User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
and if my sarcasm didn't come through re: caps, I'm sorry

and..if you bothered to read above, I specifically said that I feel most people aren't here to "test" the game. Maybe we should settle on different language than "BETA" as most guys with a dev. background or MMORPG background have a very specific definition of the word which obviously does not hold true here.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
It's a beta game, it's just setting the record for "Most people disregarding a beta label and just playing the game 'as intended'".
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
and if my sarcasm didn't come through re: caps, I'm sorry

and..if you bothered to read above, I specifically said that I feel most people aren't here to "test" the game. Maybe we should settle on different language than "BETA" as most guys with a dev. background or MMORPG background have a very specific definition of the word which obviously does not hold true here.


Sorry, I am slow at times
 
Futureking
offline
Link
 
A respec would eliminate the problems. Why not? It's not that difficult and people will stop whining. If we like our builds, all we have to do is use the respec to restore our original build. I say that's a win-win. I say the only guys who oppose it are the NIMBY people (Not In My Build Yet).

10% is great. For a lv 15, that's like a redistribution of 30 points.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 21:43:32
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
and..if you bothered to read above, I specifically said that I feel most people aren't here to "test" the game. Maybe we should settle on different language than "BETA" as most guys with a dev. background or MMORPG background have a very specific definition of the word which obviously does not hold true here.


But it will need to hold true if this game is going to have any amount of longevity.

If you aren't smart about testing your game (and to this point, the method of testing has been awful and horrendously inefficient), you won't ever knock the bugs out. You'll just keep adding more. Which is exactly what's happening.

I gotta punch out. I've got games to win.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by SCACE

and..if you bothered to read above, I specifically said that I feel most people aren't here to "test" the game. Maybe we should settle on different language than "BETA" as most guys with a dev. background or MMORPG background have a very specific definition of the word which obviously does not hold true here.


But it will need to hold true if this game is going to have any amount of longevity.

If you aren't smart about testing your game (and to this point, the method of testing has been awful and horrendously inefficient), you won't ever knock the bugs out. You'll just keep adding more. Which is exactly what's happening.

I gotta punch out. I've got games to win.


They're not bugs, they're features.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
No matter what you think about the "Speed trumps all" crowd, those with speed all over should be kicking everyones ass, for the first several seasons.

The fact that Bort has had to do things to counter the effects of speed is doing nothing more than cheating the game, for those who didn't want to catch-up with the speed that was dominating.

Yes. A guy with 80 speed and 20 catching should suck. But he shouldn't be slowed by the sim to make him suck. He should drop the ball alot. A LB with 70 speed and 40 agility, but 25 tackling and 27 Strength should suck too. But not by slowing him down. He should get trucked by stronger guys.

Never should a WR with 70+ speed, and 50+ agility be run down from behind by a punter.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84977&pbp_id=2481376

This is the result of so many GLBers not having the forsight to have their level 25 CB with more than 30 speed and 30 agility. (I've seen a few of those.)

How do you do that? How does anyone not know that a CB needs speed and agility above all-else?

No matter. Because that is no longer the case. That garbage CB build will be fine now. Eveybodys players will pretty much be equal.

I saw, in the thread starter, a comment about "cookie-cutter builds". That is exactly what we are doing. Now, your WR with 90 speed has to be slowed, so that those who don't know how to build a CB can remain competetive, despite the fact that they built their player wrong.

Everybody has to have their players with an even balance on a specific group of attributes, or they suck. You build them wrong, or else you will suck. Build them average, or waste your SP by trying to get a player that excells at something.

At level 20+, a CB with anything less than 50 speed and 40 agilty should suck. He should be completely unable to cover a WR with 80 speed and 60 agility. He shouldn't even be able to see that WR, once the ball has been snapped.

I find it hilarious that, because some were alert enough to make their players really fast, while others were left behind for failing to make their players fast, the speed attribute had to be attacked through the design of the game.

