrives on it. (think Roger Staubach or John Elway)
5. CHAMPION (or perhaps PLAYOFF PRO): This player doesn't feel the pressure of the playoffs, but rather his performance actually increases as the stakes get higher. (think Otto Graham or Joe Montana)((also activates in regular season games where the playoffs are on the line))

I think by having the "Veteran Special Abilities" the same for all positions and having it cost SP in the same fashion as the current SA trees, it will make those 5 SPs that you get after waiting half a season to level up WAY more useful and worth waiting for.




good idea, along with SA you can unlock by having certain attributes. This will allow alot of speacialization up to lvls 40-50. Then the player starts to decline. After 10seasons in the league it could unlock another SA tree(i.e. Super hands(old players always hold)
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG


Well, at least there are people out there that acknowledge and see what im getting at. Like Xiong Yoshi said, the odds are no matter how much 'we' make compelling arguments for things and against things, it's in the hands of bort and if he chooses to band-aid things towards going live and having a game falling short of its potential, then that's for him to deal with. There's absolutely zero 'ego' here from me. Nothing to do with my own ideas or anything. Parity > disparity. Money > less money. Noobs > vets. Etc.


I've been thinking about the disparity issue as well, trying to find a way to even the playing field without changing the game too much.

What about a parity system like in Madden games (I know boo imitating Madden) where a lower level team gets a boost to become roughly equal to the level of the other team.

In GLB terms, why not have it where the sim takes a level average of the two teams that are playing. If one team averages 3 levels (or whatever number Bort decides is fair) or higher less than the opponent, each player on the lower level team has their attributes boosted for the game to the average level of the opposing team.

The attribute boost could be based on a ratio of the major/minor attributes at the time of the boost.

For example, a team averaging lvl 10 goes against a team averaging lvl 20. A player on the lvl 10 team gets his attributes raised to an estimation of what his current build would look like at lvl 20.

So a WR on the lvl 10 team with 40 speed, 20 catching, 20 agility, 20 jumping would increase to the estimated attributes he'd have at lvl 20 based on the current ratio of points (taking into account the cost of softcaps). Off the top of my head, I don't know what he'd look like at lvl 20, but that's what algorithms are for (taking into account the amount of points spent in an attribute per level).

This type of system would make it so that player builds would be very important (especially for the lower level player getting the estimation boost) and would provide a more even playing field.

I imagine programming something like that would be difficult, but it wouldn't change the game and it would provide parity.

The only con I can think of is that if all the low level players are boosted, what would stop a team in a high league from fielding all low level players to save on cash. Well the sim estimation wouldn't take into account equipment upgrades, custom equipment, or the "veteran attributes". It gives an advantage to high level players, but doesn't make it impossible for lower level teams to win.

I'm very tired, so I'm not sure if I articulated that in the way I wanted, but the basic idea works in my head.

Last edited Aug 27, 2008 01:01:29
 
chapnis
offline
Link
 
great! best idea... ever!
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Anarcho...

Your idea has merit. There are flaws in it, one of which you mentioned. But at least your idea is trying to find a way to implement parity inside the existing system. I'd be ok with Bort doing that and seeing how it works. I'm not sure if it would be a stable foundation that could stand the test of time. I think re-spec/re-do is ultimately what needs to happen.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
But the base foundation needs true parity first.


Actually, this is not necessarily true.. If we were designing a game from the ground up - it might be preferential to try and design one that had balance and parity from day one... but that's not the situation we are in. It's kinda like building a scale with weights and then discovering that it isn't perfectly in balance - you aren't going to throw away the scale when you can, quite literally, just put a couple band-aids on one side to bring it to balance.

While this game might need more than the "couple band-aids" - the concept is the same.. That's how I see this idea, it has the potential to be the "patch" that is needed. At the same time, the idea has the potential to completely revitalize high level play.

 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Anarcho...

Your idea has merit. There are flaws in it, one of which you mentioned. But at least your idea is trying to find a way to implement parity inside the existing system. I'd be ok with Bort doing that and seeing how it works. I'm not sure if it would be a stable foundation that could stand the test of time. I think re-spec/re-do is ultimately what needs to happen.


Ultimately, I'd like to see a re-do as well. If there are flaws in the current system (which a lot of people seem to think) then it is something that needs to be addressed while we are in Beta.

If new attributes need to be implemented or old ones tweaked, it'd be better for the game (which is the top priority) to dump the existing system, figure out what needs to be changed, and implement a new system.

Let everyone whine about having to respec. This game is Beta and it should be treated as such to develop the best product. If it means starting all our players back at level one with new attributes (I'd hope for a full FP refund in that case though), then so be it.

I don't think that will happen any time soon though (or ever), so in the meantime, I'll just continue to think of ways to even the playing field without tweaking the existing system too much.