I built my level 24 OG with 28 blocking, so I think the game should be changed to where my 28 blocking can block all of the DTs and DEs in the game, despite their strength, speed and agility being over 50.

I think it is really that damn ridiculous to have "nerfed" the speed in this game.


Last edited Aug 9, 2008 18:30:29
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Once again, I'll say this: Speed has not been nerfed. The max speed calculation is exactly the same as it always has been. What I changed was acceleration. Before, having 90 speed meant that you also had 90 acceleration, which made it an uber-stat because you could go from 0 to 60 in a split second, even after making a cut which slowed you down. Requiring a player to have agility alongside speed makes it still worthwhile but not overpowering.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
The season 4 changes kick ass!
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Considering that sprinting is basically accelerating until you tire and decelerate, I'm not sure how faithful to reality it is to separate human speed from human acceleration. I'm also not sure how faithful to human movement it is to associate forward acceleration with the ability to change direction or move laterally. Now there's less of a difference between "rockets" and "scat backs" because they both focus heavily on agility rather than one simply on straight-line speed and the other simply on lateral quickness.

So perhaps it's more accurate to say that there was an agility boost than a speed nerf?

Either way, that's all water under the bridge -- once a change has been made it's best to stick with it. Looking forward to seeing the more recent changes in receiving and pass coverage!
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Once again, I'll say this: Speed has not been nerfed. The max speed calculation is exactly the same as it always has been. What I changed was acceleration. Before, having 90 speed meant that you also had 90 acceleration, which made it an uber-stat because you could go from 0 to 60 in a split second, even after making a cut which slowed you down. Requiring a player to have agility alongside speed makes it still worthwhile but not overpowering.


I get that, but I was one of those who believed in AGILITY from the get-go. So, wherever I have 70 SPEED, I also have 50 AGILITY. But even my guys are still slowing to a near stop, often with no reason to slow down at all.

Did you look at the 70 SPEED/50 AGILITY WR/PR getting chased down from behind by a Punter?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84977&pbp_id=2481376

With the added effects of AGILITY, my players, specifically, should be running alone very often. But instead, they are being chased down by players with no SPEED, nor AGILITY, at all.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31

Did you look at the 70 SPEED/50 AGILITY WR/PR getting chased down from behind by a Punter?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84977&pbp_id=2481376

With the added effects of AGILITY, my players, specifically, should be running alone very often. But instead, they are being chased down by players with no SPEED, nor AGILITY, at all.


That has less to do with agility changes and more to do with the fact that he was juking a bunch of times from playing elusive running style (there are still problems with that).
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Considering that sprinting is basically accelerating until you tire and decelerate, I'm not sure how faithful to reality it is to separate human speed from human acceleration. I'm also not sure how faithful to human movement it is to associate forward acceleration with the ability to change direction or move laterally. Now there's less of a difference between "rockets" and "scat backs" because they both focus heavily on agility rather than one simply on straight-line speed and the other simply on lateral quickness.

So perhaps it's more accurate to say that there was an agility boost than a speed nerf?

Either way, that's all water under the bridge -- once a change has been made it's best to stick with it. Looking forward to seeing the more recent changes in receiving and pass coverage!


We probably should have had an acceleration attribute, TBH. It would take kind of a kludge to add it now, though.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by chief31


Did you look at the 70 SPEED/50 AGILITY WR/PR getting chased down from behind by a Punter?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84977&pbp_id=2481376

With the added effects of AGILITY, my players, specifically, should be running alone very often. But instead, they are being chased down by players with no SPEED, nor AGILITY, at all.


That has less to do with agility changes and more to do with the fact that he was juking a bunch of times from playing elusive running style (there are still problems with that).


I appreciate the response.

I have changed all of my SPEED-based players from "elusive" running style, to "combo".
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
You're doing a great job Bort, keep up the good work! +1 on season 4 changes
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.