Anyway, what other flaws do you see with the idea?
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by otto_g_2k8
there is no need to keep track of separate XP or "Prestige Levels" ... instead you just use the Five SPs you get for leveling up to build them if you choose


This line alone makes it where I would oppose your interpretation. The entire point of the idea that is presented is that it lies outside of the normal level up scheme.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Anarcho...

The other flaws...

1. If it's the low level team being risen up to the average of the higher team, the higher team will still beat them silly. Maybe it could be BOTH the teams weighed up and averaged and so BOTH teams brought to the same average level.

2. A lot of teams have a bunch of level 25 players in them, but a bunch of level 15s in them. And inside that, a lot of different SA bonuses going on from play to play around speed/vision/tackling etc. There may be some teething problems here in forever tweaking/nerfing SAs due to their effect in the game. Ie, some players are level 10 and have a tree of 5-5-5-5-5 and some may be level 20 with SAs of 1-1-2-2-1. The averaging thing will end up complicated trying to have an average Base attribute effect whilst also trying to balance the SAs. Eg: high SAs with low base can cause wonky things to occur.

3. Basically, easier to re-spec and re-do, as a lot of time ideas tend to band-aid and end up requiring constant nerfings and changes that tip the scale in other areas. Like all of season 4 so far and how tweaking something here ends up creating a big problem/bug somewhere else.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 01:43:09
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Anarcho...

The other flaws...

1. If it's the low level team being risen up to the average of the higher team, the higher team will still beat them silly. Maybe it could be BOTH the teams weighed up and averaged and so BOTH teams brought to the average level.

2. A lot of teams have a bunch of level 25 players in them, but a bunch of level 15s in them. And inside that, a lot of different SA bonuses going on from play to play around speed/vision/tackling etc. There may be some teething problems here in forever tweaking/nerfing SAs due to their effect in the game. Ie, some players are level 10 and have a tree of 5-5-5-5-5 and some may be level 20 with SAs of 1-1-2-2-1. The averaging thing will end up complicated trying to have an average Base attribute effect whilst also trying to balance the SAs. Eg: high SAs with low base can cause wonky things to occur.

3. Basically, easier to re-spec and re-do, as a lot of time ideas tend to band-aid and end up requiring constant nerfings and changes that tip the scale in other areas. Like all of season 4 so far and how tweaking something here ends up creating a big problem/bug somewhere else.


1. I agree. Averaging the two teams together would be better. Maybe even working the the median level to counter act having a few really low players or really high players on one team.

2. The attribute estimation could only take into consideration the actual attributes, not special abilities. Another advantage to actually having your player be a high level instead of being averaged up to that level.

3. I agree. The only thing is that there is a huge outcry to not redo anything. Unless Bort is willing to deal with the outcry, then we will be stuck in this system and must find a way to work around it.

Last edited Aug 27, 2008 01:45:00
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Anarcho...

I like the averaging thing in principle. Basically it would mean, a level 25 team vs a level 25 team to mean two teams of level 25 players = equal contest. While a level 25 team vs a level 15 team would mean two teams playing at level 20 standard = equal contest. In principle i think this idea is good and works around the whole "re-do" thing...tho im sure it will open a can of worms of nerfings and complications. But i think it's worth a shot to see. Would only require Bort to write some nifty program and if it doesnt work it didnt mean a huge overhaul occured to just test it.

I think the SAs is a problem tho because someone with 10 pts in shed block is going to kick ass with high attributes. If you have a player 'forced' to play at a lower level 15 standard (meaning the algorithm makes his agility/speed etc more like 30 not 60) then it would cause havoc with his SAs like the current elusive running bug that exists.

I think your idea is worth a shot is what im saying, and just seeing what happens. I'd imagine a lot of bugs/nerfings, and if that occurs then re-do/re-spec is the way to go ultimately, would stand the test of time, rather than THEN trying to forever band-aid around the problems of that averaging system.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 01:59:56
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Another problem could be that people then say "well why boost then. we could just stay a level 1 team and when we play a level 20 team we're automatically made to play like a level 15 team, whilst also our stronger opposition reduced in ability to play like a level 15 team too".

 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
If the averaging worked with base attributes, it wouldn't take into account equipment upgrades, custom equipment, and whatever other nifty things get added (like veteran attributes) that would require players to boost and level up in order to take advantage of.

Sure a lvl 1 team might be equal to a lvl 20 team when they are averaged out, but the lvl 20 team will have full customs, and lvl 8 and 16 upgrades after the average. It would be incentive to the lower teams to continue to grow, but not as significant of an advantage where lower level teams stand no chance against higher level teams.

As far as the problems with SAs, I'm sure there is some way an algorithm could account for it. Also, if someone put a lot of points into SAs, they would receive less of a boost when averaged because they have less points in attributes overall.

For the higher level team, I can see how having attributes potentially cut in half could cause a problem with SAs and such. I'm not really sure what would address that, but it could be a non issue. It would just have to be implemented for anyone to find out.

I'd imagine a few bugs as well, but such is the nature of this particular beast.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 02:29:53
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.